_________ ,

1. 34M -fiW - 1158/2014/"1(

2.'34M #6lI - 1159/2014/1'(

3. 3TfrT #6W - 1160/2014/"1'

4. 314T '(i1I - 1161/2014/'*

5. 34k1 (151I - 1162/2014/1.

6. - 1163/2014/%*

1-'Ni ict tu ii iI Ri'ici 1131 fr.,

I

11 I"-I

'1I14) 31Iqc1, 97. zi—ccili, i1i I

31 4qww, 3TTT 3ft f1 TT,(i1

-i &1ThT 1Iu11 R-ticp 21.02.2017

fufg

1. 3T-cI'l U7M 7rg lo: 3l c'11 WRWt TO)-g 'IPIr'rP

f]TTr, 7qy (fvT-4 .&iit "3IL11e4 3Tf51' TF \31III) * PT 1i Ph ircpii iRci 3TMAM 3{II 1"iip 12.06.2014 * 1)c !1*,c1 ,

iiti cicii, cJc, RTF[,

3IT4'5 fi1ui 1rr' i 7RFff) ri 7FvTejm

45 3T1ffTf, 2003 (1ii &rk A11P-11" IT iiii) qt £1TT 25, 55 74 61

* i dIrIl HIc1 I12thT 3T1W * 7Rt qvpi

T7 ti * T1T 1i c4 1? d fcFT IT t I

2. i T41 qctmt * IQT PciuIci f -;:s -.TiN * 4NI T-T-C'r t5 ft

3III 1 PiPici 1bI 31T W , 1ui rfr wct, cie)

3 * r t fcfHk1cP c4iPt1r-icp

—IcI1, 1 qft, MMct)~IOTFI 7FVPW7, siiiy (itTt 374 ',iiti aijcpi'I'

TT vIIIl) * ti 31c'III 4-.I41 ZFT f iicp 24.08.2012 t TT'T 1b.ii 'TTtI

3 3TIWF c1i ci1 q1 1TT 75(1) * ic1 90èi IT

zR RYiT ccpc'I rfm c*c1IT 1ciUI 3ITf T W\-4 *

Pn fR I 3TT CP1 '1 -ffM 2007-08 2012-13

ccpc T M, fc 3llT f4i 3iicii1

cp4-qt TT 3Yr 1ci 4 T ciii ciicii

tIci .5Itu?1 IA160 * 9T[ t ciiAT 'T5T 9'1 15cPI a40611 *

111 .1 Pci fTT TT cp cl I l I 'I I cli 3111T1 c4-'J ,!j) ii Tctm

4 * trt fci f11T 7M W\9 'Y1R t I T

* mT cciI w

c1'IidI ........................2

2014 r Urt M, Ri'ici IEzT#mpff cp14 TT 3TffRFT it 'TT 83

c1c1 Zff 3iil * * HET 4*c,c1 t t, Ri-icpi [CUI 41u1

aTtzrft A aitft . t. 3fl

I1i -44 4R WR Tft

1158/14 182/,It Ill/td 24.05.13 07-08 7,56,720 5,07,000 15,13,440 27,77,160

1159/14 183 /Wt IH /14e Ill/14e 24.05.13 06-09 23,54,712 12,95,104 47,09,424 83,59,240

1160/14 184/3T ffl/ 24.05.13 09-10 10,08,800 4,33,800 20,17,600 34,60,200

1161/14 185/,It IH/14Z 24.05.13 10-11 5,16,000 1,60,000 10,32,000 17,08,000

1162/14 186/31'ft IH/tZ 24.05.13 11-12 5,03,000 95,600 10,06,600 16,04,600

1163/14 187/3P1 IH/4Z 24.05.13 12-13 4,96,000 34,700 9,92,000 15,22,700

4• 41 11 I

5. -ct cflN1 3)e14 c' * 3T1 1T T?TT 11I f5 ii'i'l

3tzlc141 IIe1 PZT1* 1jCi 15 1I1~ IIF9 3fq5 Ieii, 1TT

22(viii)(g) tTT f 31T1 tt 5/fcci tIT31' R1 kI"S 1 11c tftHTT 119r0 f rr ic11 * fTIF 4111 3zzlcI9

