1

Literatur zur Prima-facie Pflichten (Stand: 16.02.03) Jörg Schroth 1998 [1] Åqvist, Lennart (1998): Prima Facie Obligations in Deontic Logic: A Chisholmian Analysis

Based on Normative Preference Structures, in Preferences, hrsg. von Christoph Fehige und Ulla Wessels, Berlin, S. 135–55.

2002 [2] Arrington, Robert L. (2002): A Wittgensteinian Approach to Ethical Intuitionism, in Ethical Intuitionism. Re-evaluations, hrsg. von Philip Stratton-Lake, Oxford, S. 271–89.

1978 [3] Atwell, John (1978): Ross and Prima Facie Duties, Ethics 88, S. 240–49.

1997 [4] Audi, Robert (1997): Moral Knowledge and Ethical Character, New York, Oxford, S. 34–39, 279–85.

1998 [5] Audi, Robert (1998): Moderate Intuitionism and the Epistemology of Moral Judgment, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 1, S. 15–44.

1998 [6] Barcalow, Emmett (1998): Moral Philosophy. Theories and Issues, Belmont, CA, 2. Auflage, S. 199–201(“Conception of Prima Facie Duties”).

1965 [7] Baumrin, Bernard H. (1965): Prima Facie Duties, Journal of Philosophy 62, S. 736–39.

1991 [8] Beauchamp, Tom L. (1991): Philosophical Ethics. An Introduction to Moral Philosophy , Second Edition, New York, S. 188–94 (“Prima Facie Obligations”).

1994 [9] Beauchamp, Tom L./Childress, James F. (1994): Principles of Biomedical Ethics, New York, Oxford, 4. Aufl., S. 33–37, 104f.

1994 [10] Brink, David O. (1994): Moral Conflict and Its Structure, Philosophical Review 103, S. 215–47: S. 215–20.

1981 [11] Dancy, Jonathan (1981): On Moral Properties, Mind 90, S. 367–85: S. 370–73.

1983 [12] Dancy, Jonathan (1983): Ethical Particularism and Morally Relevant Properties, Mind 92, S. 530–47: S. 535f., 538–42.

1991 [13] Dancy, Jonathan (1991): An Ethic of Prima Facie Duties, in A Companion to Ethics, hrsg. von Peter Singer, Oxford, S. 219–29.

1991 [14] Dancy, Jonathan (1991): Intuitionism, in A Companion to Ethics, hrsg. von Peter Singer, Oxford, S. 411–20.

1993 [15] Dancy, Jonathan (1993): Moral Reasons, Oxford, S. 92–104.

1998 [16] Dancy, Jonathan (1998): Wiggins and Ross, Utilitas 10, S. 281–85. [Zu Wiggins (1998)]

1998 [17] Darwall, Stephen (1998): Under Moore’s Spell, Utilitas 10, S. 286–91.

1959 [18] Ewing, A. C. (1959): Second Thoughts in Moral Philosophy , London, S. 124–41.

1978 [19] Feldman, Fred (1978): Introductory Ethics, Englewood Cliffs, N. J., S. 149–59 (“Ross’s Formalism”).

1967 [20] Garner, Richard T./Rosen, Bernard (1967): Moral Philosophy. A Systematic Introduction to Normative Ethics and Meta-Ethics, New York, S. 104–9 (“W. D. Ross and Prima Facie Duties”).

1998 [21] Gensler, Harry J. (1998): Ethics. A Contemporary Introduction , London, S. 157–63.

1988 [22] Günther, Klaus (1988): Der Sinn für Angemessenheit. Anwendungsdiskurse in Moral und Recht , Frankfurt a. M., S. 261–76 („Prima facie- und definitive Normen“).

1974 [23] Hancock, Roger N. (1974): Twentieth Century Ethics, New York, S. 50–56.

2

1996 [24] Hooker, Brad (1996): Ross-Style Pluralism versus Rule-Consequentialism, Mind 105, S. 531–552.

1982 [25] Hospers, John (1982): Human Conduct. Problems of Ethics, San Diego, 2. Aufl., S. 205–12 (“Multiple Sources of Obligation”).

1983 [26] Hudson, W. D. (1983): Modern Moral Philosophy, 2. Aufl., Houndmills, S. 92–98 (“W. D. Ross”).

1966 [27] Jack, Henry (1966): More on Prima Facie Duties, Journal of Philosophy 63, S. 521–23.1 [Zu Shope (1965)]

1971 [28] Jack, H. J. (1971): Utilitarianism and Ross’ Theory of “Prima Facie” Duties, Dialogue 10, S. 437–57.

1991 [29] Loewer, Barry/Belzer, Marvin (1991): Prima Facie Obligation: Its Deconstruction and Reconstruction, in John Searle and his Critics, hrsg. von Ernest Lepore und Robert Van Gulick, Oxford, S. 359–70.

1963 [30] McCloskey, H. J. (1963): Ross and the Concept of a ‘Prima-Facie’ Duty, Journal of Philosophy 41, S. 336–45.

1969 [31] McCloskey, H. J. (1969): Meta-Ethics and Normative Ethics, Den Haag, S. 117–19, 135–37, 220–46 (“A Positive Approach: Prima Facie Duties”).

