uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

66

Transcript of uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Page 1: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

������������ ����������������������������� ������ !#"$�%�#�'&��(*) �+&����,%�� .-/�%�'�'���01�� ��� ( ���2�',�3�465 78&��0�'�9:�����2�'1�'� �;�<�%"*���*7

=2>?=�@BADC0EFG@BHJI�KLI�MNI2O�PM?Q2RTSBC0UDQ�C I�KVH�W�S?CYX�S[ZNH\K^]_B> `a> b1U[C0I\S?C0ced�@?K^fgC0Q�HhK^IiPj I2k?Q j @?]lOmM?Q\In2cGoDpgpgqsr�k?Q j @?]lOmM?Q\Iut$v j [email protected]\y j @[Z

z {l|~}N�?��������}?�J�~|

RTS?KVH��+S j$� I�C0Q'K�H��NCxfDU$I�Cx�%I\UYUgQ\�?K^I j ELcG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lI'C �?W�S j @?ADC0ceW0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@��m�NWi��OmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j EVHxw j W0UD@BW0C � I���S?K�W�S�S j H j IhI�Q j WuI\Ci��y�UDQ�C j @B��y�UgQ\C j I\I\C0@lI�K^Ug@6�NM?Q�KV@?A�I�S?CE j HJI��xp6ZDC j Q�H0>��O�I�C0Q j OmC0� � Q�C0EVK^y�KV@ j Q�Z�Q\Cxy j Q�][Hxw��S?K�W�S�W0E j Q\K^OmZ�I\S?C�H�W U � C�U$OI\S?K�H�Q�C0f[KVC0� j @B��K^@lI\Q�UN�NMBW0CYI\S?C%� j H\KVW�@?U$I j I\KVUD@�w�H\UDy�C�y�U$I�K^f j I�K^Ug@���K^EVE���C;ADKVfDC0@��SlZ�H\MBW�S�KVy � E^K�W K^IY�NC0@BH\K^IJZ�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H j Q�C�U$O~�NC0 B@?K^I\C�K^@lI�C0Q�CxHhIxw�K^@�H � K^I\C;U$O�I�S?CO j WuI�I�S j I�UD@?C¡S j H%I�U�W0U � C���KLI�S j �B�NKLI�K^Ug@ j E�W0UDy � EVKVW j I\KVUD@�H¡�¢W Ugy ��j Q�Cx��I�U6I�S?CHJI j @B� j Q����?Wuc£OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVH��u>�RTS?C�� j HhK�W�K��NC j UDO'UDQ��?KLI j E^ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@lI2�?Wuc£OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�HKVH�I\S?Cx@�K^EVEVMBHJI�Q j I\Ci���lZ;I\SBC2y�UgHhI+HhKVy � EVC j @��¤w j I�I\S?C1H j y�CTI\KVy�Cgwgy�UlHJI~KVy � UgQhI j @lIOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EBU$O�I\S?K�HIJZ � Cgw$I�S?C�C � j W I'C �?W�S j @BADCTU$O¤�NC0@�HhK^IJZ�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j ENI�S?C0UgQ\Z��¢n�kR¥ OmUDQ j Q�C0f[K^Cx�¦H\C0C�CD> AB>�§^� ¨.UDQ��+S j$� I�C0QY�i� >

b1K^fgC0@6H\UDy�C�UDQ��?K^I j E^cG�NC � C0@B�?C0@lI��?W c¢OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E'©Tª «�I\SBC; �Q�HhI�¬lM?CiHJI�K^Ug@�I�U���Cj �?�NQ�CxH�H\Cx��K�H�I\S?C�Cxf j E^M j I\KVUD@6U$O+I\S?C­W UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A�y%M?E^I\K � EVKVW j I\KVfDC��?Wuc � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E® ª «i>gRTS?KVH�KVH � UlH\H\K^�BE^C�f[K j I�S?C1¯ � I�K^y�KV°0Ci��XUDI\Cx@gI�K j E?v�C I�S?UN��±��e¯1X~v��T§ ²Nw ³s¨B��SBKVW�SKVHT�NCiH\W0Q\KV��Ci�­KV@¡´[CiWuI\KVUD@�²N>N��O�I�C0Q j @�UDMNI�E^KV@?C�U$O.I�S?Q\CxC1�?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI�HJI�Q j I\C0AgK^CiH'OmUgQ+I�S?C�NC0Q�K^f j I\KVUD@­U$O¶I�S?C�W0Q\MBW0K j E�¯1X~v·KV@lI\CxADQ j E?Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@�w j OmCx�¸C � j W I�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@BH�OmUDQ�I�S?C¯1X~v·�?Wuc � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E j Q\C1HhMBy�y j Q\KV°0Ci�¤>DFG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@�wDI�S?C1¹�Q�KVC0ADCxQhcGº.K^ceF j OmQ j I\CY�¢¹Yº.Fh�j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@6§ r$¨¤I�U�I\S?C;¯1X+v¼KV@lI\C0AgQ j E¤Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@¡KVH � Q�CxH\C0@lI�Cx�¤>

¯�@BW C¡UD@?C¡S j H j E^E�� j H\KVW�K^@BADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�H�UDO2I\S?K�H�I\SBK^Q��½AgC0@?CxQ j I\KVUD@¾UDO1n1kR¿I\UDcADC I�S?C0Qiw¶KLI�K�H�fgC0Q�Z�K^@BHhI\Q�MBW I\KVfDC;I\U j @ j E^Z[°0C%I\S?C�C �?W�S j @?ADC0c£Ug@?EVZ��m�lceUD@BE^Z?��E^KVy�KLIiw¤K^@��S?KVW�S�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�K�HT@?C0AgE^CiWuI\Ci��W0UDy � EVC I\CxE^ZgwNK^@�H\UDy�CY�NC I j KVE��¢´[CiWuI\KVUD@�³g� >�¯�@�I�S?CUD@?C1S j @��¤wlI\S?C�HhKVy � EVC�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�OmUDQ�y¿U$O.I�S?C1C � j W I�C0�NW�S j @?AgC j @B��KLI�H�M?@?KVfDC0Q�H j Ej$�?� EVK�W j �BK^EVKLIJZ j EVEVUs�2H j ¬lM j @lI\K^I j I\KVfDC2C0� j y�K^@ j I\KVUD@�UDO�I�S?C�¹Yº�F jD�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I�K^Ug@%OmUgQj f j Q�K^C0IJZ�U$O�H\ZNHJI�C0y­H0>�FG@�I\SBKVH�� j Z�UD@?C%W j @�C0� � E^K�W K^I\EVZ�fgC0Q�KLOmZ�I\SBC�S?KVADS j W0W MBQ j W ZU$O¤I\SBC1¹Yº�F j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\[email protected]��S?KVW�S�y j ]DCiH�K^I j @�K^y � UDQ\I j @gI+I\U[UDE�OmUDQ+I\SBC jD�?� EVKVW j cI\KVUD@­U$O¶UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lI'�?Wuc£OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVHx>l¯�@�I\S?C�U$I\SBC0Q�S j @B�¤wsI�S?C2C0� j WuI'�[ceUD@?EVZQ\CiHhM?E^I�H�W j @���C�M�HhCi�¡I\U�KV@[fDCxHhI\KVA j I\C�I�S?C � Q�U � C0Q\I\KVCxH2U$OI\S?C�HJI j @B� j Q���OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�HE^KV]DCYI�S?C%EVUNW j EÀ�NCx@BHhK^IJZ j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@��ÁºÀn2���%§ qs¨ j @��¡I\S?C;ADC0@BC0Q j EVK^°xCx�¡ADQ j �NKVC0@lIj$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@6�£bYb����Y§ o»Â¶�iqs¨£>Ã~ÄÅlÆ�ÇYÆ\ÈJÅlÉ$Ê�ËLÌ�ÌGÉxÇYÆ�ÈJËÍÇYÆ�Ì~ÎxÏÍÌGÉ�ÈJÆ�ÐJÇYÆuÊ;Ñ�ÒgÈJËÍÇYËÍÓ�ÆuÊ%Ô.Õ?Æ�Ö�ÈJËÍ×»Æ2ضÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏÀÚÁÑTÔÀØÀÛ\Ü

Page 2: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

RTS?C%H\Z[HhI\Cxy j I\K�W��NCxQ\KVf j I�K^Ug@�U$O�KVy � E^K�W K^I1W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�KVH��NKVH�W M�H\H\Cx�K^@ ´[CxW I\KVUD@½r�>FG@ �Bj QhI�KVW0M?E j Qxw � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@�I\SBC0UDQ�Z�UD@½I\S?C¡� j H\K�H;UDO�I\S?C�¹�UgS?@Nc´[S j y �¢¹�´?��� j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @½§^�xosÂ����s¨�K�H1MBHhCi��I\U¡�NC0Q�KVfDC j @�C � j WuI�Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmUDQ�©Tª «»>RTS?KVH�C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@ KVH�I�S?C0@¸C0� �Bj @B�?Cx�½I\U¾H\CxW Ug@B��UDQ��NC0Q�KV@�I\S?C�CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@Nc£CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@W UDM � E^KV@?A¡W UD@�HJI j @lI��%KV@�UgQ��NCxQ2I�U�Ug�NI j K^@�I�S?C%y�UlHJI�HhKVy � E^C; BQ�HJI\c � Q\KV@BW K � EVCxH�W UDQ\cQ\CxE j I\KVUD@�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j EY§L���s¨e>'RTS?C¡W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��NK^@BA�¯1X~v KV@lI\CxADQ j E�Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@ j H%��C0EVEj H�C0�lI�C0@BH\KVUD@BH�EVKV]DCYI�S?C�� j @B�NUDy·X�S j H\C�� �?� Q�U»�NK^y j I�K^Ug@�� �2X¤�1��§^���?w ²$p$¨ j @B�¡I�S?CFG@gI�C0Q j W I\KVUD@�´lI\Q�C0@?ADI\S¡FG@lI\C0Q � UDE j I\KVUD@��mFh´NFh��§ ²?� ¨ j Q�C j E�HhU�KV@gI�Q\UN�NM�W Cx�.>

RT�+U�H\C0y�K^c£Cxy � K^Q�KVW j E�UDQ��?KLI j E^ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@lI��?Wuc£OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H j Q\C2Q�C0f[KVC0��Cx��KV@�´[CxW cI\KVUD@�qN>���U$I\S�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�S j ����CxC0@­KV@�I\S?C�E^K^I\CxQ j I\M?Q�CTOmUDQ�¬lM?KLI�C�H\UDy�C�I\KVy�C2��C OmUDQ�CKLI~� j HQ�C j E^KV°0Ci��I�S j I~I\S?CxZ;H\S?UDM?E�����C�M?@B�NCxQ�HhI\U[UN� j H'KVy � E^K�W K^I+�NCx@BHhK^IJZ�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�HK^@¡I\SBC%H j y�C�H\C0@�HhC j H�I\S?CYC0� j WuI�C �?W�S j @?ADCg>?RTS?C� BQ�HJI�Ug@?CYKVH�I\S?C�H\C0E^O�c£KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@W UDQ�Q�CxWuI�Cx� �¢´NF\�T��OmUDQ�y�U$OTI\S?C¡º�n2� § ²g²»¨ew.I\SBC�H\CxW Ug@B��UD@?C�KVH�I\S?C��+UDEVE^C0cG´ j E^fgC I\I\KW UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E�§ ²D³s¨e>

kÀKV@ j E^EVZDw~I\S?C � CxQhOmUgQ\y j @�W C�U$OYI�S?C � Q\CiHhCx@gI�E^Z j f j KVE j �?E^C�K^y � EVKVW0KLI�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�K�H¡HJI�MB�NKVCx�¸KV@ ´[CxW I\KVUD@ oB>~FG@ ��j Q\I\K�W M?E j Qiw'I\SBC6H\MBW0W0CxH�H­U$OYI�S?C� BQ�HJI\c� Q\KV@BW0K � EVCxH � CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVfDC�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EÀ��KLI�S�I\S?C;�NCxH�W Q�K � I\KVUD@�U$O'�NK�H � C0Q\cHhKVUD@�OmUDQ�W CiHKVH~�NC0y�UD@�HJI�Q j I\Cx�¡§ ²sr$¨e>l¯�@�I\SBC�U$I\SBC0Q�S j @B�¤wsI�S?K�HOmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EBEVC j �BH�I\U j�NK^fgC0Q�ADCx@gI2W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@ � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�K^@�I�S?C�W j HhCYUDOÀ B@BKLI�C%HhZNHhI\Cxy�H%§ ²gq»¨e>?RTS?KVH�O j KVE^M?Q�C� Q\Ugy � I�H j @ j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\C�S j @B�NEVK^@BA�U$OBI\S?C j H�HhUNW0K j I\Cx�%¯1X+v¿KV@gI�C0AgQ j EgCi¬gM j I\KVUD@%K^@I\S?C�H � K^Q�KLI�U$O¤I�S?C1¹Yº�F j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\[email protected]��S?KVW�S j fDUDK��?H�I\S?C j H\Z[y � I\U$I�KVW��NK^fgC0Q�ADCx@BW Cj @B� � Q�U[�?MBW CiH�W UDy �Bj Q j I\KVfDCxE^Z j W0W MBQ j I\C j I\Ugy�KVW�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@ � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�H0>

RTS?C2HJI j I�MBH'U$O¶KVy � E^K�W K^I'OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVH'K�H�H\M?y�y j Q�K^°xCx��K^@�´[CiWuI�K^Ug@��N>$FG@ j �?�?KLI�K^[email protected]%K�H%H\S?Us��@�I\S j I�I�S?C�W Ug@BW C � I�U$O�KVy � E^K�W K^I�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�H�K�HY@?U$I;Q\CiHJI�Q\K�WuI�Cx�6I\U�I�S?C�NW c£Cx@?C0Q�ADZgws�?MNI+W j @­Ci¬gM j EVE^Z;�+CxE^E?��C jD�?� EVK^Ci��I\U�H\MBW�S�¬lM j @lI\K^I\KVCxH j HI�S?C�²»c �Bj QhI�KVW0E^C�NC0@BH\K^IJZD>�FG@�I�S?K�H%� j Z�KVy � E^K�W K^I�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�H � Q�Usf[KV�NC j W0W0CxH�H�I\U�¬lM j @lI\K^I\KVCxH���SBKVW�Sj Q�C1��C0ZgUD@B��I\SBC�I\Q j �NK^I\KVUD@ j E¤Q\C j EVy¿U$O'n�kR�>

����� ������� ��� � !#"$��� ��%�"&!(')!#*&+�"$+���*�!

kÀKVQ�HJI2UDO j E^E£w j OmC0� ��UDQ��?HTUD@¡I�S?C�H\W0U � CYU$OI\SBKVH�Q�C0f[KVC0� HhCxC0y I\U­��C j$�?� Q\U � Q\K j I�CD>k?UDQ�H\K^y � EVKVW0KLIJZgw j EVE�C0� � E^K�W K^I�OmUDQ�y%M?E j C�K^@½I\S?K�H��+S j$� I�C0Q���K^EVET��C�AgK^fgC0@�OmUgQ�H � KV@NcH j I\M?Q j I�Cx��H\Z[HhI\Cxy­H2UD@BE^Zg>¤¯�O~W0UDM?Q�HhCgw?I�S?C;W0UDy � EVC I\C%OmUDQ�y j EVKVH\y#W j @���C;C0�[I\C0@��NCx�I\U�H � K^@?ce�NCx@BH\KLIJZ�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E¤I\S?CxUDQ�Z6�£´Nn�kR2� j @B� j EVE.@[M?y�C0Q�K�W j E�Q\CiHhM?E^I�H�OmUDQ�H � KV@Nc� UgE j Q\KV°0Ci��H\Z[HhI\Cxy­H�AgK^fgC0@6K^@6I\S?K�H �BjD� CxQY�+CxQ\C;UD�NI j KV@?Cx�6�[Z�´Nn�kR8W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@BHx>FG@ j �?�?KLI�K^[email protected]�S?C��NK�H�W MBH�HhKVUD@�K�H%Q�CxHhI\Q�K�WuI\Ci��I\U�I�S?C�@BUD@?Q�C0E j I�K^f[K�HJI�KVW�OmUgQ\y j EVK�Hhy ¥OmUDQ�KLI�H�Q\CxE j I\KVf[KVHhI\K�W­OmUgQ\y H\C0C��+S jD� I\CxQ�³B>�RTS?C¡W0UD@BW0C � I�U$O1K^y � EVK�W K^I�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�HS j H j E�H\U%��C0C0@�C �[I\Cx@B�NCi�­I\U;I\KVy�C cG�NC � C0@��NC0@lI � S?Cx@?UDy�C0@ j I�U;��S?K�W�S��+S j$� I�C0Q�r;K�H�NC0fgU$I\Ci�¤>ÀRTSBC � Q�CxH\C0@lI;�NK�H\W0MBH�[email protected]�UD@�I\SBC�U$I�S?C0Q;S j @��¤w.OmUNW M�HhCiH%W Ugy � E^C0I\CxE^Z�UD@ADQ�UDM?@B�¡HhI j I�C � Q\Ug�?EVC0y­H0w j H\H\M?y�KV@?A%I�S?K�H2HJI j I�C�I\U���CY@BUD@NcG�NC0AgC0@?CxQ j I\C�� j @B��M�HhKV@?AI\S?C���UDQ�@Nch¯ �?� C0@?S?CxK^y�CxQ j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@�KV@�I\S?C�W j H\C�U$O � UgE^Zlc j I�UDy�KVW�H\ZNHJI�C0y­H�� >RTS?C � Q�CxH\C0@lI j I\KVUD@�KVHOmMBQhI�S?C0Q�y�UDQ�C�Q\CiHJI�Q\K�WuI�Cx�%I\UY°0CxQ\U1I�C0y � CxQ j I\M?Q�CD>,�2Us��C0fDCxQxw»I�S?CC �[I\Cx@BHhKVUD@�I\U� B@?K^I\C;I\Cxy � C0Q j I�M?Q�C;CiH\H\C0@lI\K j EVEVZ¡Q�Cx¬lM?KVQ�CxH�I\S?C j$�?� Q\U � Q\K j I�C�Q�C � E j W0C cy�Cx@lI2U$O�I�S?CYUNW0W0M �Bj I�K^Ug@�OmMB@BWuI�K^[email protected]�/[>

Page 3: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ FG@�UDQ��NC0Q�I�U�K^@lI�Q\UN�NMBW0C­I\SBC�@?U$I j I�K^[email protected]�@?Us� I\SBC�� j HhK�W�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@BH�U$O2n�kR j Q\C

HhM?y�y j Q�KV°0Cx�.w?HJI j Q\I\KV@?A���KLI�S�I�S?C�¹�´�Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@BH § q»¨ew� ��� ²���� ®�� ��������� / ��������� / � / ������� �h�i�

RTS?Q\UgM?ADSBUDMNI�I\S?K�H�W UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@�� / j @B� � / j E^� j ZNH��NCx@?U$I�C%I�S?C�¹�´�UDQ��?K^I j E�H j @B�C0KVADC0@[f j EVM?CiH0w?Q�CxH � CxWuI�K^fgC0EVZD>���H2M�HhM j E¢wBI\S?C%I\UDI j E�¹�´ � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E ®�� K�H2AgK^fgC0@��[Z�I�S?CHhM?y U$O�I\S?C�C �[I\CxQ\@ j E.�m@[MBW0E^C j Qu� � UDI\C0@lI�K j E ®�! ª#" wsI\SBC�� j QhI�Q\CxC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E ®�$ j @��%I�S?C�NW c � U$I�C0@lI\K j E ® ª «»w

® � �����%� ® ! ª#" ���¶� � ® $ ����� � ® ª « ����� �£²D�

®�$ �����&� � ('*)+-,/.�0 ��� . �1 � � � . 1 �¢³g�

® ª «s���¶�2�43 © ª « § 0 ¨3 0 ����� � �Árl�

RTS?C��NC0@�HhK^IJZ�K�H�UD�NI j KV@?Cx���[Z�H\M?y�y�KV@?A­M � I�S?CYC0@?CxQ\AgC I�KVW j EVE^Z­EVUs�+CiHJI�¹�´¡HJI j I�CxHxw

0 ���¶���65 / - / 1 � /N����� 1 87 �£qD�

��S?KVW�S�K�HTK^y � EVC0y�Cx@gI�Cx�¡f[K j I�S?CYUNW0W M �Bj I�K^Ug@�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@

- / � � ��OmUgQ9� /;: �=<p�OmUgQ9� <?> � / 7 �¢og�

��KLI�S@�=<���CxK^@?A�I\SBC�kBC0Q�y�K�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ¾�A�=<6K�H j EV� j ZNH�KV�NCx@lI\K^ BCx����KLI�S�I�S?C�C0KVADC0@[f j EVM?C� $CBEDFB U$O?I�S?CTS?K^AgS?CxHhI'UNW0W M � K^Ci�%¹�´%HJI j I\C»�u>$RTS?C+I\UDI j ENC0@?CxQ\AgZ�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E[K�HADKVfDC0@�lZ

©G"�HI"x§ 0 ¨C�KJ � § 0 ¨ � © ! ª#"u§ 0 ¨ � © $ § 0 ¨ � ©�ª «»§ 0 ¨ML � ©FN H=OQPR� � �$�

FeI�H2W0UDy � Ug@?C0@lI�H j Q�C�I�S?C�¹�´�]lKV@?C0I\K�W�C0@?CxQ\AgZDw

J � § 0 ¨�� � �²S� 5 / -�/ ' )T+-, ��U/ ����� � � /?����� 7 ���g�

I\S?CYC0�lI�C0Q�@ j E � U$I�C0@lI\K j E¤Cx@?C0Q�ADZgw

© ! ª#" § 0 ¨�� ' )+V, ® ! ª#" ����� 0 ���¶� 7 ���g�

I\S?C � j Q\I\Q�C0C�C0@?CxQ\AgZDw

© $ § 0 ¨C� � ² '*)+V,8'%)T+W,/. 0 ���¶� 0 ��� . �1 � � � . 1 7 �J�ipg�

X9Y£Ù�ÎxÏÍÏ[Z�ÉxÐJÇ\�lÏLÎxÆ\]^;_a`cb ��DÈ8dfe_a` e_hg ËÍÌ8�lÌGÆuÊ?Ü

Page 4: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

j @B�½I\S?C��?W c£Cx@?C0Q�ADZ¾©Tª «s§ 0 ¨2��S?K�W�S�K�H­�NC0 B@?Cx���[Z½=+¬�>�� �D�u>'FG@�I\SBC�W j H\C�U$O � UDEVZlcj I\Ugy�KVW­H\ZNHJI�C0y­H�Ug@?C­S j HYI\U j �?�6I\S?C�CxE^CiWuI�Q\UlHJI j I\K�W�Q�C � M?E�H\K^Ug@�UDOTI\S?C�@[MBW0E^CxK��ÁUDQK^Ug@BHTK^@ j�� H\C0MB�?U � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E¶OmQ j y�C0��UDQ�]?�uw

© N H=O � ��� ���5��� � ±

� � � � 1 � �� � 1 ��� ® ! ª#" ���¶�8� � ��� ���5

��� ±

� � � 1 � � � � 1 7 �J�g�i�

��KLI�S�I\S?C � � j @���� � �NC0@BU$I\KV@?A�I�S?CY@[MBW EVC j Q��mKVUD@?K�Wx� � UgH\K^I\KVUD@BH j @B��W�S j Q�ADCiH0>?kBUDQI\S?C�n1kR OmUDQ�y j E^K�H\y¡w¤SBUs�+CxfDC0Qiw¶I\SBKVHYE j HhI�C0@BC0Q�ADZ�W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@�K�HYK^Q�Q�C0EVC0f j @lIxwÀHhUI\S j I2KLI2K�HTUDy�K^IhI\Ci�¡K^@¡I\SBC�HhM?��HhCi¬gMBC0@lI��NK�H\W0MBH\H\KVUD@.>

����� � *�+���� "$+���*�!�� *&� *&��� � +�"&��� '#� � ��!('#��! +!��"#!$# +���*�!#" � %

RTS?C� BQ�HhI¡¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@*I\U½��C j �?�NQ�CxH�HhCi� KVH&%�`¸SlZ ��UDM?E��¸Ug@?C�I�S?K^@B] j ��UgMNI�M�HhKV@?AUDQ��?KLI j E^ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@lI­OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�Hxw~ADKVfDCx@�I\S?C�I�Q\Cxy�C0@B�NUgMBH�H\MBW0W0CxH�H­U$O�I�S?C6bYb��('RTS?C j @BH\�+CxQ�I\U I\SBKVH�¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@¦@?CxW0CxH�H j Q\KVEVZ�W0UD@BH\KVHhI�H�U$O j EVKVHhI¡UDO;H\KLI�M j I�K^Ug@BH¡K^@��S?KVW�S¡I�S?C%bYb���w?��SBKVW�S¡KVH�I\S?C�HhI j @B� j Q�����UDQ�][S?UDQ�H\C�U$O'n1k�R¦�[Z�@?Us�Yw[O j K^E�Hx>

) ��" �+* ������� ��! +�% RTS?CT �Q�HhI � Q\Ug�?EVC0yaI�UY��C�y�C0@lI�K^Ug@?Cx�;S?C0Q�CTKVH�I�S?C�EVC j HhI'K^y � UDQ\cI j @lIi>0`¸S?Cx@%W Ugy ��j Q�K^@?A�I�S?C+¬lM j E^K^IJZ�UDOBbYb���Q\CiHhMBELI�H¤OmQ�UDy �NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI�Q�C0AgK^Ug@BH¶U$ONI�S?C� CxQ\KVUN�NKVW~I j �?EVC+Ug@?C~ �@B�?HÀI\S j IÀI�S?C0Q�C�KVH j I�C0@B�?C0@BW0Z�U$O?I�S?C�bYb��½I�U�EVU[UgH\C j W0W MBQ j W Z��KLI�S;KV@BW Q�C j HhKV@?A1@[MBW EVC j Q�W�S j Q\AgC1�Á@?U$I�C�I\S j IKV@BW0Q\C j H\K^@?A1W�S j Q�ADC j MNI�UDy j I�KVW j EVE^ZYKVy�c� E^KVCxH�I�S?C � Q�CxH\C0@BW0C+UDO�S?KVADSBC0Q j @BADM?E j Q�y�UDy�C0@lI\MBy­� >gbYb���H j Q�C+][@?Us��@%I\U���C�fgC0Q�Zj W0W0M?Q j I\C�OmUDQ�E^KVADSlITy�UDEVCxW MBE^CiH0w[KV@lfgUDEVf[K^@?A;W UD@�HJI�KLI�M?C0@lI�H+OmQ�UDy/I�S?C� �Q�HhI j @B��H\CxW0UD@B�Q\Us�Y>�k?UDQ�I\S?CiHhC�HhZNHhI\Cxy�H2I\S?C�bYb���w���S?K�W�S�W Ug@BHhK�HhI\C0@lI�E^Z�HJI�Q\C0I�W�S?CiH2��UD@B��E^Cx@?A$I�SBH��, ! � j @B��Q\Ci�NMBW CiHT��Ug@B�¡C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH���- ! �TW UDy �Bj Q\Ci����K^I\S¡I\SBC�º�n2� + wBW0UDQ�Q\CiWuI�H~I�S?Cº�n2�/. H%M?@B�NCxQ\CiHJI�K^y j I�K^Ug@6UDO0, ! j @B�6I\SBC j WxW UDy �Bj @[ZlKV@?A¡UsfDCxQ\CiHJI�K^y j I�K^Ug@�UDO1- ! >�2Us��C0fDCxQxwNKV@�I\SBC%W j HhCYUDOSBC j f[Z�W Ug@BHhI\K^I\M?Cx@gI�H�I�S?C%º�n��aQ\CiHhMBELI�H j Q�CYU$O�I�C0@�Q j I\SBC0QW EVUgH\C;I�U¡I\S?C­C0� � C0Q�KVy�Cx@lI j E'@[M?y;��CxQ�Hxw.H\U�I�S j IYI�S?C�bYb��/UsfDCxQ�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI�H0>¤¯�@?C�C �[cj y � EVC�OmUDQ~I\S?K�H���C0S j f[KVUDQ�K�H~H\S?Us��@�KV@�R j �?E^C%�DwD��SBC0Q�C�I\S?C�º�n2� j @B��bYb��¸f j E^M?CiHOmUDQ+I\S?CYW UgS?CxH\KVfDC � Q�U � C0Q\I\KVCxH+U$OÀy�C0I j E^EVKVW�ADUgEV� j Q�C�EVKVHhI\Ci�¤>[FG@ �Bj QhI�KVW0M?E j Qiw$I\SBC�ºÀn2�E j IhI\K�W C�W Ug@BHhI j @lI�KVH j EVQ�C j �?Z�fgC0Q�Z j W0W0M?Q j I\Cg>l��HTHhU[UD@ j H+I\S?C1ADQ j �?K^Cx@gITW UgQ\Q�CxW I\KVUD@BHj Q�C;H\��KLI�W�S?Cx��[email protected]�I\S?C�E j IhI�KVW0C;W Ug@BHhI j @lI1KVH1C � �Bj @B�NCi� j H�MBHhM j E£w�EVC j �NKV@?A­I\U j H\KVA$c@?KL �W j @lI~CxQ\Q�UDQi>DRTS?C1H j y�C2C µ¶CxW I+K�H�UD��HhCxQ\fgCx�;OmUDQ j @[M?y%��C0Q+U$OÀq ) y�C I j EVH�§ ²��i¨ j @B�j E�HhU�OmUDQ�y�UgE^CiW M?EVCxH�W0UD@lI j K^@?KV@?A; ?O�I\S�Q�Us�*CxE^Cxy�Cx@lI�H�§ ³?�gw ³l²»¨e>

FeI'H\C0Cxy­H�+UgQhI�Sl��SBK^EVC�I\U�C0y � S j HhKV°0C�I�S j I'I�S?KVH'�?C  �W0K^Cx@BW Z;U$OBI�S?C�bYb��¸W j @;@BU$I��C�C � � E j KV@?Cx���[Z�Q\CxE j I\KVf[KVHhI\K�W�C µ¶CxW I�H&%gRTS?C�K^@�W EVMBHhKVUD@�U$O¤Q\CxE j I\KVf[KVHhI\K�W2W UgQ\Q�CxW I\KVUD@BH�K^@I\S?C�bYb�� § ³Dp$¨��NU[CxH+@?UDI~K^y � Q�UsfDC2I\S?C�Q\CiHhM?E^I�H1�ÁH\C0C�R j �?E^C;� ¥ I\S?C�OmM?EVE^Z�Q�C0E j I\KVf[KVHhcI\K�W J � j @B�6I\S[MBH�I\S?C­OmMBE^EVZ6Q�C0E j I�K^f[K�HJI�KVW­¹�´�Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@BHYS j fgC���C0Cx@ j$�B� E^KVCx��KV@ j EVEW j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@BH��u>¶RTS?K�H�UD�BH\C0Q�f j I\KVUD@�H\M?AgADCxHhI�H�I\S j I�I\S?C­bYb��8S j H�H\UDy�C;�?K32�W MBELI�K^CiH��KLI�S�I\S?C�I\Q�C j I�y�C0@lI�U$O�S?KVADS?CxQ j @BADM?E j Q�y�Ugy�Cx@lI\M?y � ) j @B�54¤� wÀH\K^y�KVE j QYI\U�I�S?Cº�n2�¿§ ³D³$¨£>6 Y£Ù6ÈJÅlËÍÌ�Ö�ÉiÙsÈGÐJË���DÈJËLÉxÙ�ÈJÅlÆ­ÒlÎ0ÐhÎxÇYÆ\ÈJÆ�ÐJËÍÓuÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ�ÉWZ87+Æ=Z¢Ü39 �;:;< ÅlÎxÌ;�NÆ�Æ�Ùh�DÈJËÍÏLËÍÓ�Æ�Ê@Z�ÉxÐ�ÎxÏÍÏÆ>=DÒlÏÍËÍÖ�Ë È@? �@A½Ö�ÎxÏÍÖ �lÏLÎ ÈJËLÉxÙlÌ�Ü

Page 5: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ �

��������� ��� ÉiÅlÆ�ÌGËL×iÆ'ÒgÐJÉiÒNÆ\ÐGÈJËLÆ�ÌÀÉWZ���ÉiÏLÊ��»Ø���� ` �����1A�×»Æ�ÐJÌ �gÌ ? �@A�ÐJÆ�Ì �gÏ ÈJÌÀÉxÙ1ÈJÅlÆ��lÎxÌGËÍÌÉWZEZ �lÏÍÏ���ÐJÆ�Ï^Î ÈJËÍ×DËÍÌeÈJËÍÖ ? A�Ø�� ÖuÎxÏÍÖ �gÏ^Î ÈJËÍÉiÙlÌ 9 ��� < ÜBÄÅlÆ2ÙgÉiÙgÐJÆ�Ï^Î ÈJËÍ×DËÍÌeÈJËÍÖ Z�ÉxÐJÇYÌ+É-Z.ÈJÅlÆGZ �lÙgÖ=�ÈJËÍÉxÙ[ÎxÏÍÌ 9 �;: b ��� < Î0ÐJÆ�Ö�ÉxÇYÒ[Î0ÐJÆ�Ê ��Ë ÈJÅ�ÈJÅlÆ�Ë Ð2ÐJÆ�ÏLÎ0ÈJËÍ×$ËÍÌeÈJËLÖ;Ö�Éc�gÙsÈJÆ�ÐJÒ[Î ÐGÈJÌ%Ú�7@? �@A b 7!���1A�Û9 � � b #" < Ü

A2� $&% '!(!)+*-,9 .�ÉiÅDÐ < 9 Æ0/ <

? � A � Ü :#� � Ü ` �7 ? � A � Ü :#� � Ü "�����1A � Ü �1� � Ü � `7!���1A � Ü �#� � Ü � �Æ>=DÒgÈuÜ � Ü :1� $Ü �2�

3 �54 "$+�� ��� � * !#% FG@�W0UD@lI\Q j HhI2I\U�I\S?K�H�E^UlH\H�U$O j W0W MBQ j W Z�OmUgQ�SBC j f[Z�CxE^Cxy�C0@lI�HxwBI�S?CHhCiW UD@�� � Q�UD�?EVC0y UDO�I�S?C�bYb���w'K^I�H�O j KVEVM?Q\C�OmUDQ�@?CxA j I\KVfDC�KVUD@�H0w'K�H�U$O1¬lM j E^K^I j I\KVfDC@ j I�M?Q\Cg>FeI�UgQ\KVADKV@ j I�CxH�OmQ\Ugy I\S?C��ÁH\C0y�K^cG�JE^UNW j E��?C0@BH\KLIJZlcG�NC � C0@��NC0@BW0C�UDO2I\SBC�ºÀn2�j @B��bYb��¿C0�NW�S j @?AgC � UDI\C0@lI�K j E¢>�RTSBC�HhK^I\M j I\KVUD@�K�HYy�UgHhI%C j HhKVEVZ j @ j E^Z[°xCx��K^@�I�S?CW j H\C�U$OÀI\S?C�ºÀn2��wNOmUgQ���S?K�W�S¡Ug@?C�S j H

®5687�9ª ������� � �Á³8: ��;< � : 0 ����� ;< � �J�»²D�

FG@�I�S?C j H\Zly � I�U$I�KVW;Q\CxADKVy�C;UDO~ B@?K^I\C­H\ZNHJI�C0y­H0w¶KV@6��SBKVW�S�I\S?C��NCx@BH\KLIJZ��NCiW j ZNH�C �[c� Ug@?C0@lI\K j EVEVZDwNUD@BC�I\S[MBH� B@B�BH j @¡C � � UD@?Cx@gI�K j E.�NCxW j Z�U$O ® 687�9ª w

0 ����� � => ?2> @!A ��B ��C � � ® 687D9ª ����� � => ?2> @EA ��B ��CGF + � �J�i³g�

RTS?C¡H j y�C�KVH;I\Q�M?C�OmUDQ;I\S?C�º�n���W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@ � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E£>v�UDQ�C0UsfDCxQxw.OmUDQ�@?C0MNI�Q j Ej I\Ugy­HYI\SBC�C0EVCxW I\Q�UgHhI j I�KVW � U$I�C0@lI\K j E+U$OTI\SBC�@[MBW EVC0M�H%W j @BW CxEVH���KLI�S�I\S?C�y�UD@?U � UgE^CI\C0Q�y�K^@ ® $ wÀ=+¬�>��Á³l�u>'�+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@gI�E^Zgw¤I\SBC­I\UDI j E ® � j E�HhU��NCiW j ZNH�O j HJI�C0QYI�S j @¸�IH , >RTS?KVH;KVy � E^KVCxH%I\S j Ixw��K^I\S?KV@�I\SBC�OmQ j y�C0��UDQ�]�UDO�I\S?C¡º�n2�%w j @?C0M?I\Q j E j I\Ugy��?UlCiH@?U$IYC �NS?KV�?K^I j ��ZN�N��C0Q�A�HhCxQ\KVCxH1U$O+C �?W K^I\Ci�6HhI j I\CxHxw j @B��I\S[MBH1K�H�@?U$I j �?E^C;I\U¡�?KV@B�j @ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@ j E¤C0EVCxW I\Q�[email protected]£> CD>NI�U�OmUDQ�y j @?C0A j I\KVfDC1KVUD@.>

RTS?KVH � Q�UD�?EVC0y·K�H j E�H\U � Q�CxH\C0@lI2OmUDQ j EVEbYb���H0w���S?UlHhC � U$I�C0@lI\K j EÀIJZ � K�W j EVEVZ¡�NC0c� Cx@B�?H�Ug@�I�S?C� BQ�HJI�IJ��U;AgQ j �NKVC0@lI�HTUDO�I\SBC��NC0@BH\K^IJZDw

® J�J�9ª § 0 ¨�� ®5J�J�9ª � 0 7 � � 0 � 7 � 0 7 � 0 K � � � 0 � ���`¸S?K^EVCYI�S?C%KV@BW EVMBH\K^Ug@�U$OI\S?CiHhC%ADQ j �NKVC0@lI�H�W j @ j µ�CiWuI2I�S?C j H\Z[y � I\UDI\K�W1OmUDQ�y�UDO�I�S?CC �?W�S j @BADC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E��OmUgQ��NC0I j K^E�H~H\C0C�´[CxW I\KVUD@�³l�uwgI\S?C�HJI j @B� j Q���OmUDQ�y8UDO¤I\S?C�bYb��KVH�KV@BW Ugy ��j I\KV�?EVC���K^I\S�I\S?C��1H , ce��C0S j f[KVUDQ~��SBKVW�S�KVH+Q\Ci¬lM?K^Q�Cx�­I\U�UD�NI j KV@ j ��ZN�N��C0Q�AHhCxQ\KVCxH�§ ³$r$¨e>N��H j W Ug@BHhCi¬lM?C0@BW0CDw?bYb���H��?U;@?UDI � Q\Ci�NK�WuITI\S?C�C0�[K�HhI\C0@�W C1U$OÀ@BC0A j I\KVfDCK^Ug@BHTC0K^I\S?CxQx>�2Us�¾H\S?UDM?E�� ® ª�Q\C j EVE^Z�EVUlUg]YE^KV]DC�KV@�I\SBC j HhZ[y � I�U$I\K�W+Q\CxADKVy�C�'TRTS?C�� j H\KVW+��C0S j flc

K^UgQ�UDO ® ª�KVH1y�UgHhI�C j H\K^EVZ�K^EVE^M�HJI�Q j I\Cx���lZ j IJ�+UDc£CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@�H\ZNHJI�C0y·EVK^]gC�I\SBC ��C0EVK^M?y

Page 6: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

: Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

j I\Ugy�>lFG@�I\S?K�HTW j HhC�I\S?C1C �?W�S j @?ADC�C0@?CxQ\AgZ��JMBHJITS j H~I�U�W j @BW0C0E�I\SBC1H\C0E^O�c£KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@K^@BW0E^M��NCx�¡KV@�I�S?C � j QhI�Q\CxC1I\C0Q�y�w

© $ !ª § 0 ¨�� � � r '%)T+W,�'%)T+W,�. 0 ����� 0 ��� . �1 � � � . 1 � �J�xrl�

RTS?C�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E.�NC0Q�K^f j I\KVfDC�U$O'© $�!ª § 0 ¨�K�HTI\SBC0@¡I\Q�K^f[K j EVE^Z�ADKVfDC0@��[Z

® $�!ª �����8� � �² '*) + , . 0 ��� .��1 � � � . 1 � �J�»qD�

�2E^I\S?UgM?ADS�I�S?C~�NCx@BHhK^IJZ��?CxW j ZNH¶C0� � UD@BC0@lI\K j EVE^Zgw ® $�!ª j H\Z[y � I\UDI\K�W j EVEVZ�ADU[CiH¶E^KV]DC � �IH , w® $�!ª ����� � => ?2> @EA � � 1 � 1 � �J�iog�

RTS?KVH � �1H , c£��C0S j f[KVUDQ�UDOYI\S?C6C � j W I ® ª K�H�OmUgM?@B�*¬lM?K^I\C6ADCx@?C0Q j EVE^Z OmUDQ j EVE2 �@?KLI�CHhZNHhI\C0y­H��¢HhCxC�´[CxW I\KVUD@�²D� >BRTS?C�H j y�C�HJI j I�C0y�C0@lI�I\SBC0@ j$�?� E^KVCxHTI�U�I\S?C�I�U$I j E ®�� w j HE^Ug@?A j H�I�S?C�HhZNHhI\Cxy KVH�@?CxMNI\Q j E£>'X�S[ZNHhK�W j E^EVZ�I\S?C¡Q�C j H\UD@¾OmUDQ�I\S?K�H�Q�CxH\M?ELI�K�H;fgC0Q�ZHhKVy � E^C %.FeO�UD@?C­CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@6y�UsfDCiHYHhM2­W0K^Cx@lI\EVZ�O j Q j � j Z�OmQ�UDy¼I�S?C­U$I�S?C0Q%C0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BH��UgM?@B�¾�[Z�I\SBC�@[MBW0E^CxMBH0w�K^I�y;MBHJI�C � � C0Q�K^Cx@BW C�I\S?C¡Q\Cxy j KV@?K^@BA�@?C0I�W�S j Q\AgC�U$O2I�S?CHhZNHhI\C0y�w.��SBKVW�S�W Ug@BH\KVHhI�HYUDO�� � �­CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@BH j @B��� � Q�U$I�UD@BHx> �2Us��C0fgC0Qiw ®�$ w j H�NC  B@BCx�Y�[ZY=~¬�>��Á³g� wxHhI\KVE^E[W Ug@lI j [email protected]\S?C��+UDM?EVUDy;�YQ\C � M?E�HhKVUD@�UDO[I\S?C�KVH\UDE j I�Cx��CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@O j Q'UDM?Ixw$��S?K�W�S�S j H�I�UY��C�CxE^KVy�K^@ j I\Ci���lZ ® ª[>g��H j W Ug@BH\Cx¬lM?C0@�W CTU$O'�J�iog�uw»I�S?C�C � j WuI®�� AgC0@?CxQ j I\CxH j ��ZN�N��CxQ\A�H\C0Q�K^CiH j @B��K�H�I\S[MBH j �?EVC~I�U1�BK^@B� j @ j �?�?KLI�K^Ug@ j E[C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@��g>

RTS?KVH j Q\AgM?y�C0@lI j H���C0EVE j H1=~¬[Hx>V�h�0rl� wV�h�iqg��KV@B�NK�W j I�C%I�S j IYUg@?C;@BC0Cx�BH j Q j I\SBC0Q@?UD@?EVUNW j E�C �?W�S j @?ADC;OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E�I\U�Q�C � Q\UN�NMBW0C�I\S?C � �IH , ce��CxS j f[K^UgQ&%¤RTS?C�W0UDy � U$c@?C0@lI+UDO ® ª ��S?KVW�S�W j @BW0C0E�H'I�S?C1H\C0E^O�ceK^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^Ug@�KV@­I�S?C�� j Q\I\Q�C0C � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�y%MBHhI~��Cj HT@?Ug@?E^UNW j E j H ® $ KLI�HhCxELOJw?��SBKVW�S¡KVH j ¬lM?K^I\CY@BUD@?EVUNW j EÀ�+UgM?EVUDy%�¡KV@gI�C0AgQ j E¢>

� ��%;� ����%�� * ! � *�� # ��% RTS?C�º�n�� j @B� bYb�� j EVH\U6O j KVETI\U�Q\C � Q�U[�?MBW C��NK�H � C0Q�HhKVUD@OmUDQ�W CxH��mUg@?C�IJZ � C;UDO�f j @6�?C0Q1` jgj E�H2OmUgQ�W0Ci�u>�FG@�I�S?KVH�W j H\C�I\SBC � Q�UD�BE^Cxy#K�H1�NM?C;I\UI\S?C2H\S?UDQ\IhceQ j @?AgCx�Y@ j I\M?Q�CTU$O�I\S?C2ºÀn2�1tDbYb���W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@%OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£>sFG@�I\S?C2ºÀn2�I\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ��NCx@BH\KLIJZ�K�H�H\K^y � EVZ�ADKVfDCx@��[Z­I�S?CYC0@?CxQ\AgZ��NC0@�HhK^IJZ � $� J« U$OI\S?CYS?Ugy�UDADCx@?C0UgMBH�C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@¡A j H�����=+bY� w?C0f j E^M j I\Ci����K^I\S¡I�S?CYE^UNW j E.�NCx@BHhK^IJZDw

© 687�9« § 0 ¨�� '%)T+W, � $� J« � 0 �����\��� �J���$�

¯�@?C�KVy�y�Cx�NK j I�C0EVZ�Q\C j EVK^°xCxH�I\S j ITUg@?EVZ­Q\CxADKVUD@BH+K^@¡H ��j W C1��K^I\S¡@?UD@Ncef j @?K�H\S?K^@BA;�NCx@NcHhK^IJZ�W0UD@lI\Q�KV�?MNI\C�I\U�I�S?C�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@6Cx@?C0Q�ADZg>�2Us�¿W0UD@BH\KV�?C0QYIJ��U�@?C0M?I\Q j E+W0E^UlHhCi�[cHhM?��HhS?CxE^E j I\UDy­H���S?K�W�S j Q\C�HhU�O j Q j$�Bj QhIÀI\S j II\S?CxQ\C�C �NK�HJI�H�@?U1UsfDCxQ\E j$� ��C IJ��C0Cx@%I�S?CI\S?CxK^Q~�?C0@BH\KLI�K^CiH0w j H'�NC � KVW I\Ci��K^@­k�K^AgM?Q�CY�D>$RTS?C2�NCx@BH\KLIJZ;U$O�I\S?K�H�H\Z[HhI\Cxy K�H'K��NC0@lI\K�W j E�� É0ÈJÆ b ÅlÉ �Æ�×»Æ�Ð b ÈJÅ[Î È2Ú ` : Û�ËÍÌ�ÉiÙgÏ���Î�ÙlÆ�Ö�Æ�ÌGÌJÎ0Ð-�;��DÈ�ÙlÉ0È�Î1Ì ����Ö�ËÍÆ�ÙsÈ�Ö�ÐJË ÈJÆ�ÐJËÍÉiÙ ZVÉxÐ�ÈJÅlÆÌeÈhÎ-�gËÍÏLË È+�­É-ZÀÎ�ÙlÆ �iÎ0ÈJËÍ×»Æ�ËLÉxÙ����+Ï ÈJËLÇ�Î ÈJÆ�Ï�� b ÈJÅgÆ�ÌeÈhÎW�lËÍÏÍË È���ÊDÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÌ+ÉxÙ­ÈJÅlÆ2ÐJÆ�ÏLÎ0ÈJËÍ×»Æ�ÌGËLÓ�ÆÉ-Z�ÈJÅlÆTÈJÉxÈhÎ0Ï�Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËLÆ�Ì+ÉWZ¶ÈJÅlÆ��¿Î0Ù[Ê%ÈJÅgÆ���� ` Æ�ÏLÆ�Ö�ÈGÐJÉiÙ�Ì �DÌeÈJÆ�Ç�Ü