f5 \r T1 *r * 59 c1Ct1

*

f5 I1t t Lc:y.s J;1 t 3TlcPI

tftfTIT t1fTqT * 1I %3I1c1 TT ti 1GI1 3Tt1T cp ]f

1kRct1 3ffW

l'IIc1I .......................3

— 3 - aTT #6W - (1-6) 1158 f 1163/2014/1

-i elI (17 q Hc*l) 489) 74 3ITT S.1I 'e'd tcN-I 3I'k 1cl, iiic

* 31I~I 1iicp 10 317 'c1 2009 'f5T P4'i 147 1I f5 '34c1

1u1 * 3TtIUR 3T#M4 TT 11 c)cperI * T t 3d1 C1*J

i* 1P1 1T9T i1T wwm I RI I '1 3TfT5 159 Rb i

* 311I zrft 15 cct)c1 7ZR L\31 el Z3t1Z i1k'i * 31c14c1

1y t t ictc1 FQIT q t TV fZT7 ZTM 51 * 3T11I

j5j)ctu1 Rbi ilIc1I ciei qcpei 45T fq-.qm Rb.ii iT

lcli t 3J: I5 1dT &1F5T TM cli cp cp * *cl I 1cq

uNTil u1' ()Cpe1 1 F*W1T** RI1)d t I

3T9F4 * r*r 4 MTN ivciciu VWWM * 14u1i (2013) 3

tRiAA 541 l*c,c1 49 Rbii f 3c1 Pi4-i * iR

ct)4-1 tJ cpiRIcci VTiff i'icil t, -'M2T 5?T Rbi f 3TT cp 9

* c1 .l -1 I TT Y t1 '1 g I RI c-cl 3Tf115 I c c -i i ur f tt

cl * C14 i P"I TT Wqff tT cl

ri 79TT 17T 1cpc1I zTft fwr TT 1t 3Ri1cc1 I,4c1 * 3TI

1?'iicp 21 31 4 k-c1 2012 *t 9QTff ZT fHi Rbi 1 ictci F

9f91 '1ic1l t t t ZD7 f1tU1 3TfP TT TRff 3JI–~I PJf cpc *

RI IIfc1 -CT5T3TrqtquT aifff ti ct pT uii

'34c111 1l-li * RIhi #ud cWU 1cPed llI11 3ff'15 ciRIeiii. 23

Ic'1 249 tt '1I'l" 3T - I1kI1 15T Pi1q u:1*i*1 C'Ict, CkI Pc1 GlTiI#

311 1 ?IT 'lI F~iicp 30 eil 2007 Ift \3,rRd Rb.LlI 74 fi

Rb .i i fct Z-CRT *i u i *ic.i ci cj f!I5 ffui if1w TT RI siI *cici'i if *, ii TT 1'lcll * 31NT iiRci 31Il 31fIf t

31'!,11c1 i 6. Tff ? 1i VM4 fii * RI I Ti I ct) -1 3T1ii 19fT

3TftT511 tr &fr * 3TrW TT T74ff cp 3TMt 3ICPI cp

Tf9T it 1T fi * 3tfTh1T fi f w l7q 13T

)cpI ff *IcPc!il IT cIlclI 1T T cu

ilRc131I'RIdTTI

ITqT1r5 3rlII -;:t tT '11c11 t I -4R &T T 41cii.) 4IRIcci 0L1ciI

eqT RbTi ccii * 9 m t i 3I5'1'I Ri it 9lTi4l \ic1c19 1IIc

TT ju 4Id fI0 ?r Pu1 f?i t zuz r24 TITI cPlI '3'HCPI

4II cL1clI i5T 9t Rkicii t, El14 0 4c1 U f10 * T4I uITi?k4

31c1u -1I4lc it fuj fZ[[ m c1uIc1 1cN'I LUc14l 9TT1tIT

PI siR iTI

el'IIclk. ...................... 4

- 4 - 311tT #6W - (1-6) 1158 1163/2014/'J11

7.

