GNSS in der Luftfahrt - Plone siteGNSS in der Luftfahrt. Galileo Architektur und Status. 2 1/14/202...
Transcript of GNSS in der Luftfahrt - Plone siteGNSS in der Luftfahrt. Galileo Architektur und Status. 2 1/14/202...
T. Pany
Professur für Satellitennavigation (LRT 9.2)
Institut für Raumfahrttechnik und Weltraumnutzung
GNSS in der LuftfahrtGalileo Architektur und Status
21/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 2SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Inhalt
Bereits besprochen• Galileo-Geschichte, Galileo-Satellit
• SatNav I, GloSatSys VO4• Galileo Dienste und Signale
• SatNav I, GloSatSys VO9
• Systemarchitektur• Konstellation• Bekannte Ausfälle und deren Gründe• Status Performance
• Galileo und autonomes Fahren• High-Accuracy-Service
31/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 3SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
SystemarchtikturPolitisch, Aufbau, GCS, GMS
41/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 4SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Political Architecture
European Commission•Overall responsibility for the programme, management and implementation of all activities lies within the European Commission•Since 2020: Galileo is handled within the Directorate General for Defense Industry and Space (DEFIS) headed by•T. Breton (Commissioner), T. Pesonen (Director General), Pierre Delsaux(Deputy director general)
European Space Agency•Deployment, design and development of new generations and technical infrastructure is carried out by ESA
European GNSS Agency•Operations and provision of services is entrusted to GSA
51/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 5SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
DG DEFIS
https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/dg-defis-organigramme_en.pdf
61/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 6SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Political Architecture
Source: https://www.slideshare.net/EU_GNSS/gsa-egnos-and-galileo-for-aviation
71/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 7SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
European GNSS Agency
• European GNSS Agency (formerly European GNSS Supervisory Authority) in Prague
• Responsible for operations and service provision• Oversees key facilities:
• Galileo Security Monitoring Center (GSMC)• European GNSS Service Center (GSC)• Galileo Reference Center (GRC)• Galileo Integrated Logistics Support Center (GILSC)• Galileo Control Centers (GCCs)
• Market analysis• GNSS/Galileo uptake
Source: https://www.gsa.europa.eu
81/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 8SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo System Architecture
Source: 2014-springer-galsyst-9789400718296-c2
91/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 9SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Control Segment (GCS)
Source: 2014-springer-galsyst-9789400718296-c2
• Responsible for satellite constellation controland management of satellites
• Provision of telemetry, telecommand and control functions for the whole satellite const.
• Core facilities:• Galileo Control Centers (GCCs)• Telemetry, Tracking & Control (TT&C) stations
101/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 10SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Mission Segment (GMS)
Source: 2014-springer-galsyst-9789400718296-c2
• Responsible for the determination and uplink ofnavigation data messages needed to providenavigation and UTC time transfer services
• Continuous, global monitoring of all Galileo navigation signals and upload of updatednavigation messages
• Core facilities:• Galileo Control Centers (GCCs)• Galileo Up-Link Stations (ULS)• Galileo Sensor Stations (GSS)
111/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 11SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Control Center (GCC)
Source: https://gssc.esa.int/navipedia/index.php/Galileo_Ground_Segment
GCS facilities within GCC:•Spacecraft & Constellation Control Facility, SCCF•Spacecraft & Constellation Planning Facility, SCPF•Flight Dynamics Facility, FDS•Operations Preparation Facility, OPF•Central Monitoring & Control Facility, CMCF•GCS Key Management Facility, GCS KMF•Constellation Simulator, CSIM
GMS facilities within GCC:•Orbit Determination and Synchronization Processing Facitility, OSPF•Message Generation Facility, MGF•Precision Timing Facility, PTF•Ground Assets Control Facility, GACF•Mission Uplink Control Facility, MUCF•Mission Support Facility, MSF•Maintenance and Training Platform, MTPF•GMS Key Management Facility, GMS KMF•Service Product Facility, SPF
121/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 12SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo System – Ground Segment -2010
Source: http://www.aiad.it/aiad_res/cms/documents/TELESPAZIOgalileocontrolcenter_eng.pdf
131/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 13SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo System – Ground Segment -2018
http://www.esa.int/Applications/Navigation/Galileo_s_ground_control_segment_contracted_for_upgrade
141/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 14SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo System Architecture – Add-on
Source: Galileo-At-the-Dawn-of-a-New-Age-of-GNSS-Services-12.19.16
Galileo Control Center Oberpfaffenhofen
Sensor plus Uplink Station
151/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 15SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
KonstellationDerzeitiger Stand, weitere Beschaffungen
161/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 16SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Launch Status
Source: https://de.slideshare.net/EU_GNSS/status-of-galileo
Overlap with next slide (2018 was Launch 10 = L10)
171/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 17SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Future Launch Status
Chatre, Eric, Benedicto, Javier, "2019 – Galileo Programme Update," Proceedings of the 32nd International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of The Institute of Navigation (ION GNSS+ 2019), Miami, Florida, September 2019, pp. 650-698.