Page 7: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ �

� �

����� �1 � Ô.ÏÍÆ�Ö�ÈGÐJÉiÙgËÍÖ�ÊDÆ�ÙlÌGË È+�;ÉWZ¤È���ÉYÎ0ÈJÉxÇYÌ�Î0È~ÏLÎ0Ð �iÆ2ÌGÆ�ÒlÎ0ÐhÎ ÈJËLÉxÙ�Ü

I\U;I\S?C�HhMBy8UDO.I\SBC�IJ��U j I\UDy�K�W��NCx@BH\KLI�K^CiH0>[RTS?K�H+K�H+I\S?C�H\KLI�M j I�K^Ug@�K^@���S?K�W�S��NK�H � C0Q\cHhKVUD@�OmUDQ�W CiH+��CxW0UDy�C�K^y � UDQ\I j @gIiw j H+I\SBC0Q�C1K�HT@?CxKLI�S?C0Q j @�CxE^CiWuI\Q�UgHhI j I\K�W�KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@��C0IJ�+CxC0@�I�S?C�IJ��U j I�UDy­H�@BUDQ%W j @ j @lZ���UD@B�NKV@?A�UgQ\�BKLI j E�H���C�OmUDQ�y�Cx�¤>'¯�@?EVZ6I�S?Cj IhI�Q j WuI�K^Ug@6��C IJ��C0Cx@�f[KVQhI�M j E+�NK � UDEVC­C �?W0KLI j I\KVUD@�H�UD@�I\S?C�IJ��U j I�UDy­H�W j @6EVC j �6I\Uy�UgE^CiW M?E j Q%��Ug@B�NKV@?ABwÀK¢> CD>�I\S?C�º�UD@B�?UD@��NK�H � C0Q�HhKVUD@�OmUgQ�W0CD>.FG@�I�S?C�ºÀn2��wÀS?Us�+CxfDCxQxwj @[Z�y�UgE^CiW M?E j Q���UD@B�NKV@?A � Q�Usf[KV�NCi�­�[Z�©�«�Q�Cx¬lM?KVQ\CiH�I�S?C j I\Ugy�K�W1�NC0@BH\K^I\KVCxH+I\U�UsfDCxQhcE jD� w j H�I�S?C��?KV@B�NKV@?AYC0@BC0Q�ADZ�y;MBHJI�Q�CxH\M?E^IOmQ\Ugy I\SBC�@?UD@?EVKV@?C j Q��NC0@BH\K^IJZ%�NC � C0@��NC0@BW0CU$O�© 687D9« w�©��?�/© 6&7�9« § 0� � 0 ¨ � © 687�9« § 0� ¨ � © 687D9« § 0 ¨e>�RTS?K�HYy�C j @BH1I\S j I�NKVH � C0Q�HhKVUD@�OmUDQ�W CiH�W j @¡@?UDIT��C��NCiH\W0Q\KV��Ci�¡�lZ�I\S?C�ºÀn2��>

��H�KV@¡I\S?C�W j H\C1UDO�@BC0A j I\KVfDC�KVUD@BH�I�S?KVH � Q\Ug�?EVC0y K�H�@?UDI2Q\CiHhUgE^fgCx���[Z�MBHhCYUDOÀI�S?CbYb���w

© J J�9« § 0 ¨�� '*) + , � J�J�9« � 0 7 � � 0 � 7 � 0 ��� �J���g�

FeI�H�W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ��NC0@�HhK^IJZ � J J�9« �����~UD@?EVZ;I j ]gCxH~K^@lI\U j WxW UDMB@gI~I\S?C��NC0@�HhK^IJZ�K^@I\S?C;K^y�y�Cx�NK j I�C%f[K�W KV@?KLIJZ�UDO��.> � J�J�9« ������I\S[MBH�f j @?K�HhS?CiH2��S?CxQ\CxfDCxQ 0 ���¶��f j @?K�H\S?CxHx>2C0K^I\SBC0QI\SBCTºÀn2� @?UDQ�I\SBC�bYb�� W j @%y�Ci�NK j I\C�I\SBC�EVUD@BA$ceQ j @?ADC'OmUgQ�W0C+AgC0@?CxQ j I\Ci�Y�[ZflKVQ\I\M j E.C �?W K^I j I\KVUD@BHx> �U$I2UD@BE^Z�I\S?C�C0� j WuI2C0�?W�S j @?AgC1OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EÀKVH2fDC0Q�Z�@BUD@?EVUNW j E£w�?MNI j E�H\U;I�S?CYC � j WuI2W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@­OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E¢>

� +��* ! 4���* #,*&������ "$+���' %;* %�+���� % RTSBC�I\S?KVQ���W E j H�H�U$O�HhZNHhI\Cxy�H�OmUgQ­��S?K�W�S I�S?Cº�n2� j @B��I�S?C­bYb�� S j fgCYOmM?@B� j y�C0@lI j E � Q�UD�BE^Cxy�H j Q�C%HhI\Q�UD@?AgE^Z¡W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�Cx��H\Z[HhcI\C0y­Hx>�RTSBC�y�UgHhI � Q�UDy�KV@?C0@lI%C0� j y � E^CiHYU$O�H\MBW�S¾H\ZNHJI�C0y­H j Q\C�I�S?C�³ ) I�Q j @BHhK^I\KVUD@y�C0I j EBy�UD@?U»�NK��NCxH'v�@�¯;wgkBC»¯;w[�+UN¯ j @B� 2Km¯;>DRTS?CiHhC�HhZNHhI\C0y­Hxw$��S?K�W�S�W Q�ZNHJI j EVE^KV°0CK^@�I\SBC�Q\UNW�]�H j E^I�HJI�Q\M�WuI\MBQ\Cgw j Q�C�K^@BH\M?E j I�K^@?A j @lI\K^OmC0Q�Q\Ugy j AD@?C0I�H1U$O�IJZ � C­F\F��¢v�U$I\IK^@BH\M?E j I�UDQ�H�� >(��U$I�S¾I\SBC�º�n�� j @B��I\SBC�bYb��%w�Ug@�I\SBC�UDI\S?CxQ%S j @B�¤w � Q�Cx�NK�WuI�k?C»¯j @B���+U[¯¦I�U;��C�y�C0I j E^EVKVW j @B���[Z�O j QTM?@��NC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I\C�I\SBC1� j @B��A j$� K^@�v�@�¯ j @B�2Km¯8§ ³lqiÂ[³��i¨e>DRTS?K�H~K�H+K^EVE^M�HJI�Q j I\Cx��K^@�k�KVADM?Q�C1²YK^@���S?KVW�S�I\S?C1º�n2� � j @B��HJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�COmUDQ2k?Cs¯ K�H � EVU$I\I\Cx� ¥ I�S?CY� j @��¡HhI\Q�MBW I\M?Q�CxHTUg�NI j K^@?Ci����K^I\S¡I�S?CYy�UgHhI�OmQ�Cx¬lM?Cx@lI\EVZj$�?� EVKVCx��bYb���H j Q\C1Q j I\SBC0Q2H\K^y�KVE j QTI\U�I\S?CxK^Q�º�n2�aW0UDM?@lI\CxQ ��j Q\I�§ ³DoBw ³��i¨e>

RTS?C­UDQ�K^AgK^@�U$O�I\SBKVH � Q\Ug�?E^Cxy¼K�HY@?U$I�ZgC I�Q�C j E^EVZ�M?@B�?C0Q�HJI�UlUN�¤>ÀRTS?C0Q�C j Q�C�Ug@?EVZHhUgy�CTKV@B�NK�W j I\KVUD@BH��S?CxQ\CTUg@?CTy�KVADSlI'S j fgC~I�U1EVU[UD] %g¯�@;I\S?C�Ug@?CTS j @B�.w»I\S?CxQ\CTC �NK�HJI�HUD@?CTf j Q�K j @lI�UDO�I�S?C2bYb�� ��S?KVW�S � Q�Cx�?KVW I�H'k?Cs¯ j @B���+UN¯�I�U1��C j @lI�KLOmCxQ\Q�UDy j Ag@?C I�KVWK^@BH\M?E j I�UDQ�H~§ ³��i¨¤� j ELI�S?UDMBADS���K^I\S%I\S?CTHhKV°0C+U$O?I�S?C�A j$� H.��C0KV@?A�y;MBW�SYI�UlU1Hhy j E^E��u>sRTS?K�HbYb��aKVH2I\S?CYUg@?EVZ�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E�UDO�I�S?K�HTIJZ � C���SBUgH\CY]DC0Q�@?CxE¤S j H���C0Cx@�U � I�K^y�KV°0Ci�¡I\UQ\C � Q\UN�NM�W C�I�S?C�C � j W I j I�UDy�K�W�C �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\C0@lI�K j EVH j H j WxW M?Q j I�C0EVZ j H � UgH�H\K^�?EVC§ ³,�s¨e>lRTS?K�H � UgK^@lI�H j I~I\SBC�KVy � UgQhI j @BW0C�U$O j @ j WxW M?Q j I�C2C �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\C0@lI�K j E�OmUgQ~I�S?C

Page 8: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

���

� ��� � ��

����� ���� .ÎxÙlÊYÌeÈGÐ��lÖ�È��DÐJÆ~ÉWZ�ÎxÙsÈJË Z�Æ�ÐGÐJÉxÇ�Î��iÙgÆ�ÈJËÍÖ1Ú�È+�gÒNÆ�Y YeÛ �gÆ Ñ ��Ë ÈJÅgËLÙ/? � A�É-�gÈhÎ0ËLÙgÆuÊ �I�ÒgÏLÎxÙlÆI� �Îu×»Æ=�ÁÒlÌGÆ �lÊgÉxÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏDÖuÎxÏÍÖ �gÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ�Ú�ÈJÅlÆ'×xÎxÏÍÆ�ÙgÖ�Æ'ÌGÒ[Î0Ö�Æ�É-Z �lÆ'ËÍÙgÖ�Ï��[ÊgÆ�Ì�ÈJÅgÆ� � b �� b��%ÎxÙ[Ê � ��ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆ�Ì b ( )���� _ �"#"+7 �lÊ b[` "1ÌGÒNÆ�Ö�Ë^Î0Ï����ÁÒNÉiËÍÙsÈJÌhÛ\Ü�NCxH�W Q�K � I\KVUD@*UDO%v�U$I\I¡KV@BH\M?E j I\UgQ�Hx>+kBM?QhI�S?C0Q�y�UDQ�CDw~I\S?C�C � � EVKVW0KLI�E^Z¸H\C0E^O�c£KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@W UDQ�Q�CxWuI�Cx�;OmUDQ�y8U$O¤I\SBC�º�n2� j E�HhUYEVC j �?H'I�UYI\SBC�W UgQ\Q�CxW I�ADQ�UDM?@��­HJI j I\CiH�§ ³ �$¨£>$`¸SBK^EVC@?U��NC0 B@?K^I\KVfDC�W UD@�W EVMBHhKVUD@�H j Q�C � UgH�HhKV�?EVCDw�I\S?CiHhC%IJ�+U�Q�CxH\M?E^I�H�@?C0fgC0Q\I\S?CxE^CiH\H�HhM?AgADCiHJII\S j I�I�S?C%KV@ j$�B� Q\U � Q�K j I\C�S j @B�NEVK^@BA�U$O~I\S?C�HhCxELO�ceKV@gI�C0Q j W I\KVUD@�K�H�Q�CxH � Ug@BH\K^�?EVC�OmUgQ�I�S?CO j KVE^M?Q�C�U$O�I\S?C�ºÀn2� j @���I�S?C�HJI j @B� j Q��¡bYb���H0>

����� � " %���# # * !$#,� �#+�* � *&��� � +�"&��� '#� � ��!('#��! +!��"#!$# +���*�!#" � %RTS?KVH�KVH�I\SBC%Q�K^AgSgI � UDKV@lI�I�U�W E j Q�KLOmZ�I\SBC%y�C j @?K^@BA�U$OI\SBC�I\CxQ\y#UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lIOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£>$RTS?C�@ j I�M?Q j ENHJI j Q\I\KV@?A � UDKV@lIÀOmUgQ�I\S?C��NK�H\W0MBH�HhKVUD@;KVHÀI\SBC�C0� j WuI�C �?W�S j @?ADC©Tª�U$O~n1kR�w¤��S?KVW�S�KVH�I\S?C�y�UgHhI�H\KVy � E^C%OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EUDO'I\S?K�H�IJZ � CD>¤RTS?C�C � j WuI�©TªKVH2�?C  B@?Ci� j H�I\S?C�kBUNW�]�C � � Q�CxH�H\K^Ug@���Q�KLI\I\C0@�KV@�I�C0Q�y­H�U$O¹�´�UgQ\�BKLI j E�H1§ rgpBw �$¨£w

©Tª�% � � � ² 5 /�� - / - � '*)+V,8'*)+V,�. � U/ �����I���\����� ��U� ��� . �I� /N��� . �1 � � � . 1 � �J���g�

RTS?KVHK�H�I\SBC�y�UlHJI j$�B� Q\U � Q�K j I\C+�?C  B@?K^I\KVUD@ j HÀK^I'ADM j Q j @lI\C0CiH.I�S?CTC � j W I�W j @�W C0EVE j I\KVUD@U$O�I�S?C­HhCxELO�ceK^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^Ug@�C0@BC0Q�ADZ�W Ug@lI j KV@?Ci��K^@�© $ w¤��S?K�W�S�S j H���C0Cx@6K��NCx@gI�KL �Cx� j HI\S?C�UgQ\KVADKV@�U$O�I\S?C � Q\Ug�?E^Cxy UDO1I�S?C�º�n��1t$bYb��¼��KLI�S¸@?C0A j I\KVfDC�KVUD@BH�� j @�� j E�HhUHhCxC0y­H�I�U;��C1Q\CxE^Cxf j @lI~OmUDQ+I\SBC1�NCiH\W0Q\K � I�K^Ug@�U$OÀv�U$IhITKV@BHhMBE j I\UDQ�H��u>lFeI j MNI\Ugy j I\K�W j E^EVZK^@B�?MBW CiH j W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A��?C  B@?K^I\KVUD@�UDO�I\SBC�W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E¤U$O'n�kR�w

© « % � © ª « � © ª � �¢²Dpg�FeI1y;MBHJI���C;Cxy � S j H\K^°xCx��I�S j IY© ª j @B��© « j Q\C;@?U$I�KV�?C0@lI\K�W j EÀ��K^I\S�I\S?C�C �?W�S j @?ADCj @B��W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@%C0@BC0Q�ADKVCxH�NC  �@?Cx�;K^@­W0UD@[fDCx@gI�K^Ug@ j Ely j @[Zlc£��UN�NZYI�S?C0UgQ\Zg>$�2E^I\S?UgM?ADS

Page 9: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ �

I\S?C�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�OmUDQ�y/U$O�©Tª j ADQ�C0CxH���KLI�S­I\S?C�C �?W�S j @?ADC�I�C0Q�y/U$O¤I\SBC�� j QhI�Q\CxC cGk?UNW�]� ��k'� j$�B� Q\U j W�S.w j �NK^µ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C+UgQ\KVADKV@ j I�CxH.OmQ\Ugy I\S?CT�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@gIUDQ��?K^I j EVHÀK^@�HhCxQhI�Cx�YKV@lI\UI\S?C�kBU[W�]�C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@ %[FG@��J���g�~I\SBC�¹�´�UgQ\�?K^I j EVH j Q\C�MBH\Cx�¤wN��SBKVW�S j Q�C�HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@BHTU$OI\S?C�¹�´6Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@�H��J�»�1��KLI�S�I\S?CxK^Q;y%M?E^I\K � EVKVW j I\KVfDC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E ®�� >�RTS?C � / �NU�@BU$Ij ADQ�C0C���K^I\S I�S?C ��k UDQ��?K^I j E�H­��S?K�W�S¸H j I\K�HJOmZ½I\S?C�@?UD@?EVUNW j E ��k Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@BHx>~RTS?C�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W C­��C IJ��C0C0@�I�S?C�Q�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?A�C �?W�S j @BADC�C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH j HY��C0EVE j H�I\S?C��NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W C��C0IJ�+CxC0@?J � j @���I�S?C�OmM?EVE.][K^@BC I\K�W�C0@BC0Q�ADZ j Q�C j �BH\UDQ���Cx��KV@lI\U�©�«»>

RTS?C%Q�K^AgSlIhceS j @B��HhK��NC�U$O~=~¬�>��J���g��K�H j �NCx@BH\KLIJZ�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j EK^@�I\S?C�H j y�C;H\C0@BH\Cj H�I�S?C�][K^@BC I\K�W�C0@BC0Q�ADZ J � %+RTSBC�¹�´�UDQ��?KLI j E�H � / j Q�C¡MB@?KV¬lM?CxE^Z �NC0I\C0Q�y�K^@BCx���[ZI\S?C½�?C0@BH\KLIJZ 0 w j H 0 M?@BKV¬lM?CxE^Z �NC I�C0Q�y�KV@?CiH ® � �m��S?K�W�SaKVH�ADM j Q j @gI�C0Ci� �[Z*I�S?C�2UDSBC0@[��CxQ\ADce¹�UgS?@¾I�S?C0UgQ\Cxy § rB� ¨TOmUgQ­@?UD@?KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?A�H\Z[HhI\Cxy­H�� w'��S?KVW�S�I�S?C0@ j E^cE^Us�2H�I\S?C�M?@ j y%�BK^AgM?UDMBH1W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@6U$O�I�S?C � /[>¤© ª I\S[MBH1Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�H j @�KVy � E^K�W K^I�NC0@BH\K^IJZ�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E£w�KV@¾W UD@lI�Q j HJIYI�U�I\S?C�C � � EVKVW0KLI;�?C0@BH\KLIJZ6OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVH;º�n2� j @B�bYb���>.RTS?K�H j Q\AgM?y�C0@lI1W j @6��C��NKVQ\CiWuI\EVZ�C �[I\Cx@B�NCi��I�U�I\SBC�y�UgQ\C;ADC0@BC0Q j EÀW0E j H\H�U$OOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H'©Tª «s§ � / 7 � / ¨?��S?K�W�S��NU�@?UDI'UD@?EVZ��NC � C0@��;Ug@�I�S?CTU[WxW M � K^Ci�R� / ws�BMNI j E�HhUUD@­I�S?C�M?@BU[WxW M � K^Ci��¹�´�HhI j I�CxH j H~�+CxE^E j H+UD@�I�S?C1¹�´­C0KVADC0@[f j EVM?CiH0w j H ®�� M?@?K�¬gMBC0EVZ�NC I�C0Q�y�KV@?CiH�I\S?C�W0UDy � EVC I\C�¹�´�H � CiWuI\Q�M?y�>

RTS?C1HhI\C � OmQ�UDy/C � � EVK�W K^I\EVZ��NC0@BH\K^IJZgcG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lI�I\U�UDQ��?K^I j E^cG�NC � C0@B�?C0@lI~�?Wuc£OmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j EVH�KVH�K^@�H\UDy�C%H\C0@�HhC j @ j EVUDAgUDMBH�I�U­I\SBC�I\Q j @�HhK^I\KVUD@�OmQ�UDy�I\S?C�RTS?UDy j HJcGk?CxQ\y�Kf j Q\K j I�K^Ug@ j E'Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@6I�U�I\S?C�¹�´�Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@BH;%¤FG@�I�S?C�E j I\I\C0Q�I\Q j @BH\KLI�K^Ug@�I�S?C�y�UgHhIK^y � UDQ\I j @lI �Bj QhI�U$OT©G"�HI"0§ 0 ¨ew¶I\S?C­][KV@?C I�KVW�Cx@?C0Q�ADZgw�K�H1Q\CiW j HJI�K^@�UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lIOmUDQ�y¡>ÀRTS?C�H j y�C�W Ug@BW C � I�KVH%@?Us� j$�?� EVKVCx�6I\U�© ª « >�FG@�I\S j I;HhCx@BH\CDw.Ug@?C�W j @�W j EVEUDQ��?KLI j E^ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@lI�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H j I\S?KVQ���AgC0@?CxQ j I\KVUD@�U$O��?C0@BH\KLIJZ�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVHx>

��I�I\S?K�H � UDKV@lIxwgI\S?C�KV�NC j U$O¤KVy � E^K�W K^I~�?W c¢OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�H'y�K^AgSgI j$�?� C j Q j H j�� M?Q�C0EVZOmUDQ�y j E�W0UD@BW0C � Ii>+FG@ I�S?C�OmUgE^EVUs��KV@?A½´[CxW I\KVUD@BHxw�S?Us�+CxfDCxQxw'K^I¡��KVEVE���C6H\S?Us��@ I\S j IK^y � EVKVW0KLI�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H2W j @���CYMBH\Cx�¡KV@ � Q j WuI\K�W Cg>

� ���2}?���8���������'}���|+}?�� ������¤}��2������������RTS?C�y�UgHhI%KVy � UgQhI j @lI;¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@¾I\U���C j @BHh��C0Q�Cx��K�H%SBUs� I�U�W j EVW0M?E j I\C�I\S?C�y%M?E^cI\K � E^K�W j I\KVfDC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E���S?K�W�S W UgQ\Q�CxH � Ug@B�?H�I�U��?Wuc£OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�UDO�I\S?C�IJZ � C½�h���g� >RTS?C0Q�C j Q�C�I\SBQ\CxC��NKVHhI\KV@BW I�� j Z[H�OmUDQ�I�S?C%�NCxQ\KVf j I\KVUD@�UDOI\S?C�� j H\KVWYCi¬lM j I�K^Ug@¡��SBKVW�SZlKVC0E��?H1I�S?KVH � U$I�C0@lI\K j E£>.��H j E^EI�S?Q�C0C j Q�C;Q j I�S?C0Q�KV@BHhI\Q�MBWuI�K^fgCDw j EVE'U$O+I\S?Cxy¼��KVE^E'��CADUD@BC~I�S?Q\UgM?ADS;K^@;I\SBC+OmUgE^EVUs��KV@?ABw j H�H\M?y�K^@?A�I\SBC+�?W c¢OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j ElI\U���C�UDOBI�S?CTADC0@BC0Q j EOmUDQ�y ©Tª «s§ � / 7 � / ¨£>� ��� � � ��� # + ��"(!�# +�� * !("&� '#����� � "$+�� ���

RTS?C­HhKVy � E^CiHJI�� j Z�I�U��NC0Q�K^fgC�I�S?C�¯1X~v Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@6KVH1I�S?C;I\Q j @BHhOmUDQ�y j I\KVUD@�U$O~I�S?COmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E¶�NCxQ\KVf j I\KVfDC;�mrl��K^@lI�U%�NC0Q�KVf j I\KVfDCiH���K^I\S�Q�CxH � CiWuI�I�UR� / j @B� � /lwgM�HhKV@?A�I�S?CW�S j KV@�Q�M?EVC1OmUDQTOmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@lI\K j I\KVUD@�§^���s¨ew

3 ©Tª «s§ � / 7 � / ¨3 0 ����� � ' )+W,�. 3 ®�� ��� . �3 0 ����� 5 /� '%)T+W,/. .�� 3 � U/ ��� . . �3 ® � ��� . � 3 ©Tª «

3 ��U/ ��� . . � ��� � � �

Page 10: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

` " Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

� 3 � /3 ®�� ��� . ��� © ª «

� � /�

�¢²?�i�

���¡K�H2@?UDI2Q\CiHJI�Q\K�WuI�Cx�¡I\U�I�S?C�UNW0W0M � KVCx��HhI j I\CxH��u> 2Us� UD@?C%S j H�C0� � Q\CiH\H\Cx� 3 ©Tª « H 3 0K^@�I�C0Q�y­H2U$O�¬lM j @gI�KLI�K^CiH2��S?K�W�S�W j @���C�C0f j EVM j I\Cx� %�RTS?C�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�NCxQ\KVf j I\KVfDCiH�U$O© ª « W j @���C2C j H\K^EVZ%W j E�W M?E j I�Cx�%OmUDQ j @[Z;C � � EVKVW0KLI�C0� � Q\CiH\H\K^Ug@ j I�S j @B�.>Dk?UgQ'K^@BHhI j @BW CgwOmUDQ2© ª UD@?C1 B@B�BH

3 ©Tª

3 ��U/ ��� . � ��� - / 5

�- � � �\��� . � ' ) + , ��U� ����� � / �����1 � � � . 1 �¢²g²D�

j @B� � ©�ª&H � � / �apB>¤RTS?C%OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E'�NCxQ\KVf j I\KVfDCiH 3 ��U/ H 3 ®�� j @�� 3 � / H 3 ®�� j Q\C%C0f j E^cM j I�Cx� �[Z½f j Q�Z[K^@BA ®�� KV@N B@?K^I\CiHhKVy j EVE^Z j @�� E^U[UD][KV@?A�S?Us� � / j @B�K� / Q�C j WuI��ÁflK j=~¬�>V�h�i�\�u>Bd�HhKV@?A� BQ�HJI�UDQ��NCxQ � C0Q\I\MBQ\� j I\KVUD@¡I\SBC0UDQ�Z­UD@BCYUD�NI j KV@BH

3 ��U/ �����3 ®�� ��� . � � � � U/ ��� . ��� /N��� . 7 �¶� �¢²D³g�

3 � /3 ®�� ���¶� � ��U/ ���¶�[� /?���¶� 7 �¢²$rl�

��KLI�S�I�S?C%b1Q�C0C0@ . H�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@

� / ��� 7 � . ��� 5���� /���J�����[� U� ��� . �� � � � / � �¢²gqD�

FeI�Q\Cxy j K^@�H�I\U¾�NC j E2��K^I\S�I\SBC�O j W I\UDQ 3 ® � H 3 0 >~RTS?C�KV@[fDC0Q�H\C�UDO�I�S?KVH�¬lM j @lI\K^IJZ¾K�HI\S?CYHhI j I�KVW1Q�CxH � Ug@BH\C�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@¡U$OÀI\S?CY¹�´ j MN�NKVE^K j Q�Z�HhZNHhI\Cxy¡w[K£> Cg>[I\S?CY¹�´�Q\CiH � UD@�HhCOmM?@BWuI�K^[email protected]

3 0 �����3 ® � ��� . � � � ��� 7 � . ��� � 5/- / � U/ ������� / ��� 7 � . �I� / ��� . � � � � � �W� �¢²Dog�

´[UBw�KLO~Ug@?C�y;M?ELI�K � E^KVCxH1=~¬�>��¢²N�»���[Z� � w j @B��KV@gI�C0AgQ j I\CxH�UsfDCxQF��w�UD@?C�Cx@B�?H�M � ��K^I\SI\S?C;¯1X+v KV@lI\C0AgQ j E¶Cx¬lM j I�K^[email protected] j k?Q�Cx�NSBUDEVy Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@¡U$OÀ BQ�HhI2][K^@��¤w

'%)T+W,�. � ��� 7 � . � ® ª «s��� . ���� �ª «»���¶� 7 �¢²��$�

��KLI�S�I�S?CYKV@?S?UDy�UgADC0@BC0K^IJZ�ADKVfDCx@��[Z

~ª «i������� 5/

� � '*)+V,�.�� � U/ ������� / ��� 7 � . � 3 ©Tª «

3 � U/ ��� . � � � � � � � � 1 � / ����� 1 �©�ª «

� � / � ��¢² �g�=~¬�>V�£²,�D�TKVH�I\SBC;W Cx@lI\Q j E�Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@�U$O'I\SBC�¯1X~v¾>�FeI j EVE^Us�2HTI�S?C�W j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@�U$O'I�S?Cy%M?E^I\K � EVKVW j I\KVfDC��?W c � U$I�C0@lI\K j E¶OmUgQ�ADKVfDC0@¡UDQ��?K^I j ELc j @���CxK^AgC0@[f j EVM?C cG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lITOmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j E�© ª « > 2U$I�C2I�S j IT=~¬�>V�£²,�D�KVH~E^KV@?C j Q~KV@�© ª « w[HhU�I\S j I+C j W�S�W Ugy � UD@BC0@lI~U$O�© ª «W j @¡��C�I\Q�C j I�Cx�¡HhC �Bj Q j I�C0EVZD>

Page 11: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ `c`�2@[Z­HhCxELOÁW0UD@BH\KVHhI\Cx@lIT¹�´­W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@�W Ug@BH\KVHhI�H+U$O.I�S?C j E^I\C0Q�@ j I\C�H\UDEVMNI�K^Ug@�U$O.I�S?C

¹�´�Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@BH­�J�»� j @B�6I�S?C�W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@�U$O ®�� OmQ\Ugy¼I�S?C�Q�CxH\M?ELI�K^@BA � / >�RTS[MBH0w j IHhUgy�C � UgK^@lI�UDO�I�S?K�H�W0Z[W0E^CgwBUg@?C�S j H�I\U�C0f j EVM j I�C ® ª «i>�FeO'I�S?KVH�KVH j @�ºÀn2� UgQ�bYb��� UDI\C0@lI�K j E¢wgUD@?C �JMBHhI~S j HI\U�I j ]gCTI\S?C��?C0@BH\KLIJZ j @B��K^I�H+�NC0Q�K^f j I\KVfDCxH j @B��KV@BHhCxQhI'I�S?CxH\C¬gM j @lI\K^I\KVCxH%K^@lI\U�H\UDy�C j @ j EVZlI\K�W j E^EVZ�AgK^fgC0@�OmUDQ�y%M?E j >�FG@�I\S?C¡¯1X+v�w.Ug@�I\S?C�UDI\S?CxQS j @B�.wÀI�S?C�HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@¾U$O�=+¬�>V�£²,�$��Q\C � E j W CiHYI�S?KVH�KV@BH\C0Q\I\KVUD@¾UDO 0 K^@lI�U�I�S?C¡ºÀn2��UDQbYb�� OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£>

� ��� � *&+�" � ��!(���I4�* � � !#� � ��� "$+�� * !RTS?C � S[ZNH\KVWxH���C0S?KV@B��I�S?C�¯1X+v KV@gI�C0AgQ j E�Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@¾��CxW0UDy�CxH%y�UgQ\C�I\Q j @BH �Bj Q�C0@lIK^@�I\SBC�HhCiW UD@�� �NCxQ\KVf j I�K^Ug@�UDO1=+¬�>��¢²��$� >�RTS?KVH j E^I\C0Q�@ j I\KVfDC��NC0Q�KVf j I\[email protected]'��SBKVW�S.w~K^@O j WuIiwgQ�C � Q\CiHhCx@gI�HI\SBC2UDQ�K^AgK^@ j E jD�?� Q�U j W�S�§ ²Nw ³s¨ew$Q�C0EVK^CiH�UD@­Cx@?C0Q�ADZ;y�K^@?KVy�K^° j I�K^Ug@.>gFeI�HHJI j Q\I\KV@?A � UDKV@lI�K�H j I\UDI j E�C0@BC0Q�ADZ�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EAgK^fgC0@�KV@�I\CxQ\y­H�U$O�I�S?C�¹�´�UDQ��?K^I j E�Hj @B��CxK^AgC0@[f j EVM?CxHxwÀ© "AH " § � / 7 � /x¨e>���H j E^Q�C j �NZ � UDKV@lI\Ci��UDMNIiw�I�S?C ��UDS?Cx@l��C0Q�A$cG¹�UDSB@I\S?CxUDQ�C0y OmUDQÀ@?UD@?KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?A ��j Q\I\K�W EVCxH.AgM j Q j @lI�C0CxH¤I\S j I�I\SBC0Q�C~K�H j M?@?K�¬gMBC~Q�C0E j I\KVUD@��C0IJ�+CxC0@ 0 j @B� ® � >?RTS[MBH+I\S?C�HJI j @B� j Q���y�K^@BK^y�KV° j I�K^Ug@�UDOÀ© "�HI" ��K^I\S¡Q\CiH � CxW I+I�U 0W j @¡��C�HhM?��HJI�KLI�MNI\Ci���lZ j y�KV@?KVy�KV° j I\KVUD@���K^I\S�Q\CiH � CxW ITI\U ® � w

pf�%3 © "�H " § � / 7 � /x¨3 ®�� ����� �¢² �g�

��OmUDQT B�[Ci� �Bj Q\I\K�W EVC�@lMBy%��C0Qu�u>BRTS?CY�NCxQ\KVf j I�K^fgC��£² �l�+W j @���CYS j @B�?E^Ci� j HTK^@��¢²?�i� w

3 © "�HI" § � / 7 � /»¨3 ®�� ����� �65/

� '%) + , .�� 3 ��U/ ��� . �3 ®�� ����� 3 © "AH "3 � U/ ��� . � � � � � � � 3 � /3 ®�� ������� © "�HI"� � /� ��Á³gpg�

FG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@ I�U�I\SBC�K^@BADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�H���S?KVW�S j Q\C j E^Q�C j �NZ½][@?Us��@�w~=~¬�>��Á³Dpl��W Ug@gI j KV@BHI\S?C�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j ET�NCxQ\KVf j I\KVfDCiHYU$O�©F"�H "���K^I\S½Q\CiH � CxW I�I\U�� / j @B� � / w���S?KVW�S¾W j @���CC0f j EVM j I�Cx��OmQ\Ugy�=+¬lHx>�� �$�Gc��h�xpl�uw

3 ©G"�HI"3 � U/ ����� � -�/ ����

²�� � ® ! ª#" ����� � ® $ ����� � � /B����� � 3 ©Tª «

3 ��U/ ����� �Á³B�i�

� ©F"�H "� � / � � ©Tª «

� � / � �Á³l²D�

¯�@?CYW j @¡I�S?C0@�MBH\C1I\S?C�¹�´�Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@BH�I�U­Q\Cx��Q\K^I\C 3 © "�HI" H 3 ��U/ w3 ©G"�HI"3 � U/ ���¶� � - /�� � /�

® ª « ���¶���T� /N���¶� � 3 ©Tª «

3 � U/ ����� � �Á³g³g�

FG@BHhCxQhI�K^Ug@�UDOT�£²$³l�uw��¢²sr[� j HT�+CxE^E j HY�Á³l²D� wV�¢³D³g�+KV@lI\U��Á³gpg�+E^C j �?H�I�U

p � 5/' )+W,�. � � U/ ����� � / ��� 7 � . ����- / � / ��� . �TL ® ª «»��� . � � � / P � 3 ©Tª «

3 ��U/ ��� . � � � � � � �� 5 / 1 � / ���¶� 1 � ©Tª «

� � / � �Á³Drl�

Page 12: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

` � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

��O�I\CxQTKV�NCx@lI\K^ �W j I\KVUD@�UDO¤I\S?C1KV@?ADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�H~UDO� � ��� 7 � . � j @�� �ª «»���¶�uw[��S?K�W�S�H\S?Us�¸M �K^@�=~¬�>��Á³Drl�uw j @B��MBHhC�UDOÀI�S?CYUDQ\I\S?UgADUg@ j EVKLIJZ�Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@

'*)+V, ��U/ ������� / ��� 7 � . ��� '%)T+W,/. � / ��� 7 � . � � / ��� . �8�*p �Á³lqD�

UD@?C j A j KV@�Cx@B�?HTM � ��K^I\S¡I\SBC;¯1X~v:K^@lI\CxADQ j E¶Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@��¢²��$�u>RTS?KVH;�NC0Q�KVf j I\KVUD@ j I% BQ�HhI%AgE j @BW C�H\M?ADAgCxHhI�H�I�S?C­�[ceUD@?EVZ�EVK^y�K^I;UDO�I�S?C�¯1X+v I\U

��C�W UD@�W C � I\M j E^EVZ�K��NCx@gI�KVW j EÀ��KLI�S�I\S?C ��k j$�B� Q\U j W�S.w j H2KV@�I\SBKVH�E^KVy�KLIY© "�HI" § � / 7 � /i¨j ADQ�C0CiH��KLI�S�I\S?C���k6C0@?CxQ\AgZYOmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E¢>gFeI�I\S[MBH�H\C0Cxy­H'�+UgQhI�S[��S?K^EVCTI\UYCxy � S j H\KV°0CI\S?C��NK^µ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C1��C IJ��C0Cx@¡I\S?C1IJ��U�H�W�S?Cxy�CiHTUD@BW0C j A j K^@ %[RTSBC���k jD�?� Q�U j W�S¡W UgQ\Q�C cH � UD@B�BH�I\U j OmQ\CxC�y�K^@?KVy�K^° j I�K^Ug@�U$OI\S?C%I\UDI j EÀC0@?CxQ\AgZ­OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EÀ��K^I\S�Q�CxH � CxWuI�I\UI\S?C � / j @�� � /[>�=+¬�>V�£² �g� w�Ug@�I\SBC;UDI\S?CxQ�S j @B�¤w¶K�H�@?UDI1Ci¬lM?K^f j E^Cx@gI�I\U j OmQ�C0C�y�KV@?K^cy�KV° j I\KVUD@­UDO�© "�HI" %�� j I\S?CxQ�I�S?CM� / j @B� � /1S j fDC�I�U%H j I\K�HhOmZ%I�S?C�¹�´�Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@BH'��K^I\SI\S?CxK^QTy%MBELI�K � EVK�W j I�K^fgC1I\U$I j E � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E£>[RTSBKVHTQ�Cx¬lM?KVQ\Cxy�C0@lI+Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�H j HhMB�BHhK��NK j Q�ZW UD@��NKLI�K^Ug@�I\U�I\SBC­y�KV@?KVy�K^° j I\KVUD@�UDOT©G"AH "0>ÀRTS?C�HhMB�BHhK��NK j Q�Z�W Ug@B�NK^I\KVUD@�K�H j W I\M j E^EVZK^y � EVC0y�C0@lI�Cx��KV@lI\UYI�S?C�¯1X~v·Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@­f[K j =~¬�>��Á³g³g�u>gFG@�´[CiWuI\KVUD@�³�I\S?K�H � UgK^@lI���K^EVE��CYKV@[fDCxHhI\KVA j I\Ci�­OmM?Q\I\S?CxQ�OmQ�UDy j ¬lM j @lI�KLI j I\KVfDC � UDKV@lI2U$OflKVC0�Y>

� ��� � ! � " ���" !�# �.* � '#��!(%�� + *RTS?C­HJI j Q\I\KV@?A � UDKV@lIYU$O~I�S?K�H�I\S?KVQ��6�NCxQ\KVf j I�K^Ug@�U$O+I\S?C�¯1X+v KV@lI\C0AgQ j ECx¬lM j I�K^Ug@�K�HI\S?C2K��NCx@gI�KLIJZ�U$O�I\SBC�¹�´��NC0@�HhK^IJZ 0 � ��K^I\S­I�S?C��NCx@BHhK^IJZ 0 UDO�I�S?C2KV@gI�C0Q j W I\KV@?A�HhZNHhI\Cxy§ r[²Nw rg³s¨ew

p;� 0 � ����� � 0 �����C� �Á³gog�2U$I�CI\S j I.I\SBC�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@��Á³gog��Q�C0EVK^CiH¤UD@1I\SBC~W Ugy � E^C0I\COmQ j y�C0��UDQ�]2U$OlI\SBC �2UgS?C0@[��C0Q�A$c¹�UDS?@ j @��­¹�´;OmUDQ�y j E^K�H\y¡>DFG@ �Bj Q\I\K�W M?E j Qiw$K^I~KVy � E^KVCxH�I\S?C jD�?� EVKVW j I�K^Ug@­U$O�I\S?C�y�KV@?K^cy%M?y � Q�KV@BW K � EVC�OmUgQ~I�S?C�I�U$I j E¶C0@?CxQ\AgZDwg��S?KVW�S�M?@B�NCxQ\EVKVCxH j EVE�UDO�ADQ�UDMB@B��HhI j I�C�n1kR�>RTS?KVH+W Ugy�y�Ug@�n�kR � j W�]lAgQ\UgM?@B� � Q�Usf[KV�NCiHI\SBC�EVK^@?]���C IJ��C0C0@��¢³Dol� j @B�­I\S?C j Q\AgMNcy�Cx@lI�H�UDO´[CiWuI\KVUD@�H�²N>V� j @B��²N> ²N>

RTS?C�¹�´��NC0@BH\K^IJZ 0 � W j @�@?Us�a��C;��Q�K^IhI\Cx@�KV@�I�C0Q�y�H1UDO�I\S?C­b1Q�C0C0@ . H�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@� � UDO+I�S?C�¹�´�H\Z[HhI\Cxy�w.��S?KVE^C�I�S?C�KV@gI�C0Q j W I\KV@?A 0 W j @���C�C � � Q�CxH�HhCi��KV@�I\C0Q�y­HYU$OI\S?C­�0c �Bj QhI�KVW0E^CYb1Q�C0C0@ . H�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ � U$O�I\S?CYKV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?A­H\Z[HhI\Cxy�w

p;� ��� I\Q�� � � ����� 7 ������� � �­���� 7 �������� � �Á³��$��2C0Q�C � � KV@B�NK�W j I\CiH j @�K^@? B@?K^I\CxH\KVy j E � UgH\KLI�K^fgC�I\KVy�C0ceH\S?K^O�I�U$O��uw$K£> Cg>�� ��� EVK^y������g��� �1 � 1 �u>~RTS?C�¹�´ j @B� I\S?C�OmM?EVE�y j @lZlce��UN�NZ�b1Q\CxC0@ . H�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j Q�C��NC  �@?Cx� �[Z¾I�S?CADQ�UDM?@B��HhI j I�C�C � � CiWuI j I\KVUD@�f j EVM?CxH�U$O�I�S?C�I\KVy�C ceUDQ��NC0Q�Cx� � Q�UN�NMBWuI­UDO�I�S?C�W UgQ\Q�C cH � UD@B�?K^@?A� BCxEV�¡U � CxQ j I\UDQ�Hxw��� � j @B���� w

� � ����� 7 � . � . �9� ����� � � 1 J �� �g�����h� �� U� ��� . � . � 1 � ��! �Á³,�g��­����� 7 � . � . � � ������" � 1 J �� �����h� �� U ��� . � . � 1 " �#! 7 �Á³,�g���KLI�S 1 � � !;��C0KV@?A6I\S?C�¹�´½ADQ�UDM?@B�½HJI j I\C��ÁK¢> CD> j ´[E j I\CxQ­�NC I�C0Q�y�KV@ j @gI­UDO2I\S?C�¹�´UDQ��?KLI j E�H(� /$� j @B� 1 " � !.�NCx@?U$I�K^@BA2I\SBC~I�Q\M?C~ADQ�UDM?@B�%HJI j I\C~U$ONI\SBC+KV@lI\C0Q j W I\KV@?A�H\ZNHJI�C0y�>

Page 13: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ ` RTS?C�K^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^@?A�b1Q�C0Cx@ . H�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@¡Ug��CxZNH�I\S?CY��C0EVELce][@?Us��@�n�ZNHhUg@�Cx¬lM j I�K^[email protected]

�­�h� 7 ²D��� ���[�J� 7 ²g� � ' ) ³ ) r����l�J� 7 ³g���¡�Á³ 7 rl���­�mr 7 ²D��� �mrlpg�

�2C0Q�C ����Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�H�I�S?C�b1Q�C0Cx@ . H1OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@�U$OTC0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BHY��S?K�W�S �JMBHhI�C � � CxQ\KVC0@�W CI\S?C�C �[I\CxQ\@ j E � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E ®�! ª#" w��aK�H'I�S?C2OmMBE^E¶HhCxELO�ceC0@BC0Q�ADZ�UDO�I�S?C�KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?A�H\ZNHJI�C0y�w

�¡�¢³ 7 r[����� ª « �Á³ 7 rl� � 3 �Á³ 7 r[� ® $ ��� + � 7 �mr��i�

j @B� I\S?C � j Q�f j Q�� @?UDI j I\KVUD@8� � ��� ± � ± �uw�� ) ³ ��� ) + , + � ) � + j @B� 3 �Á³ 7 r[�h�3�� + ��� + � � � � 3 � � + � � � �YS j H���C0Cx@¾MBH\Cx�¤>�¯�@�I\SBC�U$I�S?C0Q�S j @B�¤w.I�S?C�¹�´�b1Q\CxC0@ . HOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@�H j I�KVHh BCiH j n�Z[H\UD@6Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�KV@���S?KVW�S�I\S?C­H\C0E^O�c£Cx@?C0Q�ADZ�K�H�HhKVy � E^Z�ADKVfDC0@�lZ ® $ � ® ª « w

� � �J� 7 ²D����� � �h� 7 ²D� � ' ) ³ ) r�� � �h� 7 ³l� 3 �¢³ 7 r[� § ® $ ��� + � � ® ª « ��� + �G¨ � � �Ár 7 ²D� �mr[²D�

� ®�$ � ® ª «�KVH%I\S?C�UD@?EVZ�HhCxELO�ceC0@?CxQ\AgZ6KV@BH\C0Q\I\KVUD@�I�S j I�HhS?Us�2H�M � KV@�I\SBC�W j HhC­UDO j @C µ¶CxWuI�K^fgC2HhKV@?AgE^C0c �Bj QhI�KVW0E^CTH\Z[HhI\Cxy��u>sFeO¶UD@?C�@?Us��HhMB�NI\Q j W I�H=~¬[Hx>V�Árgpg� wV�Árl²g�¤OmQ�UDy C j W�SU$I\SBC0Q�UD@BC1Cx@B�?H�M � ��K^I\S j Q�C0E j I\KVUD@¡��C IJ��C0C0@ � j @B� � � w�­�J� 7 ²g� ��� � �h� 7 ²g� � ' ) ³ ) r�� � �J� 7 ³g��� ��ª «i�¢³ 7 rl� � 3 �¢³ 7 r[� ® ª «0��� + ��� �­�Ár 7 ²g���Y�mrl³g�

=~¬�>V�Árg³l�¤K�H j n�ZNH\UD@�Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@%��S?UgH\C~KVQ\Q�Cx�?MBW KV�?EVC~]DCxQ\@BC0ElKVHÀADKVfDCx@��[Z�I�S?CT�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W C��C0IJ�+CxC0@�I\S?C�OmM?E^E�HhCxELO�ceC0@BC0Q�ADZ j @B�6I\S?C�¹�´�H\C0E^O�c£Cx@?C0Q�ADZg>.d � UD@�KV@BH\C0Q\I\KVUD@�U$OY�mrl³g�K^@lI\U��¢³��$��Ug@?C�UD�NI j KV@BH

p;� ��� I�Q ' ) ³ ) r�� � �J� 7 ³g� ��� ª « �¢³ 7 r[� � 3 �¢³ 7 rl� ® ª « ��� + � � �­�mr 7 � � ��� �mrgrl�

=~¬�>V�ÁrDr[��K�H j W UDy � EVK�W j I�Cx��K^@lI\CxADQ j EÀCx¬lM j I�K^Ug@�W Ug@?@?CiWuI\KV@?A�I\S?C�¹�´�b1Q�C0Cx@ . H�OmM?@BW cI\[email protected]¤I�S?C­�?WucGW Ugy � Ug@?C0@lIYU$O�I\S?C�OmMBE^E�HhCxELO�ceC0@?CxQ\AgZDw¶I�S?C��?Wuc � UDI\C0@lI�K j E j @B�6I�S?C�OmM?EVEb1Q\CxC0@ . H�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@.>Dn�U[CxH�I�S?KVH�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@%S j fDC j @[ZlI\S?KV@?A1I\UY�NU���K^I\S�I\S?C�¯1X+v Ci¬gM j cI\KVUD@��¢²,�D� '�RTS?C1 BQ�HhITHhI\C � I�Us� j Q��?H j @ j @BH\��C0Q+I\U;I\S?K�H�¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@�KVH � Q�Usf[KV�?Cx�­�[Z jQ\C � C j I\Ci��MBH\C�U$OI\SBC;n�Z[H\UD@�Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@¾�mrg³l�u>���O�I\CxQ�KV@BH\C0Q\I\KVUD@�UDO��Árg³l��I\S?C;E^C j �NKV@?AI\C0Q�y KV@��mrDr[��W UD@lI j KV@BH�I\S?C � Q\UN�NMBW I'U$O � � �J� 7 ³g�À��K^I\S � � �mr 7 �»�u>$X j Q\I\K j E[Cxf j E^M j I\KVUD@U$O�I\S?CYrDc£KV@lI\C0AgQ j I\KVUD@­I�S?C0@�Z[KVC0E��?H0w