m Tr4 qUF,

* 1l1 3T1IfTI 19M !*c),c1 - 1I1 i.-d) FT 111I'1 dcP1

1I q,uj' * 1iiui * t[ftiT31 C15T TT 3e 1i

31I1I 13f1c1 1cc1 bOMti

(i) 1Tf tZ TcFf, 2003 tt rIT-2(6) c ii—ciigiRcp cpllI ET5T f

1ILl TZff cJ{y fui iiflei

1T iRI I (q) r ff wrqT;z cifti vq z i-i1ui

T/cpI t -\frT T& Cflçrfl * 3T2T1T 9TT *

\3c * lrr (1M1 Cp.<clI T4 ciiii wgeiK1 30 tt

rfffmi rfir iii l/i P1ki t i 3flcpR11cp,

-III, IIc1I, PNIic1c1I # R1ci '4T Pi/thT * 31TThTT5

r ii d9.4 *, 1 T tfTqT iiIe1 [T lI I

(ii) ITT-2(15) IT (Goods): TTffZIR ti, 0(i4T), 'iig4 tcçri

c1),—Ric—*cri j — i1ii, ii i1?ii,

9[, c jj [ —4{i (ct*—cct) -~ft vHc'1

flhT Vt 47

31 w eiifl I

(iii) .1TT-2(17) 31Ilc1 (Input Tax) : Yi)cic1 c4c1l) UM 3PT1 c.1cN1I'Ll * '4cpç cII T[ 9TT tR cpIql TmT T2T1T TzFT lA zftm

15 31IIci I

(iv) £1TT 2—(40) IM7 tM cL4IYlIcic1 (TaxableTurnover): 1cPc'l c!4IgIc1c (Toatal

turnover) t 1THT cp)ki'1 ii1 * L.1zlIc1 u4I4kIr4cI 15T 9!1T fTT tR

r4 6 it wr & TfRp:r * 3Tftr c1I t, 4q_ciLflyIc1cf cp1III I

(v) 1TT —2(41) 6141TRINd (Turnover): 9Tf 57 TF *CPeI 1ct)- 4 (Sale

3Tth9 l5 — LI TRT 5T ZI iTqq '1t iI t, c21I'-1kIcic cPc'lIIl I

(vi) <i'r 3Tf4P TFT IP4 (t4T.31TV.) tR T5 (Tax on maximum retail

price) JZF 3T2T1T Y 7TL31T.4. tR T li 31T

EN aff Yg qi q I TrT A t tt ft 1 cp I TJT 9Ta TT U: 1T 3rRT:

pT ctcç # 411IIei ftt 147qi 7III I

8.

31Th1 t ZIT 9 SfrIl t I TWNTF tZ 3111ZFE, 2003 it 1TT 2(1 1)

:-

ciciil (Dealer) 31RI1 # ci.ifi ITf i*

? f c1.<uI cp r rz1 cçiI c4f1 fl* rzf Vt rrr 'ipi

ZIT 3TRT 1 Rici cilell, t[1TT ii1ki fl1 'ilI I

( / TT IiId TITt

c1'IIc1I .......................5

- 5 - wti #W - (1-6) 1158 1163/2014/J1'(

(i:) ITT 2(35) # ci11ci m Tr siFE ZIT 1t cp cfl çvl c4{1 t 3Tq1

frq 1RTI s4 Ici'1 T Wt 3TT * 0411 T 'lct 1T 3TT

1) lFq MIr1 * fTR T5k

(1) eiIe1, cpI'1, cid crc 1T 3T 1*1) t ii •

(1i) t &l ,'d'ciI Zff Ic1I cP1 5T WO c5c1I

() fci ziT aifci IJM m

lEft ilcii t cpç * fN GuleII 1 1TT 9I1'