181/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 18SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Batch 3 Satellites (Launch 2020+)
Chatre, Eric, Benedicto, Javier, "2019 – Galileo Programme Update," Proceedings of the 32nd International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of The Institute of Navigation (ION GNSS+ 2019), Miami, Florida, September 2019, pp. 650-698.
191/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 19SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Current Constellation (Dec. 2019)
Source: https://www.gsc-europa.eu/system-status/orbital-and-technical-parameters/parameters-definition
201/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 20SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Satellites - Current Status
Source: https://www.gsc-europa.eu/system-status/Constellation-Information, 13.1.2020, 9:55 (UTC)
Wrong orbit
Next clock failure?
211/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 21SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo – Known Issues
•Overall 9 clock failures (6 PHM and 3 RAFS) until now (Status mid. 2019)
•The 3 RAFS failures occured on FOC SVs•1 PHM failure occured on an FOC SV•5 PHM failures occured on IOV satellites•3 of the 4 IOVs and 2 of the 26 FOCs are affected•Galileo still fully functional due to redundancy•PHM: issues when (re-)starting the clock related to plasma generation•RAFS: use of non-qualified electronic parts
Clock issues:
•Galileo 5 and 6 deployed in too low, elliptical orbits•Correction maneuvers were carried out, satellites are nearly fully usable for navigation purposes
Eccentrical orbits:
•Complete service outage from 2019-07-11 – 2019-07-17•Inter-related failures during GMS upgrade process
Galileo Outage:
221/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 22SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Satellite Clocks
http://insidegnss.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Galileo-At-the-Dawn-of-a-New-Age-of-GNSS-Services-12.19.16.pdf updated with https://galileognss.eu/orolia-atomic-clock-supplier-for-foc-galileo-satellites/
All clocks manufactured by SpectraTime (an Oroliacompany) being a single source for Galileo and the only non-US supplier of space atomic clocks.
* Clocks for batch 3 are updated versions of batch ½ clocks* Clocks for transition batch are “customer furnished items (i.e. provided by ESA to satellite manufacturer)
231/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 23SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
• Eccentrical Orbits: Recovery Maneuvers
Galileo – Eccentrical Orbits
Source: https://insidegnss.com/galileo-5-and-6-eccentric-satellites-mission-recovery-and-exploitation-part-i/
• Wrong orbit for GSAT201, GSAT202 due incorrect launch
• Misplaced cooling line near to fuel line in Soyuz launcher
• Gradual recovery of correct orbit• Sats fully functional
• Increased Doppler e.g. used for science experiments
• Adaptation of navigation message scheduling for official use of satswithin periods of orbit representability
241/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 24SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Incident (based on ESA/EC ION2019 presentation)
Context of incident•Upgrades to Galileo infrastructure necessary to change from “initial services” to “final operational capability”
•Feb. 2019 major upgrade of Galileo operational infrastructure started•July 2019 sequential update of GCCs was ongoing with temporary reduced redundancy of control centers
Causes of incident within GCC•Mishandling of temporary equipment •Technical anomaly of equipment related to time keeping•Non-nominal configuration of that equipment
One or two simultaneous appearances of the causes could have been recovered, but not all three of them
Manifestation•Loss of capability to generated navigation message on July 11, 0:50 UTC•Failure search took several days causing a complete reboot of the system resulting in further delays
•Recovery July 17, ~ 22:00 UTC
251/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 25SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Incident
Chatre, Eric, Benedicto, Javier, "2019 – Galileo Programme Update," Proceedings of the 32nd International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of The Institute of Navigation (ION GNSS+ 2019), Miami, Florida, September 2019, pp. 650-698.
