IJTFE 31i

t!1L4l 4T110/2015/iej4

1* 411 T. fT. —i /38 igl3T 1T f4 jp 1Ic1 114 c1k zIt[FT [[1 \iiRt 1TN fri fcpi-) 5I C'I zr T-3c1' .W

.1111

1. TcE s1kcp 19T9Iir

2. 1If T iuRt kt fi F. —121 4'1k 31c1' ......... 3TT 1TUT

cpej

.31

.1m3T. III

fi1ci, 06.06.2017 Prufzr

1. W TT 3fT fi'iv1 cp ç c (Rb), (fT 3IT4 "3T19

I'.1Ic'l'Ll" j5[ iii) cpU H. 450/2011 qftff fr'4zj f - jp

23.07.2012 'c [1FE TFeci5 3Tf1lRlT1, 1998 (f 3n4 "zrfrTzT"

cUT ii) it UM-65 I

2. WcIctTT TJ T 1CPF t JB1T2 2 f ç

1'T cf 1f 1Jf 3M 1/8 f1T m

fi1ci 3T Ick1 * T f5T TRill 3tJ LjC

ii Tf f I 3'T 'J[J * 1T1 fTDT i R'i1 90,85,050/- T)

FT qTq f5 3n-4 fcfTm T I 3tT tTlCb 1T ftT T1 Pct (r),

TZT 1 -ttc 23.07.2012 Zj 31II ZW4 TfT 3,65,555/-

g 51?I 1[1IRM TCIT 32,260/— .5L{ TfTTTO 36,555/- Wftff 58,640/— .1fI 9FT TfT 4,93,010/— qROf 3[Tt 31TT Tf[

(t), 3MR 3IT1 f icf 23.07.12012

FT ZT f T[p TTV Zft T[

3. 3wrtTT

4. IFT ZF2Tff fT TRIT f45 3T1T T 2 TT Tq 1/8 fj W,Fr fm 90

2.

—:2:— fI'I'- ll-110/2o15/3f

-ci c 9 116 t9Icp 08.03.2010 I J *, m cuft 14

t 1~IicP 08.04.2011 q t 13,44,000/— 1ri cr 451) .l ci' 1'-t Ici -1 I 90,85,050 /- JTR (ic), m 1ci Ri I ci'c (cici'), cici' q 3thI f-iii' 23.07.2012 TT 3T qycp ]J 1Iffçf 3BT cpk ci'

-cFt ,cUcP Tft1 3,65,555/— '44, 5' 4R1 -I 32,260/- *1Is1 36,555/— 7w4 wrf LcT 58,640/— 'T i1 TiTT ft 4,93,010/—

cN1cl f 1T * 311T giRci f, f iff ci'uj 31LlI fi Tt tm t i ftm 3ftwi m ci' ct (, 31 ci c rT ffff

l 1 I i-fl cT5T fv1 fcFWTFZiT I ]T2T t PV9TRT 1rci' ]J -t'IcT 9IRIc1 ccN1Ifti' zfi ITT

fRT TTT M I f ij f f

Zf5

45h-1 5T 311 ' Y i 1bi, TT I ci' TT 1T2f qi fr 9lT Z5T 31cl fz TWRit4 014qA qRt ii ffkff

\3ilc1 1I-i LP1 ci'k qR f T?1TI fi'i am jr

TU?1T f45 Cbçc 1T FtI ft -urt f T1T qTg i1è tR ci,Iki

I T l ci'i ci' ctc TT Wftci 311 JZT

3T iic gm s-q ftT R*.) 37TR Non Speaking 3flT TT ci'I fr TmT I Tffz pf Rct

- 4rq iT 1, i TMT f 3'I q l ci' UM VTffTrff 'nj r cI ci (1 I ci' T 1l l ci' ' ci, T:ffF .l'sN, H 4-qf it 4q5T ffr

311I IIz1c1 Tt iI- zii1 I 'YM -1sp plo jç4 f

t 31icic.i t1 T21T 3T 1Ic l5t 31IciI ñl.1r2

ftl RI TMT ti '34: .I1I&4 Tf {FET31f

3{1a1T tR cIci'I fT 'iThil fifi '11c1 qt ti "ici1 ciclim-j vTqTm

1-0 q f4Rft 4ci'1 m cLIcI*H{lci' lTftftf4 -'dt1I1 qt t I TffE 3'I Ci'c TT w-j[ 'Tf I5 c!.lci1I{cp 1Ii bT1 m

\3ç ci'kuñ 5"t 3csf fR1T TFzrT 9 3: 1II4

I 3Efff 9 Th2T ftF 3IIT 1T fkT IR f5 IT Z5T 1 cf4TM TMT I

eiIIc1I .....................3.