• 3TT?T 51C 1 T 1R )clI9cdI A Tt q) rz 1 I A

() 1 a1cii (*r c)

m zA *P-c'lI5 Z1T I1c1UI cp 15T zffo cp cUdi -e T

() ii, ZIT Tt WcpI' 1I01 iI't f4*1t fTT *

3c14d 1i1ci T '3TT 9, Z 3R 1 9TI t T *I

(t) 3TR1icp ccjI

(T) c-clI 'HcPk ZIT irI (1'cPI 3T2T1T 3'1cPI fFr Z1T

ct,iq1e11 T '9TT 51 1'c'1I T Ic1I -CPt I5T i1514 cPc1I ift, IT

ETTO * .wr?t iRi11 * cII 3T2T1T ft9T clIc11I1lcP i1?i11i

ct cpU T2NT t*9T cIcN1IRIcP I1?i11 * cPc1l 3t it ?ZTT T 3TTT

m

* fit cçI

ct)M4j'1, N18 CP1 34 1CP I5T

?t iii m &Wt, txTk 1Lcr1I c t514 cPc1I

tr 1 viiPct iRtPt1 * cIkul 3T 4T T N1IIcP

•

9cPc 1T 3T1 fc"bt Tq 4 ipqqT;T S4 f? 4) !,iIRcl * frt ctc1I

rqu— txgT cfj Ut rii 1955 * i'ii'< r? CFt

i ctcii ft qU iM trfvn * 31Th< c1I1 ft

9T9T "iiIiI I 9. ,4cpI 3ctc1 tftITqT * & f$ ccI'

2003 1TT 2(35) trfiifi 1cp 4c'j * ftw

~c1I 3crc1 3ltf1RT'T * 311I ZII 1CI * 4iITi

S1cP1< ~Ic1I 6cj'I t TT f1IT fIc1

T5 1 c ci f2rW 'ii I II 1T 7FvTWF 2003 I-1TT 2(l 1) *

ci4ci tt 11c TT31'1 * cITT 2(35) qftqTftU fçp.j ctj * fr'

IT9T 'ilIII I cl'IIclI .......................6

- 6 - 3T4T *isii - (1-6) 1158 1163/2014/J1'1

10. sNI t ft5 ci1I TT 1I TMT Wgt TT 1p1 [5F1T9

Isi1 (Sale)/It ccpu r 3ciPi[c1 3TQi *iIc1 (lI{ei

cp ) t5 UTf:4ff t c c{ uI/cfluI

9cP4, 31T1fltT TFffM ({ip.. 3 {1 11Ic1Iw1 14cI * 1cei

ftft 3ft

(Tx) 11 31M it '.ict'ii * Ricui IW .1141k TT 3j..çu ?t

t'ic, 3i1flRT Ic1I1 )) Zn 3T4 1b) IFFMM !,lRt4'el * GI4I t,

ZIT 1ci'1 IdI'1 * 1I tt 1 t jc4l

____

To UTf4ff t IRcI t T 3T/1ic1I/ 2TT 1

* frq/f9T &rf r tf 0I'1 Zif '1c ,3ITQTIRT Ic1I'1 ft74

k) i FCF#t ciii q 1ci *

fu * 3ici4ci 1t1ki 9 1ici'l ZU c1i * Ip TT

ic r 'iii m jqc, NTwffrr TTffF ft7t i) zn

3TT {b*) eI'l !,R11pi * 4i t,

(tq) 9ThT fcFt i1IT (ifki) Zn '1cPI TwF

tRf, fl* ri r n ref, ?r 1cPc, 3TT1RT Ic1I'1

Zn 3TT 1'+1i c14I'l * t

11.