DVS … Data Validity Status, AOD … Age of Data, SDD … Service Definition Document, IOV … In Orbit Validation, FOC … Final Operational Capability, NAGU … Notice Advisory to Galileo Users
Ephe
mer
is a
ccur
acy
0-10
m
11.7. 2:00 12.7. 2:00
261/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 26SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo PerformanzBerichte, Genaugikeiten, Verfügbarkeit, Vergleich GPS
271/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 27SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Performanz
• Technisches Monitoring • In-Orbit-Test• Im Auftrag der GSA
• Berichte• Monatliche Bericht der GSA an
• Kommission• ESA• Mitgliedstaaten der europäischen Union
• Diskussion innerhalb von Arbeitsgruppen der Europäischen Kommission
• Werden Anforderungen erreicht?• Definition neuer Anforderungsmerkmale• Vorschläge zur Verbesserung
281/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 28SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Service URA
Source: Galileo-IS-OS-Quarterly-Performance_Report-Q3-2018
291/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 29SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Satellite URA
From GSA report (Dec. 2019)
301/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 30SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Performance
Source: Galileo-IS-OS-Quarterly-Performance_Report-Q3-2018
311/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 31SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Navigation Performance
Definition Committed Target
Mar2019
Apr2019
May2019
Jun2019
Jul2019
Aug2019
Ranging Accuracy
[m]
DF95%
Worst Satellite < 7.0 0.32 0.59 0.57 0.32 0.34 0.27
Constellation Average < 2.0 0.25 0.31 0.21 0.15 0.21 0.15
SF95%
Worst Satellite < 7.0 0.73 0.56 0.59 0.57 0.57 0.50
Constellation Average < 2.0 0.51 0.38 0.36 0.33 0.31 0.31
Availability of DF Ranging [%](Global average) > 87% 100% 100% Not any more a MPL defined in the OS-SDD
Per-Slot Availability [%](monthly, OS, healthy SF/DF) > 87% 99.05% 98.80% 98.82% 98.70% 97.16% 96.98%
UTC Time Dissemination Uncertainty [ns](DF, 95% over last 12onths) < 30 8.4 8.4 8.3 9.0 11.1 13.1
UTC Frequency Dissemination Uncertainty
(DF, 95% over last 12onths)< 3 × 10-13 3.10E-14 3.14E-14 3.07E-14 3.20E-14 3.50E-14 3.90E-14
Availability of UTC Dissemination [%] > 87% 100% 100% 100% 100% 81.70% 100%
GST-GPS Time Offset Uncertainty [ns](95% over last 12onths) < 20 6.5 6.4 6.4 10.4 12.9 13.5
GST-GPS Time Offset Availability [%](over last 12onths) > 80% 97.33% 96.91% 96.65% 97.48% 95.68% 95.68%
Adapted from GSA report (Dec. 2019)
321/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 32SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo Navigation Performance
Definition Committed Target
May2019
June2019
Jul2019
Aug2019
Availability of F/NAV Global PDOP ≤ 6 ≥ 77% 99.58% 99.77% 81.27% 99.71%
Availability of I/NAV Global PDOP ≤ 6 ≥ 77% 99.74% 99.91% 81.37% 99.81%
Availability of Positioningat AUL
95% HPE ≤ 7.5m95% VPE ≤ 15m
Dual Frequency ≥ 77% 99.95% 99.96% 81.53% 99.96%
Single Frequency ≥ 77% 99.90% 99.94% 81.51% 99.94%
Availability of Positioningat WUL
95% HPE ≤ 7.5m95% VPE ≤ 15m
Dual Frequency ≥ 70% 99.69% 99.59% 80.76% 99.71%
Single Frequency ≥ 70% 99.42% 99.44% 80.69% 99.59%
Availability of UTC Determination
(Better than 31 ns, 95% over the month)≥ 87% 100% 100% 81.70% 100 %
Adapted from GSA report (Dec. 2019) AUL … average user location, WUL … worst user location
1/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 3333SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
3.73
4.93
3.38 3.28 3.29
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Sep-18 Oct-18 Nov-18 Dec-18 Jan-19 Feb-19 Mar-19 Apr-19 May-19 Jun-19 Jul-19 Aug-19
Days
bef
ore
the
even
ts st
arts
NAGU Publication Time - Planned events
Galileo Announcement of Events
0.65
2.56
0.27 0.34 0.45 0.220.81 0.92
1.77
0.37
3
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Sep-18 Oct-18 Nov-18 Dec-18 Jan-19 Feb-19 Mar-19 Apr-19 May-19 Jun-19 Jul-19 Aug-19
Days
aft
er th
e ev
ents
star
ts
NAGU Publication Time - Unplanned events
All events announced “in time”!
Adapted from GSA report (Dec. 2019)
341/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 34SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo-GPS Comparison
• Accuracy (URA, 95 %), monthly average over all satellites (2018):
• Galileo: 0.24 m – 0.5 m• GPS: 1.22 m – 1.35 m
• Time between uplinks:• Galileo: 89.95 % of uplink separations less than 20 min.• GPS: 83.8 % of uplinks less than 24 hrs
• Source: Joint Research Center in contract to GSA (Dec. 2019)
351/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 35SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo HAS + G2GGenauigkeit und Integrität durch Vernetzung der Satelliten?