'*) + , + '%) � + � �J� 7 ³l� ® ª «»��� + �� ��� I\Q ' ) ³ ) r�� � �h� 7 ³g�� ª « �Á³ 7 r[� � � �mr 7 �#����� I\Q '%) ³ ) r�� � �h� 7 ³g� � ��ª «s�Á³ 7 rl� � 3 �Á³ 7 r[� ® ª «»��� + � �� ' ) q ) o�� � �mr 7 qD� ��� ª « �¢q 7 ol� � 3 �£q 7 ol� ® ª « �����x� � �­�¢o 7 � � � 7 �mr[qD�

Page 14: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

` � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

��S?C0Q�C1I\S?C�¹�´�Q\CiH � UD@�HhC1OmM?@BW I\KVUD@

� �J� 7 ³l�8� ��� � � � � 1 J �� U� ��� ± � ± � �� �[��� ± � ± � �� U� ��� + � + � �� �l��� + � + � 1 � � ! � 0 ��� ± � 0 ��� + � �� ��� I�Q�� � � �h� 7 ³l� � � �¢³ 7 �»��� �mrlog�S j H1��C0C0@6K^@lI�Q\UN�NMBW0Cx��K^@6UDQ��NC0Q�I\U¡y j ]DC%I\S?C­H\K^y�KVE j Q\K^IJZ�U$O��Árlqg����K^I\S �¢²,�D�2y�UgQ\Cj$�?�Bj Q\Cx@lIx>ÀRTSBC�EVC O�IhceS j @B�¾H\KV�NC�U$O�=+¬�>��mr[qD��K�H�K��NCx@gI�KVW j E���KLI�S�I\S j I�U$OTI\S?C�¯1X~vCx¬lM j I�K^[email protected]»KLO¶UD@BC � C0Q\OmUDQ�y­H�I�S?C ) � + KV@lI\C0AgQ j I\KVUD@ j @B�%KV�NCx@lI\K^ BCxH�I�S?C�HJI j I\K�W�Q\CiH � UD@�HhCOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@��m°0CxQ\UDc¢OmQ�Cx¬lM?Cx@BW Z­EVKVy�K^I2U$O�I\SBC�k?UDMBQ\KVC0QTI�Q j @BHJOmUgQ\y¿UDO � �J� 7 ³g�\�uw' ) � + � �J� 7 ³g��� ' ) � + � ��� ± 7 � + 7 � ± � � + �2� � ��� ± 7 � + 7�� �*pl� � � ��� ± 7 � + ���¯�@­I\S?C1U$I�S?C0Q�S j @B�¤wgI\S?C1Q\KVADSlI\c£S j @B��H\KV�?C�U$O�=+¬�>V�ÁrlqD��KVH�HhI\KVE^E¤¬lM?K^I\C��NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI+OmQ\UgyI\S?C�KV@?S?UDy�UgADC0@BC0K^IJZ��¢² �l�u>[FG@�O j WuIiw[I\S?C�Q�K^AgSlIhceS j @B��HhK��NC��NC � C0@��?HTUD@ ® ª « KLI�HhCxELOJw�HhUI\S j I%�mrlqg�+Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI�H j @?UD@BE^KV@?C j QTK^@lI\CxADQ j E¶Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�OmUDQ ® ª «i>

`¸S?C0Q�C2�NU[CxH�I�S?KVH�OmM?@B� j y�C0@lI j EB�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CTI�U�=~¬�>V�£²,�D�W UDy�C�OmQ�UDy '�RÀU j @BH\��C0QI\S?K�H�¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@ Ug@?C�S j H­I\U�Q�C0y�C0y;��CxQ�I\S j I�K^@ I�S?C� BQ�HJI­IJ��U j$�?� Q\U j W�S?CiH;H\UDy�Cj Q��?KLI�Q j Q\Z¡UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lIY©Tª «YS j H���C0C0@ j H�H\M?y�Cx�¤w�K¢> CD>�I�S?C�OmUDQ�y#UDO+©Tª «YS j H@?U$I~��C0Cx@�H � CiW K^ BCx�¤>N¯�@�I\S?C�U$I\SBC0Q~S j @B�¤wgK^@�I�S?C � Q\CiHhCx@gI jD�?� Q�U j W�S%I�S?C�MBH\C�U$O¤I�S?Cn�ZNH\UD@¾Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@�OmUgQ%��U$I�S�I\S?C¡¹�´ j @���I\S?C¡K^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^@BA�HhZNHhI\C0y j MNI\Ugy j I\K�W j E^EVZK^y � EVK^CiH;I\S?C¡MBH\C�U$O�I�S?C¡C � j W I�©Tª «»>�FG@½UDQ��NCxQ�I\U6y j ]DC¡W EVUgH\C0Q�W UD@lI j WuI���C0IJ�+CxC0@I\S?C; BQ�HJI1IJ�+U j @B��I\S?K�H�I\S?KVQ��6�NC0Q�KVf j I\[email protected]�UD@BC�I\S[MBH1S j H2I�U¡HhI\M��NZ�I\S?C�C � j WuI1©�ª «K^@6y�UgQ\C;�NC I j KVE¢>¤RTS?K�H���KVEVEÀ��C%I�S?C�HhM?���JCxWuI1U$O�´NCxWuI�K^Ug@�rB>�FG@�I�S?C � Q\CiHhCx@gIY´[CxW I\KVUD@I\S?C¡W UDy �Bj Q\K�H\UD@�U$O�=+¬�>V�ÁrlqD�Y��KLI�S½=~¬�>��¢²,�D����KVE^E�OmUDQ�HhKVy � EVKVW0KLIJZ���C�Q�CxHhI\Q�KVW I\Ci��I\UI\S?C��lceUD@BE^Z�E^KVy�KLIiw[��S?KVW�S�W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�?HI�U j EVUs�+CiHJI+UDQ��NC0Q+C � �Bj @�HhKVUD@­UDO¤© ª « KV@�I�S?CW UDM � E^KV@?A­W Ug@BHhI j @lI � >?FG@�I\SBKVH�EVKVy�K^I2I�S?CYQ\KVADSlI\c£S j @B��H\K��NCYU$OT�mrlqg�+Q\Ci�NMBW CiH�I\U��� I\Q ' ) ³ ) r � � �J� 7 ³g��� ª �¢³ 7 r[� � � �Ár 7 � � � 7j H�C j W�S�O j WuI\UgQ~UDO � ª « UgQ ® ª « K^@lI\Q�UN�NMBW0CxH j @ j �?�?KLI�K^Ug@ j E�O j W I\UDQ+U$O � >lFG@BH\C0Q\I\KVUD@­U$OI\S?CYC0�NW�S j @?AgC1W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@ ��ª%I\U�I�S?C1OmM?E^EÀHhCxELO�ceC0@?CxQ\AgZDwNK£> Cg>[I\S?C�HhI j @B� j Q���� ceE^U[U �HhCxELO�ceC0@?CxQ\AgZ��?K j ADQ j y�w$I�S?C0@�E^C j �?H~I\U%I\S?C1C �?W�S j @?ADC�W0UDy � UD@?Cx@gITU$O~�£² �l�uwlUD�NI j KV@?Cx��lZYM�HhC�U$O�¢²D²g�u>D¯�@?C�S j HÀI�SlM�HÀC0� � E^K�W K^I\EVZ�fgC0Q�KL BCi��I\S j I'K^@;I\SBC~�[ceUD@?EVZYE^KVy�KLI�=+¬�>��mr[qD�j ADQ�C0CiH���KLI�S�I�S?C�HhI j @�� j Q���¯1X+v¼Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@�>

� ��� � "# + ����� "$+�� * !(% ����� "$+���' +�*�� � ��+C0OmUDQ�C�K^@[fgCxHhI\KVA j I�K^@BA�I�S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@;W0UDy � UD@?Cx@gI�UDO.© ª « KV@­y�UDQ�C2�NC I j KVE?KLI�HhCxC0y­H�+UgQhI�Sl��SBK^EVC�I�U�E^K�HJI j OmC0��C � j W I­Q\CxE j I\KVUD@BH���S?K�W�S Cxy�C0Q�ADC�OmQ\Ugy j @ j @ j E^ZNH\KVH�U$OI\S?C¾¯1X~v KV@lI\CxADQ j E1Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@.>�¯�@?C� �Q�HhI¡Q�CxW0UDAg@?K^°xCxH�I\S j I�I�S?C�¯1X+v Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�NC I�C0Q�y�KV@?CiH ® ª «~Ug@?E^Z;M � I\U j @ j �?�NK^I\KVfDC�W0UD@BHhI j @gIi>$FG@�O j W Ixw j H@?UDQ�y�ceW0UD@BH\C0Q�f j I�K^Ug@Q\Ci¬gMBK^Q�CxH+I\S j I ' ) + , � ��� 7 � . ��� ' ) + , . � ��� 7 � . �8�*p 7 �mr$�$�

Page 15: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ ` �UD@?C�W j @ j �?� j @[Z1W0UD@BHhI j @gIÀI\U ® ª «���K^I\SBUDMNI j E^I\C0Q�KV@?A2I�S?C~EVC O�I\c£S j @B�%H\K��NC~UDOB=~¬�>V�£²,�D�u>FG@�I\S?C � Q\UNW CiH\HTUDOH\UDEVf[K^@BA�I\S?C�¯1X+v Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@¡Ug@?C�I\S[MBH�S j H�I\U­C0@�HhM?Q�C�I\SBC�@?UDQ\cy j E^KV° j I\KVUD@�UDO ® ª «'KV@;H\UDy�C~C0� � E^K�W K^IOmUDQ�y¡>»k?UgQ� �@?KLI�C�HhZNHhI\C0y­HÀUD@?C�MBH\M j EVEVZ1Q�Cx¬lM?KVQ�CxH® ª «%I�U�f j @?K�HhS�O j Q;UDMNI�HhK��NCgw.E^KVy�� ��� ��� ® ª «s���¶�f� pB>�¯�@?C�� j Z�I�U�K^y � EVC0y�C0@lI;I\S?K�HW UD@��NKLI�K^Ug@%K�H.I�S?C�MBHhC�U$O j @�K��NC0@lI�KLIJZ�OmUgQ�I�S?C+SBK^AgS?CxHhI�UNWxW M � KVCx�;¹�´YHhI j I�C1§ rDrD¨l��SBKVW�SQ\CiHhM?E^I�H�OmQ�UDy I\SBKVH�@?UgQ\y j EVKV° j I�K^Ug@.>0FG@%I\S?C�W j H\C~U$ONI�S?CTC �?W�S j @?ADC'I�S?K�HÀK��NCx@gI�KLIJZYQ�C j �?H' )T+-, ® ª ����� 1 � < ����� 1 � �

² ' )+V, ��U< ����� 3 ©�ª

3 � U< ����� � � � � �� � � 5

�- � '%)T+W,8'*)+V,�. ��U< ���¶� � � ���¶� ��U� ��� . �I� <���� . �1 � � � . 1 7 �mr��g�

��S?C0Q�C\� < �?C0@?UDI\CxH�I\S?C1S?KVADS?CiHJI+U[WxW M � K^Ci�­UDQ��?K^I j E���I�S?C1kBC0Q�y�K�EVC0fgC0EBK�H j H�HhM?y�Ci��I\U��C�@?UD@?ce�NCxADCx@?C0Q j I�Ci�u>�=~¬�>��mr,�l� j E^EVUs�2H�I�S?C;MB@ j y;�?K^AgM?UDM�H�@?UgQ\y j E^KV° j I\KVUD@�U$O ® ª K^@I\S?C�W j H\CTU$O� B@?K^I\C�H\ZNHJI�C0y­H0>g�2@ j @ j EVUDADUgMBHxwxI�S?UDMBADS�y�UDQ�CTW0UDy � EVKVW j I�Cx��HJI j I�C0y�C0@lIKVH j f j KVE j �?E^C2OmUDQ ® «�§ r[q»¨e>gk?UgQ�H\UDEVK��?H0wlUD@�I\S?C1U$I�S?C0Q�S j @��¤wgK^ITKVH+y�UDQ�C�W Ug@[fDC0@BK^Cx@gI~I\U ?��I�S?C j fDCxQ j ADC2UDO ® ª «2KV@¡I\S?CYMB@?KLI�W0C0EVE¢>

FeI�S j H j EVQ\C j �NZ2��C0Cx@Yy�C0@lI\KVUD@?Ci�1I\S j I¤OmUDQ � S[Z[H\K�W j EsQ�C j HhUg@BH�I\SBC�C � j W I.C �?W�S j @?ADC� UDI\C0@lI�K j E.U$OÀ B@?K^I\C�H\Z[HhI\Cxy­HTy%MBHhI j H\Z[y � I\U$I�KVW j EVE^Z���CxS j fDC j H

® ª ����� � => ?�> @!A � � 1 � 1 � �mr��g�

FeI~KVH'I\S[MBH'fgC0Q�Z � EVC j H\KV@?A1I\S j I�UD@?CT B@��?H'C � j WuI\EVZ�I�S?K�H'��CxS j f[K^UgQOmUDQ'I�S?C2H\UDEVMNI\KVUD@�U$O�¢²,�D� %�=~¬�>V�Ár,�l�TW j @���C%fgC0Q�KL BCi�¡�lZ j @�C0� j y�K^@ j I\KVUD@�UDOÀI�S?C��[ceUD@?EVZ�¯1X+v:KV@lI\CxADQ j ECx¬lM j I�K^[email protected] j Q�ADC , w0Q�Cx¬lM?KVQ\KV@?A�I\SBC~HJI j @B� j Q���@BUDQ�y j E^KV° j I\KVUD@1E^KVy�� ��� ��� ® ª?���¶�8�¸pBwK¢> CD>�I\SBC�f j EVK��NKLIJZ�UDO;�mr��g��§ ³s¨e>'=~¬�>��mr,�l� � Q�Usf[KV�?CxH j @ j E^I\CxQ\@ j I\KVfDC�I\U��mr,�l��OmUgQ;I�S?C@?UDQ�y j EVK^° j I\KVUD@�U$O ® ªN>

FeIYH\C0Cxy­H���UDQ\I\S[��S?KVEVC%I�U � UDKV@lI�UDMNI�I�S j I�I\SBC���C0S j flKVUDQ­�Ár,�g��W j @6@BU$IY��C­Ug�NcI j KV@?Ci�;�[Z��NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI�K j I\KVUD@�U$O�I\S?C j HhZ[y � I�U$I\K�W+OmUDQ�y UDO�I�S?C�C � j W I�C �?W�S j @?ADC�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�NC0@BH\K^IJZ �xª[>�RTS?C j H\Z[y � I\U$I�KVW�OmUgQ\y UDO#�xª%OmUgE^EVUs�2H+OmQ\Ugy�=+¬�>��J���g��§ rlos¨ew

� ª ����� � => ?2> @!A � � 0 ���¶�² 1 � 1 � �¢qDpg�

b1K^fgC0@­I�S?C�Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@­��C0IJ�+CxC0@��xª j @B� ® ª�KV@­I\SBC�W j HhC�U$O¶I\S?C�º�n���wlUD@?C2y�KVADSlI~I�S[MBH��C�I�C0y � I\Ci�¡I\U�C � � CxW I ) � ª �����) 0 ����� �

=> ?#> @EA� � ² 1 � 1

I\U���C2I�S?C j HhZ[y � I\UDI\K�W���C0S j f[KVUDQ~UDO ® ª[>��2Us��C0fgC0QiwD©TªYK�H j @?Ug@?EVU[W j EBOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£w[HhUI\S j I ) �xª�H ) 0 S j H@?U$I�S?K^@BA�I�UY�NU���KLI�S 3 ©�ª5H 3 0 �����u>sFG@�O j W Ixw$=~¬[Hx>V�Ár,�l�uw��¢q$pl���?K^Q�CxW I\EVZQ\C��BCxW I�I�S?C;�+UDMBE^Ugy%�¡K^@lI\CxADQ j E.HhI\Q�MBWuI�M?Q�C1UDO�I�S?C�HhCxELO�ceKV@gI�C0Q j W I\KVUD@ �Bj Q\I�U$O�©�ª[>

¯�@?C�W j @ j EVH\UTCxHhI j �?E^K�H\S j @BCxW CiH\H j Q�Z�W0UD@B�NK^I\KVUD@1OmUgQ¤I\S?C~C0KVADC0@[f j EVM?C0ce�NC � Cx@B�NCx@BW CU$O'© ª « § r��i¨e>NFG@¡O j W IxwB�NKVQ�CxWuI�KV@lI\C0AgQ j I\KVUD@�UsfDC0QY�£²,�$�+Z[KVC0E��?H

' )+W, '*)+W,�. � ��� 7 � . � ® ª «s��� . ���65/3 ©Tª «3 � / � p �¢q?�i�

Page 16: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

` : Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

� � Q�Usf[KV�NCi��I�S j I�I�S?CYKV@gI�C0AgQ j E�UsfgC0QG��C �NK�HJI�H j @B��I\S j I�I\S?CYKV@lI\CxADQ j I\KVUD@�H+UsfgC0QG�.w[� .j @B��I\S?C�H\M?y�y j I�K^Ug@¡UsfgC0Q ��W j @¡��CYK^@lI\CxQ�W�S j @?AgCx�B� >

RTS?C�¯1X+v EVC j �?H�� j W�]�I�U I�S?C�W Ug@lfgC0@lI\KVUD@ j E�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E��?C0Q�K^f j I�K^fgC ® ª « �3 ©Tª «2H 3 0 OmUDQ­C � � EVK�W K^I\EVZ �NCx@BHhK^IJZlce�?C � C0@B�NCx@lI�C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@�H0>FG@�I\S?K�H�W j H\C�©Tª «��NC0c� Cx@B�?H�Ug@�I�S?C;� / Ug@?EVZ�f[K j 0 w?H\U�I\S j I�=~¬�>V�£²,�D�~Q�Cx�?MBW CiH~I�U

' ) + , . � ��� 7 � . � ® ª « ��� . �G� � 5/' ) + , . � U/ ���¶� � /N��� 7 � . � 3 © ª « § 0 ¨3 � U/ ��� . � ��� � � �� � 5

/' ) + , . � U/ ���¶� � /N��� 7 � . �I� /N��� . � 3 © ª « § 0 ¨3 0 ��� . � ��� � � �� ' ) + , . � ��� 7 � . � 3 © ª « § 0 ¨3 0 ��� . � �

FeO+UD@BC%@?Us� y;M?E^I\K � E^KVCxH1��U$I�S�H\KV�?CxH��lZ B ±� UD@?C�Q�CxW UsfgC0Q�H�I�S?C;UgQ\KVADKV@ j E��NC0 B@?K^I\KVUD@U$O ® ª « >

¯�@?C2OmM?Q\I\SBC0QTE^KVy�KLITU$O��¢²,�D� jD�?� C j Q�H�I�U%��C���UDQ\I\S j W Ugy�y�Cx@lI&%[FeO.I\SBC0Q�C�K�H~Ug@?EVZUD@?C�UNW0W0M � KVCx�¡UDQ��?K^I j E���� �1k� wNI\SBCYC �?W�S j @BADC�W UDy � UD@?Cx@lITUDO=+¬�>V�£²,�$�~Q�C j �BH

� U< ���¶� ' )+V,�. � < ��� 7 � . �I� < ��� . � � ® ª ��� . � � � ' )+W,�. . � U< ��� . . � � <��� . . �1 � . . � � . 1 ��� � � � �¸p

�mM � UD@�KV@BHhCxQhI�K^Ug@�UDOT�£²D²g�h�u>�¯�@BC�I\S[MBHTC j HhKVEVZ�KV�?C0@lI\K^ BCxH

® ª ������� � � ' ) + , . 1 � <���� .�� 1 1 � . � � 1 � � �² ' ) + , . 0 ��� .V�1 � . � � 1 �¢qg²D�

j H�H\UDEVMNI\KVUD@­UDO¶I\S?C1¯1X+v#K^@lI\CxADQ j E?Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@�OmUDQ~H � KV@NceH j I�M?Q j I\Ci�;IJ�+UDc£CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@�H\Z[HhcI\C0y­Hxw+KV@ � C0Q\OmCxWuI j AgQ\CxC0y�C0@lI���K^I\S =+¬�>��J�»qD� >~k?UgQ�I\SBCxH\C6H\Z[HhI\Cxy­H­I\SBC�C �?W�S j @?ADC� UDI\C0@lI�K j E��JMBHhI�S j H�I\U�C0EVK^y�KV@ j I�CYI\S?C;HhCxELO�ceK^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^Ug@�U$O�I\S?C;C0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BHxw?�?MNI��?UlCiH@?U$I2KV@BW EVMB�NC j @[Z�X j M?EVK¤Q\C � M?E�HhKVUD@ j y�Ug@?A;Ci¬lM j E.H � KV@BH0>

� ��� � ��� � 4 ���&��� � � � "� ��"$+�� " ���(��* � � "$+���*�!������ �¯�@?C�S j H�@?Us�*Q�C j W�S?Cx��I\S?C � UDKV@gI j I���S?K�W�S¡KLI�K�H�W0E^C j Q�I\S j Ixw j H j y j I\I\CxQ�U$O � Q�KV@NcW K � E^CgwUD@?C�W j @¾S j @��NE^C¡UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lI%OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�K^@ j O j HhS?KVUD@ W UD@�HhK�HJI�C0@lI��KLI�S6n1k�R�>.v�UDQ�C0UsfDCxQxw?I\S?C�HhMB�BHhCi¬lM?C0@lI�´NCxWuI�K^Ug@BH1U$O�I�S?K�H�Q�C0f[KVC0�a��KVE^E'H\S?Us� I\S j II\S?C­¯1X~v�K^@lI�C0ADQ j EÀCx¬lM j I\KVUD@�W j @ j E�HhU���C%H\UDEVfDCi��K^@ � Q j W I\K�W Cg>��2Us��C0fgC0QiwNK^@�flKVC0�U$OTI\S?C�W0UDy � EVKVW j I�Cx��HhI\Q�MBWuI�M?Q\C­UDOT=+¬[H0>��¢²��$�uw��¢² �g� j @��¤w.KV@ �Bj Q\I\K�W M?E j Qiw¤U$O2=+¬�>��mr[qD�I\S?C�¬lM?CiHJI�K^Ug@�¬lM?K^I\C�@ j I\M?Q j EVE^Z j Q�KVH\CxH�S?Us��C 2�W KVC0@lI�I\S?C6¯1X+v K�H>'�RTS?C j @BH\��C0QUD�[f[K^UgMBHhEVZ��NC � C0@B�BH�Ug@�I\S?C�H\Z[HhI\Cxy·M?@B�NCxQ1W0UD@BH\KV�?C0Q j I\KVUD@ j @B��UD@�I\S?C�@[M?y�C0Q�KVW j EK^y � EVC0y�C0@lI j I\KVUD@�U$O�I\S?C�¯1X~v W�S?UgH\C0@�> �C0fgC0Q\I\S?CxE^CiH\Hxw j H j Q�M?EVC�UDO2I\S[M?y;� Ug@?Cy�KVADSlI�H j Z�I\S j I%¯1X+v W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@BH j Q�C;CiH\H\C0@lI�K j E^EVZ�UD@?C�UgQ�IJ��U¡UDQ��NC0Q�H1U$O+y j A$c@?KLI�MB�NC�E^CiH\H+C 2�W KVC0@lI�I�S j @�I\S?C1W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A%bYb�� W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@BH0>N�+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@lI\EVZDwj @ j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\CY�¢HhCxy�K^c j @ j E^ZlI\K�W j E���HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@�U$O¶I\S?CY¯1X~v#KV@gI�C0AgQ j E?Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@­K�H�U$O�NC  B@BKLI�CYK^@lI\CxQ\CiHJIi>

Page 17: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ ` �RTS?C­y j KV@�Q�C j HhUg@�OmUgQYI\SBC­K^@?C;2�W KVC0@BW0Z6UDO+I�S?C�¯1X~v K�H�I\S?C � Q\CiHhCx@BW C�UDO�I�S?C

b1Q\CxC0@ . H�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@��¢²Dqg�+��UDI\S�K^@�I\SBC1Q�CxH � UD@BH\C�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@��£²$ol� j @B��K^@�I\S?CYKV@?S?Ugy�U$cADC0@BC0K^IJZ¾�¢² �l�u>¤RTS?K�HYb1Q\CxC0@ . H�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@��?C � C0@B�?H�Ug@�I�S?C�W0UDy � EVC I�C�¹�´�H � CxW I\Q�M?y�w@?U$I �JMBHhI�I\S?C�UNW0W0M � KVCx�¡HJI j I�CxHx>?� OmMBE^E�H\UDEVMNI�K^Ug@�UDO��¢²��$�~I\S[MBHTQ�Cx¬lM?KVQ�CxH~I\S?CYCxf j E^M j cI\KVUD@ j @B�.w � CxQ\S jD� Hxw[I\S?C�HhI\UgQ j ADC1U$O j E^E�U[WxW M � K^Ci� j @B�¡M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx��¹�´�HhI j I\CiH0>

FJH�I�S?C0Q�C j � j Z1I\U j fgUDK��YI\SBKVHCxf j E^M j I\KVUD@ 'TFG@B�NCxCx�¤w$H\MBW�S j1� Q�UNW Ci�NM?Q�C+S j H���CxC0@HhM?AgADCiHJI�Cx���[Z�¹�Q�K^CxADC0Qiw¶º.K j @B�6F j OmQ j I�C��¢¹Yº.Fh��§ rD¨£>¤RTS?C�K��NC j KVH1I�U�M�HhC j W0E^UlHhMBQ\Cj$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@�OmUDQ%I\S?C�b1Q\CxC0@ . HYOmM?@�WuI\KVUD@�wÀK£> Cg>�I�U jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�C�I\S?C�C0KVADC0@[f j EVM?C�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W CYKV@�I�S?C��NC0@BUDy�K^@ j I\UgQ�U$OT�¢²Dqg���[Z�HhUgy�C j fgC0Q j AgC�� ��§ ²Nw r$¨ew

� / ��� 7 � . ��� 5���� /� � �����I��U� ��� . �

� � � 3�� +� ��� � � . � � � / �����I� U/ ��� . �� � � �¢qD³g�

FG@BHhCxQhI�K^Ug@�KV@lI\U�I\SBC;¯1X~v:K^@lI\CxADQ j E¶Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@¡E^C j �?H�I\U

® ª «s�����2� �² 0 ����� 5 / � � � U/ ����� 3 ©Tª «

3 ��U/ ���¶� ��� � � � � � 1 � / ����� 1 � � ® /�� � � ©�ª «

� � / � �� ® / � ' ) + , � - / 1 � /N����� 1 ® ª « ����� � ��U/ ���¶� 3 © ª «

3 ��U/ ����� � ��� � � �-� �¢q$rl�

RTS?KVH j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�K�H%W Ugy � E^C0I\CxE^Z�M?@ j y%�?KVADM?UgMBH j H�HhU[Ug@ j H�©Tª «�K�H�KV@B�NC � C0@?c�NC0@lI­U$O\� / >~¯�@ I\S?C¡U$I�S?C0Q�S j @B�¤wOmUgQ�CxK^AgC0@[f j EVM?C cG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lI�©Tª «­I\SBC � Q\CiHhCx@BW CU$O � © ª « H � � /�KV@gI�Q\UN�NM�W CxH j @?C0�#C0@BC0Q�ADZ H�W j E^C�f[K j � �i>Tb1K^fgC0@�I\S?C�K^@?K^I\K j E�KV�?C jU$O2I�S?C¡W0E^UlHhMBQ\C jD�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I�K^[email protected]�SBUs�+CxfDC0Qiw.K^I�K�H�UD�[f[K^UgMBHYI�S j I�I\SBKVH;I\CxQ\y H\S?UDMBEV���C­@?CxADEVCxW I\Cx�.>�RTS?C­UD@BE^Z�H\K^I\M j I\KVUD@�K^@���S?K�W�S�UD@?C­W j @�HhCxQ\KVUDMBH\EVZ�K^@[fDCiHJI�K^A j I�C;I�S?CW UD@�HhCi¬gMBC0@BW0CxH;U$O�I�S?K�H­HJI�C � K�H�I\SBC¡Q�C0E j I�K^f[K�HJI�KVW�C �?W�S j @?ADC�§ r$�i¨e>FG@½I�S?KVH�W j H\C�@?C0cADEVCxWuI¡U$OYI�S?C � © ª « H � � /xcGW UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@¸Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI�H j @*C �?W CxE^EVC0@lI j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@.>RTS?C�¹Yº.F jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�K^Ug@�K�HYI�S[MBH j E^� j ZNH�M?@B�NCxQ�HhI\U[UN��I\U6K^y � EVZ�I�S?C�@BC0ADEVCxW I%U$OI\S?C � ©Tª «2H � � / c¢I�C0Q�y�w

®�� 6��ª « ���¶�2� �² 0 ����� 5 / � � ��U/ �����@3 © ª «

3 ��U/ ����� � � � � � � � 1 � / ����� 1 � ®�� 6��/ � � �¢qgqD�

� W j Q�C OmM?E¤EVU[UD] j I2=~¬[H0>��¢q$rl� wV�£qDqD�~C �NS?KV�?K^I�HTI�S j I2Ug@?C�S j HT@BU$I�ZDC0I�OmUgM?@B� j OmM?EVEHhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@6UDO+I�S?C � Q�UD�?EVC0y�w j H ® � 6��ª « j$�?� C j Q�H���U$I�S�UD@6I\S?C�EVC O�I\c£S j @B� j @���Ug@6I�S?CQ\KVADSlIhceS j @B��HhK��NCYU$O2�£qDqD� >�kBUDQ\I\M?@ j I\CxE^Zgw?UD@?C�W j @�Q�CxW j HhI�=+¬[H0>��¢q$rl�uw��¢qgqD� j H j HhC0I�U$OE^KV@?C j Q2Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@BHT��SBKVW�S j EVEVUs�*I\SBC%�NC I�C0Q�y�K^@ j I\KVUD@�U$O�� ® / ��KLI�S?UDMNI � Q\KVUDQ�][@?Us��E^cCx�NAgC�UDO ® � 6��ª « § r$¨ew»I\S[MBH � Q\Usf[K��NKV@?A j @ j @ j EVZlI\K�W j E[H\UDEVMNI�K^Ug@;UDO�I�S?CTK^@lI\CxADQ j E[Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�¢qDqg�u>[�2E^I\CxQ\@ j I\KVfDCxE^ZgwgUg@?C�W j @�K^I\CxQ j I\C�=+¬[H0>��¢q$rl�uw��¢qgqD�MB@gI�K^E¤H\C0E^O�ceW0UD@BH\K�HJI�C0@BW0ZDw[HJI j Q\IhcK^@?A���K^I\S�H\UDy�C j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@­OmUgQ� ® � 6��/ wNCg> A�>?UD�?I j KV@?Ci��OmQ�UDy¿I�S?C�º�n���>

`¸S?C0@ jD�?� EVK^Ci��I\U�I\S?C;C � j W I�C �?W�S j @?ADCgwNI\SBC;¹Yº.F�H�W�S?C0y�C;KVH j H2C;2�W KVC0@lI j H j� j Q\I\Q�C0C0cekBUNW�]�W j EVW0M?E j I\[email protected] j @B��U$O�I�C0@�Ug@?E^Z�H\E^KVADSlI\EVZ�EVCxH�HYC;2­W0K^Cx@lI�I\S j @ j bYb��W j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@.>[��I+I�S?K�H � UDKV@lI�Ug@?C�H\S?UgM?EV��@?C0fgC0Q\I\S?CxE^CiH\H+]DCxC � KV@�y�KV@B�­I�S j I�I\S?C�¹Yº.Fj$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@�Ug@?E^Z;H � C0Ci�?H�M � I\S?C�W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@;U$O � /[ws�?MNI'@?UDI�I�S j I'UDOBI\SBC�UDI\S?CxQK^@?AgQ\Ci�NKVC0@lI�H�UDO~I\SBC�¯1X~v Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@.>.RTS?C�y�UgHhIYI\KVy�C cGW UD@�HhM?y�KV@?A�HJI�C � K^@ j ¹Yº.F

Page 18: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

` � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

W j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@¡I\S[MBH�MBHhM j EVE^Z�KVH2I\S?C�Cxf j EVM j I�K^Ug@¡UDO 3 ©Tª «2H 3 ��U/ %���H�H\UlUg@ j HTI�S?C�C � j WuIC �?W�S j @BADC1KVHTMBH\Cx��I�S?C�C0f j EVM j I�K^Ug@�UDO'´NE j I\C0QTKV@lI\C0AgQ j EVH�K�H�Q�Cx¬lM?KVQ\Ci�¤w[��S?KVW�S¡MBH\M j EVEVZW UgHhI�HTy�UgQ\C1I\KVy�C�I\S j @¡I\S?CYW j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@¡U$O'�NCx@BHhK^IJZ�AgQ j �NK^Cx@lI�Hx>

RTS?C�¹Yº.F j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@ � Q�CxH\C0Q�fDCiH���UDI\S I\SBC�¹Yº.F�KV�?C0@lI\K^IJZ �Ár,�l� j @B��I�S?Cj H\Zly � I�U$I�KVW;��CxS j f[K^UgQ�UDO ® ªNw.=~¬�>��mr,�l���mOmUDQ1 B@?K^I\C­H\Z[HhI\Cxy­H�� >�FeI�K�H�C � j W I�OmUDQYH � KV@NcH j I\M?Q j I�Cx� IJ�+UDc£CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@ H\ZNHJI�C0y­Hxw~K£> Cg>~K^I j E�H\U¾H j I\K�HJ BCiH�=+¬�>��¢qg²D� >+v�UgQ\CxUsfDC0Qiw j EVEj$�?� EVK�W j I�K^Ug@BH j f j KVE j �?EVC2HhU�O j Q � UDKV@lI j I~I\S?C�Q j I\S?CxQ�S?KVADS j WxW M?Q j W0Z�U$O¶I�S?KVH j$�B� Q\U»�[cK^y j I�K^[email protected] j ITEVC j HJI�KV@¡I\S?C�W j H\C1UDO�I�S?CYC � j W I�C �?W�S j @BADC­�ÁH\C0C�´[CiWuI\KVUD@�³l�u>

� ���2� � |�� ���»�~| ��� � �[� �J}���+C0OmUDQ�C j �?�NQ�CxH�HhKV@?A­I�S?C%K�H\H\M?C�U$O~W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�KV@�y�UDQ�C;�NC0I j KVE£w�K^I�KVH�K^@�HJI�Q\MBW I\KVfDC%I\UHJI�MB�NZ�I\S?C��[c£Ug@?E^Z�EVK^y�K^I+OmQ�UDy j ¬lM j @gI�KLI j I�K^fgC � UgK^@lI�U$O.f[K^Cx�Y>lRTSBKVH j @ j E^ZNH\KVH~HhCxQ\fgCxHIJ�+U � M?Q � UgH\CxH&%�RTSBC� BQ�HJI1KVH�I\U j H�HhCxQhI�I�S?C j W0W0M?Q j W Z�U$O'I�S?C;¹Yº�F j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@.>��H�K�H¡W EVC j Q�OmQ\Ugy I�S?C6�NK�H�W MBH�HhKVUD@ UDO�´NCxWuI�K^Ug@¦²N> qNw j @[Z E j Q�ADC0ceH�W j E^C jD�?� EVKVW j I\KVUD@U$O�UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lI�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H���KVEVE�S j fgC�I\U Q\CxE^Z Ug@¸I\S?C6C 2�W KVC0@�W Z U$O�I�S?C¹Yº.F jD�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I�K^Ug@.>�¯�@?C�I\S[MBH�S j H�I\U�y j ]gC�H\M?Q�C�I�S j I­I�S?K�H j$�?� Q\U j W�S¾Z[KVC0E��?HQ\C j H\UD@ j �?E^C�Q�CxH\M?E^I�H j I�E^C j HhI�OmUDQ�I\S?C�y�UlHJI�H\K^y � EVC�UgQ\�?K^I j ELcG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lI2OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£wI\S?CYC0� j WuI�©Tª?>?RTS?CYH\CxW Ug@B� j KVy U$OÀI\S?K�H�´[CiWuI\KVUD@¡K�H�I\U­�NC0y�Ug@BHJI�Q j I\C1I\S j I�UDQ��?K^I j E^c�NC � C0@B�?C0@lI+OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H j Q�C���UDQ\I\S­I�S?C�KV@BW0Q\C j H\Cx�­W Ugy � MNI j I\KVUD@ j E�C0µ�UgQhIiw[K¢> CD>lI\S j II\S?CxZ�KV@�O j WuI�Z[K^CxEV�¡KVy � Q\UsfgC0y�C0@lI�H+UsfgC0Q�I\SBC�HJI j @B� j Q���OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVHx>

� ��� � #�#�"(��"# *)* � +��#����� � " ���#�* ��� "$+�� * !FG@�R j �?E^C�²�I�S?CT�[c£Ug@?EVZ%ADQ�UDMB@B�;HhI j I\C�Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxHUDO¤W0E^UlHhCi�[cGHhM?��HhS?CxE^E j I\Ugy�HQ�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?AOmQ\Ugy �NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@lI~n�kR y�C0I\S?UN�?H j Q�CTW0UDy �Bj Q\Ci�%��K^I\S�I�S?C2W UgQ\Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A���k�f j E^M?CiH�Á�2EVE[W j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@BH¤��C0Q�C � C0Q\OmUDQ�y�Ci��OmM?E^EVZ�@[M?y�C0Q�KVW j EVE^Zgw Q\CxE^Z[KV@?A�UD@� �@?KLI�C~�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CiHy�C0I\S?UN�?H��u>�FG@�I�S?C­ BQ�HJI�W UgE^M?y�@�I�S?C�Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxHYUg�NI j K^@BCx���[Z�H\UDEVMNI�K^Ug@�U$OTI\S?C�OmM?EVE¯1X~v·Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@��£²,�$�'OmUDQ~I\S?C�C �?W�S j @BADC%�h���g� j Q�C2ADKVfDCx@.>DFG@­I�S?C�n�kR¸W Ug@lI\C �[I+I\S?K�HC � j W I�S j @��NE^KV@?A�U$OI\S?C;C � j W I�C �?W�S j @?ADC�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E � Q�UsflK��NCiH�I\SBC%Q�C OmC0Q�C0@�W C�� j I jOmUDQI\SBC��[c£Ug@?E^Z%E^KVy�KLIi>gk?UgQ j EVENU$I�S?C0Q�y�C0I\S?UN�?HI�S?C�C0@BC0Q�ADKVCxH j Q�C�I\S[MBH'AgK^fgC0@�Q\CxE j I\KVfDCI\U�I�S?K�H+Q�C OmCxQ\Cx@BW C�HJI j @B� j Q��.>g�2y�Ug@?A�I�S?CxH\C�y�C I�S?UN�?H+I\S?C1¹Yº.F jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�K^Ug@;OmUgQI\S?C�C � j W I�C �?W�S j @?ADC%KVH�U$O � Q\KVy j Q�Z�KV@lI\C0Q�CxHhI�S?CxQ\Cg>�RTSBC% BQ�HhI�UD��HhCxQ\f j I�K^Ug@�KVH�I\S j II\S?C­¹Yº.F�C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH j Q\C�C �[I�Q\Cxy�CxE^Z�W0E^UlHhC;I\U¡I�S?C�OmM?E^E+¯1X+v Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxHx>¤k?UDQ ��C0EVK^M?yI\S?C­¹Yº.F j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�K�H�C � j W Ixw j H�C0� � E j K^@BCx��KV@�´[CxW I\KVUD@�²N> qN>¤�2EVE'U$I�S?C0QY¹Yº.FC0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH j Q\C�S?KVADSBC0QTI\S j @¡I\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��NK^@BA­¯1X+v f j EVM?CiH0w?W0UD@BH\KVHhI\Cx@lIT��K^I\S�I�S?CO j WuI�I�S j I�I\S?C�OmM?EVE¯1X+v AgC0@?CxQ j I\CiH�I\S j I � UDI\C0@lI�K j E.��S?K�W�S¡y�KV@?KVy�KV°0CiH�I�S?CYC0@?CxQ\AgZC � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@ j I1S j @��¤>�RTSBC;�NCxflK j I�K^Ug@�U$O'I�S?C�¹Yº�F j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@�HhZNHhI\Cxy j I\K�W j E^EVZK^@BW0Q\C j H\CxH;��KLI�S¾I�S?C j I\Ugy�KVW¡HhKV°0Cg> �C0fgC0Q\I\S?CxE^CiH\HxwC0fDCx@�OmUDQ�fgC0Q�Z�SBC j f[Z j I\Ugy­H%K^IKVHYHhI\KVE^E'@BU�E j Q�ADCxQ�I�S j @��iq�y � j QhI�Q\CxCD>¤�2@�K��NC j U$O+I\S?C�Q�C0EVC0f j @�W C�U$O~I�S?K�H�C0Q�Q\UgQ�K�HUD�NI j KV@?Cx���lZ j W0UDy �Bj Q�K�HhUg@���KLI�S�I�S?C­W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A�ºÀn2� j @B��bYb�� Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxHxw��S?KVW�S j Q\C j E�H\U�EVK�HJI�Cx��K^@*R j �BE^C�²N>+=�fDCx@½I�S?C6bYb��·f j EVM?CiH0w���SBKVW�S¸�NQ j HhI\K�W j E^EVZK^y � Q�UsfDC�UsfgC0QI\SBC�º�n2� C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH0w j Q\C�y�UgQ\C�I�S j @ j @�UDQ��NC0Q�UDO¤y j AD@?K^I\M��NC�OmM?Q\I\S?CxQj � j Z�OmQ�UDy¿I�S?CYC � j WuI�¯1X~v�� j I j I\S j @�I�S?C�¹Yº.F+@[M?y%��C0Q�H0>

Page 19: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ ` ��������� �� Ô+=gÖhÅ[Î0Ù��xÆ=�ÁÉiÙlÏ�� �0ÐJÉc�gÙ[Ê�ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆ~Æ�ÙgÆ�Ð �iËÍÆ�ÌÉWZ�Ö�ÏLÉxÌGÆuÊQ�ÁÌ �T�lÌGÅlÆ�ÏLÏ?Î ÈJÉiÇYÌ0���DÆ�Ï Z�Ö�ÉiÙlÌGËÍÌ �ÈJÆ�Ù$È'ÑTØ�� ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ19 � � < ×»Æ�ÐJÌ �lÌ��0? Y b ? �@A b Ø���� ` �����1A 9 �2�;< ÎxÙlÊ��9� 9 � � < Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËÍÆ�Ì�ÚmÎxÏÍÏÆ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËLÆ�Ì+ËÍÙ�Ç���Î0ÐGÈGÐJÆ�ÆuÛ\Ü

AÈJÉiÇ ( � * � ( � * � ' (��� � * �ÑTØ�� �0? Y ? �@A ���1A �G�

�+Æ ' ��� : ` Ü � "$Ü " ` � Ü " : Ü � "DÜ ".�Æ ' ` � � ��� Ü � "$Ü ` � �$Ü ` ` � Ü � '!"DÜ : Æ ' ` �2� � � �$Ü � "$Ü : ` "#� � Ü � ' � DÜ � ' ` Ü �� � ' ` ��� : `c` Ü : "$Ü � ` :� Ü � '!"DÜ � '8DÜ `A~Ð 'E� �;:#� ` � Ü � ` Ü � ��� � � Ü � � ` Ü � 'E�$Ü � Î ' :1�;:1� � ` Ü � � Ü � � �2� ` Ü � � �sÜ � ' : Ü � Ù ' ` �#����� � Ü � $Ü � #� � � Ü � ' � � � Ü : ' ` DÜ ��TÐ ' �#� � � " � � Ü � $Ü � � ` �&: Ü � ' ` � Ü � ' ` � Ü "�sÐ '8 ` ` �WcDÜ � $Ü : �#�W1�sÜ � ' � Ü � ' ` � Ü �ØÀÊ ' � �c � ��" : Ü " � Ü � :#� � : Ü " ' : �$Ü � ' ` �$Ü "� Ê 'E� � : � `-` � Ü � : Ü " ��� � � Ü : '8 ` Ü � ' ` � Ü �� Æ ' ��� � ` � ` Ü ` : Ü ` � � : $Ü � � � Ü � ' ` � Ü .�Î ' ���#� 1� �&: Ü : : Ü � �1� � � Ü � ` �sÜ � ' ` � Ü � � ' ` c#� ` � ` : Ü ` "$Ü " ` "1�2"1�sÜ : ' � � � Ü � '8��DÜ �� � ' ` � � " � � : "DÜ � �$Ü ` ` #" � "$Ü � ' ��� ` Ü � '8 ` Ü "7~Ù ' � ` � :&:1� � �$Ü � � Ü � ` � � � � Ü � Ü ' �;: Ü �7�Î ' � #"#� � ���#� Ü � � Ü � ` � � " � Ü � "DÜ � ' � �$Ü � É '8 �#��� � � ��� Ü � ` � Ü � ` ��� " � Ü � '8 � $Ü ` '8��DÜ �

RTS?C�@?C0�lIW Ugy ��j Q�KVH\UD@1I\U���C+y j �NC~K�H¤I�S j I�U$O�¯1X~v j @B� � j Q\I\Q�C0C cGk?UNW�]2Q�CxH\M?E^I�Hx>FG@ ´[CxW I\KVUD@*²N> ²�KLI�S j H­��C0Cx@¸C0y � S j HhKV°0Ci� I\S j I�I\S?C��lceUD@BE^Z�¯1X+v Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI�H jQ\CiHJI�Q\K�WuI�Cx��� j Q\I\Q�C0C0cekBU[W�]1C0@BC0Q�ADZYy�K^@BK^y�KV° j I�K^Ug@ %D¯�@?CTy�K^@?KVy�K^°xCxHÀI\SBCTH j y�C�C0@?CxQ\AgZC � � Q�CxH�[email protected]��?MNI�M?@��NC0Q¡I\SBC�H\M?�BH\K��NK j Q\Z¸W0UD@B�NK^I\KVUD@¦U$O%S j flKV@?A j y;M?ELI�K � E^K�W j I\KVfDCC �?W�S j @BADC � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E£>��2Us� KVy � UgQhI j @lI�K�H�I\SBKVH1HhMB�BHhK��NK j Q�Z�W0UD@B�NK^I\KVUD@ '%��H�R j �?EVC;²HhS?Us�2H�I�S?C­�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W CxH j Q\C�Q j I\S?CxQYHhy j EVE£>¶kBUDQ ��C;I�S?C�¯1X~v C0@?CxQ\AgZ¡K�H�K��NC0@lI\K�W j E��KLI�S�I\S?C ��k f j EVM?CDw j H%K^@�I�S?K�H%W j HhC�I\S?C ��k Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�W j @���C�I\Q�K^f[K j EVE^Z�Q\CiW j HJIj H j ¹�´¾Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@���K^I\S I\S?C6¯1X+v C �?W�S j @?ADC � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E��¢qg²D� >�v�UDQ�C0UsfgC0Qiw�C0fgC0@OmUDQ�I�S?C�S?C j flKVCxHhI2C0EVC0y�Cx@gI�H�I�S?C%�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CiH���C IJ��C0C0@6¯1X+v j @B� ��k C0@BC0Q�ADKVCxH j Q\C��CxE^Us� rlpy � j Q\I\Q�C0Cg>�RTSBC j �?�NK^I\KVUD@ j EÀf j Q\K j I�K^Ug@ j EÀOmQ\CxCx�NUgy�U$O�I�S?C ��k jD�?� Q�U j W�SI\S[MBH jD�?� C j Q�H�I\U���C�UDO�fgC0Q�Z�EVK^y�K^I\Ci��K^y � UDQ\I j @�W CD>�RTS?C��[c£Ug@?EVZ�¯1X~v�K�H2KV@�y j @[ZQ\CiH � CxW I�H � S[ZNHhK�W j E^EVZ�Ci¬gMBK^f j EVC0@lITI\U�I�S?C � j QhI�Q\CxC cGk?UNW�] j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@.>