31TIT t Zn 9, Tqzi frt 311 [[ j5 TJ 34FH 71 cfl ifii

ci TCFF ti i'1't * zt 31I41

cpc1 I t t 3TT TT cli '-I * S I '-ci cPc11 5t it [°T fi '.i i cii

i ui M141001 * ii - ir 3TtlffAiI

ilIc1I ti i 1cPk r, iI[cP cli'l 151 cii cici1b qjii TiTff Ct ¶[ tM ,

3(1cPI 3'I iI 3FM WIc1I W T6T t 3T4U 3ff7 i'-c14dI TITff *

WE 5T wFiff 3TtM4 it 3TtT * 3T9 tm * I T l cP I

VcWF t[ cii'•i'l ZF ii1icci t !44Icli t5T IT9T 'ilicli * 1TI Zff

uT it T 1Iici ic1I'1 qt 1i 31Ic1I T T<icU

TT i4cii 3T9T eii) ilIcl, qTgt TT cPs.-1I W1 I5 1iI c3um

*1 ciii 3F4cl iiT * t5 /11c t1T3ft U7M

Writ t15r4 9. 29 30 tR * 1IW 31Th1 ctclI fA 714

........................7

- 7 - r4tr iii - (1-6) 1158 1163/2014/"11

3T4 c!4{1 1i 'MIdI t UqT 11cP1 ?t -'Tifi wi tt

ci1 1bi zr ii %JlIc!il t f5 T it 3I4) ff WT4 tR 15/Icil

IT 1ii' i 11I t ii'I * f1TTS WeA Rsicii 'iRcii

ZTT yA '1ii'-i Ic1 cPc1I 3TtEt 9Ff 3ctc1 cH'1 ZFT

11*IT1 cpclI c1ct1Id c1I f4qM IcR 3jt ju

* I f lcPUi'i 9Ic1 1TT 3T1fE5T NT TT 1RIT f .RF 1;I 4 tR 5FM iI bci' ET5T 'j I cii '1 Tt cP i 'i I tR JU

fT 21T, 3[ qrut zI5t T NiA c 1 I 'TIT qT I *c7 EM co cr1

3Tf1fRFf, 1988 ZA ITT 51 IY'lI4N 1T M Tr4 cJJj * T

i wi

c1l1 15T *c1I f 3T1.11kFf it qM 50 * .31c14c1 c1Il 5T

i i * u1Tci)G

f i - c u irM qTff c ci i * f~R f4it1 rii cp i

c1cciIc1 utj) i"i 3ieii2 * [PT qrgt T51 qlcmui 15

• fzrr TmT p i q cii -i TT 3TMcr1 I 2ff Ti ITZIT I 3T'1V4 TT

fPT T1 qrgt 951 tT7F 9!1 cli 'I m coa (T%) 1TT -cb7 fcFm Tff I

TKq-qcli -t P LodTT 95, 3T7t cPo1 fr cli 051 1 cp -i --It 1I I 1TIT

IT1I'1' 4Tq 9t *I3T T TOT *f5

cli'1 * 1cP4 * YRU1FH *1 i1t WtT tt t 51tU1) or &n

* i * iciiiic.ic1I) 9M ciIrui * 1TtT ffT/119?crl 051 \3YI

1bi urrciT t, ZE Ic1IIc1 * E2IT 11PI 951 \cI Zn 1cNl

wtr ifi 051 1 P rI st -i it ITH tJ 30 q' cii tR Tr r i c'I

95TI 1b t

• IT 1 cfi T t91, 91i , tt 4Ic1cPc11 * R?

Tfi 7T cii 1T c1cii t I 3TT: 3PfF f iTTw tR qro7q * 1 cP -1

Hc21cI' tR cPcii * iIc'i'i t Tcfff 91 t iiIdI t I c'4cii1 u7m Z

051 fWfM f47M t 4- 31fFf * S41r4qk * d Tvg 1-J c tR cli t Tr [Ff 3Tffk * ci ci o

r1i- ciL1ciII T1 ciI5 05t cPG 1cP fi1Rci 41 9T cPclI 05, 3TTf

9Ff clI'1 qlcici cPc1I 95, f: !1i 1Pe1 * Giccl ciii'I 05' 1 3T 95 1cr *iT * 9Ff ciI1 051 1ii'i cPc1RlI lIdi *1 fTff