361/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 36SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Hintergrund
• Autonomes Fahren ist wie Luftfahrteine sicherheitskritische Anwendung
• Sicherheitsanforderungen für autonomesFahren sind Gegenstand aktueller Diskussionund dürften über jenen von den Zivilluftfahrtliegen (höhere Anzahl an Nutzern)
• Navigationsfähigkeit ist für beide Anwendungen eine Grundvoraussetzung
• Konzepte aus der Luftfahrt (Integrität, ..)können entsprechend übertragen werden
• Beim autonomen Fahren finden aus historischen Gründen vielfach modernere Konzepte der Navigation Einsatz (GNSS: RTK/PPP, optische Verfahren, Radar, KI, …)
371/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 37SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo HAS for Autonmous Vehicles
• High Accuracy Service• +/- 20 cm accuracy through PPP corrections
• Support of innovative applications• Autonomous vehicles
• Online System• All data computed in real-time, uplinked and broadcast from so-called connected Galileo satellites
• Data broadcast on Galileo E6 frequency• Orbits, clocks, code biases at high rate (5 – 10 s)• Phase biases at low refreshment rate (30 s – 120 s)• Data support also for GPS measurements carried out by the user (in addition to Galileo
measurements)
• Mean time to retrieve data to allow PPP computation:• Highway conditions (66 % of Galileo sats in view): 7-8 s• Urban conditions (2 Galileo sats in view): 10 – 30 s
• Status:• 2019: CS demo for system connectivity (only dummy data transmitted)• 2019: ITT published and KOM in 2nd half of 2019, draft HAS ICD published in Feb. 2019• 2020/21: engineering work ongoing
381/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 38SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo HAS – Connected Satellites
Source: Munich Satellite Navigation Summit 2018 Archive, Session 3, Galileo High Accuracy Service, Ignacio FernandézHernández, European Commission
System integrity achieved through connectivity
391/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 39SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo HAS – Comparison to other Services
Source: Munich Satellite Navigation Summit 2018 Archive, Session 3, Galileo High Accuracy Service, Ignacio FernandézHernández, European Commission
401/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 40SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo 2nd Generation
Chatre, Eric, Benedicto, Javier, "2019 – Galileo Programme Update," Proceedings of the 32nd International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of The Institute of Navigation (ION GNSS+ 2019), Miami, Florida, September 2019, pp. 650-698.
411/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 41SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo 2nd Generation
• Continuous development of Galileo (G2G) decided by EU and ESA in 2013
• Allocated budget approx. 7 Bill. EUR
• Phase A (concept phase) completed• Three different evolution scenarios analyzed
• From light-weight to major changes
• Consideration of new signals, higher power, inter satellite links
• To improve: accuracy, time-to-first fix, robustness against spoofing/jamming
• New services: Advanced timing, Space service volume, emergency warning service, improved search-and-rescue, ionospheric prediction service, ARAIM
• G2G currently in phase B0 (requirements consolidated)
• Transition Batch Satellites currently under procurement• To start testing of new technologies• Cf. Navigation Test Satellite (NTS-3) for GPS
• https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=38903.0
• Currently threes bidders: Thales, OHB, Airbus • Two will be selected to build each two satellites (=total of 4)
• Transition Ground Segment• Phase B: ongoing• Phase C/D: procurement starting in 2020
421/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 42SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Challenges of a New Generation
Chatre, Eric, Benedicto, Javier, "2019 – Galileo Programme Update," Proceedings of the 32nd International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of The Institute of Navigation (ION GNSS+ 2019), Miami, Florida, September 2019, pp. 650-698.
431/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 43SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Galileo 2nd Generation, Tech. Enablers
2020 around 340M€ (150+ contracts) in GNSS R&D, Chatre et al., 2020.
441/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 44SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
FragenAuswahl möglicher Prüfungsfragen
451/14/2020 Conference/Workshop/Event 45SatNav 2: GNSS in der Luftfahrt
Fragen inkl. Punkte
• Wie unterscheidet sich Galileo HAS vom Galileo Open Service. Nennen und beschreiben sie zwei wesentliche Merkmale? (6)
• Hinweis: Konnektivität/Uplinkrate, Genauigkeit
• Welche drei Arten von Performanz-relevanten Vorfällen gab es bei Galileo? Beschreiben Sie sie und geben Sie an, inwiefern jene für eine Nutzung von Galileo in der Zivilluftfahrt relevant sind. (6)
• Welche Rolle haben die europäische Kommission, die ESA und die GSA bei Galileo? (3)
• Erläutern sie die Begriffe Transition Batch und G2G und welche technologischen Zielsetzungen damit erreicht werden sollen (4)
• Welche Schranke wird für den horizontalen Positionierungsfehler angenommen, damit die Verfügbarkeit einer Zweifrequenz-Galileo-Positionierung als gegeben angesehen wird? Welche Zielvorgabe für die prozentuale zeitliche Verfügbarkeit an der dafür ungünstigsten Nutzerposition wird gesetzt (Juni 2019)? (2)