RTS?KVH%HJI j I\Cxy�C0@lI%K�H%W UgQ\Q�UD��UDQ j I�Cx���lZ�R j �?EVC�³?w.KV@���S?K�W�S�I\S?C��lceUD@BE^Z6ADQ�UDM?@B�HJI j I\C1C0@BC0Q�ADKVCxH+U$O j @lMBy%��C0QTU$OÀ�?K j I\UDy�K�W2y�UDEVCxW0M?EVCxH j Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�Cx���ÁC0f j EVM j I�Cx� j II\S?C�C � � C0Q�K^y�Cx@gI j E���Ug@B��E^Cx@?A$I�SBH�� >[FG@�R j �?EVC1³%I\SBC1¹Yº�F�C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH�§ qN�0¨ j Q\C�MBH\Cx� j HQ\C0OmC0Q�C0@BW0C�@[M?y;��CxQ�Hxw»OmUDQ j Q�C j HhUg@�I\S j I'��K^EVE?��CxW0UDy�C2W EVC j Q�KV@ j y�Ugy�C0@lIx>D��E^ENUDI\S?CxQC0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH j Q\C�ADKVfDCx@�Q�C0E j I�K^fgC%I�U�I�S?C�¹Yº.F�f j E^MBCxHx>¤FeO�Ug@?C�W0UDy �Bj Q\CiH�I�S?C­¹Yº.F j @B���k¾Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxHTUg@?C� B@B�BH0w j HTC � � CxWuI�Cx�¤w?I\S j I�I\S?C�E j I\I\CxQ�C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH j Q�C j E^� j ZNH~EVUs��C0Q¥ ��KLI�S6I�S?C­C �?W0C � I�K^Ug@�U$O � w j H1OmUgQ�I�S?K�H�H � K^@NcGH j I\MBQ j I\Cx��IJ�+UDc£CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@�HhZNHhI\Cxy��UDI\S�C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH�y%MBHhI2��CYK��NCx@gI�KVW j E£>

Page 20: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� " Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

������������ Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ��xÆ=�ÁÉiÙgÏ � �0ÐJÉc�gÙ[Ê�ÌeÈhÎ ÈJÆÆ�ÙgÆ�Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì.É-ZNÊgËLÎ0ÈJÉxÇYËLÖ�ÇYÉiÏÍÆ�Ö �gÏLÆ�Ì0���$Æ�Ï Z�Ö�ÉxÙlÌGËÍÌeÈJÆ�ÙsÈÑTØ�� 9 ��" < ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌT×»Æ�ÐJÌ �gÌ �0? Y09 � ` < b ? � A¸Î0Ù[Ê �G��9 � � < Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËÍÆ�Ì2Î0ÈTÈJÅgÆ1Æ>=DÒNÆ�ÐJËÍÇYÆ�ÙsÈhÎ0Ï�NÉxÙ[Ê%ÏLÆ�Ù��xÈJÅgÌ2ÚmÎxÏÍÏ�Æ�ÙgÆ�Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì�ËÍÙ�Ç���Î0ÐGÈGÐJÆ�Æ Û\Ü

ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆ���� '!( � * � ( � * � ' (����� * �9 .�ÉxÅgÐ < �0? Y ÑTØ�� ? �@A �9�

� X à � ` Ü � "�" `-` c$Ü : "DÜ � � �$Ü � "DÜ "?�Ë X à � �$Ü " � : ` � �1� "DÜ � � � $Ü � ' ` Ü �.�Æ X à � � Ü : "�" � � ` ��� Ü � :&: : Ü � ' : Ü . X 6�� DÜ "#"- � ��" � �$Ü � ��� $Ü :� X à � � Ü � � � �W#� � Ü " �#� : Ü X à � � Ü " � � ` " � � � �$Ü ` �$Ü : ` ��� �$Ü " ' � Ü �Ñ X 6�� � Ü ��� ` ` � � :#� ` Ü `-` Ü � ` � � � Ü "� X à � � Ü :1�2� ` � �#�&: "DÜ � ` : Ü ` � "c$Ü ?�Ë � à � DÜ " ` � � � � : Ü � �2�� Ü : '!"DÜ �.�� à � � Ü c : � � ` � �DÜ " � �#�$Ü ` ' � Ü : � 6 � � Ü " � � � � � ��� Ü � DÜ � � `c` Ü � � à � ` Ü � - ` "#"�" :#� Ü � `-` Ü " � ` : Ü '8DÜ . � à � � Ü �&: ` � � ` :�� Ü ` ` ` � Ü ` ' : Ü �� Ñ Ã � � Ü ` � `c` ����� DÜ : Ü � ` � � � Ü � ' � Ü � Ñ X�� � Ü ` � � ` � � � �#�$Ü � ` c : Ü �

¯�@ I\S?C�UDI\S?CxQ�S j @B�¤w+I\S?C�OmM?E^E�¯1X~v Q�CxH\M?E^I�H6§ qDps¨ j Q\C�Cx@?C0Q�ADC0I\K�W j E^EVZ½S?KVADSBC0QI\S j @�I\S?C¡¹Yº.FY� j I j w j E^I\S?UgM?ADS�I\SBC�¯1X~v �[Z�W UD@�HJI�Q\MBW I\KVUD@ � Q�UN�NMBW0CxHYI�S?C�U � I\K^cy%M?y C0�?W�S j @?AgC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E£> �2Us�#W j @½I\S j I­S j$�?� C0@ '�RTS?C j @BH\��C0Q�KVH�S?K��?�NCx@ K^@I\S?C%I\CxW�SB@?KVW j E��NC I j KVEVH�U$OI\SBC�W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@BH0>�RTS?C ��k Q�CxH\M?E^I�H��+CxQ\C�Ug�NI j K^@BCx�¡OmM?EVE^Z@lMBy�CxQ\K�W j E^EVZDwÀMBH\K^@?A�E j Q�ADC­Q�C j ELcGH �Bj W0C­ADQ�KV�?H�§ qg²»¨e>À�2EVE+n1kR¿W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@BH�Q\CxE^Z�UD@� j H\KVH�H\C IC � �Bj @�HhKVUD@BHx>0FG@%I\S?CTW j HhC+U$O?I�S?CT¹Yº.F~� j @B��ºÀn2����W j E�W M?E j I�K^[email protected]�lI�Q\Cxy�C0EVZE j Q\AgC2IJ��U$cGW C0@lI�C0Q�� j H\KVHTH\C I�HTS j fDC���CxC0@¡MBHhCi�6§ qN�0¨£wNH\U%I�S j ITI�S?CY¹Yº.F~@[M?y;��CxQ�H j Q\CCxH�HhCx@gI�K j E^EVZ�W UD@[fgC0Q�ADCx�1��K^I\S;Q\CiH � CxW I�I\U�I\S?C�� j HhK�HÀH\C IHhKV°0Cg>s¯�@�I\S?C�U$I�S?C0QÀS j @B�.wxI�S?C¯1X~v¿Q�CxH\M?E^I�H.��C0Q�C~Ug�NI j K^@BCx�Y��K^I\S�HJI j @B� j Q���b j MBH�HhK j @Y� j HhK�H�HhC0I�HÀU$O?y�UDQ�C~y�UN�NCxHhIHhKV°0Cgw¶H\U�I�S j I�I�S?C;� j H\KVH1HhC0I1EVKVy�K^IYKVH1@?UDI1ZgC I�Q\C j W�S?Ci�¤>.�+E^C j Q�E^Zgw�W0UD@[fDCxQ\AgCx��¯1X~vC0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH�y;MBHJI�EVK^C���C0IJ�+CxC0@�I\S?C�¹Yº.F j @B��I�S?C ��k @[M?y%��C0Q�Hx>.¯�@BC;W j @�I�S?C0Q�C OmUgQ\CW UD@�W EVMB�NC�I\S j I�I�S?C¡C0Q�Q\UgQ%U$O�I\S?C�¹Yº.F j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@�K�H­Hhy j EVEVC0Q;I\S j @¾I\SBC¡KVy�c�Bj W I�UDO1�NK^µ¶C0Q�C0@lI�� j H\KVH­H\C I�H0>FG@�U$I\SBC0Q��+UgQ��BH;%'RTS?C j$�B� Q\U � Q�K j I\C�W�SBUDK�W C¡U$O�I�S?C� j H\KVH+HhC0I+K�H~y�UgQ\C�K^y � UDQ\I j @lI�I�S j @�I\S?C�S j @��NE^KV@?A;U$O¤I\SBC�¯1X~v¼K^@lI\CxADQ j E?Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@.>�+UDy �Bj Q�Cx����K^I\S�I\S?C%OmM?EVE�¯1X+v�w?I�S?C�¹Yº.F j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@¡I\S[MBH�C0K^I\SBC0Q j EVE^Us�2H2I\UH � C0Ci�%M � y�UDEVCxW0M?E j Q'W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@BH��m]gC0C � K^@BA�I�S?CT� j H\K�H'HhC0I� B�[Ci�B�ÀUDQ�I\U�A j KV@;S?KVADSBC0Qj W0W0M?Q j W Z­�[Z�Cx@?E j Q�ADKV@?A%I�S?CY� j HhK�H�HhC0Ix>

d2@lI\KVE�@BUs� I�U$I j EBCx@?C0Q�ADKVCxH~S j fDC���C0Cx@�W0UD@BH\KV�?C0Q�Cx�¤> ��Us�+CxfDCxQxwsI�S?C � SlZNH\KVW j E j @B�W�S?C0y�K�W j E � Q\U � CxQhI�K^CiH;M�HhM j E^EVZ½�NC � Cx@B��UD@�C0@?CxQ\AgZ¾�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CiH0>'FG@¸R j �?EVC�r6I�S[MBHI\S?C¡y�UgHhI�H\K^y � EVC�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CgwÀ@ j y�C0EVZ6I�S?C¡K^Ug@?K^° j I�K^Ug@ � UDI\C0@lI�K j E��ÁFJX+� wÀK�HHJI�MB�NKVCx��OmUgQ j I\Ugy�Hx>À��A j K^@�I�S?C�¹Yº.FYQ�CxH\M?ELI�H j Q\C�C �[I\Q�C0y�C0EVZ�W EVUgH\C�I\U�I\S?C�¯1X~v� j I j w¶��S?K�W�S j AgQ\CxC%fgC0Q�Z¡��C0EVE��KLI�S�I�S?C � j Q\I\Q�C0C0cekBUNW�]�FJX+H0>�¯�@�I�S?C�U$I\SBC0Q�S j @��¤wUD@?C1 B@B�BHTI\S?C��Á�+CxE^E^ce]l@BUs��@��+C0Q�Q\UgQ�H+K^@¡I�S?C�W j HhC�U$OÀI\S?C�ºÀn2� j @���I�S?C%bYb���>

Page 21: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � `����������D� Ô =DÖhÅ[ÎxÙ,�iÆ=�ÁÉxÙlÏ��1ËÍÉxÙlËÍÓuÎ0ÈJËÍÉxÙ%ÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏÍÌÀÉWZBÎ0ÈJÉxÇYÌ0���DÆ�Ï�ZVÖ�ÉiÙgÌGËÍÌeÈJÆ�ÙsÈ'ÑTØ��aÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ×iÆ�ÐJÌ �lÌ �0? Y b ? �@A b Ø���� ` �����1A ÎxÙlÊ �9� ÊgÎ0ÈhÎ$Ü A+ÏÍÌGÉ��iËÍ×»Æ�Ù�ËÍÌ�ÈJÅgÆ;ÅgË �iÅlÆ�ÌeÈ�ÉsÖ�Ö �gÒlËÍÆuÊÆ�Ë �xÆ�Ù$×iÎ0Ï��lÆ����

� �É-�gÈhÎ0ËLÙgÆuÊ ��Ë ÈJÅlËÍÙ�ÈJÅgÆ2ÑTØ���ÚmÎ0ÏÍÏ�Æ�ÙgÆ�Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì~ËÍÙ�Ç��TÎ ÐGÈGÐJÆ�Æ Û\Ü

'�� �

YeØ YeØC��YeØ���� ÑTØ�� ÑTØ�� �0? Y ? � A ���1A �9�

�+Æ � ` � � :� " 'E� ` � ".�Æ #"�� � �1� " ' ` � : `� � � �W � � � " ' � ` � `� Î ` � : ` �#� " ` ` � "�$Ð ` � � ` � ` " ` "� � � � " � ` ' � � � � � �A � ����� � ` � ' ` : � ` A8� ��� � ` : ' � � � � �?BË ` � : ` � : " ' `-` � " Î ` ��� ` � ` " ' � ` " `� ` � � ` � � " � ` " "78� ` � ` � " � ` � `� Ì ` � � ` � " � `c` "� Ù � �- �#�&: " � � � �

RTS?C'y�UgHhI�W Q�KLI�KVW j E$Cx@?C0Q�ADZ��?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C�UD@BC�W j @�EVU[UD] j I¤OmUDQ j I\Ugy�H¶K�H¤I�S?C�CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@j 2­@?K^IJZ��Á=+���u>NFG@�R j �?EVC�qYI�S?CY=~��HTUDO�k B j @B� j B j H � Q\UDI\U$IJZ � C�@BC0A j I\KVfDC�K^Ug@BHj Q�C­E^K�HJI�Cx��I�UDAgC I\SBC0Q���K^I\S�I�S?C�S?KVADSBCxHhI%UNW0W M � K^Ci��C0KVADCx@lf j E^M?CiH�OmUDQ�I\S?C�OmM?E^E2¯1X~vj @B�%I\S?C2¹Yº�F j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�>$¯�@BC+ �Q�HhIH\S?UgM?EV�;@?UDI\CTI\SBC�y�CxQ\CTC �NK�HJI�C0@BW0CTU$OBI�S?CxH\C

������������ Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ��xÆ=�ÁÉiÙgÏ �½Æ�ÏÍÆ�Ö\ÈGÐJÉiÙ Î �YÙlË ÈJËÍÆ�Ì�É-Z�Î0ÈJÉxÇYÌ0� �$Æ�Ï Z�Ö�ÉxÙlÌGËÍÌeÈJÆ�ÙsÈ �0? Y%×»Æ�ÐJÌ �gÌÑTØ��:ÐJÆ�Ì �gÏÍÈJÌ�Ü�A+ÏÍÌGÉ �xËÍ×»Æ�Ù�ËÍÌ�ÈJÅgÆ�ÅlË �iÅgÆ�ÌeÈ�ÉsÖ�Ö �gÒlËÍÆuÊ�Æ�Ë �iÆ�Ù$×xÎxÏ��lÆ���

ÚmÎxÏÍÏ~Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËÍÆ�Ì

ËÍÙ�Ç���Î0ÐGÈGÐJÆ�ÆuÛ\ÜA'ÈJÉxÇ ��Æ�ÈJÅgÉ$Ê '�� �

� �Ô A�� ÑTØ�� ` � ` Ü " � � Ü �

�0? Y ` � "DÜ � � � Ü � Î� ÑTØ�� ` $Ü � � Ü �

�0? Y ` $Ü � � � Ü HhZNHhI\C0y­H%��KLI�S?K^@½I\S?C�¯1X~v § q$³$¨£w j H�@BC0A j I\KVfDC­KVUD@BH;W j @¾@?U$I;��C�S j @B�?E^Ci���[Z6I�S?Cº�n2� j @B��I�S?C�bYb��%>�RTSBKVH1�NC  �W KVC0@BW0Z¡UDOI\S?C�W Ug@lfgC0@lI\KVUD@ j E.�NCx@BHhK^IJZ¡OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVHxw��S?KVW�S�� j H j @�KVy � UDQ\I j @lIy�UDI\KVf j I\KVUD@;OmUDQ�HhI\MB�?ZlKV@?A�KVy � E^K�W K^I'OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVH2�£´[CxW I\KVUD@�D> ²D�uw¤K�H j MNI\Ugy j I\K�W j E^EVZ�Q�CxH\UDEVfDCx���[Z�MBH\C­U$O�I\S?C­C0� j WuI�C0�?W�S j @?AgCD>¤RTS?C­C0�[K�HhI\C0@�W CU$O2@?CxA j I�K^fgC�KVUD@BH%KVH j �NK^Q�CxW I�W0UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@BW C�UDO2I\SBC � �1H , c£��C0S j f[KVUDQ�UDO2I\SBC�C � j WuIC �?W�S j @BADC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E£>���H�I\SBC�¹Yº�F � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E�KVH �Bj QhI�KVW0M?E j Q�E^Z¸W EVUgH\C�I�U�I\S?C6OmM?EVE

Page 22: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

��� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

¯1X~v � UDI\C0@lI�K j E'K^@�I\SBC­f j E^Cx@BW C�Q�C0AgK^y�CDw¶I�S?C­¹Yº.F1=~��H j Q\C j E^y�UgHhIYKV�?C0@lI\K�W j EI\UI\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?A�¯1X~v:f j EVM?CxHx>

¯�@?C­@?C �[I�Ug�BHhCxQ\fgCxH1I�S?C�S[M?ADC��?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C­��C0IJ�+CxC0@�I�S?C�=~� j @B�6I\S?C�S?K^AgS?CxHhIU[WxW M � K^Ci�­C0KVADCx@lf j E^M?C��A� $�B DFB �u>[RTS?KVH+�NK�H\W0Q\C �Bj @BW0Z%K�H+H\UDy�Cx��S j I+H\M?Q � Q�KVH\K^@BAYADKVfDC0@I\S?CYO j WuI2I�S j I�I\S?C;FJX~H�UDO�@?CxMNI\Q j E j I�UDy­H j Q�CYKV@�Q\C j H\UD@ j �?E^C j ADQ�C0C0y�Cx@gI���K^I\S�I�S?CW UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A\� $CBEDFB �¢HhCxC�R j �?E^C�rl� j @B��I�S j I'Ug@?C�W j @ � Q�UsfDC~I\S j I�I�S?C�C � j WuI'=~�KVH�KV�NCx@lI\K�W j EÀ��KLI�S�I\SBC%C � j WuI � $CBEDFB § q$r$¨��ÁK^@�W EVMB�NKV@?A�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@��u>��2Us��C0fDCxQxwNUg@?CS j H�I�U�]gC0C � KV@�y�KV@B��I\S j I�I\S?CY� j I j KV@�R j �BE^CYq�W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�­I�U;I�S?C��[c£Ug@?EVZ­E^KVy�KLIi>RTS?C��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C���C IJ��C0Cx@�I\S?C�=~� j @B� � $CBEDFB H\K^y � EVZ;Q�C ��CxWuI�HI\SBC2K^y � UDQ\I j @gI+Q\UgE^C��S?KVW�S­W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@ � E j ZNHÀOmUDQ�@BC0A j I\KVfDC�K^Ug@BHx>Dk?UgQI\S?C2H j y�CTQ\C j H\UD@%I\S?CT�[ceUD@?EVZ%=~��HHhS?UgM?E���@?UDI2��CYC0� � CiWuI\Ci��I\U���C�W0E^UlHhC1I�U�I\S?CYC0� � C0Q�KVy�Cx@lI j E.=+��Hx>

FG@�I\S?C%¬lM j @lI\M?y·W�S?C0y�K�W j EÀW Ug@lI\C �[I2I�S?C�y�UgHhI�KV@lI\C0Q�CxHhI\KV@?A�¬lM j @lI\K^I\KVCxH j Q\CYI�S?CH � CxW I\Q�UgH�W U � KVW�W Ug@BHJI j @lI�Hx>g�+UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A1� j I j OmUgQ�HhUgy�C��NK j I�UDy�K�W+y�UgE^CiW M?EVCxH j Q\CADKVfDC0@�KV@�R j �?EVC;oB>���H2OmM?EVE~¯1X~v Q�CxH\M?E^I�H�OmUgQ2I�S?CxH\C;¬lM j @gI�KLI�K^CiH j Q\C%@?U$I�ZgC I j f j K^E^c

������������ Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ,�iÆ=�ÁÉiÙgÏ���ÌGÒNÆ�Ö�ÈGÐJÉiÌGÖ�ÉiÒlËÍÖTÖ�ÉiÙlÌeÈhÎ0ÙsÈJÌ'É-Z¤ÊDËLÎ0ÈJÉiÇYËÍÖ+ÇYÉiÏÍÆ�Ö �gÏLÆ�Ì0� �DÆ�Ï Z�Ö�ÉiÙlÌGËÍÌ �ÈJÆ�Ù$È �0? Y 9 � ` < ×»Æ\ÐJÌ �lÌ �G� 9 �#� b � :;< ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ�Ü

ÇYÆ\ÈJÅlÉ$Ê � � � � �9 .ÀÉiÅgÐ < 9 Æ0/ < 9 Ö�Ç Ã <

� X �0? Y ` Ü �&: DÜ : � � : "c�G� ` Ü �&: DÜ : ` � � �

?�Ë X �0? Y �$Ü �&:&: "DÜ ` :#� - ��G� �$Ü ��� � "DÜ ` : " ` :

. X �0? Y DÜ " :�� "DÜ : " � � ����G� DÜ "#� : "$Ü � � �-#�

� X �0? Y � Ü c � "DÜ �2� ` ` �-c�G� "$Ü � ` � ` �

X �0? Y � Ü " `-` � Ü � ��� �#� :�G� � Ü " � � Ü �#� � �#� �

Ñ X �0? Y � Ü ` � � ` Ü �&� ` ` � � `�G� � Ü � ` ` Ü � �#� � "�" �� X �0? Y � Ü � � : ' ` Ü : " � ` �2� �G� � Ü ��" � ' ` Ü :��#� ` � � �

?�Ë � �0? Y DÜ "c � ` Ü � � ` � �#��G� DÜ "c � ` Ü � :� ` � " :� � �0? Y ` Ü : � � � Ü � "c � �2" `�G� ` Ü : �#� � Ü ` � � � � ���

� Ñ �0? Y � Ü " � " � Ü �W#" � �&� ��G� � Ü ` "#� � Ü �W � � � #�

� Ï X �0? Y DÜ ����� Ú ` Ü " � »Û : ` �G� DÜ � � Ú ` Ü � »Û : ` �

j �?EVCDw[I�S?C�¹Yº.F+@lMBy%��C0Q�H�W j @¡UD@BE^Z­��C�W Ugy ��j Q�Cx����K^I\S � j Q\I\Q�C0C cGk?UNW�]�� j I j > �2Us�Tc

Page 23: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � C0fDCxQxw�OmUgQ�C j W�S K^@B�?K^f[K��NM j ETy�UDEVCxW0M?E j Q�ADCxUDy�C I�Q\Z�I\SBC¡C0� j WuI�¯1X~v C0@?CxQ\AgZ�y%MBHhI��C�H\UDy�C0��SBC0Q�C;KV@6��C IJ��C0Cx@�I\S?C­¹Yº.F j @B��I\SBC���k*Cx@?C0Q�ADZ¾�mOmUDQ� ?�NCi��� j HhK�HYH\C I�� >�+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@gI�E^Zgw?I�S?C�¯1X~v Cx@?C0Q�ADZ¡HhMBQhO j W C�EVK^CiH2KV@���C IJ��C0C0@�I�S?C;¹Yº�F j @B��I�S?C���kHhM?Q\O j W0CD>��H�EVUD@?A j H%I\S?C�E j I\I\C0Q;IJ��U�H\M?Q\O j W CiH j Q\C�fDCxQ\Z�W EVUgH\CDw�UD@BC¡W j @ j EVH\U���CHhM?Q�C�I�S j I+I\S?C1¹Yº.F j @B�¡¯1X~v#Q\CiHhMBELI�H j ADQ�C0C�fDCxQ\Z;�+CxE^E£>[RTS?KVH~KVH+C � j WuI\EVZ���S j I~Ug@?C B@B�?H&%NRTS?CY¹Yº.F j @�� ��k½H � CxW I\Q�UgH�W U � KVW�W UD@�HJI j @lI�H1� j H j y�C j HhM?Q�C2OmUgQ~I�S?C�C0@?CxQ\AgZHhM?Q\O j W0Ci��HhSBUs� fDCxQ\Z�AgUlUN� j ADQ�C0Cxy�C0@lIxw¶KV@ �Bj QhI�KVW0M?E j Qiw�K^O�Ug@?C;I j ]gCxH1KV@gI�U j W0W0UDM?@lII\S j I1@?UDI j E^E ��k Q\CiHhM?E^I�H1KV@6R j �?EVC;o�y�K^AgSlI1��C%OmMBE^EVZ�W Ug@lfgC0Q�ADCi����KLI�S�Q�CxH � CiWuI1I\UI\S?C�� j H\KVH�H\C I%H\KV°0CD>ÀFG@�W UD@�W EVMBHhKVUD@�w.UD@?C�W j @¾HhI j I\C�I\S j I%KV@�I\S?C��lceUD@BE^Z�EVKVy�K^I%I�S?C¹Yº.F�Q\CiHhM?E^I�H j Q�C�CxH�HhCx@gI�K j E^EVZ�K��NC0@lI�KVW j EB��K^I\S�I�S?C1¯1X+v f j EVM?CiH0wg��S?KVW�S�w$K^@�I�M?Q�@.w j Q\CKV�NCx@lI\K�W j E¶I�U�I\S?C ��k½� j I j >

d2@lI\KVE�@BUs�¸UD@?EVZ�ADEVUD� j E�¬lM j @lI�KLI�K^CiH~EVK^]gC�I\UDI j E�Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxH j @B�­Cx@?C0Q�ADZ��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CiHS j fDC+��CxC0@;W0UD@BH\K��NC0Q�Cx�¤>�2Us��C0fgC0Qiw I�S?C�¯1X+v j E�H\U�U$µ¶C0Q�H�I\S?C � UlH\H\KV�?K^EVK^IJZ�I�U j @ j EVZ[°0CE^UNW j E.¬lM j @lI\K^I\KVCxH�EVK^]gC1I\S?CYC0�NW�S j @?AgC � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E£>NFG@�k�KVADM?Q�C�³%I�S?C�C �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\Cx@NcI\K j E�U$O 2CxUD@�K�H�H\S?Us��@.>�RTS?C%Ug@?E^Z��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C%��C0IJ�+CxC0@�I�S?C�OmM?EVE�¯1X~v Q�CxH\M?ELI j @B�

-9

-8

-7

-6

-5

-4

-3

-2

-1

0

0.01 0.1 1 10

���

�������� ����������

���������� � �"!$#$!$%&%&'

� � (�)�* !$'

����� � ��� Ô =DÖhÅ[Î0Ù��iÆ�ÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJË^Î0Ï[É-Z Æ#� �DÆ�Ï�ZVÖ�ÉiÙgÌGËÍÌeÈJÆ�ÙsÈ�ÑTØ�� b �0? Y b ? �@A�Î0Ù[ÊYØ���� ` � ���1AÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ�ÜI\S?C�¹Yº�F � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�KVH'OmUDM?@B��KV@�I\SBC�I\Q j @BH\K^I\KVUD@�Q\CxADKVUD@;OmQ\Ugy I�S?C�¹1c.I�U�I\S?C�º.ceH\S?CxE^E£w��S?C0Q�CYI\SBC%HhSBC0EVE�UgH�W KVEVE j I\KVUD@�U$O ® � 6��ª KVH�@?U$I j H � Q�UD@BUDM?@BW0Cx� j H�I\S j I�U$OI�S?C�C � j WuI� UDI\C0@lI�K j E¢> �2Us��C0fgC0Qiw.I�S?KVH�UlH\W0K^EVE j I\KVUD@¾S j H;E^K^IhI�E^C�KVy ��j WuI�UD@¾I\U$I j ETC0@BC0Q�ADKVCxHx>�kBUDQE j Q\AgC , ��UDI\S � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�H2AgU�EVK^]gC � �1H , wBK£> Cg>���U$I�S � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E�H j Q�C%H\C0E^O�c£KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@OmQ\CxCD>[¯�@�I�S?C2UDI\S?CxQ�S j @��¤w$I�S?C�ºÀn2� j @���bYb��*W M?Q�fDCiH0wD��S?KVW�S j Q\C�Q j I�S?C0Q+W EVUgH\CTI\UC j W�S�U$I�S?C0Q~K^@�I�S?C�Q\CxE^Cxf j @lI�Q\CxADKVy�CDw$�NK^µ�CxQ~H\M?�BHhI j @lI�K j E^EVZ�OmQ�UDy I\S?C�C0� j WuI ® ª %[�+Ug@NcHhK�HJI�C0@lI���K^I\S�I\S?C j Q�ADM?y�C0@lI2KV@6´[CiWuI\KVUD@½�D> ²Nw?I�S?C0Z��NCiW j Z�y%MBW�S�y�UgQ\CYQ j$� K��NEVZ�OmUgQE j Q\AgC , >Bv�UgQ\CxUsfDC0Qiw$I�S?C0Z�HhS?Us� @?U­HhS?CxE^E¤UlH\W0K^EVE j I\KVUD@ j I j EVE��ÁH\C0C j E�H\U�´[CiWuI�K^Ug@�³?> ²D� >kÀKVADMBQ\CY³�C � � E j KV@BH�I\SBC� B@B�NKV@?AgH2K^@�R j �?EVCxH2²sceo%OmQ\Ugy j y�KVW0Q\UlH\W0U � K�W � CxQ�H � CiWuI�K^fgCD>

��I­I\S?K�H � UDKV@gI j H\KV�?C0Q�C0y j Q�]¾HhCxC0y­H j$�B� Q\U � Q�K j I\CD>'��E^E � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�H�H\S?Us��@�K^@kÀKVADMBQ\C�³�UgQ\KVADKV@ j I�C�OmQ�UDy H\C0E^O�ceW0UD@BH\K�HJI�C0@lI�W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@BH%��K^I\S½I\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?A

Page 24: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

H\W�S?Cxy�CxHx>i¯�@?C�y�KVADSlI.I\S[MBH j H\]�S?Us��I�S?CxH\C~W MBQ\fgCxH.W�S j @?ADCK^ONI\S?C+H j y�C+�NC0@BH\K^IJZ�� j @B�I\S[MBH¤I�S?C+H j y�C�UgQ\�BKLI j E�H�� j Q\C�M�HhCi�1OmUDQ.I�S?C~Cxf j EVM j I�K^Ug@1UDONI\S?C+�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lIÀOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H 'RTS?KVH~KVH�H\M?C�K�H j �?�NQ�CxH�HhCi�;KV@�k�KVADM?Q�C2r�KV@­��S?K�W�S­I\S?C�HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@­U$O¤I�S?C1¯1X~v·KV@lI\CxADQ j ECx¬lM j I�K^Ug@�UD@�I\S?C1� j H\K�H~UDO.I\S?Q�C0C1�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@gI�H\C I�H�UDO.UDQ��?KLI j E�H~K�H � E^UDIhI�Cx�¤>[FG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@

-8

-7

-6

-5

-4

-3

-2

-1

0

0.01 0.1 1 10

���

�������� ������� ������������

!�"$#�%& ')(+*-,-*-././0

# & 132�45*-0

����� � �D� Ô =DÖhÅ[Î0Ù��iÆ�ÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏ�ÉWZ Æ#�TY£ÇYÒNÉ0ÐGÈhÎxÙgÖ�Æ�É-Z.ÌGÆ�Ï ZVÖ�ÉiÙgÌGËLÌeÈJÆ�ÙlÖG�sÜ �$ÉiÏ��gÈJËÍÉxÙ�É-ZÀÑTØ��Æ76S�lÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ ��ËÍÈJÅ�Æ>=gÎxÖ�È �� b =S�ÁÉiÙgÏ �;ÑTØ��¿ÎxÙlÊ�? �@A½É0Ð��lË ÈhÎxÏÍÌ�ÜI\U�I\SBCYC � j W I��[ceUD@?EVZ�UgQ\�?K^I j EVH�MBH\Cx��OmUgQ2kÀKVADMBQ\CY³ j E�H\U%I�S?CYC � j W I�¹�´�UgQ\�BKLI j E�HY§ q��i¨j @B��I\S?C�ºÀn2�8UDQ��?K^I j E�H j Q�C;KV@BH\C0Q\I\Ci��KV@lI\U�=~¬[Hx>V�£²D²D�Gc��£² �l�u>�FeIYI\M?Q�@BH�UDM?I1I�S j IYI�S?CI\S?Q�C0C�HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@BH j Q�C j EVy�UgHhI�KV@B�NK�HJI�K^@?AgM?K�HhS j �?EVCD>¶RTS?C%UgQ\KVADKV@�U$O'I�S?C�UDQ��?KLI j E�H%� j @B�I\S[MBHYUDO+I�S?C��NCx@BHhK^IJZ?�1KVH�y%MBW�S�EVCxH�H�K^y � UDQ\I j @gIYOmUgQYI\SBC�HJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�C­U$O j I�UDy�K�W ® ª «I\S j @�I\S?C�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�OmUgQ\y:U$O�© ª « >�FG@�UDI\S?CxQY�+UgQ��?H&%�k�KVADM?Q�C­³��+UgM?EV��EVU[UD]�fgC0Q�ZHhKVy�K^E j Q�K^O j E^E¶OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H���C0Q�C�Cxf j E^M j I\Ci�¡��KLI�S�I�S?C�H j y�CY�NC0@BH\K^IJZD>��C I�M?Q\@BK^@?A�I\U�I\SBC j W0W0M?Q j W Z¡U$O+I\S?C�¹Yº.F jD�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I�K^[email protected]¶kÀKVADMBQ\C�q � Q�Usf[KV�?CxH

j W0UDy �Bj Q�K�HhUg@ j @ j E^UgADUgMBHYI�U�k�KVADM?Q�C¡³�OmUDQ�I�S?C�W j H\C�UDO j HhUgE^K��¤>'RTS?C¡C �?W�S j @?ADC� UDI\C0@lI�K j E�U$OT�?M?EV]6��E^M?y�KV@[M?y:K�H � EVU$I\I\Ci� j E^Ug@?A¡I\S?C�§^�D�ips¨~�NKVQ�CxWuI�K^Ug@.>.��H j EVE � UDcI\C0@lI�K j EVH+UDQ�K^AgK^@ j I\CTOmQ�UDy � H\C0M��NU � U$I�C0@lI\K j E¶W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@BHxw$I�S?C j IhI�Q j WuI\KVfDC �Bj Q\I+UDO ® ªj H�HhUNW K j I�Cx����K^I\S�I\S?C­W0UDQ�C%C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@BH�K�H�y�K�H\H\KV@?A�KV@6k�KVADM?Q�C�q ¥ I\S?C­W0UDy �Bj Q�K�HhUg@W UDy � EVC I�C0EVZ�OmUNW M�HhCiH2UD@¡I�S?C%�NCxE^UNW j E^KV°0Ci�¡f j E^Cx@BW C�HhI j I\CiH�U$OI\SBC�y�C I j E¢>��2A j K^@�I�S?C¹Yº.F j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�K�H1Q j I\S?CxQ1W0E^UlHhC%I\U�I\S?C�¯1X~v � UDI\C0@lI�K j E¢>¤RTS?C j AgQ\CxC0y�C0@lI�K�H�Bj Q\I\K�W M?E j Q�EVZ�W Ug@[flKV@BW0K^@?A�KV@�f[K^Cx�¦UDOI\S?C�bYb��aQ\CiHhMBELI %�RTS?C�AgQ j �NKVC0@lI�W UgQ\Q�CxW I\KVUD@BHI\U�I\SBC�ºÀn2� C0fgC0@�ADU�KV@gI�U�I\S?CY��Q�UD@BA��NKVQ�CxWuI�K^Ug@.>

kÀKV@ j E^EVZDwsk�K^AgM?Q�CTo1H\S?Us�2H.I�S?C�y�UgHhIH\KVAD@?K^ �W j @lI�NCxf[K j I\KVUD@%UDO j ¹Yº.FÀQ\CiHhM?E^I�OmQ\UgyI\S?C;OmM?EVE+¯1X~v H\UDEVMNI\KVUD@6UD�BH\C0Q�fDCi��HhU�O j Qi>¶FG@6k�K^AgM?Q�C;o�I\S?C��+UDEVE^C0cG´ j EVfDC I\I\KW UgQ\Q�C cE j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E1§ ²$³$¨���OmUgQ;�NC0I j K^E�H;H\C0C¡´[CxW I\KVUD@½qN> ²D�YKVH%C � j y�KV@?Cx�¤wÀQ j I\S?CxQ�I�S j @I\S?C¡C � j W I�© ª ��OmUDQ ��Al�u>~¯�@?C� B@B�BH;C0�?W C0EVEVC0@lI j ADQ�C0Cxy�Cx@lI;U$O�I\S?C�¹Yº.F jD�?� Q�U»�NKLcy j I\KVUD@���K^I\S�I�S?C�C0� j WuI�HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@�U$O��¢²��$�1OmUgQ�I�S?C�UgMNI\CxQ\y�UgHhI%H\S?C0EVEVH j @���K^@�I�S?Cj H\Zly � I�U$I�KVW�Q�C0AgK^y�Cg>[¯�@�I\SBC�U$I�S?C0Q+S j @��¤wDOmUgQ�I�S?C�KV@?@?CxQ+H\S?C0EVEVH�I\S?C1�NC0f[K j I�K^Ug@BH j Q\CW EVC j Q�EVZ�E j Q�ADC0Q�I\S j @�I\S?C¡�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CiH�f[KVH\KV�?E^C�K^@¾k�KVADM?Q�CxH;³ j @��½qN> 2C0fgC0Q\I\S?CxE^CiH\Hxw

Page 25: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � �

-0.1

0.0

0.1

0.2

������������ � �

0.00

0.01

0.02

0.03

3 4 5 6 7 8

���� ���������������

���� �!� "$#&%'�)(+*,�

� -�.0/21+.��43657.8� "$#&%'���

9

����� � ��� Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ��xÆ¡ÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJË^Î0Ï�É-Z Z�Ö�Ö A+Ï��lÇYËÍÙS�lÇ�ËÍÙ 9 `c` " < ÊgË ÐJÆ�Ö�ÈJËÍÉiÙ��8��lÏÍÏ2ÑTØ�� ×»Æ\Ð �Ì �gÌ��0? YYÎ0ÒlÒgÐJÉ =DËÍÇ�Î0ÈJËÍÉiÙ b ? � A ÎxÙlÊ�Ø�� � ` �����1A·Ú;: _ ÈJÅgÆ­ÒNÉiÌGË ÈJËÍÉiÙ¾É-Z�Î ÈJÉiÇ%Û\Ü�A+ÏÍÏÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏÍÌ�Å[Îu×»Æf�NÆ�Æ�Ù�Æ�×iÎ0Ï �lÎ0ÈJÆuÊ ��Ë ÈJÅ�ÈJÅlÆ ��¡ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆ�Ì=<xÊgÆ�ÙlÌGË È���ÐJÆ�Ì �gÏ ÈJËLÙ,� ZVÐJÉiÇ#έÌGÆ�Ï Z �Ö�ÉiÙlÌGËÍÌeÈJÆ�ÙsÈ =S�ÁÉiÙgÏ�� �0? Y�ÖuÎxÏÍÖ �gÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ ��ËÍÈJÅgËÍÙ6ÈJÅlÆ%ÒlÏLÎ0ÙlÆ=� �'Îu×»Æ;ÒlÌGÆ �lÊgÉxÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏ�ÌGÖhÅlÆ�ÇYÆÚ ( )���� _\` "#"&7 �gÊ b �&� ÌGÒNÆ�Ö�Ë^Î0Ï �S�ÁÒNÉiËÍÙsÈJÌ2ZVÉxÐ2ËÍÙsÈJÆ �xÐhÎ ÈJËÍÉiÙ�É0×iÆ�Ð�.ÀÐJËÍÏÍÏÍÉc�gËLÙ�Ó�ÉiÙgÆ b � �2";ÌeÈhÎ ÈJÆ�ÌÒNÆ\Ð �S�ÁÒNÉxËLÙsÈ�ËÍÙ?>A@�ËÍÙ�ÈJÅlÆ�ÖuÎxÌGÆ�ÉWZ�ÈJÅgÆYÑTØ��­Û\Ü�ÄÅgÆ1Ö�É0ÐGÐJÆ�ÌGÒNÉiÙlÊgËÍÙ��;×iÎ0ÏÍÆ�ÙlÖ�Æ�ÊgÆ�ÙgÌGËÍÈ+�­ËÍÌÎ0ÏÍÌGÉ �iËÍ×»Æ�ÙBÜ

-0.1

-0.09

-0.08

-0.07

-0.06

-0.05

-0.04

-0.03

-0.02

-0.01

0

0.01 0.1 1 10

BDC

EGFIHJGKML

N=O�P6Q&RS T�UWV�X�V�Y�Y�Z

Q S []\=^�V�Z

����� � ��� �0? Y.Î0ÒlÒgÐJÉ =DËÍÇ�Î0ÈJËÍÉiÙY×iÆ�ÐJÌ �lÌ Z �lÏÍÏ?ÑTØ�� ÌGÉxÏ��gÈJËÍÉiÙ�� � ÉiÏÍÏÍÆ=� �gÎxÏÍ×»Æ\ÈGÈJËNÖ�ÉxÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ ÈJËLÉxÙ;ÒNÉW�ÈJÆ�Ù$ÈJËLÎ0Ï ZVÉxÐ+ÙlÆ �DÈGÐhÎxÏ � �DÜ

Page 26: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

�;: Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

C0fDCx@�K^@¡I\SBKVH�Q�C0AgK^y�C1I\SBC�HhS?CxE^E�UgH�W KVE^E j I�K^Ug@BH j Q�C�Q\C � Q\UN�NM�W Cx�¡W UgQ\Q�CxW I\EVZD>Bb1KVfDCx@�I�S?CE^KVy�KLI�Cx�6K^y � UDQ\I j @�W C�U$O ® «YKV@6I\S?C�KV@?@?C0QYH\S?C0EVE'Q�C0ADKVUD@�wBI�S?C�C0@?S j @BW Ci��KV@ j WxW M?Q j W0ZU$O�I\S?C�¹Yº�F j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�OmUDQYI�S?K�H �Bj Q\I\K�W MBE j Q�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E~H\S?UgM?EV�6I�SlM�HY@?U$IY��CUsfDC0Q�C0y � S j H\K^°xCx�¤>

FG@ j @[Z¾W j H\CDw�UD@?C�W j @ W Ug@BW EVMB�NC�I\S j I�I\S?C�¹Yº.F;H\W�S?Cxy�C � Q�Usf[KV�?CxH j @½C0�?W C0E^cE^Cx@gI j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�I�U�I\SBC�¯1X~v K^@lI\CxADQ j E+Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@�K^@½I\S?C¡W j HhC�U$O�I\SBC�C � j WuIC �?W�S j @BADCD>

� ��� ����* � ����+�� ��% * � +��#�.� "# + � # �#" ! 4������ * � � "$��� %�*�!�� � + �)� +� � � # � +'#��!(%�� + * ��"#!$# +�� * !#" � %

RTS?C�C0� j WuI2¯1X~v�Q�CxH\M?E^I�H��NU�@?U$I�UD@?EVZ j EVE^Us� j @ j @ j EVZ[H\K�H�U$O�I\S?C�¹Yº.F jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j cI\[email protected]�?MNI j EVH\UYU$O.W0UD@[fDCx@gI�K^Ug@ j E?�?C0@BH\KLIJZ%OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVHxw j H�K�H j EVQ\C j �NZ�W EVC j Q'OmQ\Ugy I�S?C�NKVH�W M�H\H\K^Ug@�U$O�´[CxW I\KVUD@�³?>V�D>�FG@�I�S?KVHY´[CiWuI�K^Ug@�I\SBC�W0UDy �Bj Q\K�HhUg@�U$OTº�n2� j @B��bYb��� j I j ��K^I\S;I\SBC2W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A�¯1X+v Q�C OmC0Q�C0@�W C�Q\CiHhM?E^I�H��KVEVEN��C�C0�lI�C0@B�?Cx�¤wsKV@;UgQ��?C0QI\U¡S?K^AgS?EVK^AgSgIYH\UDy�C � Q�U � C0Q\I\KVCxH�U$O~I\S?C�C � j WuI�C0�?W�S j @?AgCD>�FG@�I�M?Q\@�w�I�S?C�E^KVy�KLI j I�K^Ug@BHU$O�I\S?C�HhI j @B� j Q��%OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVH'��SBKVW�S���CxW Ugy�C2UD�[f[K^UgMBHKV@;I�S?K�H~W Ugy �Bj Q�KVH\UD@ � Q�UsflK��NCj �?�NK^I\KVUD@ j E¤y�U$I�K^f j I�K^Ug@¡OmUDQ�Q�CxH\UDQ\I\KV@?A�I�U­K^y � EVKVW0KLI�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H0>

¯�@?C+KVy � UgQhI j @lI � Q\U � CxQhIJZ1I�S j I'S j HÀ��C0Cx@%Cxy � S j H\K^°xCx� j @[M?y;��CxQ'U$O?I�K^y�CxH@BUs�KVH�I�S?C � �1H , �NCxW j Z�U$O�I\S?C�C0� j WuI'C0�NW�S j @?AgC � U$I�C0@lI\K j ENUDO� �@?KLI�C2HhZNHhI\Cxy�Hx>sFG@�f[K^Cx�½U$OI\S?C�E^Ug@?A$ceQ j @?ADC�W�S j Q j WuI�C0Q�UDO¤I\S?C�M?@B�NCxQ\EVZ[K^@?A;HhCxELO�ceK^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^Ug@�K^@lI\CxADQ j E�UD@?C2y�KVADSlIj H\]%��S?C0I\S?CxQ~K^I+K�H � UgH�HhKV�?EVCTI\U�Q�C � Q�UN�NMBW0CTI\S?K�H~��C0S j flKVUDQ'�[Z�HhUgy�C2C � � EVKVW0KLI��NC0@BH\K^IJZOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�'%FG@�´NCxWuI�K^Ug@��D> ²;KLI�S j H���C0Cx@��NC0y�UD@�HJI�Q j I\Cx��I�S j I�I�S?C%º�n�� � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E�NCxW j Z[H�C0� � UD@BC0@lI\K j EVE^Zg>'FG@½I�S?C�W j HhC¡U$O1I\SBC�bYb��%w'I\SBC�HhCiW UD@��½C0� � E^K�W K^I��NC0@BH\K^IJZOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�U$OÀKV@lI\CxQ\CiHJIiw