cciI oo ri 1i TmT o trfrT # 3miT *1 * c1c1 3TOm2ff c1ciI -cT)7 ITT4 * fT * I

crl'iIc1I .......................8

- 8 - isii - (1-6) 1158 1163/2014/i11

12. ZT#qW 11 * 5

ri z ciiI T t 1P.i 1bI 'T1T t 1tcN.1 l.q/c.flYI< 9t t

9I'l' 3vc1c141 IIIe1'1 4Ic1 14e1 t15 fo T5T I'1 fi

1 qi 1TtE1TW

IT fi*i0 1Il'k4 '3c11 -1IIe11 3fitfr 1bi j:—

"Whether sale of pledged ornaments for consideration falls in the course of trade or business of the bank. It is no dout true that banks have to act on instruction of the borrower. In the present case, we are not concerned with the provision of section 176 of the contract Act, 1872. We are concerned with the definition of the word "sale" under the 1963 act. When a bank sells the pledged ornaments it is not acting as an agent of the borrower even under the 1949 Act. When the bank sells the goods pledged with them they do not act as the agents of the borrower. As pledgees, the banks, acting under section 176 of the contract act, 1872 have a right to sell the goods. That sale is not as agents but that sale is in exercise of the statutory power under the 1949 Act. No doubt the sale is on behalf of the pledgor, however the sale is in exercise of the statutory power (Dy. CCI v. A.R.S) Thirumeninatha Nadar Firm (1968) 21STC 184 (MAD). To the same effect is the judgment of the Punjab and Haryana high court in high channel video v. enclave electronics (1999) 116 STC 131 (P&H).Further, on reading the provisions of the 1949 Act, one finds that every bank is required to maintain its balance sheet in form 'A' of the Third schedule quoted above. The prescribe form indicates that non-banking assets acquired by the banks even in satisfaction of claims,are required to declare their holdings. The prescribed form of balance sheet indicates that banks are required to show on the asset side non-banking assets acquired by them in satisfaction of claims. Similary, in form 'B' of the Thired schedule under profit and loss account, banks are required to show income from non-banking assets and profit from sale of such assets.In our view,therefore sale of pledged assets takes place in the course of banking business.Therefore as stated above,the banks in selling the goods pledged to them did not act as agent of the borrowers/pledgors and that their sale was in exercise of statutory power under the 1949 Act.Further in our view it is no dout true that under section 8 of the 1949 Act. banks are prohibited from trading in goods. However if one reads Section 8 along with the third schedule to the 1949 act it is clear that dealing in non-banking assets is a banking business and the expection made in section 8 which allows banks to realize security and which allows banks to engage in trade in order to realise security, falls within the banking whenever undertaken. When a pledged article is old in an auction, the bank recovers not only its dues but also recovers interests and its other charges.This realisation falls within the parameters of the Third schedule to the 1949 Act. In the circumstances,we are of the view that sale of pledged ornaments falls within the course of banking business under the 1949 Act. In the circumstances, such transactions are taxable under section 2(viii) (q) read with section 5 of the 1963 act. We also find merit in the contention advanced on behalf of the department (the respondents here in) that the very object of the kerela finace act 1998 was to introduce clause (g) in section 2 (viii) in order to get over the judgments of the highcourt which took the view that sale of pledged goods did not fall in the course of banking business. We have quoted clauses (g). That clause makes it very clear that even if the sale of pledged ornaments takes places outside the banking business, the 1963 act would cover even such transaction. Therefore once such transaction fall under said 1963 act.banks become "dealers" and they are liable to pay sales tax under the said 1963 Act. It is true that the definition of the word "sale" under section 2(xxi) of the 1963 act does include mortgage,hypothecatiOfl.Charge or pledge, however the important point to be

ed is that the definition of the word "sale" under the 1963 act is not the same as under section .9

- 9 - 3T4flI #&W - (1-6) 1158 1163/2014/iN

2(xxi) in the 1963 act is very similar to section 2(g) of the central sales tax Act,1956 which is held to be having a very wide meaning as compared to the definition of the word "sale" in section 4 of the sale of goods Act, 1930 (State of Maharastra v. Embee Corp. (1997) 7SCC 190). Further when charges or pledge is enforces that enforcement is by way of sale of the pledged or hypothecated goods; that sale is for consideration and, therefore, it falls within the ambit of section 2(xxi) of the 1963 act." ____ _____ _____ _____

13. 3c 3cç1 1T cc1cvi f

1N1 1TLtT t I vg 3I1T FT ff iE6 *c)4k f

T1T 3cM 11cp irc1 i1?M clI 1TTJ R1T I

14. 3TtMeff m 3I'1 vi - cii iiei.i i5T wqftcp ici (1966) 17

r P Tr2. f 489 401P14 fro ii r

U fTO Zr 3TT [ 11'14q dcV1 I!cI z T t f5 :-

"We are accordingly of the view that the intention of the appellants in obtaining the higher purchase and the allied agreements was to secure the returned of loan advanced to their customers, and No real sale of the vehicle was intended by

the customer to the appellant."