—:3:—

5. 3TW4 T-U*cl '3 1TfT ff 3-q c) 3TJ TT 52Jf 1[ TMT f fh 1ii'1 * 1I' cPRl*c f 1IciT 3IlT

fi Tf{ j Tffz~

II f47M TMT

ftTM \Tq &fF fT flcbT fur R

5-T1 f j T[J

6. Rvr I'.iic1 5T ZIPT * f5 1T4TTU1 r ,-iclI T fn 1TITI WOTm q r urt i1è urt f T{ 6IIChY \ c1I4)i

TTuI * 3T9W I-lIciT 9M IT T1TfT f P1T f f cjj{ ç T

{li 3'T I\Azmq &1TtfT5 fT f5 1iiftzi 01/09 fjjp

01.09.2010 JTtTffR vTqTrc1r ii-i1t 5J uTTffrftEF y1cj fjfr 1c 20 TZ it 41 C, R I Trc5 3PT qTPT 5' ciIFl{r'L1cf 9Nicp eflci5T fn

-jTm *1 3Tr: ctcicr (cUcP), 31Q1C1 gm '-iiIci 3ITF I 1TTE mThiui Pi) cti f zñ' *

7. 3WT'4T T 99 fcFm TmT up4T Y I ci c') T (3I ci eli Ct, '1 f8m TFm I 8. I_kVct,c1f m 1i &I1TT CThT 5 Z TMTff 1*cjcl qT49T

'3 ciRlici aTTh? '1 A -i co fii Tfr{ t[

f5 51TT ç HT {bi '311c11 * T2T lcfr

—:4:— fii'-1 l-11O/2O15/3g

ii1b cpc t 3Tf[ {1dci&r1 3i1bi wm 0 &r fufq YIIc1 {1I iiNii --Erftt 21T! T

1t9I 1c iIci 1i TFZrT ctctc 3fl{ Zm T1FTT 31Ii T1

51T '-Jcç ti I lIcpc1 1ICM c1IIM .3Tft9T RIIe14

ITT t Hci Ri 7Cpl4ZT cN4c1I i' rr j

'WI9T 4-ftHrjF RT *1IIcT Cp'jl IyM1- ZJ fb1

cp) J 9N Wtf 9t -cb7 'dcPclIf 3fff1?[ 31IT fIICf 28.01.2013

cicpi iir 3 c1ci 9t fbii TrZ1T t l

Rc Tcuq&fm -CT-)T4 1 q-)I' c irm

r -IcbdnI

13. 3TThR2T - IIc4 &[fi[ 31II {1ICr.i 23.07.2012 TT 95T I?Zf Zm

cpk fll t fb Z 3Tf1T Zl I'H J I(P iN 2004

ct,kUJ I1Z4ii 5T &RT Te *1 TTUT VWWc,M 115T Z[ lIc'I qT 15

3cj T1TT N- ,c1 !,cp. UJ 3ciI'i T1R 31'1 i11 Ii'ii l5

0 I ' 'R - i 2Z1t tl 311TftT 3TT 9T i c ct -1 I t I

Tf II "H' 3T9T 3II'I * ft'c 3u1 T t{

T'FftTT -LIILlIc-1 3T'FIT fu1.i '-iiRci 7ic4) f & 3 /-nic

l5T Pi4-i 3TT?.1T [ 14c 41I-I II

a

—:5:— —1 10 / 2015 /

cause Of justice as well as avoids uncertainty. As a matter of fact it helps in the observance of law of precedent. Absence of reasons on the contrary essentially introduces an element of uncertainty, dissatisfaction and give entirely different dimensions to the questions of law raised before the higher appellate Courts. When reasons are announced and can be weighed, the public can have assurance that process of corection is in place and working. It is requirement of law that correction process of judgments should not only appeaaar to be implemented but also to have been properly implemented. Reasons for an order would ensure and enhance public confidence and would provide due satisfaction to the consumer ofjustice under our justice dispensation system."

14. r [I5T 3Tft9 1T4TRTT TT Non Speaking Tt Non Reasoned 3ITT .iiRc f 1f J 3f: 3Taft9T 9M ITftT 31TT ffffizU 23.07.2012

iir 1T rr fcffqT Tfff Tr2TT WffTrUJ 3IT I TF9f f ffgfcT

23.07.2012 ftruur t * riZUT

fi RT t ?T 3TW TTT TrftrT

POi* ffnr q5T ?tftT urt fç

ff 111T fllT fTt 20.04.2012 ZJ5' fTt5 15.05.2012 5't 3qftQJf T14T 3ITt fzJT TIZ1T PT, VT ñftT 25.05.2012 m f1Ti 25.06.2012 qr

f fT r

If fT ThT T M#r& 1J

* t[ tRT 79t * I 3I1I[ 31T1 Non Speaking tt Non Reasoned 31TT * T1ct5T?f Z F1 q f[9T rf

TTc * I fWT 65(2) * wirff * 3J i I - I L4 RPT TT Y I ft ft ffini t wcm

f 1T, 2004 * 65 *

f ifl : ftf9T VffITUJ n1t f 1 f ik zzj f

fkT & TPT 7f 15. t[fu1j q fpi- r i1

(t), 5T 1T1 f9t5 23.07.2012 z* NTT f nrr

3T TW ffFT (t), fj

S F1 Z15 RfN ffiTT 5 fPf 2004 * ThRP1 65 it 15k

1RfZJ l 02.08.2017 m I

16. f4 iirr

(fttM) 1T