© J�J�9ª § 0 ¨�� '%)T+W, � J J�9ª � 0 7 � � 0 � � 7I\S?C�H\K^I\M j I\KVUD@�KVH%HhUgy�Cx��S j IYy�UDQ�C�W Ugy � E^K�W j I\Ci�¤>�k?UgQ�I\S?C¡bYb��/I\S?C j HhZ[y � I�U$I\K�W��CxS j f[K^UgQ��NC � Cx@B�?H1UD@�I\S?C��NC I j KVE^Ci��HhI\Q�MBWuI�M?Q\C;U$O�I�S?C;OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E . H�]gC0Q�@?C0E#� J�J�9ª >`¸S?K^EVC�y�UgHhI¡bYb���H­E^C j ��I�U�C � � Ug@?C0@lI�K j E^EVZ �NCiW j Z[KV@?A � UDI\C0@lI�K j EVHxw ��CxW�]gC�y j �NCj @ j IhI�C0y � I�§^�iqs¨�I\U�K^@�W UDQ � UDQ j I\C�I\SBC � �1H , ��CxS j f[K^UgQ�KV@lI\U�I\SBC�bYb��#OmUDQ�y �[ZQ\Ci¬gMBK^Q�K^@BA � J�J�9ª I�U�H j I�KVHhOmZ¾=~¬�>��¢qDpg����� � �scJbYb���� > �2Us��C0fDCxQxw j H�Cxy � S j H\K^°xCx�½K^@´[CxW I\KVUD@�²N> r­I�S?C j H\Z[y � I\UDI\K�W�OmUDQ�y�UDOI\S?C;C0@?CxQ\AgZ��NCx@BHhK^IJZ¡KVH�@?U$I�Q\CxE j I\Cx��I�U�I\S j IU$O~I�S?C � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E¢>¤FG@6O j W Ixw¤Ug@?C­W j @�HhSBUs� I\S j I%bYb���HYW j @�@?U$I�H j I\K�HhOmZ�=~¬[H0>��mr��g�j @B� �¢q$pl��H\KVy%M?E^I j @?C0UgMBHhEVZ¾§ ³$r$¨e> 2CxfDC0Q\I\SBC0EVCxH�H0w�I\S?C � U$I�C0@lI\K j EQ�CxH\M?ELI�K^@BA�OmQ�UDy�I�S?C� �,�scJbYb��¾AgUlCiH�EVKV]DC��IH , OmUDQ�E j Q\AgC , w$HhU�I\S j I�Ug@?C~y�KVADSlI�C0� � CiWuI j @�KVy � Q\UsfgC0y�C0@lIUsfDC0Q�I�S?CYC � � UD@?Cx@gI�K j E.�NCxW j Z�U$O j EVE¤U$I�S?C0Q�bYb���H0>�2Us��C0fDCxQxw�K^I�KVHY@BU$IYUD@?EVZ�I�S?C­M?E^I\KVy j I\C j HhZ[y � I\UDI\K�W;OmUDQ�y�I\S j I�y j IhI�C0Q�H0w¤�BMNI

j E�HhU�I�S?C � UDKV@lI¡��C0ZgUD@B� j I���S?K�W�S*K^I�H\C I�H�KV@.>�RTS?K�H�K�H�KVEVE^MBHhI\Q j I�Cx�¸KV@ k�KVADM?Q�C ���S?KVW�S�H\S?Us�2H�I�S?C%C0�NW�S j @?AgC � U$I�C0@lI\K j EÀU$O���@.>�RTS?C�� � �$cGbYb�� K�H�W0UDy �Bj Q�Cx����K^I\SKLI�H � Q\Ci�NCxW0CxH�HhUgQ � �Do�§L�xr$¨ j @��­I\SBC1C0� j WuI ® ªN>NRTS?C1IJ�+U�bYb���H j Q�C�W�S?UgH\C0@ j H+I\S?CxZS j fDC���C0Cx@6W0UD@BHhI\Q�MBWuI�Cx��KV@�I�S?C�H j y�C�O j H\S?K^[email protected]¶K¢> CD>�KV@���U$I\S�W j HhCiH�I\SBC j @BH j I\°YOmUgQ� J J�9ª S j H;��C0Cx@ U � I\KVy�K^°xCx�½I\U�Q�C � Q�UN�NMBW C¡C � j WuI j I\Ugy�KVW¡C �?W�S j @?ADC�C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH j H

Page 27: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ �#�

-1.4

-1.2

-1

-0.8

-0.6

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.1 1 10

��������������

��

�� ��������� ��� ��� �

� � �����! "�

����� �$#�� A+Ì �DÇYÒgÈJÉ0ÈJËLÖ�ZVÉxÐJÇ ÉWZ�%�&I�&. � : � 9 ` � < ÎxÙlÊ . �#� � ���1A 9 ` � < ×iÆ�ÐJÌ �lÌÑTØ�� ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ È Z�É0Ð� Ù�ÜlÄÅlÆ����1A�ÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏÍÌ~Å[Îu×»ÆG�NÆ�Æ�Ù�Æ�×xÎxÏ��lÎ0ÈJÆuÊ ��Ë ÈJÅ�ÈJÅgÆTÆ>=gÎxÖ\È =S�ÁÉiÙgÏ��%ÊgÆ�ÙgÌGËÍÈ+�sÜ

�+CxE^E j H � UlH\H\KV�?E^Cgw���K^I\S�HhKVy�K^E j Q�H\MBW0W0CxH�H0>¤¯�@�I\SBC%U$I�S?C0Q1S j @B�¤w�I\S?C j @ j E^ZlI�KVW�OmUDQ�yU$ONI\SBC+]gC0Q�@?C0E j @B��I�S?C~Q�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?A j HhZ[y � I�U$I\K�W���C0S j flKVUDQÀ�NKLµ¶C0Q�Hx>i��H�k�KVADM?Q�C �2HhS?Us�2HxwI\S?K�H��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C�S j H+@BU�C0µ�CiWuI�KV@�I�S?C � S[ZNHhK�W j E^EVZ­Q\CxE^Cxf j @lI ��j Q\I�UDO�I\SBC j HhZ[y � I�U$I\K�WQ\CxADKVy�Cg>s��H j W Ug@BHhCi¬lM?C0@BW0CDw»I�S?C �1¯1v6¯1HUDOBI\SBC+IJ��U�bYb���H j Q\C j EVy�UgHhIK��NCx@gI�KVW j E£>RTS?C%IJ��U�bYb�� � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�H j Q�C j E�H\U�fDCxQ\Z�W0E^UlHhC�K^@�I\S?C�KV@?@?CxQ�H\S?CxE^EQ�C0ADKVy�CD>¶��H jW UD@�HhCi¬gMBC0@BW0CDwNUD@BC� B@B�?H�EVK^IhI\EVC%�NK^µ¶C0Q�C0@BW0CY��C0IJ�+CxC0@¡I\S?C � CxQhOmUgQ\y j @�W C�U$O�I\S?C � �,�scj @B��I\S j I1UDO�I\S?C � �Do$cGbYb��%w�KV@6H � K^I\C�U$O�I�S?C;OmUDQ�y j EK^y � Q�UsfDCxy�Cx@lI�U$O ® ª �lZ�I�S?C� �,� j @BH j I\°g>N��H j y j IhI�C0Q�U$O � Q\KV@BW0K � EVCDw[I�S?CYHhCxy�KLceE^UNW j E�OmUDQ�y¿U$OÀI\S?C�bYb�� ]DCxQ\@BC0E�NU[CxHT@?UDI j EVE^Us�¸I�S?CYQ�C � Q�UN�NMBWuI�K^Ug@�UDOÀI�S?CYC � j WuI ® ª KV@�I�S?C j H\Z[y � I\UDI\K�W�Q\CxADKVy�Cg>�2Us�·W EVUgH\C�W j @ bYb���H�W Ugy�C�I\U�I\SBC�C � j W I ® ª KV@ I\SBC�K^@B@?C0Q�H\S?CxE^E�Q\CxADKVy�C�'

kÀKVADMBQ\C�³ j E^Q�C j �NZ�KV@B�NK�W j I\Ci��I\S j I1I\S?C­W Ug@[fDC0@lI�K^Ug@ j E��NC0@BH\K^IJZ�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H��NU�@BU$IOmUDEVE^Us� I�S?C1H\S?CxE^E¶UgH�W KVEVE j I\KVUD@BH+U$O¤I�S?C�C0� j WuI ® ªN>NRTS?KVH � UDKV@lI�K�H~KV@[fDCiHJI�K^A j I\Ci��OmM?Q\I\S?CxQK^@�kÀKVADMBQ\C ����S?K�W�S�OmUNW M�HhCiH;Ug@�I\SBC¡@BUD@?EVUNW j ETW Ug@lI\Q�K^�?M?I\KVUD@�I�U ® ªN>'��H�@?Ug@?E^UNW j EW UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@�Ug@?C�M?@B�NCxQ�HhI j @B�?H�I\SBC��NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W CY��C IJ��C0C0@ j ADKVfDCx@ ® ª j @B��I\SBC�W UDQ\cQ\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?AYºÀn2� � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E¢wD��UDI\S�C0f j EVM j I\Cx����K^I\S�I\SBC�H j y�CT�?C0@BH\KLIJZg>$FG@�I\S?K�H'� j ZUD@?C�HhC �Bj Q j I�CxH¤I�S?C+ B@?CTHJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�C~KV@ ® ª�OmQ�UDy K^I�HH\y�U[UDI\S j fgC0Q j ADC'��C0S j flKVUDQiw0��SBKVW�SKVH~�+CxE^E�Q\C � Q\UN�NM�W Cx���[Z%I\S?C1º�n2�%>gFG@­UgQ��NCxQ'I\U%C j H\C�I�S?C�W Ugy �Bj Q�KVH\UD@�UDO�I�S?C1bYb���H��KLI�S�I\SBC;C0� j WuI�Q\CiHhMBELIiw ® ª

�® 687D9ª KVH�OmM?Q\I\S?CxQ�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI�Cx�¡OmUDQ1I�S?C;AgE^Ug� j E�HhSBKLO�IYQ�C c

HhM?E^I\KV@?A;OmQ\Ugy8I\S?C j H\Z[y � I\U$I�KVW2��CxS j f[K^UgQ&%?�+UDy �Bj Q\Ci����KLI�S�I\SBC�C0� � UD@BC0@lI\K j E¶�NCxW j ZU$O ® 6&7�9ª I\S?C � �IH , ce��CxS j f[K^UgQ�UDO¶I\S?C1¯1X+v � UDI\C0@lI�K j EBCxH�H\C0@lI\K j EVE^Z%E^C j �?HI�U j ADEVUD� j Ej IhI�Q j WuI�K^fgCTH\S?K^O�I+KV@ ® ª ��S?K�W�S­K�H'K^Q�Q�C0EVC0f j @lI'OmUDQ�I\S?C2KV@?@?CxQ~H\S?C0EVE?OmC j I\MBQ\CiH0>DRTSBKVH�H\S?K^O�IKVHY��C0EVE j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\Ci���[Z�I�S?C��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C­��C IJ��C0Cx@6I�S?C­S?KVADS?CiHJIYUNW0W0M � KVCx��C0KVADCx@Ncf j E^MBCxH1U$O+I\S?C�IJ��U¡H�W�S?C0y�CiH���SBKVW�S6KVH1I�S?C0Q�C OmUgQ\C�HhM?�?I\Q j WuI�Cx�¤>¤FG@6UDQ��NC0Q1I�U�Ug�NI j K^@I\S?C � C0Q�W C0@lI j ADC+@?UD@BE^UNW j ENW UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^[email protected]�S?C��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW CTK�H� �@ j EVE^ZY@BUDQ�y j E^KV°0Ci�Y��K^I\SQ\CiH � CxW I�I�U�I\S?CYC0� j WuI ® ªNw

� ® ª � ® ª � , � � ® 6&7�9ª � , � � � $CBEDFB � � 687D9$CBEDFB® B�'[Dª � , � � �¢qDog�

Page 28: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

�2� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

-0.3

-0.2

-0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.01 0.1 1 10

������������� � � ���

�����

��� ������� �

����� �"!�� Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ,�iÆ~ÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏNÉWZ � Ù��$ضÆ�ÐJÖ�Æ�ÙsÈhÎ��iÆ�ÙlÉiÙgÏÍÉsÖuÎxÏ?Ö�ÉxÙ$ÈGÐJË��T�gÈJËÍÉiÙ�ËÍÙYÈJÅlÆ�Æ =lÎ0Ö�È % &Î0Ù[Ê�È+�É ���1A~Ì 9 ��� b �;< Ü A~ÏLÏÀÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏÍÌ�Å[Îu×»Æ �NÆ�Æ�Ù�Æ�×xÎxÏ��[Î ÈJÆuÊ ��Ë ÈJÅ�ÈJÅlÆYÆ>=gÎ0Ö�È(=S�ÁÉiÙgÏ��ÊDÆ�ÙlÌGË È+�sÜ

kÀKVADMBQ\C �2C � � EVKVW0KLI�E^ZYH\S?Us�2H¶I\SBC+H\K^°xC�U$O[I\SBC+H\S?C0EVEgUlH\W0K^EVE j I\KVUD@�H¤K^@�I�S?CT¯1X+v � UDI\Cx@gI�K j EI\U���C%UDO'I\S?C;UDQ��NC0Q�U$O2�xp$cG²Dp$#�>Bº�UlUg][K^@?A j I�I�S?C;X~` �?� cJbYb��aK^I�K�H�Ug�[flKVUDM�H�I\S j IKLI�H��NCxflK j I�K^Ug@�UD@�I\SBC�E^UNW j E.EVC0fgC0E�K�H�y;MBW�S�E j Q\AgC0QTI�S j @�I�S?C%W UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A�ADEVUD� j EC0Q�Q\UgQ�§ ³ �$¨ %ÀRTS?C��xp$c��»q%##�NCxf[K j I\KVUD@�U$O ® ''&)( ±ª OmQ\Ugy ® B�'[Dª S j H�I\U���C�W0UDy �Bj Q�Cx���KLI�S6I�S?C­p?>V�*##CxQ\Q�UDQ1KV@�©Tª��ÁH\C0C­R j �?EVC �$�u>.RTSBKVH � K�WuI�M?Q�C�K�H�@?UDI%H � CxW0KL �W;I�U �¶@.w

�������� #�� Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ,�iÆ%Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �2��ÉWZ � Ù��¶Ø���� ` � 9 �2�;< ÎxÙlÊ�Ô / �cV� ���1A 9 � < ×»Æ�ÐJÌ �gÌ1Æ>=gÎxÖ\ÈÑTØ��8ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈuÜ

ÑTØ�� Ø���� ` Ô�/ �-'!( & : �DÜ : ` � : �DÜ :�� : : �$Ü � "1�

�?MNI�¬lM?K^I\C�W�S j Q j WuI\CxQ\K�HhI\K�W2OmUgQ j EVE j I\Ugy­H0>RTS?KVH�KVy%� j E j @BW0C � Q\Ugy � I�H�I�S?C�¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@���S?C I�S?C0Q%UD@?C­W j @�UD@?C�KVy � Q\UsfgC;I�S?C

j W0W0M?Q j W Z1U$ONI�S?C�bYb�� � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�'��2@ j IhI�C0y � IK^@YI�S?K�H��?K^Q�CxW I\KVUD@�EVCx��I�U�I�S?C+=,+��g³scbYb�� § ³ �s¨g��S?UgH\C']DCxQ\@?CxE$� j H.U � I\KVy�K^°xCx�1I�U2Q\C � Q�U[�?MBW CI�S?C�C � j WuI j I\UDy�K�WC �?W�S j @?ADC� UDI\C0@lI�K j EVH j H j W0W0M?Q j I\CxE^Z j H � UgH�H\K^�?EVCD>[k�K^AgM?Q�C����NCxy�Ug@BHhI\Q j I\CiHI\SBC;�mEVKVy�K^I\Ci�B�+HhMBW cW CxH�HTU$OÀI\S?K�H2HhI\Q j I�C0ADZg>NRTS?CY=-+��g³scJbYb�� Q\C � Q\UN�NM�W CxH+I�S?C j y � EVKLI�MB�NCxH2U$O�I�S?C�H\S?C0EVEUgH�W KVE^E j I�K^Ug@BH'KV@ ® B�'[Dª y%M�W�S­��C0IhI\CxQ�I�S j @�UDI\S?CxQ+bYb���Hx>��2Us��C0fDCxQxw»I�S?C0Q�C2K�H j�� Q�K�W CI\U���C �Bj KV�¡OmUgQ2I�S?KVH�K^y � Q�UsfDCxy�C0@lIxw?��SBKVW�S���CxW0UDy�CxH�UD�[f[K^UgMBHTOmQ�UDy·R j �?E^C � %���@[ZK^y � Q�UsfDCxy�Cx@lI�UDO ® ª KVH j W0W0UDy �Bj @?K^Ci���[Z�HhUgy�C�EVUgH�H�U$O j WxW M?Q j W0Z�OmUDQ%© ª >.FG@�HhK�HJI\cK^@?A�UD@½I\S?C�U � I\KVy%M?y E^UNW j E j W0W0M?Q j W Z � Q�CxW0E^M��NCxH;I\SBC�H\M?�NI�E^C¡C0Q�Q�UDQ�W j @�W C0EVE j I\KVUD@Q\Ci¬gMBK^Q�Cx��I�U j W�S?K^CxfDC�U � I�K^y;M?y j WxW M?Q j W0Z%OmUgQ+KV@lI\C0AgQ j I\Ci��¬lM j @lI\K^I\KVCxH+EVK^]gC1©TªN>NRTS?K�Hj A j K^@ � UgK^@lI�H j ITI\SBCYE^KVy�KLI j I\KVUD@�H�U$O�I\S?C%bYb�� OmUgQ\y�>

Page 29: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � �

RTS?C0Q�C�KVH~UD@?CTOmMBQhI�S?C0Q�W UD@�HhCi¬gMBC0@BW0C�U$O¶I\S?C�@?UD@BE^UNW j E^K^IJZ%UDO¶I\S?C2C0� j WuI~©�ª���UDQ\I\SI\UY��C�@?U$I�Cx�¤>D��H�H\UlUg@ j HUD@?CTAgUlCiH�I\U�U � C0@?ceH\S?C0EVEBH\ZNHJI�C0y­H�I\S?C2�?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C���C0IJ�+CxC0@I\S?C;S?K^AgS?CxHhI�UNWxW M � KVCx��C0KVADC0@[f j EVM?CiH�U$O'I�S?C%y j �JUgQ\K^IJZ�H � KV@½�¢H � KV@NceM � � j @B��I�S?C%y�K^c@?UDQ�KLIJZ¡H � K^@¾�¢H � KV@NcG�NUs��@��TW�S j @?@?CxEVH2W0UDy�CxH�K^@lI�U � E j Z %?FeI1�NC I�C0Q�y�KV@?CiH�I\SBC�Q\CxE j I\KVfDCHJI j �?KVE^K^IJZYU$OB�?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI'H � KV@;HhI j I\CiH0w»K£> Cg>xI�S?C�y j AD@?C0I\KV° j I\KVUD@�KV@�I�S?C�W j H\C~UDO�HhUgE^K��?Hx>i��HI\S?C�S?K^AgS?CxHhI+UNWxW M � KVCx��CxK^AgC0@[f j EVM?CxH+HJI�Q\Ug@?ADEVZ;�?C � C0@B�­Ug@ ® ªNwDI�S?C�� j E j @BW0C2��C0IJ�+CxC0@I\S?C�H � K^@?c£M ��j @B�¾I\S?C�H � KV@Nce�?Us��@½C �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\Cx@gI�K j ETS j H j y j �JUDQ�K^y �Bj WuI�UD@I\S?C�EVUNW j E.y j AD@BC I\K�WYy�UDy�Cx@gI�H0>BFG@�kÀKVADMBQ\C ��I�S?C%�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C%��C0IJ�+CxC0@�I\SBC%H � K^@NceM �j @B��I\SBC%H � K^@NcG�NUs��@�C �?W�S j @?ADC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E.UDO+�+Q2KVH�HhS?Us��@�>BRTS?C��NCxflK j I�K^Ug@BH�UDO�I�S?C

-0.3

-0.2

-0.1

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.01 0.1 1 10

��������������

���

����� ��������� �� �����! !�!"�"$#

% � &')(��!#

����� �+*�� Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ,�iÆ�ÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏ?É-Z � Ð � �$ÒlËÍÙf�[Î0Ï^Î0ÙlÖ�Æ�É-Z�ÈJÅgÆ�Æ>=gÎ0Ö�ÈÐJÆ�Ì �gÏÍÈ×»Æ�ÐJÌ �lÌ ? �@A½Î0Ù[ÊØ���� ` �����1A�Ü

º�n2� j @B��I�S?C�bYb��¿OmQ�UDy:I\SBC�C � j WuI�Q�CxH\M?ELI j Q�C�UD�[f[K^UgMBH­§ r,�s¨e>ÀkBUDQ;E j Q\AgC , I�S?CC � j W I ® ª-, .�KVH��NUgy�KV@ j I\Cx�6�[Z�I\S?C � �IH , c¢I j KVE�OmUDQ���UDI\S�H � K^@BH0/¦�!/ �21 7�3 �u>¶FG@�I�S?Cf j E^Cx@BW C�Q\CxADKVy�C2I\S?C1�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W C ® B�'[Dª-, 4

�® B�'[Dª-, 5 K�H'I\S[MBH+EVCxH�H j µ¶CxW I\Ci���lZ�I�S?C j W I\M j E

� UlHhK^I\KVUD@BH�U$OTI\S?C�H � KV@Nc j EVK^Ag@?Cx�6r760c j @B��³ ) c£CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@BH1I\S j @�I\S?C�º�n2� j @B��bYb��� UDI\C0@lI�K j EVHxw?��S?K�W�S¡�?K^Q�CxW I\EVZ�Q�C �BCiWuITI\S?C;HJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�CxHTUDO�I�S?C�f j EVC0@BW0CYH � KV@NcG�NC0@�HhK^I\KVCxH&%® B�'[Dª-, 4

�® B '[Dª-, 5 KVHYW0E^UlHhCxQ1I\U�°0CxQ\U j @���Q�C � MBEVH\K^fgCDw¤��S?KVEVC�I\S?C�ºÀn2� j @B��bYb��/Q�C c

HhM?E^I�H�@?CxW0CxH�H j Q\KVEVZ�y%MBHhI2��C j I\I\Q j WuI�K^fgCD>?FG@�I�S?C%º.c j @B��¹1cGHhSBC0EVE.Q\CxADKVy�C�I\S?C%�?KLµ¶C0Q\cC0@BW0C���C IJ��C0C0@ H � KV@NceM � j @B�¾H � KV@Nce�?Us��@¾�NC0@BH\K^I\KVCxH;CxH�HhCx@gI�K j E^EVZ�f j @?K�HhS?CiH0wH\U�I\S j IK^@�I\S?C­º�n�� j @B�6bYb�� I\S?C­�NK^µ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C ® ª-, 4

�® ª-, 5 j$�?� Q\U j W�S?CiH�°0CxQ\U�>�RTS?C�C � j WuI

OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£w[UD@­I�S?C1U$I\SBC0Q�S j @B�.wlEVC j �?H~I\U j @ j E^y�UgHhI�W0UD@BHhI j @lI�H\S?KLO�IT��C IJ��C0C0@ ® ª-, 4j @B� ® ª-, 5l>NRTS?C�@BUD@?EVUNW j EVK^IJZ�UDO¤I\S?C1C � j WuI�©�ª � Q\U �Bj A j I�CxHI�S?C1�?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@BW0CxH+��C0IJ�+CxC0@H � KV@NceM ��j @B�¡H � K^@?ce�NUs��@¡KV@�I�S?CYf j EVC0@BW0C�Q\CxADKVy�C�KV@lI\U�I\S?CYKV@?@?CxQ�H\S?C0EVE¤Q\CxADKVUD@.>

¯�@BW C�UD@BCYS j H2HhI\M��NK^Ci� j I\Ugy�KVW�C0�NW�S j @?AgC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�H0w?I\S?C�@BC �[I�HJI�C � y%M�HJI2��Cj @ j @ j E^ZNH\KVH�UDO�I�S?C���Ug@B�NKV@?A�Q\CxADKVy�C¡UDO1y�UgE^CiW M?EVCxH j @B� HhUgE^K��?Hx>+�+UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?AQ\CiHhM?E^I�H j Q\C�ADKVfDC0@�K^@¡kÀKVADMBQ\CiH��ipsc��i²N>lk�K^AgM?Q\C��xp;HhSBUs�2H�I�S?C�C0�?W�S j @?AgC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E¶U$OI\S?C�y�UlHJI�H\K^y � EVCYy�UDEVCxW0M?E^Cgw&� wNOmUgQ2��S?K�W�S�I�S?CYC � j WuI ® ª Q\Ci�NMBW CiH�I\U j�� MBQ\C�H\C0E^O�cK^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^Ug@�W UDQ�Q�CxWuI�K^Ug@�� j H�� KVH j H � K^@?ceH j I�M?Q j I\Ci�¡IJ�+UDc£CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@�H\Z[HhI\Cxy��u> �+UDI\SI\S?C�ºÀn2� j @��%I�S?C�� � �$cGbYb�� §^�iqs¨ � UDI\C0@lI�K j E j Q�C�W UDy �Bj Q\Ci�%��K^I\S�I�S?C2C0� j WuI ® ª >DFG@

Page 30: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

�" Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

����������� �������

–2

–3 –2 –1 0 1 2 3

–0.8

–0.6

–0.4

–0.2

0

��� � �������������

� � ���� ���! � �"�� ���

#%$'&

–2

–3 –2 –1 0 1 2 3

–0.8

–0.6

–0.4

–0.2

0

(�)* +�,�-�.�-�/�/�0

1 * 2�3�4�-�0

5 * 2"3�4�-�0

6"7�7�8�9:9�;

–2

–3 –2 –1 0 1 2 3

–0.8

–0.6

–0.4

–0.2

0

<�=> ?�@�A�B�A�C�C�D

E > 6�F�G A�D

H > 6"F�G A�D

� � � �IJI�� Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ,�iÆ�ÒNÉxÈJÆ�Ù$ÈJËLÎ0Ï�ÉWZ � X � ? �@A Î0Ù[Ê�. �#� �����1A�×iÆ�ÐJÌ �lÌ�Æ>=gÎxÖ\È % &$Ü

j �?�NK^I\KVUD@;I\U�I�S?C�HhSBKLO�I�Q�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?A1OmQ\UgyaI\S?C � �IH , c j H\Zly � I�U$I�KVWxHÀUDOBI�S?C�C � j W I ® ª wsUg@?CUD�BH\C0Q�fDCiH j y�KV@?KVy%M?y�U$O�I\S?CYC0� j WuI � U$I�C0@lI\K j E.KV@¡I\S?CY��UD@��NK^@BA­Q\CxADKVy�CgwN��S?KVE^CYI�S?Cº�n2� � UDI\C0@lI�K j E � C j ][H j I�I�S?C�@[MBW0E^C j Q�HhK^I\CiH0>'¯�@?C j A j KV@�@?U$I�KVW0CxH�I\S?C¡�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@�W C��C0IJ�+CxC0@ I\S?C�@?Ug@?E^UNW j E��+UDM?EVUDy;�¾KV@gI�C0AgQ j E j @B��I�S?C��NKVQ\CiWuI 0 ± F + ce�NC � Cx@B�NCx@BW C�U$O® 687D9ª >�RTSBC � C j ]�HhI\Q�MBWuI�M?Q\C%KVH�C0fgC0@�y�UDQ�C � Q�UD@?UgM?@BW0Cx��KV@�I\S?C�W j HhC�UDO'I\S?C�bYb����S?UgH\C � U$I�C0@lI\K j EN�NKVfDCxQ\AgCxH.��C j ][E^Z j IÀI\S?C � UgH\KLI�K^Ug@BHÀU$O?I�S?C � Q\UDI\UD@�H � > �C0fDCxQhI�S?C0EVCxH�HUD@?CY �@B�?H j @�UsfDCxQ j E^E¤KVy � Q�UsfDC0y�Cx@gI��lZ�I\SBC�bYb�� ��SBKVW�S.w�UD@ j fgC0Q j AgCDw[ADCx@?C0Q j I�CxHj y�UgQ\C j I\I\Q j W I\KVfDC ® ª;KV@�I�S?CY��UD@B�NKV@?A­Q�C0AgK^y�CD>

kÀKVADMBQ\C¡�D� � Q\Usf[K��NCxH�I�S?C­W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A�W Ugy �Bj Q�KVH\UD@�OmUDQ >¤FG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@6I\UK ÄÅlËÍÌÀÊgËÍ×»Æ�Ð �xÆ�ÙlÖ�Æ'ËLÌ�ÇM�gÖ\Å �Æ�Î"L»Æ�Ð.ÈJÅlÎxÙ1ÈJÅlÎ0È�É-ZNÈJÅgÆ'ÙQ�gÖ�ÏÍÆuÎ0Ð�ÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJË^Î0Ï b ÌGÉTÈJÅ[Î È�ËÍÈÀÊDÉsÆ�ÌÙlÉ0È�Å[Îu×»Æ�Î0ÙI��ÎxÊg×»Æ\ÐJÌGÆ�Æ�Õ?Æ�Ö�È~ËÍÙ�ÒgÐhÎ0Ö�ÈJËÍÖuÎxÏBÖuÎ0ÏLÖ=�lÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙgÌ�Ü

Page 31: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ `����������� � �����

–2

–3 –2 –1 0 1 2 3

–1.8

–1.6

–1.4

–1.2

–1

–0.8

–0.6

–0.4

–0.2

0

��� � �������������

� � ����� ��� � �!��� ���

"�#%$

–2

–3 –2 –1 0 1 2 3

–1.8

–1.6

–1.4

–1.2

–1

–0.8

–0.6

–0.4

–0.2

0

&�'( )+*�,�-�,�.�.�/

0 ( 1�2�3�,�/

4 ( 1!2�3�,�/

5!6�6�7�8�8+9

–2

–3 –2 –1 0 1 2 3

–1.8

–1.6

–1.4

–1.2

–1

–0.8

–0.6

–0.4

–0.2

0

:�;< =+>�?�@�?�A�A�B

C < 5�D�E ?�B

F < 5!D�E ?�B

����� �I � Ô =DÖhÅ[ÎxÙ,�iÆ+ÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏ?É-Z X ��? � A¾Î0Ù[Ê . �#� � ���1A½×»Æ�ÐJÌ �gÌ �0? Y�ÎxÒgÒgÐJÉ =DËÍÇ�Î0ÈJËÍÉiÙÈJÉ�ÈJÅlÆTÆ>=gÎ0Ö�È % & Ü

I\S?C�OmC j I\MBQ\CiH j EVQ\C j �NZ�Ug�BH\C0Q�fDCx�¾OmUDQ � w�Ug@?C�W j @ @BUs�#H\C0C¡I\SBC�HhSBC0EVE2HJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�CK^@½I\S?C�y�UDEVCxW0M?E j Q ® ª > 2UDI\C�I\S j I­K^@½I\S?C�W j HhC�U$O2I�S?C�C � j W I;C �?W�S j @?ADC�I\S?C�¹Yº.Fj$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@�KVHYM�HhCi��OmUgQYI\SBC�C0f j EVM j I\KVUD@�U$O ® ª >�FG@ j @ j E^UgADZ�I�U�I\S?C�HhK^I\M j I\KVUD@OmUDQ j I\Ugy­H��Ák�KVADM?Q�C�³l�YUg@?C�C0� � CxW I�H%I\S?C�H\S?C0EVE�HhI\Q�MBW I\M?Q�C�KV@�I\SBC�C0� j WuI ® ª I�U���CC0fDCx@�y�UDQ�C � Q�UD@BUDM?@BW0Cx��I�S j @�I\S j I+UD�?I j KV@?Ci����K^I\S­I�S?C1¹Yº�F j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@.>lRTS?CbYb�� � UDI\C0@lI�K j E j E�HhU¡C �NS?KV�?K^I�H j @6KV@B�NK�W j I\KVUD@�U$O+I\S?C�H\S?CxE^E~HhI\Q�MBW I\M?Q�CDw¤��S?KVEVC�I\S?K�HOmC j I�M?Q�C1K�H2W0UDy � EVC I\CxE^Z j �BH\C0@lI�K^@¡I�S?C�º�n2�%>

��H j W0UDy � EVC0y�C0@lI�I\U�k�K^AgM?Q\CYq�I\S?C1C �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\C0@lI�K j E�UDO��?M?EV]�´[K¶K�H � EVU$IhI�Cx�K^@�kÀKVADMBQ\C1�i²%� j EVUD@BA2I\SBC1§^�D�g� ¨Vce�NKVQ�CxWuI�K^Ug@��u>»RT��U1bYb���H j Q\C�W UDy �Bj Q\Ci��I\U�I\SBCTºÀn2�j @B��I�S?C�C � j WuI ® ªN>¯�@BC�W j @�H\C0C�I\S j I�I\S?C¡bYb�� UsfDCxQ�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI�H2I�S?C�CxQ\Q�UDQYUDO�I�S?C

Page 32: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

���� �������� �

��� ��� ���

����� �I �� Ô+=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ��xÆ'ÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏDÉ-Z��$ËlÎ0ÏÍÉiÙ�� 9 `-`c` < �¢ÊgË ÐJÆ�Ö\ÈJËLÉxÙ�É-ZBÊgËLÎ0ÇYÉiÙ[Ê�ÌeÈGÐ��lÖ�È��DÐJÆ#�iÔ =gÎxÖ\ÈÆ =gÖhÅ[Î0Ù��xÆ�ÒNÉxÈJÆ�Ù$ÈJËLÎ0Ï�ÚÁÑTØ��­ÛÀ×»Æ\ÐJÌ �lÌ ? �@A¾ÎxÌ���Æ�ÏÍÏ�Î0Ì . �#� �ÀÎxÙ[Ê%Ø���� ` � ���1A ÊlÎ ÈhÎ;Ú;: _ÈJÅgÆ�ÒNÉxÌGËÍÈJËÍÉxÙ1É-ZNÎ0ÈJÉiÇ%Û\Ü;A~ÏÍÏ»ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJ̤Å[Îu×»Æ(�NÆ�Æ�Ù�Éc�DÈhÎxËÍÙlÆuÊ �I��ÒlÏLÎxÙgÆ=� �'Îu×»ÆÀÒlÌGÆ �lÊgÉiÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏÖ�ÎxÏÍÖ �lÏLÎ ÈJËLÉxÙlÌ!��ËÍÈJÅ�Î1ÏÍÉsÖuÎxÏ�ÒlÌGÆ �lÊgÉiÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏ�Ú ( )���� _ � �;7 �lÊ b[` �1ÌGÒNÆ�Ö�Ë^Î0Ï����ÁÒNÉiËÍÙsÈJÌhÛ\ܺ�n2�%>À�2@½K^y � Q�UsfDCxy�Cx@lI�KVH%UD@?EVZ�Ug�BHhCxQ\fgCx��KV@�S?K^AgS¾�NC0@�HhK^IJZ6Q�C0AgK^Ug@BHxw¤K¢> CD>ÀK^@�I�S?C��Ug@B�NKV@?A%Q�C0AgK^y�C2��C IJ��C0Cx@­I\S?C1@?C j Q�CxHhI~@?C0KVADS[��UDQ j I\Ugy­H0>N¯�@­I\S?C�U$I�S?C0Q+S j @B�.wgI�S?CbYb�� . HY�NC � C0@B�?C0@BW0C�Ug@�I�S?C;EVUNW j E�?C0@BH\KLIJZ�AgQ j �NKVC0@lI�H�K^@lI�Q\UN�NMBW0CxH�H\UDy�C j QhI�KL �W K j EHJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�C�K^@¡I�S?CYE^Us� �NC0@�HhK^IJZ�Q�C0ADKVUD@�>

��H j  �@ j ETC � j y � E^C�OmUDQ�I\SBC�Q�UDEVC�UDO2I\SBC�H\C0E^O�ceK^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^Ug@½W Ugy � UD@BC0@lI�KV@ ® ªHhUgy�C6� j @��*A jD� H�UD�NI j KV@?Cx� ��KLI�S I�S?C6C0� j WuI¡C �?W�S j @?ADC j Q�C�EVKVHhI\Ci�*KV@ R j �?EVC �B>�2EVELceC0EVCxW I\Q�UD@�¯1X~v:Q\CiHhM?E^I�HY§ q �$¨¤� j H\Cx��UD@�I\S?C�¹�UgQ\Q�KV@?A j ce¹�UgS?@Nc ��UgHhI\Ug]DC0Q2�¢¹Y¹ ���

�������� !�� .Î0Ù[Ê �iÎxÒ (���ÉWZ�ÌGÆ�ÇYËÍÖ�ÉiÙlÊT�gÖ�ÈJÉxÐJÌ0� � � 78� A ��A 9 � �;< Î0Ù[Ê¡ÒgÏLÎxÙlÆI� �Îu×»ÆYÒlÌGÆ �Q�ÊDÉiÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJË^Î0Ï 9 ��� < ÑTØ��/ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ+×»Æ�ÐJÌ �lÌ ? �@A b �G�59 : " < Î0Ù[Ê�Æ>=DÒNÆ�ÐJËÍÇYÆ�ÙsÈhÎ0϶ÊlÎ ÈhÎ�ÚmÎxÏÍ϶Æ�ÙQ�Æ\Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì'ËÍÙ;ÆG/�Û\ÜDÄÅlÆ�ÊgË ÐJÆ�Ö�È#�»Î0Ò�����ÎxÙlÊYÈJÅgÆ�Ö�ÉxÙsÈGÐJË �T�gÈJËÍÉiÙ�� & ) É-Z�ÈJÅlÆ+ÊgÆ�ÐJËÍ×xÎ0ÈJËÍ×»Æ�ÊgËÍÌGÖ�ÉiÙQ�ÈJËÍÙS�lË È+�;ÉWZ�( & ) Î0ÐJÆ �xËL×iÆ�Ù�ÌGÆ�ÒlÎ0ÐhÎ ÈJÆ�Ï��sÜ

( & ( ) ÇYÆ�ÈJÅgÉ$Ê � �$Ë ��Æ� � ? � A ? �@A � � 78� A ��A � Ü ` � "DÜ � � "$Ü � "

? � A ? �@A Ø��@�£Ø�Ø � Ü ` : "DÜ � �� � Æ>=gÎxÖ�È ? �@A � � 78� A ��A � Ü � � ` Ü ` � ` Ü "-

Æ>=gÎxÖ�È ? �@A Ø��@�£Ø�Ø �$Ü " : ` Ü � �Æ>=gÎxÖ�ÈE���1A Ø��@�£Ø�Ø "DÜ � � "$Ü ���Æ>=gÎxÖ�È�� Ø��@�£Ø�Ø ` Ü � "$Ü � �

� & ) Æ>=gÎxÖ�È�� Ø��@�£Ø�Ø � Ü � " �$Ü :�(�� �G� � ? A�Ø�� � Ü � : Ü �( � Æ>=DÒgÈuÜ �$Ü � � ` Ü ` � "$Ü �#�

y�C0I\S?UN� j @B��I\S?C j I�UDy�K�W�H � S?CxQ\C j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@��¢��´N�1� j Q\C�W Ugy �Bj Q�Cx�­��K^I\S�OmM?EVE� UDI\C0@lI�K j E � E j @BC ce� j fgC � HhCxMB�NU � UDI\C0@lI�K j EÀ�ÁX~`*X~X��'� j I j § q �$¨BOmUDQ2��wN´[K j @B��b1Cg>gFG@j �?�NK^I\KVUD@�I�U�I\S?C��lceUD@BE^Z�� j I j�j E�HhU¡I\SBC�f j EVM?CxHYQ�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?A�OmQ�UDy:I\S?C�W0UDy;�?K^@ j I\KVUD@

Page 33: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ cU$O'I\SBC%C � j WuI�©Tª���K^I\S�C0K^I\S?CxQ1ºÀn2� UgQ1bYb�� W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@ j Q�C�EVKVHhI\Ci�¤>¶RTS?C;H\K^@BADEVC c�Bj Q\I\K�W EVC;W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@ � � w�K£> Cg>�I�S?C��NK^Q�CxW I�� j @B��A j$� w�K�H�H\C �Bj Q j I\Ci�¡OmQ\Ugy·I\S?C%�NW cW UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@ �%ª «�I�U�I\S?CY� j @B��A j$� ©��[w

© � � ��� � � ª « � �¢q��$�

`¸S?K^EVC�I�S?C�OmUDQ�y�C0Q­K�H­ADKVfDCx@ �[Z¾I�S?C�HhI j @�� j Q�� �?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C���C0IJ�+CxC0@�I\SBC�S?K^AgS?CxHhIC0KVADC0@[f j EVM?C�U$O+I\S?C­f j EVC0@�W C�� j @B� j @���I�S?C­E^Us��CxHhI�C0KVADC0@[f j EVM?C�U$O+I\S?C­W Ug@B�NMBW I\KVUD@� j @B�.wgI�S?C�E j IhI�C0QTUDQ�K^AgK^@ j I\CiH'OmQ�UDy/I�S?CY�NC0Q�K^f j I\KVfDC��?KVH�W Ug@gI�K^@[M?K^IJZ­U$O�I\S?C1C � j W IT©�ª «�ÁH\C0CYCD> AB>���C OJ>�§L�0¨�� >�kBUDQ�W0UDy �Bj Q�K�HhUg@ j EVH\U�I\S?C%W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��NK^@BA�ºÀn2� j @�� ��k½� j @B�A j$� H j Q\C�EVKVHhI\Ci���ÁK^@6I\SBC�W j H\C�U$O~I�S?C�º�n�� I�S?C��NKVQ\CiWuIYA jD� K�H�KV�?C0@lI\K�W j E'��KLI�S6I�S?CI\U$I j E¤A j$� w j H�I\S?C�ºÀn2�a�NU[CxHT@?UDI2C � � EVKVW0KLI�E^Z¡�NC � C0@���Ug@�I�S?C �Bj QhI�KVW0E^C�@[M?y%��C0Qu�u>

RTS?C�ºÀn2� Q\CiHhM?E^I�H�H\C0Q�fDC�IJ��U � M?Q � UgH\CxH&%$¯�@�I\SBC+Ug@?C~S j @B�¤wiI\SBC0Z��NUNW MBy�Cx@lI�I�S?C�+CxE^E^c£][@?Us��@�M?@B�NCxQ\CiHJI�K^y j I�K^Ug@�UDO~� j @���A jD� H1�[Z�I\S?C­º�n���>�¯�@�I�S?C�U$I\SBC0Q�S j @��¤wI\S?CxZ H\S?Us� S?Us�#W EVUgH\C�W0UD@[fDCxQ\AgCx�¾¹Y¹ ��ce�1´N� j @B� X�`*X+X Q�CxH\M?E^I�H j Q\C¡OmUDQ�I�S?CHhUgE^K��?H2MB@B�NC0Q�W Ug@BH\KV�NCxQ j I\KVUD@.>B`¸S?C0@�Q�C � E j W KV@?A­I\SBC;º�n�� C �?W�S j @?ADC%�lZ�I\SBC%C � j WuI© ª w?I\SBC%�NKVQ\CiWuI�A j$� KVH�W UD@�HhK�HJI�C0@lI\EVZ�Cx@?E j Q�ADCx�.>?FG@�O j W Ixw?I�S?C%�NKVQ�CxWuI2A j$� H2UD�NI j KV@?Cx���KLI�S�I�S?CYC � j W IT© ª j Q�C�KV@�y%MBW�S���C0IhI�C0Q j ADQ�C0C0y�Cx@gI���KLI�S¡I\S?C�C � � C0Q�K^y�Cx@gI j E¤� j I jI\S j @�I�S?C�º�n2� A j$� Hxw[K^Q�Q\CiH � CxW I\KVfDCxE^Z­UDO�I\SBC�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@­OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E jD�?� EVK^Ci�¤>B´[M?Q\c� Q\K�H\K^@?AgE^Z�Ug@?C% �@B�?H1I\S j I1OmUDQ�´[K�I\S?C�KV@BW EVMBH\K^Ug@�UDO+W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�UD@�I�S?C­º�n2� EVC0fDCxEK^@BW0Q\C j H\CxH � � W Ugy ��j Q�Cx����KLI�S�I\S?C��[ceUD@?EVZ�Q�CxH\M?E^Ixw?��S?KVEVC�I\S?C�KV@BW0E^MBH\KVUD@�U$O j bYb��OmUDQ�©�«1EVC j �BHTI\U j Q�Cx�NM�W Cx�¡A j$� >�¯�@BC j E�HhU­@?UDI\K�W CiHTI\S?C%C0@?S j @BW Ci���NC0f[K j I\KVUD@�H���C0cIJ�+CxC0@6I\S?C�¹Y¹ ��ce�1´N� j @B�6I\SBC�X�`*X~X � j I j OmUDQ�I�S?C��NKVQ�CxWuIYA j$� w¤��S?K�W�S�C0K^I\S?CxQK^@B�?KVW j I\CiH�H\UDy�C�EVKVy�K^I j I\KVUD@BH�U$O'I�S?C���´N� K^@�I\S?C�W j H\C�UDO'I\S?C�C � j W I�©Tª�UgQ � UDKV@gI�Hj I�W Ug@[fDC0Q�ADCx@BW C � Q�UD�?EVC0y­Hx>

RTS?C � K�WuI\MBQ\CT��CxW Ugy�CxH'CxfDC0@�EVCxH�H�W EVC j Q j H'H\UlUg@;K�HI�S?C2�NC0Q�KVf j I\KVfDC2�NK�H�W UD@lI�K^@[M?K^IJZU$O;© ª K�H�I j ]gC0@*KV@lI\U j WxW UDMB@gIi>+RTS?C�W UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A½W0UD@lI\Q�KV�?MNI\KVUD@ � ª K�H�y%MBW�SE j Q\AgC0Q�I\S j @ � � § q �s¨ew'HhU�I�S j I­I�S?C j AgQ\CxC0y�C0@lI���KLI�S�C0� � CxQ\KVy�C0@lI�KVH­W0UDy � EVC I�C0EVZE^UlHJIi>?FG@¡O j WuIiwNI\SBC�HhM?y�U$O�� � j @B� � ª UD�NI j KV@?Cx��KV@�I\S?C��[ceUD@?EVZ¡¯1X~v�W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@KVH j EVy�UgHhIÀCx¬lM j EDI�U2I�S?C+fgC0Q�Z�E j Q�ADC~� j @B��A j$� ��S?KVW�S%UD@?C~ B@B�?HÀK^@%I\S?C � j QhI�Q\CxC cGk?UNW�]j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@�§ oDp$¨£>lFG@�I�S j I�H\C0@BH\C j A j K^@�I\S?C��[c£Ug@?E^Z�¯1X+v j @���I�S?C ��k¾H�W�S?C0y�Cj Q�C�Cx¬lM?KVf j EVC0@lIx>~¯��[f[K^UgMBH\E^Zgw�I�S?C¡W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@¾W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@½I\U �%ª «­y;MBHJI­W j @BW CxEI\S?C�E j Q�ADC �%ªN>.��H1EVUD@?A j H1@?U j �NCx¬lM j I\C�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E��K^I\S��NC0Q�KVf j I\KVfDC�NKVH�W Ug@lI\KV@lMBKLIJZ�K�H j f j KVE j �?EVCDw �%ª;S j H�I\U���CYK^Ag@?UDQ�Cx�¤>

FG@ ´[CiWuI�K^Ug@ �g> ²�I�S?C�K^@�HhM 2�W0K^Cx@gI�S j @B�NEVKV@?A�U$O1I\S?C�H\C0E^O�c£KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@ � j H­HhMBA$cADCxHhI\Ci� j HYUg@?C � UgH�HhKV�?EVC�Q�C j H\UD@�OmUgQ�I\SBC­O j KVE^MBQ\C�UDOTI\S?C¡º�n2� j @B��I�S?C¡bYb��/OmUgQv�U$I\I�KV@BH\M?E j I\UgQ�Hx>~� j @�UD@?C¡Q�CxH\UDEVfDC�I�S?K�H � Q�UD�?EVC0y �[Z¾MBH\C¡U$O�I�S?C�C � j WuI­©Tª�'��� Q\CxE^KVy�K^@ j Q�Z j @BH\��C0QTI\U�I�S?K�H�¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@�K�H�ADKVfDCx@�KV@�k�K^AgM?Q�C��i³�K^@���S?K�W�S j A j KV@�I�S?C� j @B��HhI\Q�MBW I\M?Q�CYU$O�k?Cs¯ KVH�W UD@�HhK��NC0Q�Cx�.>?`¸KLI�S?KV@�I\S?C;X�`*X~X jD�?� Q�U j W�S�I�S?C�C � j WuI© ª KVH1W Ugy%�?KV@?Cx����K^I\S�I\S?C�º�n2� OmUDQ�© « >�`¸S?KVE^C%I\S?C;Q\CiHhMBELI�K^@?A�� j @B��HJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�C�K�H¬gMBKLI�C��NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lIYOmQ�UDy¼K^I�H%º�n2�¿W0UDM?@lI\CxQ ��j Q\I��¢W UDy �Bj Q\C­k�KVADM?Q�C�²D�uwÀk?C»¯¿KVH j A j K^@� Q\Ci�NK�WuI\Ci� I\U�S j fDC j y�C I j EVE^K�W�ADQ�UDM?@�� HhI j I\CDw j H��[Z�I\SBC�º�n2� j @B� I\S?C�bYb��%>k?UDQ;I\SBC�KV@lI\C0Q � Q�C I j I\KVUD@�UDO�I\S?K�H�@?C0A j I�K^fgC�Q\CiHhMBELI�KLI�KVH�KVy � UgQhI j @lI%I�U�Q�C j EVKV°0C�I�S?CI\CxW�SB@?KVW j E?EVKVy�K^I j I\KVUD@BH~U$O¶I\SBC�W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@.>gkÀKVQ�HJI~UDO j E^E£w$I�S?C�¹Yº�F jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�K^Ug@;K�HMNI\KVE^KV°0Ci�¤>Db1KVfDC0@�I\S?CTQ�CxH\M?ELI�H�UDO�´[CiWuI\KVUD@�³?>V�DwiS?Us��C0fDCxQxw0I\S?K�H'H\S?UDM?E��Y@?UDI���C j H\C0Q�K^UgMBH