15. 3T [4I' 3cc1 ii1icp i1 'crc1 T''1Il RT c1i*c1I1ct

TM * f5 Tt7 zft qTTrt tR, 3Pl4 i I'4I t _45T 3Tt1 cpë

cp cii -i T * i '-I 3Tq1 P1 cli m ci l

cpuj frr rr * cl,iI q flmtq zuwm mLiIciI * 11cp

tId 4<ci U fro 3T [141Ic1 fi.ci * 31T1T tR41 1)I1

fro * Piu1 T, 14 t5 t ii T&f frcii t I

16. 2010 NTN (Vol.44)-368 [WEST BENGAL TAXATION TRIBUNAL] ICICI bank ltd. v/s Joint commissioner,sales tax, central section Kolkata and others 3T f1IhTITtf 5 _ "Dealer - definition scope of - banking companies as well as non-Banking

finance companies are dealer under section 2(1 1)-baning companies as well as non banking finance companies are dealers under section 2(11) of West Bengtal Value

Added tax 2003 and are liable to pay tax on the sale of hypothecated goods/vehicles for satisfaction of calims under the Hypothecation agrrement.

Whether banking companies/Non banking companies are dealer under section 2(11) of west Bengal value added tax 2003 and liable to tax when have sold the pledged goods though for satisfaction of their claim"

tft i 3TT uu 17. 3ii T[ 3T1fT * Td f

wp.;u i'f * I * Pii t 'ThTI 3t1c19 IIIci4 * -i1ct'

itzi-I ci U fT0 * P1 pcii-1 WT

4I1cI i-ci'1 5T tiii 31'dT cci1'1 T [T frcii I 3: cpc1I *

gui I

(t7~ \qm vrFff 3T

PIlc1k.......................10

- 10 - &'r #M - (1-6) 1158 1163/2014/4

18. TT T5T I9 t [RITT Pi, 2006 ct f,1 -I 18 3fl'T

I tI-tu

11 fi iRT qT I 1T T

1T, 3T cp I U 3T dl F'1 & t, T iT iTTI 4[ aiii4 i1

Tr4t t f f 47 71 1 3T1IT d H I

3EJ iI'ile1I -ct qftcp Irci (2007) 10 535TL)

jf r1ii &31t t ZT & fTfft1 f'1l t f5 —All Transaction dully

recorded in books of account- no mala fide intention of not paying tax-Mere rejection

of explanation of assessee as not acceptable does not attract penalty-

19. fq;fM v, I fi.ut ZIt f4T46Ftf tT iiRcii 3I''IY'I 5T

f 9i'1' t4ciT 1Ti.iIe14 * f44 (2009) 23 C1Ie1 249 3?r TWff

ctCP( ii 3Th IIItzM 3T' cIki 43 Mi 4 1T 158,

4c-ci qW Kmftuff t4 rt1r i1T

1320/2013/f1 13I't T911i fTI fio ft4.i f~-Iicp 26.06.2014 ET

3Th1 1i '1l1 3i'f 1I 7 L1& 621 9III Q1l T

Ct i1cp 4.Ic1 * 3T 1T T1f5 umTt * d1'(-c1 1CII 3fc

20. iiRci * f t iiii?T zz1c111 miTITT (2009) 23 249

(Iwll ct5)eH 1T1T Oz AFF 43 1T 4 5T 158 TT

T1TT 3-ec;kI PF-1I1l *:- "So far as the question of penalty is concerned the items which were not included in the turnover were found incorporated in the appellant's account books, where certain items which are not included in the turnover are disclosed in the dealer's own account books and the assessing authorities includes these items in the dealers' turnovers disallowing the exemption penalty cannot be imposed. The penalty levied stands set aside."

3: 9I'1 t q 3ct< 1l.t1lc1 TT MRfi1i C1C1QT[ * 311 3Th111T

iiFci.uI t 3T'lT*d 1i ilNI f1T5 Mc11)d tIT t I &f: iiRciu1 * f9 t

3fIU 1I 1PI 1I \4R11

17. q,ejd: 5yctc1 f1ti'i t fui * &I1T tR 31ll4TM

_\3jlt ti fu *J1ll PITI

_t ( n)

g'ti