1988 [32] McNaughton, David (1988): Moral Vision. An Introduction to Ethics , Oxford, S. 197–201.

1996 [33] McNaughton, David (1996): An Unconnected Heap of Duties?, Philosophical Quarterly 46, S. 433–47.

1998 [34] McNaughton, David (1998): Ross, William David, in Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy , hrsg. von Edward Craig, Vol. 8, London, S. 365–67.

2000 [35] Mappes, Thomas A./DeGrazia, David (2000): General Introduction, in dies. (Hrsg.), Biomedical Ethics, 5. Aufl., New York, S. 1–55: S. 24–27 (“W. D. Ross’s Theory of Prima Facie Duties”).

1977 [36] Melden, A. I. (1977): Rights and Persons, Berkeley, S. 4–12.

1988 [37] Melden, A. I. (1988): Rights in Moral Lives. A Historical-Philosophical Essay, Berkeley, S. 92–97.

1940 [38] Muirhead, J. H. (1940): The New Deontology, Ethics 50, S. 441–49.

1998 [39] Norman, Richard (1998): The Moral Philosophers. An Introduction to Ethics , 2. Aufl., Oxford, S. 98–100, 161f.

1954 [40] Nowell-Smith, P. H. (1954): Ethics, Harmondsworth, S. 27–32, 252–54.

1992 [41] Pietroski, Paul M. (1992): Prima Facie Obligations, Ceteris Paribus Laws in Moral Theory, Ethics 103, S. 489–515.

1993 [42] Rosen, Bernard (1993): Ethical Theory. Strategies and Concepts, Mountain View, Cal., S. 138–50.

1930 [43] Ross, W. D. (1930): The Right and the Good, Oxford; Reprint: Indianapolis 1988: S. 18–36, 41f., 58, 61–64, 138.

1 “In this reply to Robert Shope three points are made: (1) that the interpretation of “prima facie”/actual duties

in terms of good moral reasons/conclusive reasons is not new; (2) while Shope’s term “moral demand” confuses ross’ “prima facie”/actual obligation distinction, nevertheless Shope is correct in saying that Ross is ambiguous (contrary to a previous criticism by Baumrim), and the present author favors the line that “prima facie” obligations are real obligations which continue to exist even when over-ridden; (3) that the notion of “exception to a “prima facie” duty” seems to be either senseless or artificial which poses a somewhat different problem about “exceptions” than the one Shope claimed to find in Ross.”

3

1939 [44] Ross, W. D. (1939): Foundations of Ethics, Oxford, S. 84–86.

1998 [45] Schaber, Peter (1998): Ross’ ethischer Pluralismus, in Jean-Claude Wolf und Peter Schaber, Analytische Moralphilosophie, Freiburg, S. 105–7.

1991 [46] Schauer, Frederick (1991): Playing by the Rules. A Philosophical Examination of Rule-Based Decision-Making in Law and Life, Oxford, S. 113–15.

1978 [47] Searle, John R. (1978): Prima Facie Obligations, in Practical Reasoning, hrsg. von Joseph Raz, Oxford, S. 81–90. Erweiterte Fassung in Philosophical Subjects, hrsg. von Z. van Straaten, Oxford 1980, S. 238–59.

1999 [48] Shaw, William H. (1999): Contemporary Ethics. Taking Account of Utilitarianism , Oxford, S. 21–24 (“Ross’s Commonsense Pluralism”), 112–14.

1988 [49] Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter (1988): Moral Dilemmas, Oxford, S. 97–102 (“Prima Facie”).

1965 [50] Shope, Robert (1965): Prima-Facie Duty, Journal of Philosophy 62, S. 279–86. [Vgl. dazu Jack (1966)]

1974 [51] Snare, Frank (1974): The Definition of Prima-Facie Duties, Philosophical Quarterly 24, S. 235–44.

2000 [52] Stratton-Lake, Philip (2000): Kant, Duty and Moral Worth, London, S. 78–91 (“Filling Out the Details: Ross’s Theory of prima facie Duties”).

2002 [53] Timmons, Mark (2002): Moral Theory. An Introduction, Lanham, S. 192–97.

1978 [54] Warnock, Mary (1978): Ethics since 1900, Third Edition, Oxford, S. 39–44.

1999 [55] Weinberger, Ota (1999): Prima Facie Ought. A Logical and Methodological Enquiry, Ratio Juris 12, S. 239–51.

1998 [56] Wiggins, David (1998): The Right and the Good and W. D. Ross’s Crticism of Consequentialism, Utilitas 10, S. 261–80. [Vgl. dazu Dancy (1998)]

1995 [57] Zimmerman, Michael J. (1995): Prima Facie Obligation and Doing the Best One Can, Philosophical Studies 78, S. 87–123.

1996 [58] Zimmerman, Michael J. (1996): The Concept of Moral Obligation, Cambridge, S. 5–10 (“Overall and prima facie obligation”), S. 141–88 (“Prima facie obligation).

1998 [59] Zoglauer, Thomas (1998): Normenkonflikte – zur Logik und Rationalität ethischen Argumentierens, Stuttgart-Bad Canstatt, S. 116–24 („Prima-facie-Pflichten“).