Page 34: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

���

����� �I ��� .ÎxÙlÊ�ÌeÈGÐ��lÖ�È��DÐJÆ�ÉWZ�ÎxÙsÈJË Z�Æ�ÐGÐJÉxÇ�Î��iÙgÆ�ÈJËÍÖ6Ú�È+�DÒNÆ Y YeÛ �lÆ Ñ¿Éc�gÈhÎ0ËÍÙlÆuÊh�I�6ÒlÏLÎxÙgÆ=��Îu×»Æ=�ÁÒlÌGÆ �lÊgÉxÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏ�ÖuÎxÏÍÖ �gÏ^Î ÈJËÍÉiÙ ��Ë ÈJÅ­Æ>=gÎxÖ�È (

�Î0Ù[Ê ? � A½Ö�ÉxÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ ÈJËLÉxÙ�ÉxÙ�ÈJÅlÆ �lÎxÌGËÍÌ

ÉWZ[ÈJÅlÆ��0? YA�¢Î0ÒlÒgÐJÉ =DËÍÇ�Î0ÈJËÍÉiÙ%Ú�ÈJÅlÆ�×iÎ0ÏLÆ�ÙlÖ�Æ'ÌGÒlÎxÖ�Æ'ÉWZ[�lÆ'ËÍÙlÖ�Ï��lÊgÆ�̶ÈJÅgÆ� � b ���Î0Ù[Ê � ��ÌeÈhÎ ÈJÆ�Ì b( )���� _ � �2" 7 �gÊ b 1ÌGÒNÆ�Ö�ËLÎxÏ����ÁÒNÉiËÍÙsÈJÌhÛ\Ü� UgK^@lIx>�v�UDQ�CYKVy � UDQ\I j @lI2y�KVADSlI���CYI�S?C�O j WuI2I�S j I2I�S?C%³76�HhI j I�C�U$O�kBC�S j H2@?C0K^I\S?CxQ��CxC0@¡K^@BW0E^M��NCx��K^@�I\SBCYf j E^Cx@BW C�H �Bj W0C�UDO�I\SBC�kBC � HhCxMB�NU � UDI\C0@lI�K j E�@BUDQTS j H�K^I���CxC0@I j ]gC0@�KV@lI\U j WxW UgM?@lI�f[K j H\UDy�C�@?Ug@?EVK^@?C j Q�W0UDQ�C cGW UgQ\Q�CxW I\KVUD@.>NRTS?K�H2@?CxADEVCxW I�E^C j �?H�I\Uj @�K^@�W UDQ�Q�CxWuI'AgQ\UgM?@B��HJI j I�C�K^@�I�S?C�W j HhCTUDO¤�?K j I\UDy�K�W�k?Cs¯ § o?�0¨£>DkBM?Q\I\S?CxQ\y�UDQ�CDwsUg@?EVZ³YH � CxW0K j E �lc � UgK^@lI�H'S j fDCT��C0Cx@�MBH\Cx�;OmUDQ+K^@lI\CxADQ j I�K^Ug@BHUsfDCxQI\S?C���Q�K^EVEVUDM?KV@�°0UD@BC j @B�I\S?C � E j @?C0c£� j fDC2W0MNIhceU$µ�UDO�²DqDp ��ZN�N��CxQ\A�K�H+@BU$I �Bj Q\I\K�W M?E j Q�EVZ;E j Q�ADC�K^@�flKVC0� U$O�I�S?CE^UNW j E^KV°0Ci�;³�� j @B��³ ) HhI j I�CxHx>sFeI'Q\Cxy j K^@�H�I\U���CTKV@[fDCxHhI\KVA j I\Ci�YI\U���S?K�W�S�C �[I\Cx@lI�I�S?CxH\CI\CxW�SB@?KVW j E+E^KVy�KLI j I\KVUD@�H j µ¶CxW I�I\S?C�� j @��?H�H\S?Us��@�K^@¾k�KVADM?Q�C��x³Bw�H\U�I\S j I%KLI�HhCxC0y­HI\U�C j Q\EVZ�I\U��NQ j � �NC0 B@?K^I\KVfDC�W Ug@BW EVMBH\K^Ug@BH­W Ug@BW CxQ\@?KV@?A�I\S?C��NCiH\W0Q\K � I�K^Ug@ UDO1v�UDIhIK^@BH\M?E j I�UDQ�H+�[Z�MBHhC�UDOÀI�S?CYC � j W I�C �?W�S j @BADCD>

� �­�h� �g} � ���B�\|��¤��� ��� �6{ � � �h�\�¤�G}�6���?� � �� �}?�J�~|�2��|���}?�J�~| � �´[UDy�C­U$O�I\SBC­C � j y � EVCxH�W0UD@BH\K��NC0Q�Cx�6K^@�I�S?C � Q�C0f[K^UgMBH�´[CiWuI\KVUD@ j E^Q�C j �NZ�KV@B�NK�W j I�Cx�I\S j I­I\S?C�C0� j WuI­C0�NW�S j @?AgCDw'��S?KVE^C � Q\Usf[K��NK^@BA6Ug�lf[KVUDMBH � Q\UgADQ�CxH�H�W0UDy �Bj Q\Ci�¾��K^I\SI\S?C�ºÀn2� j @B�½I\S?C�bYb��%w�S j H�I\U���C�W0UDy;�?K^@BCx� ��KLI�S j @ jD�?� Q�U � Q�K j I\C�UDQ��?K^I j E^c�NC � C0@B�?C0@lI�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E.KV@¡UgQ��?C0Q�I\U­��CYMBH\C OmM?E.KV@ � Q j WuI�KVW0CD>Bb1KVfDCx@�I�S?C BQ�HhIhc � Q�K^@�W K � E^CiH�@ j I\MBQ\C�U$O�I�S?C�C � j W I�© ª w�K^I�HhM?AgADCiHJI�H�K^I�H\C0E^O%I�U��NCxQ\KVfDC�HhM�W�S jW UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@6OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E~KV@ j H\Z[HhI\Cxy j I\K�W�O j H\S?KVUD@�OmQ�UDy I\S?C�C0� j WuI�© « >ÀRTS[MBHYI�S?C BQ�HhI�I j H\]�K�H�I\U2CiHJI j �?EVKVH\S j H\M?K^I j �?E^C+C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@1OmUgQ�I�S?C~C0� j WuIÀ© ª « ��SBKVW�S%W j @�H\C0Q�fDCj H~HhI j QhI�K^@BA � UgK^@lI�OmUgQ�I\SBC�H\M?�BH\Cx¬lM?C0@lI~�NK�H�W MBH�HhKVUD@­UDO j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@BHx>$RTS?K�H�C � j WuIOmUDQ�y%M?E j OmUDQ�© ª « j I�I\S?C�H j y�C�I�K^y�C%Q�CxH\UDEVfDCiH�I�S?C;�NK�H�W Q�C �Bj @BW Z¡��S?K�W�S�� j H2OmUgM?@B���C0IJ�+CxC0@�I\S?C�UgQ\KVADKV@ j E�¯1X+v Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@ �¢²��$� j @��½I�S?C�´[S j y�cG´NW�SBEJPMNI�C0Q�Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�mrlqg�u>

Page 35: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ 1�� ��� � "&! * � � * '$* +��#��*&��* * ! � " %���% * � � * �#! � � �#" � %&* % +���� � � "# +

� +�#���%�%���*�!�� *&�������º.C IMBH j H�H\M?y�C�OmUDQ j y�Ugy�C0@lIÀI�S j I ®�� wiI\SBC~I�U$I j EN¹�UDS?@NcJ´[S j y � UDI\C0@lI�K j E¢w»K�HÀ][@?Us��@§L�io?wV��[w og²s¨£>¤RTS?K�H j E^EVUs�2H�I�S?C��NC0 B@?K^I\KVUD@¾UDO j @BUD@?KV@lI\C0Q j W I\KV@?A ��c �Bj Q\I\K�W EVC�� j y�K^E^cI\UD@BK j @ �� � wB��S?K�W�S�KVH2I\S?C�HhMBy#UDOI\S?C;]lKV@?C0I\K�WYC0@?CxQ\AgZ j @B� j @�C0�lI�C0Q�@ j E � UDI\Cx@gI�K j EI\C0Q�y � j H\Cx��UD@ ®�� w

�� � � �J � ' )+-, �0 ����� ®�� �����C� �¢q �g�

RTS?C;AgQ\UgM?@B�6HJI j I\C 1 � �#!�� j H\H\M?y�Cx��I\U¡��C�@?Ug@B�NC0AgC0@?CxQ j I\C»�2W UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A­I�U �� �KVH�Ug�NI j K^@BCx���lZ�HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@�UDOÀI�S?C%´NW�S?Q»PUg�?K^@?AgC0QTCx¬lM j I\[email protected]

�� � 1 � � !��*© � 1 � � !�� �¢q �g�1 � � !�KVH j ´[E j I�C0Q2�NC0I\CxQ\y�KV@ j @lI2U$OÀI\S?C�¹�´�UgQ\�?K^I j EVHxw1 � � !�� ���� � � �� U/ 1 p ! 7 �Áogpg�

��S?C0Q�C �� � U / �NC0@?UDI\CiH�I�S?C j @?@?KVS?K^E j I�K^Ug@��ÁW0Q\C j I�K^Ug@��'U � CxQ j I\UDQ�OmUDQ+I\S?C1HhKV@?ADEVC c �Bj QhI�KVW0E^C¹�´�HhI j I�Cf� / j @�� 1 p !~KVH�I�S?CYW UgQ\Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A;¹�´�f j W MBM?y�w��� / 1 p !��*pB>NRTS?C�ADQ�UDM?@B�HJI j I\C�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ�© � j @B���NC0@BH\K^IJZ j Q�C�ADKVfDC0@¡�[Z

© � �6J � � '*)+W, 0 ���¶� ®�� ������� 5 / - / � / �ÁoB�i�

0 �����9� ��� � 1 �0 ����� 1 � ��!8��5/- / 1 � / ����� 1 � �Áol²D�

�+Z�W UD@�HJI�Q\MBW I\KVUD@��Áol²D�+KVH2KV�NCx@lI\K�W j E¤��K^I\S¡I�S?C��NC0@�HhK^IJZ�UDO�I\SBCYK^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^@?A­H\ZNHJI�C0y�>RTS?CY¹�´�H\ZNHJI�C0y W�S j Q j WuI�C0Q�K^°xCx�­�[Z �� � � Q�Usf[KV�NCiH j EVE¶I\S?CYKV@?ADQ�Cx�?K^Cx@gI�HTQ\Ci¬lM?K^Q�Cx�

OmUDQ�HJI j @B� j Q��¾y j @[Zgce��U[�?Z�I�S?C0UgQ\Zg>ÀFG@ �Bj Q\I\K�W M?E j Qiw.I�S?C¡C � � EVKVW0KLI�OmUDQ�y U$O�I\SBC¡¹�´ BC0E��¡U � C0Q j I\UgQTK^@ �2CxKVH\C0@[��C0Q�A;Q�C � Q\CiHhCx@gI j I�K^[email protected]

�� �g�����h��� �������� � �� ���¶� � B �������� �65/

�� / � / ���¶� � B � �� � 7 �Áog³g�

j EVE^Us�2H+I\SBCYC0f j EVM j I�K^Ug@�UDOÀI�S?C�¹�´¡b1Q\CxC0@ . H�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@��Á³,�g�uw

� � ����� 7 � . � . �9� ���-�� � � � . �@5� � � �� � / �����I��U / ��� . � ��B � �� � � B � �

� �-�� � . � �h� 5������� � /?�����I��U / ��� . � � B � � � � � B � � � �ÁoDrl�

FG@�UDQ��NC0Q�I�U��NC0Q�KVfDC j @�C0� j WuI%Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmUgQ;© ª « UD@BC­@?Us� M�HhCiH �� � j HY@?Ug@?KV@NcI\C0Q j W I\KV@?A­Q�C OmC0Q�C0@�W C � j y�K^E^I\Ug@?K j @.>�k�KVQ�HhI2I�S?CYI\UDI j E �� U$OI�S?C�KV@gI�C0Q j W I\KV@?A�HhZNHhI\Cxy

Page 36: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

: Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

KVH��NCiW UDy � UgH\Cx��KV@lI\U �� � j @B� j Q�C0y j KV@B�NCxQ �� ± w���SBUgH\C�y j KV@¾KV@?ADQ�Cx�?K^Cx@gI�K�H%I�S?CC0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@NceC0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@ KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@ ��8>+FG@ j �?�NK^I\[email protected] �� ± S j H­I\U½W0UDy � Cx@BH j I\C�I�S?UgH\C�Bj Q\I�HTUDO �� � ��S?KVW�S j Q�C�@?U$I � Q�CxH\C0@lI�KV@ ��¾w

�� ± � �� � '*)+-, �0 ����� ®�$ ª «s���¶��� �ÁolqD�

�2C0Q�C ®�$ ª «�Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�H+I�S?CYC0EVCxW I\Q�UD@NceC0EVCxW I\Q�UD@�KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@¡W Ugy � UD@BC0@lI�HTKV@ ®�� w®�$ ª «»������� ®�� ���¶� � ®�! ª#"0�����8� ®�$ ����� � ® ª «s�����C� �Áogog�

FG@�I\SBC1H\CxW0UD@B��HhI\C ��j Q\MB@?@?KV@?A;W0UDM � EVKV@?A�W0UD@BHhI j @lI���KVH�KV@gI�Q\UN�NM�W Cx��K^@lI\U;I\SBC�I�U$I j E� j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @�w

��¾���N��� �� � � � �� ± 7 �Áo��$���S?KVW�S¡HhMB�BHhCi¬lM?C0@lI\EVZ j EVEVUs�2H'I\SBC1M�HhC1U$O.I�S?C�W UDM � E^KV@?A�W UD@�HJI j @lI�KV@lI\CxADQ j I\KVUD@�I�Q\K�W�]¶>RTS?C�ADQ�UDM?@B��HJI j I�C 1 " �l���?� !TW UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A%I\U ��¾���?�1� j E�H\U j H\H\M?y�Cx��I\U���C1@BUD@B�NC0cADC0@BC0Q j I\C»�+KVHTUg�NI j K^@?Ci��OmQ�UDy I\S?CYKV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?A­´NW�S?Q»PUg�NKV@?AgC0QTCx¬lM j I\[email protected]

������?� 1 " � ���N� !��*©����?� 1 " � ���N� !�� �Áo,�g�

¯�@?C�W j @­@?Us� j$�?� EVZ;I\S?C�W0UDM � E^KV@?A%W0UD@BHhI j @gI�KV@lI\CxADQ j I\KVUD@­H�W�S?C0y�C�I�UYI\SBC��gcG�NC � Cx@Nc�NC0@lI2ADQ�UDMB@B��HhI j I\CYC0@BC0Q�ADZDw

©����?��� ��" � ���N� 1 ��½���?� 1 " � ���N� !�� �Áo,�g�

¯�@?CYHJI j Q\I�HT�[Z��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@lI\K j I\KV@?A�©����N����K^I\S�Q�CxH � CiWuITI\U��¶w

�� �©����?��� � " �l���N� 1 �� ± 1 " �l���?� ! 7 � �$pg�

MBHhKV@?A�I\SBC�O j WuI�I�S j I 1 " � ���?� !�@?UgQ\y j EVKV°0Cx��OmUDQ j E^E��¶w��" �l���N� 1 " �g���?� !�� ���

¯�@?C+W j @�I�S?C0@;K^@lI�C0ADQ j I�C�� �spg�.��KLI�S%Q�CxH � CiWuI�I\U���>»RTS?C�K^@lI�C0ADQ j I�K^Ug@�HJI j Q\I�H j I� �¸pBwOmUDQ���S?K�W�S ��¾���N� j AgQ\CxCxH���KLI�S�I�S?C­¹�´ � j y�K^E^I\Ug@?K j @.w j @B��C0@B�BH j I� � �Dw¶��S?C0Q�C��¾���?�¤K�H.K��NC0@lI�KVW j El��KLI�SYI\S?C~I\Q�M?C~KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?A�� j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @.>s¯�@YI\SBC~EVC O�IhceS j @B��H\KV�NCgwI\S?C;K^@lI\CxADQ j I�K^Ug@�I\S[MBH�E^C j �?H2I\U�I�S?C;�?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C���C IJ��C0C0@�I\S?C;C0@?CxQ\AgZ¡©��h�i�F� © "AH "U$O�I�S?C�K^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^@?A¡HhZNHhI\Cxy �m��S?K�W�S�K�H�I\S?C�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ�UD@BC;K�H1K^@lI\CxQ\CiHJI�Cx��K^@�� j @B��I�S?C¹�´�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ�©��Ápg��� © � w

©��h�i� � ©��¢pg���¸© "�H " � © � � © ± � ' ±� ) � � " � ���?� 1 �� ± 1 " � ���?� !�� � �N�i�

k?UDQTI�S?C�Cxf j E^M j I\KVUD@�UDO'© ± I\S?C;W UD@�W C � I2U$O j �NK j � j I\K�WYHh��K^I�W�SBK^@?A­K�H jD�?� EVK^Ci��I\U�� ± w�K£> CD> �� ± K�H�H\��KLI�W�S?Cx��UDµ6OmUgQ�E j Q�ADC � UgH\K^I\KVfDC j @B��@?CxA j I�K^fgCYI\KVy�CxHxw�M�HhKV@?A�H\UDy�C

Page 37: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ �C � � Ug@?C0@lI�K j E�H\��KLI�W�S?K^@BA�O j W I\UDQi>+RTSBC6HhI j @�� j Q���y j W�S?KV@?C0Q�Z UDOYy j @[Zgce��U[�?Z � C0Q\cI\M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@¡I\S?CxUDQ�Z�I\SBC0@�EVC j �?HTI\U j @�C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@���S?K�W�S�W Ug@?@?CxW I�H2I\S?C�KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?AADQ�UDM?@B�¡HhI j I�C 1 " ��!���KLI�S¡I\S?C�¹�´�ADQ�UDMB@B��HhI j I\CDw

1 " � !9��� E^KVy� �������+, �u�Áp 7���� � 1 � ��!��� � 1 �� � , � �Áp 7��� � 1 � � ! � �D²D�

� � EVK^y�;, �� ��� � ��� � 1 ����+, � ; � � � 7 pg� 1 � ��! ��� � 1 ����+, ��D�Áp 7 � � � 1 � ��!��� � 1 �� � , � ; � � � 7 pg� �� � , � s�Áp 7 � � � 1 � � ! ± F � �$³g�

��� C0@BH\M?Q�CxH+I\SBC�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI�@?UDQ�y j EVK^° j I\KVUD@�U$O 1 " ��!h�u>�RTS?C�y j K^@¡K^@BADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lITU$O�� �$²g��K�HI\S?CYKV@lI\C0Q j W I\KVUD@ � K�WuI\MBQ\C1I\KVy�C ceC0fgUDEVMNI\KVUD@¡U � C0Q j I�UDQiw

����+, �u��� 7 � . �9� �5 � �

� ����?� 0�� ' �

� �) � ± K2K�K ' �

� �) � � B � � � � ; � ������� � � ��� �

� J � �� ± , �l� � ± � K2K2K �� ± , �l� � � � 7 � �srl�

��S?KVW�S�K�HTADKVfDCx@��[Z j�� Us�+CxQ2HhCxQ\KVCxH�U$O �� ± K^@¡I�S?CYK^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^Ug@ � K�WuI�M?Q�CDw

�� ± , �l� �h�2� � � ������ �� ± ��B � ���� � � ����l���h� � '*)+V, �� U� ����h� �� �[�����h� ®�$ ª «»������� � �DqD�

FG@BHhCxQhI�K^Ug@�U$O�� �$²g�¤KV@lI\U�I\S?CTW UgM � EVK^@?A1W Ug@BHJI j @lIÀKV@lI\CxADQ j E¶� �[�»�¤EVC j �?H.I�U�I�S?CTHJI j @B� j Q��C0@?CxQ\AgZ¾W UDQ�Q�CxWuI�K^Ug@¾��S?K�W�S Q�CxH\M?E^I�H;OmQ�UDy H\��KLI�W�S?K^@BA�Ug@ H\UDy�C � CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@ I\U j@?UD@?KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KV@?A�Q\C0OmC0Q�C0@BW0CYHhZNHhI\C0y�w

© ± � EVK^y� � � ' ±� ) � �5

�� �� ���

�?� 0�� ' �B �) � ± K�K2K ' �B � ) � ��B � � � � ; � ������� � � ��� �

���� � 1 J �� ± , � �¢pg� �� ± , � � � ± � K2K2K �� ± , � � � � 1 � � !��� � 1 ����+, �u� � � 7 � � � 1 � � ! � � �$og�

d�H\K^@?A­=+¬lHx>�� �[�»� j @B��� �D��UD@?CYW j @� �@ j EVE^Z�C �[I\Q j W I2© ª « w

© ª « �¦© ±� © $ � ' ) + , 0 ����� ® $ ª « ������ �

² ' ) + , ' ) + , . ��1 � � � . 1 � ��� � 1 �� U ����� �� U ��� . � �� ��� . � �� ���¶� 1 � � ! � 0 ����� 0 ��� . � �� E^KVy� ���

�5 � ±

� ��� �� � 0 � �»� �

' �B �) � ± K�K2K ' �B � ) � � B � � � � ; � ����� � � ��� �

� ��� � 1 J �� ± , �D�¢pg� �� ± , �l� � ± � K2K2K �� ± , �l� � � 1 � � ! � 7 � �,�$�

Page 38: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

��S?C0Q�C�I�S?C;KV@B�NC0����KV@B�NK�W j I\CxH�I�S j I�UD@?EVZ�E^KV@?]gCx���NK j AgQ j y­H j Q�C�I�U���C;KV@BW0E^MB�?Cx�6K^@I\S?C2Cxf j EVM j I�K^Ug@�UDO�� � �D�f[K j `¸K�W�] . H'I\S?CxUDQ�C0y·��I\SBKVH~Q\CiHJI�Q\K�WuI�K^Ug@�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��?H�I\UYI�S?CW j @�W C0EVE j I\KVUD@�UDO�I\S?C¡�NC0@BUDy�K^@ j I\UgQ%UDO%� �sol�h� >�RTS?C� BQ�HJI�I�C0Q�y UD@�I�S?C�Q�K^AgSlIhceS j @B�HhK��NC��¢HhCiW Ug@B��E^KV@?C»��Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�H�I\S?C% BQ�HhI�UgQ��NCxQ�W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@���K^I\S�Q�CxH � CxWuI�I\U�I�S?C� CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@ �� ± j @B� KVH�C j HhKVEVZ�KV�NCx@lI\K^ BCx� j H;I\SBC�C �?W�S j @BADC�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ¸�h���g� >�RTS?CHhCiW UD@���I\CxQ\y�w¶��S?K�W�S j �BHhUgQ\��H j E^ES?KVADS?CxQ�UDQ��NC0Q�H�KV@ �� ± w�I\S[MBH � Q�UsflK��NCiH j @�C � j WuIC � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@ OmUDQ�I�S?C�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@½Cx@?C0Q�ADZ½©2«i>+RTS?C�K^@BADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�H�Q\Ci¬gMBK^Q�Cx�½OmUDQ­I�S?CC0f j EVM j I�K^Ug@�U$O¶I\S?K�H+C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@�f[K j `¸K�W�] . H'I\S?CxUDQ�C0y j Q�CTI\S?C�¹�´­b1Q�C0Cx@ . HOmM?@BW I\KVUD@�Áo$r[�uw¤I�S?C��+UDMBE^Ugy%��K^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^Ug@ j @B� ® $ ª « � j H �� ± �NC � C0@��?HYUD@�I�S?KVH � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E�� >RTS?C�� j QhI�Q\CxC�W Ugy � Ug@?C0@lI~UDO ® $ ª « KVH~Q\C j �NKVEVZ�W j E�W M?E j I�Cx��OmQ�UDy I\S?C�¹�´�UgQ\�BKLI j E�H0wlHhUI\S j I%� � �D���NC � C0@B�BH�UD@¡I\SBQ\CxC1� j H\KVW1KV@?ADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�H0w � /[w � / j @B� ® ª « >

¯�@?C�I�S[MBH�C0@B�?H�M � ��K^I\S j @�C � j W I�Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI j I\KVUD@�UDO1© ª « KV@ I\C0Q�y­H�U$O�I�S?C¹�´�UDQ��?K^I j E�H j @B��CxK^AgC0@[f j EVM?CxH j H;�+CxE^E j H%I\S?C��?Wuc � UDI\C0@lI�K j E1§ r��»¨£>��+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@lI\EVZDw=~¬�>V� � �D��KVH­@BU$I j @ j E^AgC0�?Q j K�W j H�HhKVAD@By�Cx@lI�UDO�HhUgy�C���C0EVE^ce�NC0 B@?Ci� C0� � Q\CiH\H\KVUD@ I\U©Tª «»w+�?M?I�Q j I\SBC0Q�Q�C � Q\CiHhCx@gI�H j S?KVADSBE^Z @?Ug@?E^KV@?C j Q�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E1Cx¬lM j I\[email protected] j H�©�ª «KVH�ADKVfDCx@¾KV@¾I\CxQ\y­H�U$O2K^I&. H�Us��@�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E��NC0Q�KVf j I\KVfDC��s>'RTS?KVH�@?Us�¿C0� � E j K^@�H%I�S?C@?UD@?EVKV@?C j Q�W�S j Q j W I\C0Q�U$O�I\S?C�´NS j y�cJ´NW�S?EJPMNI\CxQ­Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@ �Árlqg�u> ��Z j @ j EVZl°xK^@BA6I�S?CC � j W I%©Tª «%��S?K�W�S��NC I�C0Q�y�K^@?CiH�I\SBC�Q\KVADSlI\c£S j @B��HhK��NC��¢² �g�1UDO+I�S?C¡¯1X~v Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@UD@?C� �@B�?H~I\S j I+C � j WuI\EVZ�I�S?C�H j y�C2@BUD@?EVK^@BC j Q�K^IJZ%C �NK�HJI�H�KV@­I\SBC�W Ug@[fDC0@lI�K^Ug@ j E�¯1X+v�>�2Us��W j @YUg@?C��NC j ED��K^I\S�I\S?K�H.@?Ug@?EVK^@?C j Q�KLIJZ'~RTS?C0Q�C j Q�CIJ�+U � UlH\H\K^�BE^C�HhI\Q j I�C0ADKVCxH&%

=�K^I\S?CxQ+Ug@?C2I�Q\KVCxH�I\U;H\UDEVfDC2I\S?C1@?UD@BE^KV@?C j QT¯1X+v�Cx¬lM j I\[email protected]��S?KVW�S�KVH j S?KVADSBE^Z�@?Ug@NcI\Q�K^f[K j E�I j H\]¶wgH\U�I�S j I�KLITS j H+@?UDI+ZDC0I+��C0Cx@ j I\I\C0y � I�Cx�¤>N��H j @ j E^I\CxQ\@ j I\KVfDC�Ug@?C�W j @I\Q�Z�I\U�EVK^@BC j Q�KV°0C�I\S?C��?W c£Cx@?C0Q�ADZ�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E j @B��I�S[MBH�I\SBC�¯1X~v Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@.>.RTS?K�HQ\UgMNI\C�K�H � M?Q�HhMBCx��K^@¡I\SBCY@?C �[I�´[CiWuI\KVUD@�>

� ��� ���,�+ " ��� "$+������ " ���(��* "# � +�* � �(" � � � # �#���" +��,� ���+"("$+�� * !�� � � # * !('*���'(��� #,*&������ "$+�� * !���"#!$# +���*�!#" �

b1K^fgC0@�I\S?C�UDQ�KVADKV@�U$O=~¬�>�� � �D�uw j @¡C � �Bj @BH\K^Ug@�U$O© ª « � j @B��I\S[MBH ® ª « �+K^@ � Us�+CxQ�H�U$O� K�HI�S?C�@ j I�M?Q j EN BQ�HhI jD�?� Q�U j W�S�I\U�I�S?C2EVK^@BC j Q�KV° j I�K^Ug@;UDOBI�S?C1¯1X~v�Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�§^���s¨e>RTS?C­E^Us��CxHhI�UDQ��NC0Q1I\CxQ\y K^@�I\SBKVHYC0� �Bj @BH\KVUD@�K�H1I\SBC­C �?W�S j @BADC�C0@?CxQ\AgZD>.�2EVE�S?KVADSBC0QUDQ��NC0Q�I\CxQ\y­H2W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��­I\U­©�«»w

©Tª « � �5� � ±� � © � � ª « § 0 ¨��*©�ª � © � �« � �W�-� � � �g�

® ª « � �5� � ±� � ® � � ª « § 0 ¨�� ® ª � ® � « � �W�-�C� � � �g�

��O�I\CxQ�KV@BH\C0Q\I\KVUD@¡U$O�� ���l�uw�� ���l��K^@lI\U�I�S?C�¯1X+v Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@���U$I�S�KLI�H�Q\KVADSlI\c£S j @B� j @B�KLI�H~EVC O�I\c£S j @B��H\KV�?C j Q�C2AgK^fgC0@ j H � Us��C0Q+HhCxQ\KVCxH~��KLI�S�Q\CiH � CxW I~I�U��$>[RTS?C�K��NC0@lI�KLIJZ�U$O� É0ÈJÆYÅlÉ �Æ�×»Æ�Ð b ÈJÅ[Î0È�ÈJÅgËÍÌ2ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ È�ËLÌ2Ö�ÉxÙlÌGËÍÌeÈJÆ�ÙsÈ ��ËÍÈJÅ�ÈJÅlÆ �lÎxÌGËÍÖ�ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆ�ÇYÆ�ÙsÈJÌ�ÉWZ��F�¤Ä �A+Ì % & ) ËÍÌ�Î1ÊgÆ�ÙgÌGËÍÈ+� Z �lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙ[Î0Ï�Ë ÈJÌGÆ�Ï Z b ÈJÅlÆTÐJË �iÅsÈ �ÁÅ[Î0Ù[Ê%ÌGË^ÊDÆ2É-Z�Ô 6NÜLÚ ��� ÛËÍÌ�Î0Ù�ËÍÇYÒlÏÍËÍÖ�Ë ÈÊgÆ�ÙlÌGË È��fZ �gÙlÖ�ÈJËÍÉxÙ[ÎxÏ�Ü

Page 39: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ #���UDI\S6H\K��NCxH1K�H�@?Us�aQ�Cx¬lM?KVQ�Cx��UgQ��NCxQ��[Z�UDQ��NCxQx>�FG@�I\SBC;EVUs�+CiHJI1UDQ��NC0Q�� � �2I\SBC�EVC O�I\cS j @B��H\KV�?C�UDO+I�S?C�¯1X~v Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@ �JMBHhI;W Ug@gI j KV@BH ® ª?w¤��S?KVE^C�I�S?C­Q\KVADSlI\c£S j @B��HhK��NCKVH2�?C I\CxQ\y�KV@?Cx�¡�[Z��£²D²D� >?RTS?K�H2HhKVy � EVZ�Q�C �BCiWuI�H�I�S?C�O j W I�I\S j I�©Tª;K�H j ��C0EVELcG�NC  �@?Cx�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EBU$O�I\S?C\� / UD@BE^Zg>DR�U�EVUs�+CiHJI'UgQ��NCxQ'UD@?CTI�S[MBH'C0@��?H'M � ��K^I\S�I\S?C�HJI j @B� j Q��E^KV@?C j Q�¯1X~v:Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�OmUDQTI\SBCYC � j W ITC0�?W�S j @?AgCDw

'*)+V,�. � ��� 7 � . � ® ªB��� . ���� �ª?���¶� � �gpg�

�ª?������� � 5/'*)+V,�. ��U/ ���¶� � / ��� 7 � . � 3 © ª

3 ��U/ ��� . � ��� � � �-� � �B�i�

RTS?CY BQ�HJI�I�K^y�CYI�S j I�I�S?C�@?Ug@?EVK^@?C j Q�KLIJZ�HhS?Us�2H2M � KVH�K^@¡I\SBC�UDQ��NC0Q � �g>�RTS?K�H�EVUs�+CiHJIUDQ��NC0Q�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�W j @¡��CY��Q�KLI\I\Cx@ j H

© � �« �¸© D ' « � ©�� $ <« � � �l²D�RTS?C' BQ�HJI.UDOgI�S?CxH\CI\CxQ\y­H�KVH j @�C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@1��S?K�W�S1� j H\KVW j EVE^Z�E^U[UD]NH¶EVK^]gCI\S?C+HJI j @B� j Q��HhCiW UD@���UgQ��NCxQ�v��$EVE^CxQhcGX�EVCxH�H\C IY�Áv�X�²D��W UgQ\Q�CxW I\KVUD@�I�U�I\S?C ��k¾Cx@?C0Q�ADZgw

© D ' « � � �² 5 ��� /�� - � - � �J��- /$� �h� � - �¢� � ��� 1 1 � �¢�0§^��� � 1 1 ��� � � ��� � 1 1 � � �e¨� � � � � � � / � � � �·� �g³g�

�2Us��C0fDCxQxwlI�S?C%´[E j I\CxQ�K^@lI�C0ADQ j E�H�� ��� 1 1 � �£�uw� ��� 1 1 � �£�2� '@)T+-, ± 'h)T+W, ��U� ��� ± �I� / ��� ± � ��U� ��� � � � ��� �1 � ± � � 1 7 � �Drl�

j Q�C�W j EVW0M?E j I\Ci����KLI�S­I\S?C1¹�´�UDQ��?K^I j E�H2� /[w j @���I\S?C1�NC0@BUDy�K^@ j I\UgQ�U$O~���D³l�Q\CxE^KVCxH~UD@I\S?C2¹�´;C0KVADCx@[f j E^MBCxH � /[wDH\U�I�S j I~© D ' « W j @�ADKVfDCTQ�CxH\M?E^I�H��S?K�W�S j Q�CT¬lM?K^I\C2�?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@lIOmQ\Ugy HJI j @B� j Q���v�X�²�� j I j �¢HhCxC���CxE^Us��� >BRTS?CYHhCiW Ug@B��W0UD@lI\Q�KV�?MNI\KVUD@�I\U����g²g��I j ]gCxHK^@lI\U j WxW UDMB@gI~I\S j I~I\SBC � Q�CxH\C0@lI � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I\KVUD@�C0� ��j @BH\K^Ug@­KVH~@?U$I�� j H\Cx��UD@�I\SBC���k� j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @�wN�?MNI�Ug@�I�S?C�¹�´ � j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @.w

© � $ <« � 5� �- � �J�

�- � �� � � � �

� � 1 ® ª 1 ��! � � 5�- � �

��� 1 1 � �¢� � � �lqD�

FeIÀKV@lfgUDEVfDCiH¶I\S?CT�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C~��C0IJ�+CxC0@YI�S?C~UgQ\�?K^I j EDC0� � CxW I j I\KVUD@�f j EVM?C+U$O[I\S?C�@?Ug@?E^UNW j E��kÀc¢IJZ � CYC �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E� � - �

� 1 1 � j @���I�S j I2UDO ® ª w��� 1 ® ª 1 � !�� ' ) + , ��U� ����� ® ª �����I���\������� � �gog�

FeI�HhCxC0y­H��+UgQhI�S[��S?K^EVC j I­I�S?KVH � UgK^@lI­I\U�Cxy � S j H\K^°xC�I\S?C��?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C���C0IJ�+CxC0@ j @C � �Bj @�HhKVUD@���K^I\S¾Q�CxH � CxWuI%I\U�I�S?C � C0Q\I\MBQ\�?KV@?A.� j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @ �� ± j @B��I�S?C � Q�CxH\C0@lIC � �Bj @�HhKVUD@�K^@ � Us�+CxQ�H�UDO�� >+RTS?C�OmUDQ�y�C0Q�C � �Bj @BHhKVUD@�EVC j �BH�I\U�I\SBC�H j y�C�� j HhK�WC � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@BH­���D³l� j @B� � �lqD� w�S?Us��C0fgC0Qiw���K^I\S ® ª ��C0KV@?A�Q�C � E j W0Cx���[Z�I\SBC­OmM?EVE ® ª « >

Page 40: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� " Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

�+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@gI�E^Zgw?I�S?C�@?Ug@?E^KV@?C j Q�KLIJZ¡KVH�@?U$I�Q\CiHhUgE^fgCx�¡K^@�I�S?K�H2IJZ � C�U$O�C0� ��j @BH\K^Ug@.>�¯�@I\S?C6U$I\SBC0Q�S j @B�¤w j H�HhU[Ug@ j H�Ug@?C�C0� ��j @B�?H ® ª «���KLI�S*Q\CiH � CxW I�I\U � w+Ug@?EVZ I�S?CE^Us��CxHhI'UDQ��NC0Q�W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@ ® ª1K�H'Q�C0EVC0f j @lI'KV@�� �gqg���NM?C�I�U�I\S?C2¬lM j �NQ j I\K�WTHJI�Q\MBW I\M?Q�CU$OTI\S?K�H�C0� � Q\CiH\H\KVUD@.>���H�@?C0I;Q�CxH\M?E^I%UD@?C� �@B�?H j �+CxE^E^ce�?C  B@?Ci��E^KV@?C j Q�Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@6OmUgQI\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E.© � « >

RTS?C�W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@½© � $ <« Ug@BW C j A j K^@�KVEVE^MBHhI\Q j I�CxH%I\S?C¡Q�C0E j I\KVUD@½��C0IJ�+CxC0@¾I�S?C�lceUD@BE^Z�¯1X~v j @B��I�S?C�HJI j @B� j Q�� ��k jD�?� Q�U j W�S.>¤FG@�I\S?C­�[ceUD@?EVZ�EVKVy�K^I�I�S?C¡¯1X~vW UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�?H�I\U j y�K^@BK^y�KV° j I�K^Ug@�U$O~I�S?C���k¦C0@BC0Q�ADZ�C � � Q�CxH�H\K^Ug@�M?@B�?C0QYI�S?C�HhMB�NcHhK��NK j Q�Z�W0UD@B�NK^I\KVUD@�I\S j I+I�S?C�UgQ\�BKLI j E�H~H j I\K�HhOmZ;I�S?C�¹�´­Cx¬lM j I�K^Ug@BH1�ÁH\C0C1´NCxWuI�K^Ug@�²N> ²D� >RTS?CT¯1X+v¿C0@?CxQ\AgZ�K�H�I\S[MBH�HhEVK^AgSlI\EVZ�S?KVADSBC0QÀI\S j @YI\S?C ��k¡f j EVM?Cgwi��SBKVW�S�Q�CxH\M?E^I�H.OmQ\Ugyj OmQ\CxC­y�K^@?KVy�K^° j I�K^Ug@�U$OTI\S?C�H j y�C�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�C � � Q�CxH�H\K^Ug@.>.RTS?C��NK^µ¶C0Q�C0@BW0C���C0IJ�+CxC0@I\S?C+IJ�+U�C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH�W j @���C+Cxf j EVM j I�Cx��UgQ��?C0Q��[Z�UDQ��NCxQxwxMBHhKV@?A�I\S?CT�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C���C0IJ�+CxC0@I\S?C ��k j @B��I\S?C��[c£Ug@?EVZ6¯1X~v � j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @ j H � CxQhI�M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@.>¤R�U¡E^Us��CxHhI�UgQ��?C0QI\S?K�H � Q\UNW0Cx�NM?Q�C%EVC j �?H�I\U�I\S?C�C0@BC0Q�ADZ�� �lqD�u>¤RTS?K�H1C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@�KVH j EV� j Z[H�@?C0A j I�K^fgCDwW UD@�HhK�HJI�C0@lI���KLI�S¡I\S?CYO j WuITI\S j I�I\SBC���k½C0@?CxQ\AgZ­y%MBHhI2��CY��C0EVUs�¦I\S?C��[ceUD@?EVZ¡¯1X~vf j E^MBCD>�¯�@�I\S?C�U$I\SBC0Q%S j @B�¤w�K^O2UD@?C�C � j y�KV@?CxH�� �gqg�Y¬lM j @lI�KLI j I\KVfDCxE^Zgw�Ug@?C�MBH\M j EVEVZ B@B�?H�K^I�I\U���CYQ j I\S?CxQ2Hhy j E^E��¢HhCxC%´[CxW I\KVUD@BH�ol�u>

��H j EVQ\C j �NZ�C0y � S j H\K^°xCx�¤wN© � �« K�H��+CxE^E^ce�?C  B@?Ci� j H�H\U[UD@ j H ® ª KVH�][@?Us��@.>[RTS[MBHI\S?C� BQ�HJI�HhI\C � U$O j H\C0E^OÁW Ug@BH\KVHhI\Cx@gI jD�?� EVKVW j I\KVUD@6U$O����g²g��K�H�I\S?C­H\UDEVMNI\KVUD@�U$O~I\S?C��[cUD@?EVZ6¯1X~v Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@ � �gpg�2OmUDQ1ADKVfDCx@�UDQ��?K^I j EVHx>¤¯�@�W C ® ª KVH j f j KVE j �?EVCDw�KLIYQ�C0y j KV@BHI\U­C0f j E^M j I\C

® � « ������� 3 © � �« § � / 7 � / 7 ® ª»¨3 0 ����� � � ���$�

�2Us� W j @ I\S?K�H���C��NUg@?C '6¯�O�W UgM?Q�H\CDw�I�S?C¡OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E2�?C0Q�K^f j I�K^fgC�UDO1© D ' « ��K^I\SQ\CiH � CxW I2I\U 0 W j @���C%S j @B�NEVCx� j H2KV@�=~¬�>��¢²N�»�uw j H�I�S?KVH�I\CxQ\y·�NU[CxH�@?UDI��NC � C0@���UD@® ª >gRTS?C�H j y�CTKVHI�Q\MBCTOmUDQI\SBC\� /ic j @��R� /xcG�NC � C0@��NC0@BW0C�U$O¤© � $ <« >gRTS?C2HhMB�BHhCi¬lM?C0@lI�NKVH�W M�H\H\K^Ug@�I�S[MBHTOmUNW MBH\CxHTUg@�I�S?C ® ª ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@BW CYUDO© � $ <« >

¯�@?C�HhI j Q\I�H��lZ�Q�C j EVKV°0KV@?A�I\S j I%I�S?C�C � � EVK�W K^I ® ª ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@BW C�U$O2© � $ <« K�H�@BU$IOmM?@B� j y�Cx@lI j EVEVZ½�NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@gI�OmQ�UDy I�S?C � / c j @B� � / ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@BW Cg>+¯�@?C¡I\S[MBH�S j H;I\UK^@BW0E^M��NC j OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E.�NC0Q�KVf j I\KVfDC���KLI�S�Q�CxH � CiWuI+I\U;I\S?K�H j �?�?KLI�K^Ug@ j E¶f j Q�K j �?EVCDwl��S?C0@C0EVK^y�KV@ j I�K^@?A�I\S?C;UDQ�K^AgK^@ j E.�NC0Q�KVf j I\KVfDC 3 H 3 0 flK j I\SBC;W�S j K^@�Q�M?EVC�� j H�K^@ �¢²N�»�h� >�RTS?K�HE^C j �?H�I�U j @ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@ j E.W Ug@lI\Q�K^�?M?I\KVUD@�I\U�I\S?CYKV@?S?Ugy�UDADCx@?C0K^IJZ��£² �g� w

� � « ������� ' ) + , . 3 ® ª ��� . �3 ®�� ����� 3 © � $ <«3 ® ªN��� . � � � �,�g�

RTS?C� BQ�HJI¡K^@BADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lIxw�I\S?C�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E��NCxQ\KVf j I\KVfDC�UDO ® ª���K^I\S Q\CiH � CxW I�I\U ®�� w+K�Hj W0W0CxH�HhKV�?EVC�f[K j I\SBC��[ceUD@?EVZ�¯1X+v Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@.>�FeO�Ug@?C¡�?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI\K j I�CxH�=~¬�>�� �Dpl����K^I\SQ\CiH � CxW I�I�U ®�� j @B�¡KVH\UDE j I�CxH+I\SBC��NCxH\K^Q�Cx�¡�NCxQ\KVf j I\KVfDC�Ug@?C�C0@B�?H2M � ��KLI�S

3 ® ª?��� �3 ®�� ��� ± � � ' )T+W, + B ±� ��� 7 � + � � 3 ~ªN��� + �3 ®�� ��� ± � � ' )T+W, � 3 � ��� + 7 � � �3 ®�� ��� ± � ® ª ��� � � � �%� �,�g�

Page 41: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � `RTS?C�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E��?C0Q�K^f j I�K^fgC;UDO ~ª���KLI�S�Q\CiH � CxW I�I�U�I�S?C­¹�´ � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�W j @ j A j K^@��CYUg�NI j K^@?Ci���[Z�MBHhC�UDOÀI�S?C�W�S j KV@¡Q\M?EVCDw

3 ~ª[��� + �3 ®�� ��� ± � � � 5 / ' ) + , � � ��U/ ��� ± ��� /N��� ± 7 � � �Q3 �ª?��� + �3 ��U/ ��� � � � � � � � �� 5 / 1 � /?��� ± � 1 � ~ª?��� + �

� � / � � �gpg�

RTS?C¡H\CxW0UD@B�¾@?C0� C0� � Q\CiH\H\KVUD@�KV@¦� �,�g�%KVH;I�S?C¡�?C0Q�K^f j I�K^fgC�UDO2I\S?C¡EVK^@?C j Q�Q\CiH � UD@�HhCOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@¾��K^I\S�Q�CxH � CiWuI�I�U�I\S?C¡¹�´ � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E¢>�d�H\K^@BA�I\S?C��NC  B@BKLI�K^Ug@ �¢²Dog�1U$O�I�S?CE^KV@?C j Q�¹�´�Q�CxH � UD@BH\C~OmMB@BWuI�K^[email protected]$UD@BC�W j @�Q\Cx��Q\K^I\C�I\SBKVH'¬lM j @gI�KLIJZ j HÀI\S?C2H\CxW0UD@B�%OmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j E.�NC0Q�K^f j I\KVfDC�U$O 0 ��K^I\S�Q\CiH � CxW I�I\U ® � wNK£> Cg>NI\SBC�¬gM j �NQ j I�KVW�Q\CiH � UD@�HhC�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@U$O�I\S?C�¹�´�HhZNHhI\Cxy¡w

3 � ��� + 7 � � �3 ®�� ��� ± � � 3 0 ��� + �3 ®�� ��� � � 3 ®�� ��� ± � � � �B�i�

RTS?KVH�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@�W j @¡��CYCxf j EVM j I�Cx��K^@¡I\SBC�H j y�C1O j H\S?KVUD@ j H � �¢W UDy �Bj Q\C�§ r��i¨m�u>?��H3 © � $ <« H 3 ® ª W j @���C�I j ]DCx@��?K^Q�CxW I\EVZDw j EVE�KV@?ADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�H�U$O���� �g� j Q�CY]l@BUs��@.w�H\U­I\S j I® � �« W j @¡��C�W j E�W MBE j I\Cx�.>

FG@ � Q\KV@BW K � EVCDwgUD@?C2W0UDM?E���@?Us�½I�M?Q�@�I\UYI�S?C�I\SBK^Q���UDQ��NC0Q'I�C0Q�y­H0>DRTSBCTI\S?KVQ���UgQ��?C0QOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E2�?C � C0@B�?H�@?UDI­UD@?EVZ�UD@ ® ª w'�BMNI j E�HhU6UD@ ® � �« > �2Us��C0fgC0Q ® � �« K�H��+CxE^E^c�NC  B@BCx� �[Z½@?Us�Yw+HhU�I�S j I j EVH\U�© � +�« KVH��+CxE^E^ce�?C  B@?Ci�¤>~v�UgQ\CxUsfDCxQxw�OmUDEVEVUs��K^@?A�I�S?CQ\UgMNI\C�H\]DC0I�W�S?Ci� j ��UsfDC�I�S?C6W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?A�I�S?KVQ��¸UgQ��?C0Q � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�W j @ j E�HhU���CS j @B�?E^Ci�¤>�RTS?C�H�W�S?Cxy�C � Q\CiHhCx@gI�Cx�6S?C0Q�C�I\S[MBH%CxHhI j �?E^K�H\S?CxH j Q�CxW0M?Q�H\KVfDC � Q�U[W0Cx�NMBQ\COmUDQ2W j EVW0M?E j I\KV@?A­© ª « j @B��I\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��NK^@BA ® ª « UgQ��?C0QT�[Z�UDQ��NC0Q�KV@ � >

¯�@�I\SBC­U$I\SBC0Q�S j @��¤w¤KLI�K�H�UD�[f[KVUDMBH�I\S j I�I\S?K�H j$�B� Q\U j W�S�H\U[UD@?CxQ�UDQ�E j I\CxQY��K^EVE��CiW UDy�C�C �?W0CxH�HhKVfDCxE^Z¾W0M?y%��C0Q�HhUgy�CD>'FG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@�w'I\S?CxQ\C j Q\C�¬lM?KLI�C j @lMBy%��C0Q­U$OHhZNHhI\C0y­H�OmUgQ���S?K�W�S � C0Q\I\MBQ\� j I\KVUD@;I\S?CxUDQ�ZYO j KVE�H0w$y�UlHJI�@?UDI j �?E^Z%y�C0I j EVHx>$FG@�I\S?C�@?C �[IHJI�C � UD@?C;I\S[MBH�S j H�I\U�W Ug@BHhK��NCxQ1C0�[I\C0@�HhKVUD@BH1UDO�© � �« ��SBKVW�S j EVE^Us�aI�S?C�I\Q�C j I\y�C0@lIU$Oy�C0I j E^EVKVW�H\ZNHJI�C0y­H0>

� ��� � +���!#%���*�!#% * � %�� # * !(' *��'#��� ��"(!�# +�� * !("&�� " !#'(* � � �#" %�� " �$�#��* � � " +�� * ! � � � � RTS?C�y�UgHhI�HhI\Q j KVADSlIhOmUgQ\� j Q�� jD� c� Q\U j W�S�I�U;AgU%��C0ZDUg@B�­I�S?C�HhCiW UD@��­UDQ��NC0Q+OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E¶KVH j Q�CxH\M?y�y j I�K^Ug@�U$O�W C0Q\I j K^@�NK j ADQ j y�y j I�KVW6W E j H�HhCiH�UDO;¹�´ � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I\KVUD@*I�S?C0UgQ\Zg>T´[I j Q\I\KV@?A OmQ\Ugy I\S?C�C � j WuIQ\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI j I�K^Ug@�� � �D��U$O�©Tª «»w?UD@BC%W UgM?EV�.wNOmUDQ2C0� j y � EVCDwBQ�CxH\M?y I\S?C�Q�KV@?A��NK j ADQ j y­H§L���?w ²$ps¨��mQ j @��NUDy � S j H\C jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�K^Ug@ ¥ �2X¤��� w¤��S?KVW�S j Q�C%][@?Us��@�I\U���C;I�S?Cy�UlHJI�KVy � UgQhI j @lI�W E j H�H+OmUDQTI\SBC��NCxH�W Q�K � I\KVUD@¡U$Oy�C0I j EVHxw

©�� ' 9ª « � �²�5 � ±

�0 ' ) � ) � . K2K�K ' ) 0 ) 0 . 3 � � ± � � 3 � � ±� � . ± �1 � ± � � . ± 1 � �h� . 7 ²D� K2K2K

� � 3 ��� � � . �1 � � � . 1 � � 0 .A7 �i� 7 � �l²D�

Page 42: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

��KLI�S � �h� 7 ²g����C0KV@?A�ADKVfDCx@��lZ�=~¬�>��mrlog�u> 2U$I�C�I�S j I%K^I;K�H�@BU$I�I�Q\KVf[K j E'I\U�K��NCx@gI�KLOmZj$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@BH+E^KV]DC1I�S?C �2X¤� KV@�I�S?C � Q�CxH\C0@lI2W UD@lI�C �[Ixw j HTK^@�� �,�$�~I\SBC�HJI j @B� j Q���NK j ADQ j y�y j I�KVWTW Ug@lI\Q�K^�?M?I\KVUD@BH j Q\CTKV@gI�C0Q\IJ��K^@BCx����KLI�S­�NK j ADQ j y­H'�NC � Cx@B�NKV@?AYUD@ ® ª «»>RTS?C�E^Us��CxHhI�UDQ��NC0Q�Q�K^@?A��NK j AgQ j y HJI�MB�NKVCx��K^@*´[CiWuI�K^Ug@ r�> ²6K�H�I\S?C�y�UgHhI­UD�[f[K^UgMBHC � j y � EVCD>'�+UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@BH%HhKVy�K^E j QYI�U�© � $ <« j Q\C�OmUgM?@B��I�U j EVE~UgQ��NCxQ�Hx>.FeI%K�HYI�S[MBH@?U$I�W EVC j Q���������������S j I�K^I�y�C j @BH1I�U¡Q�CxHhI\Q�K�WuIY© � ' 9ª « I�U¡I\S?C­¹�´�Q\KV@?A��NK j ADQ j y­HUD@?EVZD> ��Us�+CxfDC0QiwgI\S?CY¬lM j @lI�KLI j I\KVfDCY�NUgy�K^@ j @BW C1U$OÀI\S?C�H\CxW0UD@B��UDQ��NC0QTQ�K^@BA��NK j AgQ j yUsfDC0Q'© � $ <« H\C0C0y­H�I�UYE^CxADK^I\KVy�KV°0C�I�S?KVH jD�?� Q�U j W�S.>»FeI~HhCxC0y­H��+UgQhI�Sl��SBK^EVC�I\U�y�C0@lI\KVUD@I\S j Ixw�OmUDQ�@BUD@Ncey�C I j E^EVK�W�HhZNHhI\Cxy�Hxw?I�S?C;H\CxW0UD@B�¡UgQ��NCxQ2C �?W�S j @?ADC��?K j ADQ j y KV@BW0E^MB�?Cx�K^@�� �l²D��W j @���C��NKVQ\CiWuI�E^Z j �?�NCi��I�U�� �l²D�u>

� ! +�����"# +�� * ! %�+ ����! 4&+ � � ! +��,��� * � " +�� * ! ��� � � RTS?C�C0f j E^M j I\KVUD@�UDOC0� � Q\CiH\H\KVUD@BHE^KV]DC%���g²g� j @B�.wgKV@ �Bj Q\I\K�W MBE j Qxw$K^I�H��NCxQ\KVf j I\KVfDCiH'K�H+¬lM?K^I\C�W�S j EVE^Cx@?ADKV@?AB>N�+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@lI\EVZDwUD@?C�y�K^AgSgI j H\]���S?C I�S?C0Q�K^I1K�H � UlH\H\KV�?E^C%I\U j WxW UDMB@gI�OmUDQ1I\SBC;S?KVADSBC0Q1UDQ��NC0Q�W Ug@gI�Q\K^c�?MNI\KVUD@�H+KV@ j y�UDQ�C2C 2�W KVC0@lIT� j Z'�RTS?K�H+K�H~I\S?C1� j H\K�W2K��NC j ��CxS?KV@B�­I�S?C�KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@HJI�Q\Cx@?A$I�S%KV@gI�C0Q � UgE j I\KVUD@¡�mFh´[Fh��§ ²N� ¨ewi��S?KVW�S�y j ]gCxH j @ j IhI�C0y � II\U1Q\CiW j HJI�I\S?CTS?KVADSBC0QUDQ��NC0QTI�C0Q�y�H2K^@¡I\SBCYOmUDQ�y UDO j @¡C0� � E^K�W K^I��NCx@BH\KLIJZ�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£>BRTS?C�HhI j QhI�K^@BA � UgK^@lIOmUDQ�I\S?C��NCxQ\KVf j I�K^Ug@¾U$O�I\S?C�Fh´[F�K�H;I\S?C j �NK j � j I�KVW¡W Ug@?@?CiWuI\KVUD@�w���SBKVW�S y j ]DCiH%I�S?CI\Q j @BH\KLI�K^Ug@%OmQ�UDy I\S?C�@BUD@NceK^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^@BA�¹�´�H\ZNHJI�C0yaI�U�I\S?C�OmMBE^EVZ%KV@lI\C0Q j W I\KV@?AYHhZNHhI\CxyK^@�H\MBW�S j � j Z%I\S j I~I\SBC��NCx@BHhK^IJZ�Q\Cxy j KV@BH'I�S?C�H j y�C j E^E j EVUD@?AYI�S?C�� j Z�§ rgoBw og³?w o$rD¨£>RTS?C1W0UDM � E^KV@?A;W0UD@BHhI j @lI+KV@gI�C0AgQ j I\KVUD@­I�Q\K�W�]�I\S?Cx@�EVC j �BH~I�U j OmUDQ�y%M?E j%j @ j EVUDAgUDMBH'I\U� �[�»�uw

©Tª «G� ' ±� ) � ���N§ 0 ¨ 7 � �g³g�

��KLI�S� � � § 0 ¨C� ��" � ���N�0§ 0 ¨ 1 �� 1 " � ���?� § 0 ¨ ! � © $ § 0 ¨T� � �Drl�

RTS?C�� j H\KVW�KV�NC j UDO2I\S?C¡Fh´[FYK�H;I\U�UD�NI j KV@ ����KV@¾I�S?C¡K^@lI\CxQ\CiHJI�K^@BA�Q\CxADKVy�C � ���OmQ\Ugy j @�KV@lI\C0Q � UDE j I\KVUD@���C0IJ�+CxC0@�I�S?C��+C j ]���� > > �i� j @B��I\S?C�HhI\Q�UD@?A�������� �i�K^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^Ug@YE^KVy�KLIi>»RTSBC�OmUDQ�y�C0QÀE^KVy�KLIKVHÀ��C0EVELce][@?Us��@Y�[Z1@BUs� %xk?UgQÀ��C j ]�KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@UD@?C�W j @%C0� ��j @B��©Tª «�KV@ � Us��C0Q�HÀUDOBI�S?C�W UDM � E^KV@?AYW Ug@BHhI j @lI����S?K�W�S j MNI\Ugy j I\K�W j E^EVZZlKVC0E��?H j W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?A;C � �Bj @BHhKVUD@�OmUDQ � � w

©Tª «G� ' ±� ) � � ©Tª � �5

� � ���� B ± © � � «

� � � �lqD�

RTS?CYE^Us��CxHhI�IJ�+U�UDQ��NCxQ�H�U$O ��� j Q�C1I\S[MBH2�NC0I\CxQ\y�KV@?Cx���[Z�©Tª j @B�¡© � �« >RTS?C�HhI\Q�UD@?A%K^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^Ug@�E^KVy�KLITQ�Cx¬lM?KVQ\CiH j @?C0�*W0UD@BW0C � Ii>���Us�+CxfDC0Qiw$OmUgQ�� = �

I\S?C�C0EVCxW I\Q�UgHhI j I\K�W�OmUgQ�W0CxH�W Ugy � E^C0I\C0EVZ½�NUgy�K^@ j I\C¡UsfDCxQ�][KV@?C I�KVW¡C0µ�CiWuI�Hxw�H\U�I�S j I j��� � % Ú��gÛ��~ËLÌ2ÙgÉxÈ2ËLÊgÆ�ÙsÈJËÍÖuÎ0Ï ��Ë ÈJÅ�ÈJÅgÆ��xÐJÉ-�lÙ[Ê�ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆYËÍÙsÈGÐJÉ$ÊT�gÖ�ÆuÊ�ËÍÙ �$Æ�Ö�ÈJËÍÉiÙ � Ü `cb ÎxÌ�ÈJÅlÆÒNÆ�ÐGÈ��DÐ��[Î0ÈJËÍÉxÙ�ËÍÙ�ÈJÅlÆTÎiÊgËLÎW�[Î0ÈJËÍÖ2Ö�ÉxÙlÙlÆ�Ö�ÈJËÍÉiÙ�ËÍÌ~ÊgË Õ?Æ�ÐJÆ�ÙsÈ�Z^ÐJÉiÇ Ú : �xÛ\Ü

Page 43: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � HhKVy � E^C�y�UN�NC0E�HhZNHhI\Cxy ����� � ������� ���� � ����� � � ��� � � ������� ������ ��K�H�H\M 2�W KVC0@lI¡I\UC �[I\Q j W I ����§ olq»¨e>sFG@�I\S?K�H'� j Z�UD@?CT �@B�?H'I�S?C�EVC j �?K^@?A�IJ��U�UDQ��NC0Q�HU$O�I\SBC2C � �Bj @BHhKVUD@U$O ����KV@ � Us��C0Q�H�U$OT�1H�� �¶w

EVKVy� ��� � � § 0 ¨ � � � § 0 ¨ � � .� § 0 ¨ � B ± F � �-�W� 7 � �gog�

��KLI�S

� � § 0 ¨E� ' ) + , � � 0 � F + ��� � � 0 � 0 � F +�

� ���$�

� .� § 0 ¨E� ' )+-, ��� 0 + F � - � � 0 � 0 F ��

� �,�g�

��OmUDQ2I\S?CYf j EVM?CiHTU$O�I\S?C�W0UlC;2�W KVC0@lI�H � � -·H\C0C­§ ²?� ¨m�u>?FG@lI�C0Q � UgE j I\KVUD@¡��C0IJ�+CxC0@�© ª w© � �« Ug@�I�S?CYUD@?C�S j @B� j @B� � � w � .� Ug@�I�S?CYU$I�S?C0Q�S j @B��I\S?Cx@�E^C j �?H�I�U

© � � �ª « � � � � ²"!# � �J� � #%� ± F � � � �¡E^@%$ �J� � #;� ± F � �� � � & 7 � �,�g�

��KLI�S�I�S?C j �B�?Q\Cxf[K j I\KVUD@BH! �('*) + # �,' ) + � � �('*) + +' � � rg© � « ) � � .� + � � �� ©�ª9� �J�xpgpg�

=~¬[H0>�� �,�g� wV�h�xpDpl�THhSBUDM?E�����C%M?@B�?C0Q�HJI�UlUN� j H j @�C µ¶CxW I\KVfDC%Q�CxH\M?y�y j I�K^Ug@�U$O'I�S?C;¹�´� CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@�HhCxQ\KVCxHx>¶RTS?C�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@ �Bj QhI�U$O�© � � �ª « K�H�Ug�NI j K^@BCx���[Z�H\M?�NI�Q j WuI\KVUD@U$O�I\S?CYC0� j WuI2© ª OmQ\Ugy � �,�g�u>

- . � �/� � � � �1�J�B�\� �� �¾�0/1�G}� �� �s� � � ��|�� ��|+} ���2� � '|�� ����¶���B��� �� �}?�J�+|�2��|���}?�J�+| �� �

b1K^fgC0@�I\SBC�W Ugy � E^C0�[K^IJZ%UDO¶I\S?C� �Q�HhIhc � Q�K^@BW0K � E^CiH'K^y � EVK�W K^I+W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@%OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�H�U$O´[CxW I\KVUD@�rBw�UD@BC�KVH j MNI�UDy j I�KVW j EVE^Z6E^Ci��I\U�E^U[UD]6OmUDQ;y�UDQ�C�HhKVy � E^C j @B��I�S[MBH%y�UgQ\CC 2�W KVC0@lI1H\C0y�K^c£Cxy � K^Q�K�W j E j E^I\CxQ\@ j I\KVfDCiH0>�RT�+U�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�U$O'I\SBKVH�IJZ � C;S j fDC%��CxC0@HhM?AgADCiHJI�Cx��OmUDQ�MBH\C���KLI�S�I�S?C;¯1X~v¾>

� ��� � ����� � ��! +�����"# +�� * !�#,*&���� # +���' � � �

RTS?C~ �Q�HhI�UDO?I\SBCxH\C~OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�HÀK�HÀI\S?C�H\C0E^O�c£KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@;W UDQ�Q�CxWuI�Cx��ºÀn2� �¢´[F\�~cGº�n2�1�§ ²g²»¨e>xFeI�S j HÀ��CxC0@;C0y � S j HhKV°0Ci� j W0UDM � EVC~UDO?I\KVy�CxHÀ@?Us��I\S j I�I\S?CTHhCxELO�ceKV@gI�C0Q j W I\KVUD@YC0Q\cQ\UgQ�UDO�I�S?C�º�n2� j @B�;I\S?C2bYb��%wDK�H j y j �JUDQ'HhUgM?Q�W C�U$O � Q\Ug�?EVC0y­H0>sFeI'K�HI\S[MBH�I�C0y � I\cK^@?A�I�U¡I\Q�Z�I\U�CxE^KVy�K^@ j I\C�I�S?KVH%HhCxELO�ceK^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^Ug@6KV@ j HhCxy�K^ceC0y � KVQ\K�W j EOmUDQ�y¡w¤��SBKVW�S

Page 44: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

�&� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

KVH�I\SBC;y j KV@�K��NC j ��C0S?KV@B��I\S?C­´[F\�~cGº�n2�%>¤RTS?C­HJI j Q\I\KV@?A � UDKV@lI�OmUgQ�I�S?C�´[F\�~ceºÀn2�KVH+I\SBC�H � KV@NcG�NC0@BH\K^IJZ��NC � C0@B�?C0@lI�fDC0Q�H\K^Ug@�U$O.I�S?CYHJI j @B� j Q���º�n2�%w?© 687D9ª « § 0 4 7 0 5x¨£>NFG@W UD@lI�Q j HJIYI�U�I\S?C�C � j W I;©Tª «s§ 0 4 7 0 5 ¨�I\S?K�H�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E��NU[CxH�@BU$I%Q�Cx�NM�W C­I�U j�� M?Q�C�+UDM?EVUDy;��H\C0E^O�c£KV@lI\C0Q j W I\KVUD@�KV@lI\CxADQ j E�KLO�Ug@?EVZ­UD@?C�HhKV@?AgE^C �Bj Q\I\K�W EVC���K^I\S�H � K^@�M ��j @B��NC0@BH\K^IJZ 0 4 � 1 � ± , 4[����� 1 �K�H � Q�CxH\C0@lIxw

© 6&7�9ª « § 0 4 7 p$¨��� � � ² ' ) + ,�) + , . 1 � ± , 4N����� 1 1 � ± , 4[��� . � 1 1 � � � . 1 � ©������� �ª « § 1 � ± , 4 1 7 ps¨T�+�J�xpB�i�

FG@ j y j @[Zlc ��j Q\I\K�W EVC�H\ZNHJI�C0yaI�S?KVH'H\C0E^O�ceK^@lI\CxQ j WuI�K^Ug@%C0Q�Q�UDQ�KVH � Q\CiHhCx@gI�OmUDQ j E^E ��j Q\I\K�W EVCxHK^@%I\S?C�HhZNHhI\C0y�>D¯�@?C~I\S[MBHÀC0EVK^y�KV@ j I�CxH�I\S?CTHhCxELO�ceKV@gI�C0Q j W I\KVUD@�W Ugy � Ug@?C0@lI � � �"� � ���� ����lZ�C0� � E^K�W K^ITH\M?�NI�Q j WuI�K^Ug@­U$O¤I\SBC�CxQ\Q�UD@?CxUDMBH'I\C0Q�y­H�OmUgQ~I�S?C1K^@B�?K^f[K��NM j E¶¹�´­HhI j I\CxH+U$O��UDI\S�H � K^@BHxw

© � �� B 687D9ª « � © 687D9ª « § 0 4 7 0 50¨ � 5 / , . - / , . ��© $ � 1 � / , . 1 � � © 687D9ª « � 1 � / , . 1 S7 p � �� © 687D9ª « § 0 4 7 0 50¨ � 5 / , . - / , .N© 687D9ª « � 1 � / , . 1 S7 p �� �

² 5 / , . - / , . '*)+V,�)+V,�. 1 � / , ..����� 1 1 � / , ..��� . � 1 1 � � � . 1 � �J�xpl²D�

�+Z�W UD@�HJI�Q\MBW I\[email protected]?© � �� B 687�9ª « H j I\K�HJ BCiH�=~¬�>��J�xpB�i� >RTS?C2HJI j @B� j Q��;H�W�S?C0y�CTOmUgQ'I\S?C jD�?� EVKVW j I�K^Ug@�UDO�I�S?K�H'OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E?KVy � E^KVCxHI�S?C2MBH\C

U$O�UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lI�¹�UgS?@NcJ´[S j y � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E�H;%�� H\C �Bj Q j I\C�¹�´�Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@�S j H2I\U��CTHhUgE^fgCx�1OmUgQ�C j W�S�KV@B�NKVflK��NM j El¹�´�HJI j I\Cg>iRTSBKVH � Q�U[W0Cx�NMBQ\C�KV@%AgC0@?CxQ j EDEVC j �?H¤I�U�@?Ug@NcUDQ\I\S?UgADUD@ j E¤¹�´�UDQ��?KLI j E�H0w?H\U�I\S j I j @ ��� �"� � ���� ���¤UDQ\I\SBUDADUg@ j EVKV° j I�K^Ug@�K�H�Q\Ci¬lM?K^Q�Cx�§ ogos¨e>���Us�+CxfDC0Qiw0K^IS j HÀ��CxC0@�Q\C j EVK^°xCx�YfgC0Q�Z�C j Q�E^Z­§ o��»¨gI�S j I�I\S?C�´[F\�~cGº�n2��H\S?UDM?E��Y��Cj$�?� EVKVCx����K^I\S?KV@�I�S?C�OmQ j y�C0��UDQ�]�UDO'I\S?C­¯1X~v�>�k?UgQ j @[Z¡UDQ��?K^I j E^cG�NC � C0@B�?C0@lI2OmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j EDI�S?CT¯1X+v � Q�U[�?MBW CiH¤I\SBC�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?A2¹�´[c¢IJZ � C~y%MBELI�K � EVK�W j I�K^fgC � U$I�C0@lI\K j E£w��S?KVW�S j MNI\Ugy j I\K�W j E^EVZ j fDUgKV�?H+I�S?C � Q�UD�?EVC0y UDO�@BUD@NceUDQ\I\S?UgADUg@ j EVKLIJZg>

¯�@YI\S?C�U$I�S?C0QS j @B�¤w»MBH\C~UDO?I\S?C2¯1X~v �NU[CxH�@?U$IQ�CxH\UDEVfDC'I�S?C+MB@?KLI j Q�KLIJZ � Q�UD�BE^Cxy��S?KVW�S�K�H�KV@?S?C0Q�C0@lI2KV@�I\S?K�HTOmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E+§ o �s �$ps¨�%lFeOUD@BC � CxQhOmUgQ\y­H j M?@?K^I j Q\Z�I\Q j @BHhcOmUDQ�y j I\KVUD@ j y�UD@?A�I\SBC2¹�´�UgQ\�?K^I j EVHxwiI\S?C�KV@B�NKVf[KV�?M j ENUgQ\�?K^I j EN�NC0@BH\K^I\KVCxH'��KVE^E?W�S j @?AgCDwC0fDCx@�K^O�I\S?C�I�Q j @BHJOmUgQ\y j I\KVUD@�Ug@?EVZ�W UgM � EVCxH��NCxADCx@?C0Q j I�C1¹�´�HJI j I�CxHx>��+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@lI\EVZDwj E�HhU1I\SBC�f j E^MBC�UDO¶© � �� B 687�9ª « W�S j @?AgCxHx>s�2@ j �B�NKLI�K^Ug@ j E � Q\CiH\W0Q\K � I\KVUD@;��S?K�W�S��?C  B@?CiHj HhMBKLI j �?EVC2Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI j I\KVUD@�U$O¶I�S?C�¹�´�UgQ\�?K^I j EVH��m��S?K�W�S­MBH\M j EVE^Z�KVy � E^KVCxH j E^UNW j EVK^° j cI\KVUD@��TK�H2@BCxW CiH\H j Q�Z­OmUgQ � Q j W I\K�W j EÀW j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@BH�§ �[�0¨£>B`¸S?K^EVCYI�S?C%Q�CxH\M?E^I�HTOmUgQ j I�UDy­Hj Q�C�@?U$I�fDC0Q�Z�H\C0@�HhK^I\KVfDCYI�U�I�S?KVH�M?@?K^I j Q\K^IJZ � Q\Ug�?E^Cxy�wBK^I���CxW Ugy�CxH�y�UgQ\CYKVy � UgQhI j @lIK^@�C �[I\Cx@B�NCi��H\Z[HhI\Cxy­H0>¤k?UgQ1I\S j I1Q�C j HhUg@�I\S?C­´[F\�~cGº�n2�8S j H1Q j Q\CxE^Z¡��CxC0@ j$�?� E^KVCx�I\U­y�UDEVCxW0M?E^CiHY§ �D²iÂ&�»r$¨e>

� ��� � * � � � � � " ������+ +�� ��"#!$# +�� * !#" �� H\CxW Ug@B��UDQ��?K^I j ELcG�NC � C0@��NC0@lI�C0� � Q\CiH\H\K^Ug@���S?K�W�S�� j H2UDQ�KVADKV@ j EVE^Z�K^@lI�Q\UN�NMBW0Cx��KV@ j�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI2W Ug@lI\C �[ITKVH�I�S?C%�+UDEVE^C0cG´ j EVfDC I\I\K'�£�T´B�TW UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�§ ²$³$¨ %[FeI�� j H

Page 45: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � �

K^@?K^I\K j EVEVZ��NC0fgC0EVU � Cx��OmUDQ�MBH\C���KLI�S�I�S?C � j Q\I\Q�C0C0cekBUNW�]�H�W�S?Cxy�Cg>?RTS?CYHJI j Q\I\KV@?A � UgK^@lIOmUDQ�I�S?C��NCxQ\KVf j I�K^Ug@­U$O¶I\S?CY�T´;OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E�K�H j @ j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@;OmUDQ�I�S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\Ci�� j fgC OmM?@BW I\KVUD@

" ��� ± / ± 7 �-�W� � � / � � >.RTS?C j @�H j I\°�OmUDQ " ��� ± / ± 7 �W�W�I� � / � ��W Ug@BHhK�HhI�HU$O j;� Q\UN�NMBW I�U$O�I\S?C ��k ´[E j I�C0Q2�NC0I\C0Q�y�K^@ j @lI j @B��_ j HhI\Q�Us� O j WuI�UDQ�H0w

" ��� ± / ± 7 �W�-� � � / � ��� � $ < ��� ± / ± 7 �-�W�I� � / � � �� � �

�£� ��� ��� � 7 � � ���G� �J�xpg³g�

�T´�I\S?Cx@½MBH\C j y�U[�?C0E+OmUDQ;I\S?C¡W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@�H � ��� � 7 � � �%��S?K�W�S½H j I\K�HJ �CxHI\S?C­CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@?c£CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@�W MBH � W UD@��NKLI�K^Ug@ j I � � � � � § �$q»¨e>.RTS?C�OmQ�C0C �Bj Q j y�C0I\CxQYK^@I\S?C2y�UN�NCxEBK�H j � �JMBHJI�Cx��I�U�I\S?C1W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@;C0@?CxQ\AgZ%UDO�I�S?C���C j I�UDy�§ ²$³$¨£>gRTS?C� B@ j EOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�Q\C j �?H

© *�« � ��� �r '*) + ,���� � r95 / . - / 0 . 1 � � / . 1 � 1 � 0 1 � 5 . 0 . � 0 . � 0 � 0 � � ' )T+-,�� 0 7 �J�xpDrl�

��KLI�S�I�S?C j �B�?Q\Cxf[K j I\KVUD@BH

� �����9�*r 0 4l����� 0 5l�����0 ����� �J�xplqD� �����\� � � ) 0 ����� B ± F + �J�xpgog�� ���¶�f� 0 ����� B � F + C � � § � � 0 ����� B ± F + ¨ ���¶� � �J�xp��$�

RTS?KVH�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EB�?C � C0@B�?H�UD@;I\S?C2H � KV@Nce�?C0@BH\KLIJZ 0 . j @���I�S?C�][K^@?C0I\K�WTC0@?CxQ\AgZYU$O¤H � K^@/w / - / 1 � � / . 1 >$FG@�I\SBC2n�kR W Ug@gI�C �[Ixw$I\S?K�H'E j IhI�C0Q~�?C � C0@B�NCx@BW C�y j ]DCxH'© ��« j @K^y � EVKVW0KLI+OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EBOmUgQ~��S?K�W�S­I\SBC�¯1X~v·S j H'I�U���C�MNI�K^EVK^°xCx�¤>[RTS?CY�T´­W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E¤S j H~I\S[MBHT��C0C0@�H\M?ADAgCxHhI\Cx� j H j  BQ�HhITW j @B�NK�� j I\C�OmUDQ�I\S?C j M?ADy�C0@lI j I\KVUD@U$O�I\S?CYC0� j WuI�C �?W�S j @?ADC�§ �sos¨e>�2Us��C0fDCxQxw�E^KV]DC�I�S?C­W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@ ��j Q\I�UDO�I\SBC­´NF\�~ceºÀn2� I\S?K�H%�T´�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E'K�H

Q j I\S?CxQ�EVUNW j E£>�FeI�H1@?UD@BE^UNW j E^K^IJZ�KVH�Q�CxHhI\Q�KVW I\Cx��I\U�I\S?C; BQ�HJI1ADQ j �NKVC0@lI�H�U$O'I�S?C­¹�´�UDQ\c�?KLI j E�H0>NFG@¡I�S?KVHTQ�CxH � CxWuI�K^I2KVHTfgC0Q�Z�HhKVy�K^E j Q�I�U;I�S?C�v�C0I j cJbYb��/§ �,�i¨e>NFG@�I�S?C�W j HhC1U$OI\S?C�v�C0I j cGbYb��/S?KVADSBC0QYADQ j �?K^Cx@gI�H1U$O�I\S?C��NCx@BH\KLIJZgw.K¢> CD>�KLI�H�º jD� E j W K j @.w j Q\C�C µ¶CxW cI\KVfDC0EVZ�KV@BW0E^MB�?Cx��KV@gI�UTI\S?C�bYb���f[K j I�S?C'][K^@?C0I\K�W'C0@BC0Q�ADZ2C0� � Q\CiH\H\K^Ug@ / - / 1 � � / . 1 >�2Us��C0fDCxQxwNKV@�W0UD@lI\Q j HhITI\U­I�S?C��T´lc£OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E¢wBI\S?C�v�C I j cJbYb��aS j H�@?U$I1ZDC0I2��CxC0@j$�?� EVKVCx�¡��KLI�S?KV@�I\S?C�¯1X+v � j E^I\SBUDM?AgS.w?KV@ � Q\KV@BW K � EVCDw�KLI�H\S?UDMBEV����C�I\Q�C j I\Cx�¡��K^I\S?KV@I\S?C�¯1X~v�� >ÀFG@ j @[Z�W j HhCgwÀ@?CxKLI�S?C0Q�I�S?C�´NF\�~ceºÀn2� @?UgQ%I�S?C��T´ j @��½v�C0I j cJbYb��OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H j Q�C�H\M 2�W KVC0@lI\EVZ­@?Ug@?E^UNW j E�I\U��NC j E���K^I\S¡�NK�H � C0Q�HhKVUD@�OmUDQ�W CxH&%[RTS?C j Q\AgMNcy�Cx@lI�ADKVfDCx@�KV@�´[CxW I\KVUD@��D> ²;OmUDQ2I\S?C�ºÀn2�aCx¬lM j E^EVZ���C0EVE jD�?� EVK^CiHTI\U�I�S?CxH\CYIJZ � CiH�U$OOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�Hx>

Page 46: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� : Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

� �¸| �� �l� ����� �¾�0/1�G}� �� �s� � � ��|�� ��|+} �6���?��� �� �}?�J�~|

� ��� � ��%&# ����(+�� * !)* ��'(��%;� ����%�� * !�� *�� # ��% �+*)%�� #,*�!#')*&��'#��� # *��������"$+���*�!��"#!$# +�� * !#" �

b1K^fgC0@¾I�S?C¡y�UDI\KVf j I\KVUD@½OmUDQ�KVy � E^K�W K^I�W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H;I\S?C� BQ�HJI­¬lM?CxHhI\KVUD@I\U���C j �?�NQ�CxH�HhCi��KVH�I\S j I;U$O��?KVH � CxQ�H\KVUD@�OmUDQ�W CiH0>À��H;@?UD@?C�U$O�I\SBC�H\C0y�KLceC0y � KVQ�KVW j EOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�U$O1´NCxWuI�K^Ug@ q6W j @ �NC j E���K^I\S½I\S?CiHhC¡EVUD@?ADc£Q j @?AgC�OmUDQ�W CiH0wÀI\S?C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�NKVH�W M�H\H\K^Ug@%OmUNW0MBHhCiH'UD@;I\SBC2HhCiW UD@��;UgQ��?C0Q'W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E�� �l²D� j H�I\S?C�y�UgHhIHhKVy � E^C� �Q�HhIhc � Q�K^@BW0K � E^CiH~OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£>

�+UD@BH\KV�?C0Q;IJ�+U6@?C0MNI�Q j E j I\Ugy­H;� j @�� �1w'HhC �Bj Q j I�Cx���[Z j H\M 2�W KVC0@lI�E^Z�E j Q�ADC�NKVHhI j @BW C ,�w�HhU6I\S j I�@?U�y�UgE^CiW M?E j Q�UDQ��?K^I j EVH j Q�C�OmUgQ\y�Ci�¤>'k?UDQ�I�S?KVH­H\ZNHJI�C0y I�S?CUsfDC0Q�E j$� ��C0IJ�+CxC0@�I\SBC j I�UDy�K�WYUDQ��?K^I j E�H � / , � W Cx@lI\C0Q�Cx��Ug@ j I�UDy·� j @B� ��� , W Cx@NcI\C0Q�Cx�¾UD@ j I�UDy �8f j @?K�HhS?CiH�C0� � UD@BC0@lI\K j EVE^Z���K^I\S¾KV@BW Q�C j HhKV@?A ,�>�RTS?C�H\M?y­H%UsfgC0Qj EVE�¹�´�HhI j I\CxH�K^@�� �g³g� j @B�¾� �lqD�TC0µ�CiWuI�K^fgC0EVZ�H � EVKLI1M � KV@lI\U�H\M?y­H2UsfgC0Q�I�S?C j I\Ugy�K�WHJI j I\CiH0w 5

��= 5

��� � 5 ��� �RTSlM�H0w$K^O¤UD@?CTI j ]gCxHI�S?C j I�UDy­H j$��j Q\Ixw$Ug@?E^Z%I\S?UlHhC�´NE j I\C0Q~K^@lI\CxADQ j E�HK^@­© � « H\M?Q\f[KVfDC��S?KVW�S¡�NU�@?U$I�EVK^@?]­UgQ\�BKLI j E�H~OmQ�UDy �?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI j I\Ugy�KVW1W Cx@gI�C0Q�H j I�I\S?CYH j y�C � UDKV@lI9�À>�+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@gI�E^Zgwx@BC0K^I\S?CxQ�© � $ <« @?UDQ�I\S?C�C �?W�S j @?ADC+W UDy � UD@?Cx@lIÀU$OB© D ' « W Ug@lI\Q�K^�?M?I\CI\U�I�S?C%KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@���C IJ��C0Cx@�I\SBC�IJ��U j I�UDy­H�OmUgQ�E j Q�ADC/,�w j H�OmUgQ�I�S?CxH\C�I�C0Q�y�H j EVEHhM?y­H+UsfDCxQ+HhI j I�CxH+y%MBHhI+��C0EVUD@BA�I\U;I\SBC1H j y�C j I\UDy�>[v�UDQ�C0UsfgC0Qiw$KV@�I\SBC1W j H\C2U$O.I�S?CQ\KV@?AY�NK j ADQ j y�w»��S?K�W�S � Q\Usf[K��NCxHÀI�S?C2�NKVQ\CiWuI�y j I�Q\K^�%C0EVC0y�Cx@gI�H'KV@�© D ' « w$C j W�S;UDO�I�S?CIJ�+U�Q�K^@?AlH�y%MBHhI2UD@?EVZ�KV@[fDUDEVfDC�HhI j I�CxH�UDOÀUg@?C�U$O�I\S?C j I\UDy­HxwNCD> AB>

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

� � >

RTS?C�W UDy � EVC I�C�Q\KV@?A��NK j ADQ j y �NCiW UDy � UgH\CxH�KV@gI�U�OmUgM?Q�I\CxQ\y­Hxw j H;OmUDQ­��U$I�S Q�K^@BAgHC0K^I\S?CxQ j I\UDy �:UDQ j I\Ugy �#W j @*��C6W�SBUgH\C0@.>TRTS?C6W0UDy;�?K^@ j I\KVUD@�H���� j @�� � �W UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�C%I�U�I�S?C j I�UDy�KVW�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxH�U$OT� j @B� ��w j H�KVH�I\SBC�W j H\C%OmUgQ© � $ <« j @B� I�S?C�C �?W�S j @?ADC�W0UDy � Ug@?C0@lI�UDO�© D ' « >�¯�@?EVZ¾I�S?C�W Ugy%�?KV@ j I\KVUD@BH­���j @B� �T��w.��S?K�W�S�Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI1I�S?C­KV@gI�C0Q j W I\KVUD@�UDO�f[KVQhI�M j E �Bj QhI�KVW0E^C0c£SBUDEVC�C0�?W K^I j I�K^Ug@BHUD@ I\SBC�IJ�+U¾W0C0@lI\CxQ�Hxw~EVC j � I\U½H\UDy�C�y�UDEVCxW0M?E j Q��?KV@B�NKV@?A¾Cx@?C0Q�ADZg>~v�UgQ\CxUsfDC0Qiw@?UU$I\SBC0Q+W0UDy � UD@?Cx@gI�UDO¶I\S?C�I\U$I j E�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E�W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\CiHI\UYI�S?C�KV@lI\CxQ j WuI\KVUD@��C0IJ�+CxC0@ I\S?C¡IJ��U j I\UDy­Hxw � Q\Usf[K��NCx�¾I\S j I�� j @B� � j Q�C¡W0E^UlHhCi�[ceH\M?�BH\S?CxE^E j I�UDy­H�ÁH\U�I\S j I;@BU6HhI j I�KVW�y%MBELI�K � UDEVC�y�UDy�Cx@gI�H j Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI��u>RTS?C¡K^@lI�C0Q j WuI�K^Ug@�C0@?CxQ\AgZ��C0IJ�+CxC0@�� j @B� � I�SlM�H�Q\Ci�NMBW0CxH�I\U

© � �« , N O " � � � 5��� / �

- � � �J� � -�/�� 5��� � �

- � � �J� � - ��� �

���1 1 ����0���

��1 1 ����� ��� � � ��� � � / � � � � � �

�J�xp,�g�

Page 47: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � �

FeO�UD@?C¡C � �Bj @B�?H��J�ip �l�YKV@ � Us�+CxQ�H;U$O%�IH , j @B�½Q\CxK^@lI�Q\UN�NMBW0CxH%I\S?C�OmQ�Cx¬lM?C0@�W Z�KV@NcI\C0AgQ j I\KVUD@�KV@?S?CxQ\Cx@gI1K^@�I\S?C�Q\KV@?A��?K j ADQ j y�wBUg@?C%Cx@B�?H�M � ��K^I\S j @�C � � Q�CxH�H\K^Ug@¾§ r$�i¨��S?KVW�S�K�HTy%MBW�S¡y�UDQ�C1O j y�K^EVK j Qiw

© � �« , N O " � � ��

, �� � ³ � �, � ' �� )��

:�� � � � � ��

� � � ��� �J�xp,�g�

�2C0Q�C� �

� � � �;�NC0@?UDI\CiH�I\S?C j I�UDy�K�W � UDE j Q�K^° j �?KVEVKLIJZ*�mOmUDQ�I\S?C�W j H\C�UDO1W EVUgH\Cx� HhMB�NcHhS?CxE^E�H��uw?Cxf j E^M j I\Ci� j I�K^y j AgK^@ j Q�Z�OmQ\Ci¬gMBC0@BW0ZDw

� �� � ��� ' ) + , ± ' ) + , + ± + �� , � ��� ± 7 � 7�� � 7 �J�D�ipg�

��S?UgH\C6� j H\KVW�KV@?ADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�KVH¡I�S?C�OmQ\Ci¬lM?C0@BW0Zlce�NC � Cx@B�NCx@gIiw�Q\C0I j Q��NCi� ¹�´ Q\CiH � UD@�HhCOmM?@BWuI�K^[email protected]

�� ��� ± 7 � 7�� �9� 5� , /

§ - ��- / ¨ ��U� ��� ± � � /B��� ± � ��U/ ��� �I� � ��� �� � � / � � � � � � �J�D�g�i�

=~¬�>V�h�xp,�g��S j HÀI\SBC2HJI j @B� j Q���OmUDQ�yaU$O�I\S?C2�NK�H � CxQ�H\K^Ug@�OmUgQ�W0CD>D¯��[flKVUDM�HhEVZ�© � �« K�H j �?EVCI\U�Q�C � Q�UN�NMBW0CTI\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI�EVUD@?ADc£Q j @BADC���CxS j f[K^UgQ � Q�U � UDQ\I\KVUD@ j E[I\U��IH , � >,��Us�+CxfDCxQxwI\S?C�C � j W I~Q\CiHhMBELI�OmUgQ�I�S?C�W U[C;2­W0K^Cx@lI

��KV@[fDUDEVfDCiH�I\S?C�OmM?EVE j I\UDy�K�W � UDE j Q�K^° j �?KVE^K^I\KVCxHxw

��S?K^EVC�I\S?C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�n1kR�c£f j Q�K j @lI%U$O��

K�H;�NC0I\CxQ\y�KV@?Cx�½�lZ�I�S?C¡¹�´ � UgE j Q\KV° j �?K^E^cKLI�K^CiH¡� j H j W0UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@BW C�U$O�H\CxW0UD@B�½UDQ��NC0Q � CxQhI�M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@¾I\SBC0UDQ�Z?�u>�´[U�w�I�S?C�@?C �[I¬gMBCxHhI\KVUD@¾K�H�S?Us� W EVUgH\C�I�S?C¡¹�´½W U[C 2�W0K^Cx@gI�H;W0UDy�C�I�U�I�S?C¡C � j W I

��'�k�KVQ�HhI­W j E^c

W M?E j I�K^Ug@BH%§ ���$¨ÀHhSBUs� I�S j I�OmUDQ2EVK^AgSlI j I�UDy­H�=+¬�>��J�ip �l�~Z[KVC0E��?H2Q�C j HhUg@ j �BE^Z j W0W0M?Q j I\CW U[C 2�W KVC0@lI�H;%BRTSBC0Z�MB@B�NC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I�CYI\S?C�OmMBE^E

���[Z��xp$cG²Dp #�>¤¯�@�I�S?C�UDI\S?CxQ2S j @��¤w

OmUDQ�S?C j flKVC0Q j I\Ugy�HTSBK^AgS?C0Q�UgQ��NCxQ2W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@���CiW Ugy�CiH�KVy � UDQ\I j @lIxw?H\U�I\S j I%�J�xp,�g�KVH2H\M?�BHhI j @lI\K j EVE^Z­UDµ�>

��IYI\S?K�H � UDKV@gIYK^I�KVH�S j H���C0Cx@�fgC0Q�KL �Cx��I\S j IYI\S?C�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E����g²D��Q�C � Q�UN�NMBW0CxHI\S?C�EVUD@BA$ceQ j @?ADC���CxS j f[K^UgQYU$O�I\S?C��NKVH � C0Q�HhKVUD@6OmUDQ�W Cgw.�?MNI%K^I%K�HY@?UDI�ZDC I%W0E^C j Q�SBUs�KLI � CxQhOmUgQ\y­H�KV@�I\SBC%KV@gI�C0Q�y�Cx�NK j I�C��m��UD@B�?K^@?A[��Q�C0AgK^y�CD>��2Us��C0fDCxQxwBK^@�UgQ��NCxQ�I\U � Q�C c�NKVW I%I�S?C�Cx¬lM?KVEVK^�?Q�KVM?y:AgC0Ugy�C0I\Q�Z�UDO j f j @¾�NC0Q;` jgj E�HY��UD@B��y�UDEVCxW0M?EVCDw�K^I;K�H�@BU$I�JMBHJITHhM2­W0K^Cx@lI~I\U;S j fDCTI�S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI j HhZ[y � I�U$I\K�WY�IH , � c j IhI�Q j WuI�K^[email protected]�?M?I+Q j I\SBC0Q�I�S?CW UDy � EVC I�CYC0@?CxQ\AgZ�HhMBQhO j W C�y%MBHhI2��C j W0W0M?Q j I\Cg>?RTS?K�H � UgK^@lI2K�H�K^@[fgCxHhI\KVA j I�Cx��K^@�k�K^ADcM?Q\C­�xrBw?KV@���S?K�W�S¡I\S?C;C0@?CxQ\AgZ�H\M?QhO j W C��¢© �l�TUDOI\S?C���C%�NKVy�C0Q�K�H2H\S?Us��@�§ ²$r$¨e>&�2C KVH j��Bj Q\I\K�W MBE j Q\EVZ�W Q�KLI�KVW j E'H\Z[HhI\Cxy�w¤��S?KVW�S�y j @?K^OmCxHhI�H�K^I�H\C0E^O+KV@6I\S?C­H�W j EVC�MBH\Cx��OmUgQkÀKVADMBQ\C��0r %NFeI2KVHTy�C"+%w?Q j I�S?C0Q�I\S j @¡I\S?C�HhI j @B� j Q��¡H\W j EVC�UDO�C"+%>BRTSBC���C ��UD@B�¡K�HC �[I\Q�C0y�C0EVZ��+C j ]¶wD��S?K�W�S�EVC j �?H'I�U j fgC0Q�Z��NCxE^UNW j EVK^°xCx��ADQ�UDMB@B��HJI j I\C�� j fgC OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@§ �B� ¨e>0FeI�I�S[MBH � Q�Usf[KV�?CxH j @YKV�NC j EgI\CiHJI�K^@?A�ADQ�UDM?@B��OmUgQ j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\C�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@1OmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j EVHx>[FG@¡k�KVADM?Q�C%�xr;Q�CxH\M?E^I�H+OmQ\Ugy/I\S?Q�C0C�n1k�R¦W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@BH j Q\C1W UDy �Bj Q\Ci�­��K^I\S��k8� j I j § ���$¨ j @B� I�S?C�C � j W I�© �?w�Ug�NI j K^@BCx���[Z¾f j Q�K j I\KVUD@ j E2W j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@BH���K^I\SW UDQ�Q�C0E j I\Ci��� j fDC OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@BH�§ �Dp$¨�� j EVE2© � j Q\C¡HJI�Q\K�WuI�E^Z½@?UD@?Q�C0E j I�K^f[K�HJI�KVWi�u>k?UNW M�HhKV@?A BQ�HhI�UD@�I�S?C��[c£Ug@?E^Z�Q�CxH\M?E^I�Hxw�Ug@?C�K^y�y�Cx�NK j I�C0EVZ�@?U$I�KVW0CxH�I\S j I��NK�H � C0Q�HhKVfDC;��Ug@B�NKV@?AKVH j�� M?Q�C�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�C0µ�CiWuIi> �+UDI\S�I\S?C�C � j WuI1�lceUD@BE^Z6¯1X+v W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@ j @B�6KLI�H��k W UgM?@lI\C0Q �Bj QhI � Q�Cx�NK�WuI j Q\C � M?E�HhKVfDCYCx@?C0Q�ADZ¡HhMBQhO j W CD>�v�UDQ�C0UsfgC0Qiw j H2KV@�H\U­y j @[Z

Page 48: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4 5 6 7 8 9 10

������������ �� ������������ �������� ��!"#�

$�%& ')(+*-,

. & /1032 45,

����� �I �D� Ô.ÙlÆ\Ð ����Ì �gÐ Z�ÎxÖ�Æ!(76~ÉWZ ��Æ X ��(98 X3:) ËÍÙ�Ö�ÉiÇ\�lËÍÙ[Î ÈJËLÉxÙ ��Ë ÈJÅ�Æ>=gÎ0Ö�È ( & Ú�� � � ۶׻Æ�ÐJÌ �gÌ? � A b =Q�ÁÉxÙlÏ���ÑTØ��¿ÎxÙlÊ �9� 9 � � < ÊlÎ0ÈhÎ1ÎxÌ �Æ�ÏÍÏ�ÎxÌ~Æ>=gÎxÖ�È'ÐJÆ�Ì �gÏ È(9 � " < ÜU$I\SBC0Q'HhK^I\M j I\KVUD@�H��¢HhCxC2´[CxW I\KVUD@�³g�.I\S?C��[c£Ug@?EVZ;¯1X~v � j I j1j Q�C�fDC0Q�Z�W EVUgH\C+I\U�I\S?C ��k@lMBy%��C0Q�H0>BRT��U�. W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\Ci�+.?n1k�R Q�CxH\M?E^I�H j Q\C j EVH\U�HhSBUs��@�KV@�k�K^AgM?Q\C­�xrB>�¯�@�I�S?CUD@?C­S j @B�¤w¤I�S?C­C0@BC0Q�ADZ�H\M?Q\O j W C�Q�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?A�OmQ\Ugy j HhI j @�� j Q��6ºÀn2� W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@6K�H� E^UDIhI�Cx�¤>lRTS?C2º�n2� � Q\Ci�NKVW I�HI�S?C2y�KV@?K^y;M?y8U$O¤© �1I\UY��C�I\U[U�O j Q'KV@­�[Z�� ��UDSBQ j @B�I\S?C­W UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A���C0EVE'�NC � I\S�I\U¡��C�I�UlU¡E j Q�ADC%�[Z j @�UDQ��NCxQ�UDO~y j AD@BKLI�MB�NC�%.��H� UgK^@lI\Ci��UDM?I�K^@�´NCxWuI�K^Ug@¾�D> ²Nw?I\S?C�º�n2�aQ�Cx¬lM?KVQ�CxHTI�S?C;�NCx@BH\KLI�K^CiH2U$OI�S?C�IJ��U j I�UDy­HI\U¡UsfDC0Q�E j$� w�K^@6UDQ��NC0Q�I\U � Q\UN�NM�W C%�BK^@B�?K^@?A�>¶FeI1I�S[MBH�W UD@lI�Q j WuI�H2I\S?C��NKVy�C0Q1O j Q�I\U[Uy%MBW�S.>?RTSBC�ºÀn2� K�HT@?U$I2H\M?KLI j �?EVC1I\U��NCiH\W0Q\KV��C1H\MBW�S�HhZNHhI\C0y­HxwNK^@�H � K^I\C�U$OÀI\S?C�O j WuII\S j I2KLI2AgC0@?CxQ j I\CxH j @ j IhI\Q j W I\KVfDCY© � >

RTS?C;H\CxW0UD@B� . W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�Cx�+.�n�kR W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@�K�H�� j HhCi��UD@�I\S?C�W Ugy%�?KV@ j I�K^Ug@�U$OI\S?C�C � j WuI�© ª ��K^I\S�© � �« �Ák�T²D��§ ²$r$¨���I�S?C�E j IhI�C0Q�C0@BC0Q�ADZ�KVH j �?�NCx� � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I�K^fgC0EVZI\U j HhCxELOÁW0UD@BH\KVHhI\Cx@lI��[ceUD@?EVZ½W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@½��K^I\S?KV@�I\S?C�¹Yº�F j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@��u>'RTS?Cj ADQ�C0Cxy�C0@lI2U$O'I�S?C%Q�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?A�© �­��K^I\S�I\S?C�C0� j WuI�HhMBQhO j W CYK�H�@?UDI � C0Q\OmCxWuIiw��BMNI�I�S?CQ\CiHhM?E^I\KV@?A�© � ��,Y�K�H j I~EVC j HJI~¬lM j E^K^I j I\KVfDCxE^Z�W UDQ�Q�CxWuIi>$RTS[MBH�© � �« �NU[CxH'@BU$I~Ug@?E^Z;ADKVfDCI\S?C2�NCiHhKVQ�Cx���1H , � ce��CxS j f[K^UgQxw»�?M?I j E�HhU � Q�UsflK��NCiH j Q�C j E^K�HJI�KVWT�NCiH\W0Q\K � I�K^Ug@%U$O�I\SBC�Q�CxHhIU$O'© �B��,Y� >

b1K^fgC0@YI�S?C~O j WuI�I\S j I�© � �« UDQ�K^AgK^@ j I\CiH¤OmQ�UDyaH\CxW Ug@B��UgQ��?C0Q � C0Q\I\MBQ\� j I\KVUD@%I\S?CxUDQ�ZDwUD@?C�y�K^AgSgI��C+I�C0y � I�Cx�%I\U�W UD@�HhK��NC0QÀI\SBKVH j I\Q�K^f[K j E[Q\CiHhMBELI %»��HÀI\S?C j Q�ADMBy�Cx@lI�HÀADKVfDC0@K^@YI�S?C���CxADKV@?@?KV@?A�UDONI\S?K�H�´NCxWuI�K^Ug@ j$�B� E^Z1I�U j @[Z�HhCiW Ug@B��UDQ��NC0Q � CxQhI�M?Q�� j I�K^fgC�C0@?CxQ\AgZOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£wgI\S?C��IH , � ce��CxS j f[K^UgQ�K�H~W Ugy�y�Ug@�I\U j E^E�U$O¶I\SBC0y�>���Us�+CxfDCxQxw j H � UDKV@gI�Cx�UDMNITC j Q\EVK^CxQ~I�S?C�W UDQ�Q�CxWuI�E^Ug@?A$ceQ j @?AgC���CxS j f[K^UgQ��NU[CiH+@BU$ITK^y � EVZ�I\S j ITI\S?C�W Ugy � E^C0I\C© �B��,Y�.KVH j W0W0M?Q j I\Cg>0RTS?K�H.K�HÀ�?C0y�UD@BHhI\Q j I�Cx�1C � � EVK�W K^I\EVZ1KV@�k�K^AgM?Q�C2�iq?w K^@%��S?KVW�S�I�S?Q�C0CHhCiW UD@���UDQ��NC0Q�Q\CiHhMBELI�H�OmUDQ�© �B� ,Y� j Q\C%W0UDy �Bj Q\Ci�¤>BFG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@�I�U�I�S?C;k�T²»ceQ\CiHhMBELIj EVQ\C j �NZ�H\S?Us��@¡K^@�k�K^AgM?Q�C��xr%I�S?C�H\M?QhO j W C�UD�?I j KV@?Ci����K^I\S¡I\SBC�W UD@[fgC0@lI\KVUD@ j E¤v�X+²j$�?� Q�U j W�S��¢HhCiW UD@��%UgQ��NCxQ � CxQhI�M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@%I�S?C0UgQ\Z�Ug@%I�S?C�� j HhK�HU$O ��k'��K�H'ADKVfDCx@.>$RTS?Ck��T²»ceQ�CxH\M?ELI�UsfDCxQ\CiHJI�K^y j I�CxH~I\S?C1C � j WuIT�+CxE^E.�NC � I\S�I\U�Q�UDM?AgS?E^Z�I�S?CYH j y�C1C �[I�C0@lI j HI\S?C�v�X�²¡HhM?Q\O j W0C;MB@B�NC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I�CxH�K^I��Á³Dp'#��u>.RTS?C­EVUNW j I�K^Ug@6UDO~I�S?C­y�K^@?KVy%MBy U$O

Page 49: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � �

-1.6

-1.4

-1.2

-1

-0.8

-0.6

-0.4

-0.2

0

4 5 6 7 8 9 10

������������� ���� ����� � ����������� ���� ����� � �����! � "�"# � � ��� "� ��$ �%�&�

')(* +-,�.0/

1 * 2)3�4657/

����� �I���� Ô.ÙlÆ�Ð �2��Ì �gÐ Z�ÎxÖ�ÆE(76gÚ ��Û¶É-Z �+Æ X �/��ËÍÕ?Æ\ÐJÆ�ÙsÈ�ÒNÆ�ÐGÈ��DÐ��[Î ÈJËLÉxÙYÆ>=DÒ[Î0ÙlÌGËÍÉiÙgÌ�ÈJÉ2ÌGÆ�Ö�ÉxÙ[ÊÉ0ÐhÊgÆ�ÐuÜ5(98 X3:) ËÍÙ;Ö�ÉiÇ\�lËÍÙ[Î ÈJËLÉxÙ ��Ë ÈJÅ�Æ =lÎ0Ö�È!( & Ú�� � � Û×»Æ\ÐJÌ �lÌ'Ö�ÉxÙD×iÆ�ÙsÈJËLÉxÙ[Î0Ï ��Ø � 9 �� < Î0Ù[ÊÌGÆ�Ö�ÉiÙlÊ�ÉxÐhÊDÆ�Ð~Æ>=DÒ[ÎxÙgÌGËÍÉiÙ�ÉxÙ;ÈJÅlÆ9�[ÎxÌGËÍÌ~É-Z ? � A¾ÉxÐ��gËÍÈhÎ0ÏÍÌ�Î0Ì ��Æ�ÏÍ϶Î0Ì~Æ =lÎ0Ö�È89 � " < ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈuÜ© �B��,Y�2KVH � Q\Ci�NK�WuI\Ci�¡I\U���CYI�U[U�E j Q�ADC��[Z�pB> ²#��UDSBQ��[Z�I�S?C;v�X+² j$�B� Q\U j W�S.wB��S?K^EVCI\S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@B�?K^@?A�k��T²sc£@[M?y;��CxQTKVHTI�U[U�H\y j EVE¤�[Z�p?> ² ��UDS?Qi>

FG@6I�S?C­I�S?K^Q���H\CxW Ug@B��UDQ��NC0Q jD�?� Q�U j W�S�I\SBC�k��T²¡Cx@?C0Q�ADZ�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E+KVHYCxf j EVMNcj I\Ci����K^I\S ºÀn2� UgQ\�BKLI j E�H0w�K¢> CD>ÀI\SBC��NK^µ�CxQ\Cx@BW C¡��C IJ��C0C0@¾I\S?C¡º�n2� j @B��I\S?C¡k��T²OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EÀKVH j �?�NCi� � CxQhI�M?Q�� j I�K^fgC0EVZ�I\U�I�S?C%ºÀn2� H\M?QhO j W Cg>&��Z¡W0UD@BHhI\Q�MBWuI�K^Ug@¡I\S?K�HOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�Z[K^CxEV�BH'I\SBC��1H , � c j HhZ[y � I\UDI\K�W0Hx>,��Us�+CxfDC0Qiw»I\SBC

��cGW U[C 2�W0K^Cx@gI+UD�NI j KV@?Cx�

OmQ\Ugy¼�J�xp,�g�~��KLI�S�º�n2� UDQ��?K^I j EVH1§ � �s¨¤K�HTy%MBW�S¡E j Q\AgC0Q+I\S j @�I�S?C��Q�CxH\M?E^I\KV@?A;OmQ\Ugy

�lceUD@BE^Z½¯1X~v UDQ��?KLI j E�H��Á��S?K�W�S½K�H j E^Q�C j �NZ�I\U[U�E j Q�ADC»�u>RTS?KVH�K�H%Q�C ��CxWuI�Cx�½�lZ�I�S?CE j Q\AgC c ,a��CxS j f[K^UgQ�U$OI\SBC%W UgQ\Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�H\M?QhO j W Cg>B=�fgC0@¡y�UgQ\CYKVy � UgQhI j @lIKVH%I\S?C¡W Ugy � E^C0I\C�O j K^EVM?Q�C�U$O�I�S?K�H�I�S?K^Q��¾H\CxW0UD@B��UgQ��NCxQ�C � �Bj @BH\K^Ug@�K^@�I�S?C�f[K�W KV@?K^IJZU$O'I\SBC;y�KV@?K^y;M?y�U$O�© �?>¤RTS?C%y�KV@?KVy%M?y�K�H1E^UNW j I\Ci��Q\UgM?ADSBE^Z�² ��UDS?Q�I\U[U�O j Q�UgMNIj @B��KLI�H��?C � I�S�K�H+I\U[U;H\y j EVE��[Z j @�UDQ��NC0Q�U$OÀy j AD@?K^I\M��NCD>NRTS?K�HT�NC0y�UD@�HJI�Q j I\CxH~I\S j II\S?C j$�B� E^K�W j I\KVUD@�UDO�H\CxW0UD@B��UgQ��?C0Q � CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@�I\S?CxUDQ�Z��NU[CxH1@?UDI j MNI\Ugy j I\K�W j E^EVZADM j Q j @gI�C0C j Q\C j EVKVHhI\K�W�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�H\M?QhO j W C�OmUDQ;�NKVH � C0Q�HhKVfDC���UD@B�?H&%��¿H\M?K^I j �BE^C­@?Ug@?KV@NcI\C0Q j W I\KV@?A�Q\C0OmC0Q�C0@BW0C � j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @.w'��SBKVW�S � Q�UsflK��NCiH%I�S?C�HJI j Q\I\KV@?A � UgK^@lI­OmUDQ�I�S?CC � �Bj @�[email protected][K�H�Q\Ci¬gMBK^Q�Cx�¤>NRTS?C1C0@BC0Q�ADZ�H\M?QhO j W C�UD�NI j KV@?Cx����KLI�S�I�S?CYk��T²sc¢OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j EUD@�I\S?C�� j H\KVHUDO�I�S?C1¯1X~v#H\S?UDM?E��;I\S[MBH'��C�M?@B�?C0Q�HJI�UlUN� j H j @�C0@BW0UDM?Q j AgK^@?A1Q�CxH\M?ELIi>

¯�@?C� B@ j E � UgK^@lIQ\CxE j I\Ci�YI\U�I\SBC+Cx@?C0Q�ADZYH\M?QhO j W C+U$O���C HhCxC0y­HÀ�+UgQhI�S j Q�C0y j Q\]¶>FG@;k�K^AgM?Q�C2�xo2I\S?CTk��T²TQ�CxH\M?E^IÀK�HH � EVK^IÀKV@gI�U�K^I�HÀKV@B�NKVflK��NM j ENW UDy � UD@?Cx@lI�Hx>0FG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@I\U�I\SBC��[ceUD@?EVZ �Bj QhI�Ug@?C�S j HTIJ��U�W UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@BH�OmQ\Ugy © � �« w

� D ' ��,Y� � © D ' « § �2C ¨e� ,Y� � ²D© D ' « § �2C0¨e� ,�� �J�D�»²D�� � $ < ��,Y�2� © � $ <« § ��C ¨e� ,Y� � ²D©�� $ <« § �2C0¨e� ,�� 7 �J�D�i³g�

W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A�I\U­I�S?C�IJ��U­K^@BADQ�Cx�NKVC0@lI�H2U$O�=~¬�>�� �g²g�u>�¯�@BC%W j @�C � � EVKVW0KLI�E^Z�HhCxCYI\S j I� � $ < f j @?K�HhS?CiHYC � � UD@?Cx@lI\K j EVE^Z6OmUDQ�E j Q�ADC ,�wÀ��S?K^EVC � D ' AgK^fgCxH�I�S?C��NUgy�KV@ j @gIiwj IhI�Q j WuI�K^fgC�W UDy � UD@?Cx@lI2U$O�© � > �2Us��C0fDCxQxw[KV@�I\S?C%flK�W KV@?K^IJZ�UDOI\S?C�y�KV@?KVy%M?y#U$O�© �

Page 50: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

�2" Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

-2.5

-2

-1.5

-1

-0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 8

��������� ���� ������ ���������������

���� "!$#&%

' � (�)�*�+,%

����� �I ��� Ô.ÙlÆ\Ð ����Ì �DÐ Z�ÎxÖ�Æ�É-Z ��Æ X �C�TÆ�Ö�ÉiÇYÒNÉiÌGË ÈJËÍÉiÙ�É-Z2� � � �£ÑTØ��¼ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ È�ËÍÙsÈJÉ�Ö�ÉiÇYÒNÉW�ÙgÆ�ÙsÈJÌ�Ü

I\S?C�W UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@¡UDO � � $ < KVH�@?U�EVUD@?AgC0Q�@?CxADEVK^AgK^�?EVCD>�RTS?C�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ¡HhM?Q\O j W0CYU$O �2C KVH�Ug@?C�U$OÀI\S?CYQ j Q�C1W j H\CxHTKV@���S?KVW�S�© � $ <« W Ug@lI\Q�K^�?M?I\CxH�H\KV° j �BE^Zg>

� ��� � * � �#" ���%�* ! * � " � " � ��" �#��� *����#� +�" � � '#� � ��!('#��! +�" �$�#��* � � " +�� * !#%� *�� � �

��O�I\CxQ2CxHhI j �?EVKVH\S?KV@?A�I\S?CY� j HhK�W j �?KVEVKLIJZ�U$O'© � �« I�U��?C j E���KLI�S��?KVH � CxQ�H\KVUD@�OmUDQ�W CxH�I�S?C@?C �[I�HJI�C � KVH j ¬lM j @lI�KLI j I\KVfDCTHhI\MB�NZ%U$O�y�UgQ\CTW Ug@lfgC0@lI\KVUD@ j EgH\ZNHJI�C0y­Hx>sFG@�R j �?EVC ��I�S?CW UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�C0@BC0Q�ADKVCxH�UD�?I j KV@?Ci�6��K^I\S�I�S?K�HYOmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E�OmUgQ%W EVUgH\Cx�[cGH\M?�BH\S?C0EVE j I�UDy­Hj Q�C�W UDy �Bj Q\Ci����KLI�S¾f j Q�K^UgMBH�U$I�S?C0Q j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@BH j @B��I\S?C�C � j W I;W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH�§ �D³s¨'�m��SBKVW�S�S j fDC���C0Cx@�C �[I�Q j WuI\Ci�­�[Z­W UDy;�?KV@?K^@BA%f j Q�K j I\KVUD@ j EBQ�CxH\M?E^I�H'OmUgQIJ�+UDc j @B�½I\S?Q�C0C0c£CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@ HhZNHhI\C0y­H���K^I\S�C � � C0Q�K^y�C0@lI j E2� j I j OmUDQ�I\S?C�KVUD@BK^° j I\KVUD@C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH~UDO¤I\S?C�Q�C0y j KV@?KV@?A�C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@BH��u>NRTS?C1º�n2� Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxH+HhS?Us� I�S?C1�+CxE^E^c£][@?Us��@UsfDC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I�K^Ug@�UDO�I\SBC�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI j I\UDy�K�W�©�«��[Z j O j WuI�UDQ¡U$O�²?>�RTS?C�bYb�� § ² �s¨K^y � Q�CxH�HhKVfDCxE^Z�KVy � Q\UsfgCxH�Ug@�I\S j Ix>'RTS?C��T´lc£OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j EY§ ²$³$¨ j E�H\U�EVC j �BH�I�U�Q j I\SBC0Qj W0W0M?Q j I\C�f j EVM?CxH+OmUDQTEVK^AgSlI j I\Ugy�Hxw[�?MNI2H\M?�BHhI j @lI�K j E^EVZ�M?@B�NCxQ\CiHJI�K^y j I�CxH+I\SBC�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI©�«�U$OÀI\S?C1S?C j f[KVC0QTH � CxW0K^CiH0>?© � « W EVC j Q�EVZ�UsfgC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I\CiH j I\Ugy�K�W�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�Cx@?C0Q\cADKVCxHxw?W UD@�HhK�HJI�C0@lIT��KLI�S�I�S?C�Q\CiHhMBELITOmUDQTI�S?C�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�HhMBQhO j W C�U$O �2C >?RTS?C��NCxflK j I�K^Ug@BHj Q�C�y%MBW�S­E j Q�ADCxQ'I\S j @�I\S?UlHhC�UD�BH\C0Q�fDCi�%OmUgQ�I�S?C�bYb���>[v�UgQ\CxUsfDC0Qiw»I\SBC j WxW M?Q j W0Z%U$O© � �« KVH+UD�[f[KVUDMBH\E^Z�EVUs�+CxQ�I�S j @­I�S j ITU$O�I\S?C�W Ug@lfgC0@lI\KVUD@ j E�v�X+²�H�W�S?Cxy�CgwgKV@ ��j Q\I\K�WucM?E j QTOmUDQ j I�UDy­HT��K^I\S�y j @[Z�C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@BHx>B¯�@�I�S?CYU$I�S?C0Q�S j @B�¤w[I�S?CYFh´[F+C �[I\Cx@BHhKVUD@¡U$O© � �« H\C0Cxy�H�I�U­C0EVK^y�KV@ j I�C�y�UlHJI2UDO�I�S?CYC0Q�Q\UgQTU$O�I�S?C�H\CxW Ug@B��UDQ��NC0QTOmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E£>

FG@¡R j �?EVC �;I\S?C�© � $ <« W0UDy � Ug@?C0@lI�U$O�I\SBC�W0UDy � EVC I�C�© � �« K�H j E�HhU�EVKVHhI\Ci�¡H\C ��j cQ j I\C0EVZD>?© � $ <« f j @?KVH\S?CiH�OmUDQTIJ��U$ceC0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@�H\ZNHJI�C0y­H j @B�¡K�HTy�UDQ�C�I�S j @�²;UDQ��NCxQ�H�U$Oy j AD@?K^I\M��NC%H\y j E^EVC0Q2I\S j @�© D ' « OmUDQ j E^EÀU$I�S?C0Q j I\Ugy�Hx>BRTS?K�H2Q�CxH\M?E^I�HhMBADADCiHJI�HTI\S j I© � $ <« W j @���C�@BC0ADEVCxW I\Ci��KV@�y�UlHJI�H\KLI�M j I�K^Ug@BHxw¤��S?KVW�S��NC0 B@?K^I\KVfDC0EVZ�H\K^y � EVK^ BCxH�I�S?Cj$�?� EVK�W j I�K^Ug@�UDO© � « >

Page 51: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � `�������� *��E� É0ÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ�Æ�ÙgÆ�Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì%Ú '!( ) ÛTÉ-ZÖ�ÏÍÉiÌGÆuÊS�¢Ì �T�lÌGÅgÆ�ÏÍÏÎ0ÈJÉxÇYÌ0�+? � A 9 �;:;< b Ø���� ` ����1A 9 ���;< b � � 9 � < b ( 8 X3:) 9 ` �;< ÎxÙ[ÊfY �SY@9 � ` < ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ�ÚmÎxÏÍÏBÆ�ÙlÆ\Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì�Éc�DÈhÎxËÍÙlÆuÊf�I��ËÍÙlÌGÆ�ÐGÈJËÍÉiÙÉWZ1=S�ÁÉiÙlÏ��6ÊgÆ�ÙlÌGË ÈJËÍÆ�ÌhÛ�ËLÙ6Ö�ÉiÇYÒlÎ0ÐJËÍÌGÉiÙ ��ËÍÈJÅ ��Ø � 9 � � b � � < ÎxÙlÊ6Æ>=gÎxÖ\È 9 � < Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËÍÆ�Ì�Ú�ËÍÙÇ���Î0ÐGÈGÐJÆ�ÆuÛ\ÜlÄÅgÆ�Ö�ÉiÙsÈGÐJË���DÈJËÍÉiÙ¡Ú � �iÛÈJÉ ( 8 X3:) ËÍÌ+ÎxÏÍÌGÉYÏÍËÍÌeÈJÆuÊ�ÌGÆ�ÒlÎ0ÐhÎ0ÈJÆ�Ï �sÜ

��Ø � Æ>=gÎxÖ\È Y �SY ( 8 X3:) '!(�����) ? �@A ���1A � �

�+Æ � � � #� � � "DÜ " `c` � : � �.�Æ �;: � � ` � � "DÜ : ��� � � � �c Æ ��� #� ` � ` " � ��� ` Ü � � � : ��� � �� � � �2� � � � ��� DÜ � � � � � �2" � � `A~Ð � "�� ����� � :&: �$Ü � ` � ` �#� ` � � � Î � � � �#� : : Ü � ` � � ` � � � ��� �� Ù ` :1�2� � " ` : ` � Ü � �;: :#� ` � �;: ` � �&:� Ê �&: ` � ` " � ` �DÜ � � � � ` �#� �� � � ` �� Æ #" ��� � �#� ` � Ü � � ` �#� ` � � �#� �

�2@ j E^UgADUDM�H�� j I j OmUgQ�I\SBC��2C�K�H\UlCxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@?KVW�H\C0Q�K^CiH j Q�CYADKVfDCx@�KV@�R j �?EVC­�xp�§ og²»¨e>RTS?CxH\C2@[M?y%��C0Q�H'fgC0Q�KLOmZ%I\S j I+© � �« KVH�I\S?C2Ug@?EVZ j f j KVE j �?EVC��NC0@BH\K^IJZ%OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j EB��SBKVW�S

�������� JI�� � ÉxÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ ÈJËLÉxÙ¾Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËÍÆ�Ì¡Ú '!( ) Û�É-Z�ÈJÅlÆ �+Æ­ËÍÌGÉsÆ�ÏÍÆ�Ö�ÈGÐJÉiÙgËÍÖ¡ÌGÆ�ÐJËÍÆ�Ì0� ? � A 9 �&:;< bØ���� ` �����1A 9 ���;< b � � 9 � < b (98 X3:) 9 ` �;< Î0Ù[Ê&Y �QY(9 � ` < ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ%ÚmÎxÏÍÏ�Æ�ÙgÆ�Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì�Éc�DÈhÎxËÍÙlÆ�Ê&�I�ËÍÙgÌGÆ�ÐGÈJËÍÉiÙ�É-Z =S�ÁÉiÙlÏ���ÊgÆ�ÙgÌGË ÈJËLÆ�ÌhÛ~ËÍÙ­Ö�ÉiÇYÒlÎ0ÐJËÍÌGÉiÙ ��Ë ÈJÅ ��Ø � 9 �&:;< ÎxÙlÊ�Æ>=gÎxÖ�È(9 �1� < Æ�ÙlÆ�Ð �xËÍÆ�ÌÚ�ËÍÙ;Ç��TÎ0ÐGÈGÐJÆ�Æ Û\Ü Y¢ÉiÙ ? �@A ���1A � � (98 X3:) Y �QY�Æ>=gÎxÖ�È ��Ø �

��Æ `c` � Ü � � �$Ü � � ` Ü : � � Ü � ` #�$Ü �/� � Ü " � � Ü ` Æ���� � "-DÜ " : ` Ü � � "DÜ : � : Ü � ` � �sÜ " � �$Ü : � � � Ü �� Î Ã���� � � DÜ :1� Ü � #�$Ü � � : Ü : � � �sÜ � � : Ü ` � � �sÜ �� Ù X��� �&:#� Ü � � ` Ü -DÜ � � : Ü :1� � : Ü � � �sÜ �� Ð 6��� ��� � Ü � � � Ü " ` Ü � � : Ü : : � : Ü � : Ü � � � �sÜ ��DÙ � ��� � � � Ü � �&: Ü " �"DÜ " � : Ü : � � : Ü � � � : Ü " Ê K��� #" � Ü � �#� Ü � � �DÜ " � : Ü : � � : Ü � : Ü � `� � ���� ` � Ü " � �DÜ �2� Ü � � : Ü : � : Ü �-� � � ��� �;: Ü ` � "DÜ : ��� Ü : � : Ü :� � : Ü �/� : Ü �#�ÄÅ����� c-DÜ � � ` Ü �)��� Ü " � : Ü :� � : Ü � :�¶Ç ���� c��DÜ : �� Ü � �;: Ü " � : Ü :� � : Ü �/� : Ü � �

H j I\K�HJ BCiH�I�S?C�W0UDQ�Q\CiWuI�H�W j E^KV@?A�E j �a��KLI�S�Q�CxH � CiWuI�I�U�I�S?C%@[MBW0E^C j Q�W�S j Q�ADC!��>BFeI���C0cW UDy�CiH�C0� j WuI1K^@�I\S?C�E^KVy�KLI�U$O�E j Q�ADC��Yw¶KV@���S?K�W�S�I\SBC�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�U$O'IJ��U$cC0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@�K^Ug@BH jD�?� Q�U j W�SBCxH j W0UD@BHhI j @gIi>�RTS?C�bYb�� C0@BC0Q�ADKVCxHxw?UD@�I�S?C�U$I�S?C0Q�S j @��¤wHhS?Us� j HhZNHhI\C0y j I\K�W+KV@BW0Q\C j H\C���K^I\S�KV@BW Q�C j HhKV@?A �Y>gRTS?CTU �?� UgH\KLI�C���CxS j f[K^UgQKVHOmUgM?@B�OmUDQI\SBC��T´YOmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E£w$E^C j �NKV@?A�I\U j @�CxQ\Q�UDQ�U$O¤q$p$# OmUDQ'S?C j flZYKVUD@�H0>$RTS?CTFh´[FÀOmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j E¢w¤��S?UlHhC��NUgy�KV@ j I\KV@?A�K^@?AgQ\Ci�NKVC0@lIYKVHY© � « w j EVH\U jD�?� Q�U j W�S?CxH j W UD@�HJI j @lI�OmUgQ

Page 52: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

E j Q\AgC ��>#��Us�+CxfDC0Qiw.I�S?C�W UD@lI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@BH;I\U6© � � �« ��CxZDUD@��¾K^I�H�HhCiW Ug@B��UDQ��NCxQ;� j HhK�H© � �« �?U�@?U$I�W UDy � EVC I�C0EVZ%f j @BKVH\S­K^@�I�S?K�H~EVK^y�K^IxwlHhUYI�S j I~I\S?C2Fh´NFW0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�C0@?CxQ\AgZKVH2H\EVK^AgSgI�E^Z�Hhy j EVEVC0Q�I\S j @¡I\S?CYC0� j WuI�Q�CxH\M?ELIi>

� y�UgQ\CTHhCx@BH\KLI�K^fgC+I�CxHhIOmUDQ�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@YOmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVH�I�S j @;I\UDI j E j I\Ugy�KVW�W UgQ\Q�C0E j cI\KVUD@%Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxH�K�H � Q\Usf[K��NCx���lZ j I\Ugy�K�W�=~��Hx>»FG@;R j �?EVC��D�~I\S?C�=~��HÀOmUDQ � B UD�NI j KV@?Cx���KLI�S;f j Q�KVUDMBH.OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H j Q�C~EVKVHhI\Ci��§ og²s¨£>»FG@ j E^ENW j H\CxH�I\S?C�C � j W IÀC0�NW�S j @?AgC~K�HÀM�HhCi�¤w

�������� � � ÉxÐGÐJÆ�Ï^Î ÈJËÍÉiÙ¾Æ�ÙlÆ\Ð ����ÎxÙ[Ê6Æ�ÏÍÆ�Ö�ÈGÐJÉiپΠ�YÙlË È+��ÉWZ � ��7~Æ�Ì �gÏÍÈJÌ%Éc�DÈhÎxËÍÙlÆ�Ê@�I�Ö�ÉiÇM�gËÍÙ[Î0ÈJËÍÉxÙYÉ-Z?ÈJÅlÆ'Æ>=gÎ0Ö�È�Æ =gÖhÅ[Î0Ù��xÆ ��Ë ÈJÅ%ÊgË Õ?Æ�ÐJÆ�Ù$È�Ö�É0ÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙfZ �gÙlÖ�ÈJËÍÉxÙ[ÎxÏÍÌ+Ú ? �@A�9 �&:;< bØ���� ` �����1A 9 �2�;< b � �!9 � < b � � Ú (98 X3:) Û 9 ` � < ÎxÙlÊ Y �QY�9 � ` < ÛÀËÍÙYÖ�ÉxÇYÒ[Î0ÐJËÍÌGÉxÙ ��Ë ÈJÅ ��Ø � 9 ���;<Î0Ù[Ê%Æ>=gÎxÖ�È89 � � < Æ�ÙgÆ�Ð �iËÍÆ�Ì�Ú�ËÍÙ�Ç��TÎ ÐGÈGÐJÆ�Æ Û\Ü

��Æ\ÈJÅlÉ$Ê '!( ) Ô A� � ' ` � Ü `� �1? � A � �$Ü � :�� Ü :� �����1A #�$Ü � ��� Ü �� � � � ` Ü � ` � Ü �� � � � � � Ü : � � Ü :� �9Y �QY � Ü ��� Ü �Æ>=gÎ0Ö�È ��DÜ � ��� Ü ���Ø � ��� Ü ` �$Ü �

UD@?EVZ�I�S?C%W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@ �Bj Q\I�U$O�© ª « f j Q�K^CiH0>���H�I�U���C%C � � CxW I\Cx�.w?I\SBCY�[c£Ug@?E^Z�W j EVW0MNcE j I\KVUD@ � Q�Cx�NK�WuI�H�� B I�U���C�M?@[��UgM?@B�¤wÀ��S?K^EVC�ºÀn2� W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@ � Q\UN�NMBW0CxH j @�=~���S?KVW�S6KVH�y�UgQ\C%I\S j @ j O j W I\UDQ1U$O�²­I�U[U�E j Q�ADCg>�RTS?C��T´�Q\CiHhM?E^IYHhM?��HJI j @lI\K j EVE^Z�MB@Nc�NC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I\CiH+I\S?C�C � j WuI�=~��>?© � « W EVC j Q�EVZ­UsfDC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I�CxH'I�S?CYW UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�C0@?CxQ\AgZU$O(� B j @B�­I�SlM�H j EVH\U�I�S?C���=0%N��H�OmUDQ+I\S?CYW UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@­C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH~UDO�@?CxMNI\Q j E j I�UDy­Hj @B� � UlHhK^I\KVfDC1KVUD@BHxwN© � �« j @���I�S?CYW UD@[fgC0@lI\KVUD@ j E�v�X+²%C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH~�?Q j W�]gC I+I\S?C�C � j WuI=~��>�RTSBC¡KV@BW0E^MBH\KVUD@�U$O�SBK^AgS?C0Q­UgQ��NCxQ%I�C0Q�y­H�K^@ © � �« f[K j I�S?C�Fh´[F;K^y � Q�UsfDCiH%I�S?Cj ADQ�C0Cxy�C0@lIxw j ELI�S?UDM?AgS6Ug@?C�@?U$I�KVW0CxH j I�C0@B�?C0@BW0Z�I\U�UsfgC0Q�W UgQ\Q�CxW I2I\S?C�C0Q�Q\UgQ1UDO+I�S?CHJI�Q j K^AgSgIYH\CxW Ug@B��UgQ��?C0Q1C � �Bj @�HhKVUD@.>¤v�UgQ\CxUsfDCxQxwBI\S?C�bYb��/W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EZlKVC0E��?H j H\K^y�KVE j Q\EVZ j W0W MBQ j I\C¡@lMBy%��C0QiwI\S[MBH�¬lM?CiHJI�K^Ug@?K^@BA6I�S?C�MBH\C OmM?EV@?CiH\H­UDO�I�S?CK^y � EVKVW0KLI�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�Hx>

RTS?C�@?C0�[ITHhI\C � U$O¤I�S?C j @ j E^ZNH\KVH+U$O.UgQ\�?K^I j ELcG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lITW UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�HW UD@�HhK�HJI�HYU$O j EVU[UD] j I;W0Usf j E^Cx@lI\EVZ���Ug@B��y�UDEVCxW0M?EVCxHx>�R j �?EVC��i²¡EVKVHhI�H�I\S?C�H � CxW I\Q�U$cH\W0U � K�W2W Ug@BHhI j @lI�H'U$O UD�NI j KV@?Cx����K^I\S j f j Q\KVC IJZ;U$O j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�H ¥ I�S?C�� j I jOmUDQ j Q\C;¬gMBKLI�C�W�S j Q j WuI�C0Q�KVHhI\K�W1OmUDQ�y j @[Z��?K j I\UDy�K�W�y�UDEVCxW0M?EVCxHx>¶¯�@?C% BQ�HhI�UDO j EVEUD�BH\C0Q�fDCiH�I\S j I�I\SBC��[c£Ug@?EVZ j$�B� Q\U j W�S¡Z[K^CxEV�?H j Q�C j H\UD@ j �?EVZ j WxW M?Q j I�CY��Ug@B��EVC0@?ADI\S��, ! � wB�?M?I1H\M?�BHhI j @lI�K j E^EVZ�M?@��NC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I\CiHTI\SBC%C � � C0Q�K^y�Cx@gI j E��?KVH�HhUNW0K j I\KVUD@�C0@?CxQ\AgZ��- ! �uwB��SBKVW�S�Cxy � S j H\K^°xCxH2I\S?C�KVy � UgQhI j @BW0C�U$O�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@.>NFG@�R j �?EVC��»²;I\S[MBH� �fDC�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI'W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H j Q�C j �?�NCx�YI\U�I\S?CTC � j WuIÀC0�?W�S j @?AgCD>id�H\C+UDO�bYb��W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@¡KVy � Q\UsfgCxH - ! w j E^I\S?UgM?ADS¡I�S?C�Q�C0y j KV@?KV@?A�C0Q�Q\UgQ�KVH2¬lM?K^I\C%E j Q\AgCD>B��I2I�S?CH j y�C�I�K^y�C�bYb��¿W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�EVC j �BH1I\U j Q\Ci�NMBWuI�K^Ug@6UDO , ! w¤I\S[MBH���UDQ�HhCx@?KV@?A�I�S?C

Page 53: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ �-�������� �� �$ÒNÆ�Ö�ÈGÐJÉxÌGÖ�ÉiÒgËLÖ2Ö�ÉxÙlÌeÈhÎ0Ù$ÈJÌ~É-Z X � 7~Æ�Ì �gÏÍÈJÌ~Éc�DÈhÎxËÍÙlÆ�ÊR�I��Ö�ÉxÇM�gËLÙlÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ�É-Z¤ÈJÅlÆÆ =lÎ0Ö�ÈTÆ =gÖhÅ[Î0Ù��xÆ ��Ë ÈJÅ�ÊgË Õ?Æ�ÐJÆ�Ù$È+Ö�É0ÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ Z �gÙlÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ�Ú ? � A 9 �&: < b Ø���� ` �����1A 9 ���;< b� � 9 � < b �QY � � ? � A 9 ��� < b � � Ú (98 X3:)¦Û 9 ` � < ÎxÙ[Ê Y �QY 9 � ` < Û+ËÍÙ­Ö�ÉxÇYÒ[Î0ÐJËÍÌGÉxÙ���ËÍÈJÅ �9� b ��Ø � b6��lÎiÊDÐhÎ ÈJËÍÖ�Ö�ÉiÙ����c�DÐhÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ2ËÍÙsÈJÆ�ÐhÎxÖ�ÈJËÍÉxÙ ��Ë ÈJÅ�ÌGËÍÙ��xÏLÆ�ÎxÙlÊ�ÊgÉc�T�lÏÍÆ.Æ>=DÖ�Ë ÈhÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙgÌÚ�� � Y �S�2Û 9 �#� < bÖ�ÉiÇYÒlÏÍÆ�ÈJÆ��SY � � ? �@A b Ö�ÉiÙ$×»Æ�Ù$ÈJËÍÉxÙ[ÎxÏ�? �@A�ÎxÙlÊ�Ø���� ` �����1A b ÎxÌ���Æ�ÏÍÏ$ÎxÌ�Æ>=DÒNÆ�ÐJËÍÇYÆ�ÙsÈhÎxÏ�9 ��" <ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌ2ÚmÎxÏÍϤÑTØ��/×iÎ0Ï �gÆ�ÌÐJÆ�Ï��;ÉiÙ�ÈJÅgÆ �0? Y�ÎxÒlÒDÐJÉ =gËÍÇ�Î ÈJËLÉxÙ b � � � �S�¢ÊlÎ ÈhÎ Z^ÐJÉiÇ 9 � ` < Û\Ü

ÇYÆ�ÈJÅlÉ$Ê � � ( 6 _ � � ��]^ � ��� � � �9 .�ÉxÅgÐ < 9 Æ0/ < 9 Ö�Ç Ã <

Æ>=DÒgÈuÜ � Ü " � � �DÜ �#" � � : "�G� � Ü "- � � Ü �1� � �#� ���Ø � � Ü ` 1� �DÜ c- � ` � "� � Y �S� � Ü ` "1� � Ü � ��� � � "#"� � Ü " `c` � Ü � ��� �#� :� �����1A ` Ü ��� � � Ü � � � ��� " `� � � � ` Ü ��� � � Ü � ` �� � �QY � � ? �@A � Ü "�"c � Ü �#� " �#��� "� � � � �gÙQ�NÉ-�lÙlÊ� �9Y �SY � Ü � 1� ` � Ü ��� � ` � " `�QY � � ? �@A�Ú = ��Ö Û ` Ü �#�&: ' � �DÜ � �#" � � �? �@A � Ü " :#� `c` Ü : " ` � �� :���1A � Ü " � � ` "DÜ � � � � #� �

j ADQ�C0Cxy�C0@lIÀ��K^I\S;C � � CxQ\KVy�C0@lIx>sRTS?CTW UgQ\Q�CxW I\KVUD@ j EVH\U�AgUlCiH�KV@lI\U�I\S?CT��Q�UD@?A��NK^Q�CxW I\KVUD@K^@;I\S?C�W j H\C~U$O�I\S?CTf[KV�?Q j I\KVUD@ j EDOmQ�Cx¬lM?Cx@BW Zg>sRTS?C�H j y�CTHhI j I�C0y�C0@lI�H jD�?� EVZ�I\UYW Ugy%�?K^c@ j I�K^Ug@BH~UDO¤I\S?C1C � j WuI+C0�?W�S j @?AgC2��K^I\S­I�S?CY�T´­OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E j @B�­��K^I\S�I�S?CY´[F\�~ceºÀn2�OmUDQ2W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@.>

R�M?Q�@?KV@?A¡I\U¡I\SBC� BQ�HhIhc � Q�K^@�W K � E^CiH�UDQ��?K^I j E^cG�NC � C0@B�?C0@lI�W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EVHxwUD@?C�Q\C j EVK^°xCxH~I\S j IT© � « �?UlCiH�@?U$I � Q\Ci�NK�WuI� I\U;��C1��UgM?@B� j I j EVE¢>NRÀU%M?@B�?C0Q�HJI j @B�I\S?K�H1Q\CiHhM?E^I�UD@?C�S j H�I�U�AgU�� j W�]�I�U¡=+¬�>V���D³g� j @���C � j y�KV@?C%I\S?C­HhI\Q�MBWuI�M?Q\C;U$O+I\S?K�HC � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@.>s© D ' « Q�C � Q�CxH\C0@lI�H�I�S?C�KV@gI�C0Q j W I\KVUD@%UDOBIJ��UYHhKVy%M?E^I j @?C0UgMBH �Bj Q\I\K�W EVC ceS?UgE^CC �?W K^I j I\KVUD@BH&%NRTS?C � Q\Ug� j �?KVEVKLIJZ�OmUgQ+I�S?CxH\C�I\Q j @BH\KLI�K^Ug@BH�KVHT�NC0I\CxQ\y�KV@?Cx���lZ�I\S?CY´[E j I\CxQK^@lI\CxADQ j E�H'KV@­I\S?C�@lMBy�CxQ j I\UgQ�U$O~���D³g� wD��S?KVEVC2I\SBC0KVQ~EVKLOmC0I\KVy�C1�NC � C0@��?H~Ug@�I\S?C�C0@?CxQ\AgZA j$� KV@�I\SBC��NCx@?UDy�KV@ j I�UDQi>.FeOTI\S?C¡HhC �Bj Q j I�K^Ug@�UDOTI\S?C­IJ��U j I\Ugy�H%KVH%K^@�W Q�C j H\Cx�I\S?C¡S?KVADS?CiHJI�U[WxW M � K^Ci� j @���I\S?C¡EVUs�+CiHJI�M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx�¾¹�´¾E^CxfDC0E�H�KV@¾I�S?C¡y�UgE^CiW M?EVCj$�?� Q�U j W�S6C j W�S�U$I�S?C0Q%OmM?Q\I\S?CxQ j @���OmM?QhI�S?C0Qi>�´NUBw���K^I\S�KV@BW0Q\C j H\K^@?A , I\SBC�C0@?CxQ\AgZA j$� KV@�I\SBC��NCx@?UDy�KV@ j I�UDQ�UDOY���D³l�YHhSBQ\KV@?]NH�y�UDQ�C j @���y�UgQ\Cgw�K£> Cg>.I�S?C�EVKLOmC0I\KVy�C�U$OI\S?C�C0�NW0KLI j I�K^Ug@BH���CiW UDy�CiH�E^Ug@?ADCxQ j @B� E^Ug@?ADCxQx>'��H­I\S?K�H­�NKVfDC0Q�ADCx@BW C¡K�H�@?U$I�OmM?EVE^ZW UDy � C0@BH j I�Cx�6�[Z�I\SBC­@lMBy�CxQ j I\UgQxw¤© D ' « ��CxW0UDy�CxH�E j Q�ADCxQ j @B��E j Q\AgC0Q���S?Cx@6I�S?Cj I\Ugy­H j Q�C�I j ]DC0@ jD�Bj Q\Ix>ÀRTS?KVH%C µ¶CxW I;�NU[CxH%@?U$I%Ug@?EVZ6H\S?Us� M � OmUDQ�E j Q�ADC ,�w.�BMNIj EVQ\C j �NZ�KV@½I�S?C�flK�W KV@?K^IJZ¾U$O�I\S?C�Ci¬gMBK^EVK^�BQ\KVM?y �NK�HhI j @�W CD>'��H j W0UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@BW Cgw�Ug@?C�NU[CxHT@?UDI2C0fDCx@� �@B� j EVUNW j E¤y�KV@?KVy%M?y#KV@�I�S?CYC0@?CxQ\AgZ�H\M?QhO j W Cg>

RTS?KVH � Q\Ug�?E^Cxy K�H'K^@lI�Q\KV@BH\KVW j EVE^ZYQ�C0E j I�Cx�%I\U�I\SBC�C �NKVHhI\Cx@BW CTUDO�I�S?C ��ZN�N��C0Q�A�H\C0Q�KVCxHK^@�I\S?CY¯1X~v¼H � CiWuI�Q\M?y�wl��S?K�W�S�UDQ�K^AgK^@ j I\CiH'OmQ�UDy8I\SBC � �IH , c£��C0S j flKVUDQ~U$O¤I\SBC�C � j WuI

Page 54: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

C �?W�S j @BADC � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E£>gRTS?C�W0UD@[fDCx@lI\KVUD@ j E?v�X+²�W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@�AgK^fgCxH�¬lM?K^I\C�Q\C j H\UD@ j �?E^CQ\CiHhM?E^I�H2OmUDQ w j H2I�S?C%M?@��NC0Q�E^Z[KV@?A ��k)� j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @��?UlCiH�@BU$I�Z[KVC0E�� j ��ZN�N��C0Q�AHhCxQ\KVCxHx>gRTS?C�H j y�C�� j H\KVW�C µ¶CxW I�H\S?Us�2H'M � KV@�f j Q�KVUDMBH � E j W CxH&%[¯�@BC2 B@B�BH0wgOmUDQ+C � j y�c� E^Cgw�I\S j I�I\SBC�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\KVUD@�C0@?CxQ\AgZ�UDO ��C%K�H �Bj QhI�KVW0M?E j Q�E^Z¡UsfDCxQ\CiHJI�K^y j I�Cx���[Z�© � �« w��S?KVW�S¡K�H��NM?C�I\U�I�S?C � Q�CxH\C0@BW0C�UDO�I\SBCYE^Us�TceE^Z[KV@?A�M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx��² ��HJI j I�CxHY�ÁW0UDy �Bj Q\CR j �?E^C �g� >�RTS?C � Q�CxH\C0@BW0C�U$O'I�S?C ��ZN�N��C0Q�A�H\C0Q�KVCxH2K�H�MBHhC0OmM?EÀOmUDQ2I�S?C�W j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@�U$Oy j @[Z j I\Ugy�KVW � Q\U � CxQhI�K^CiH0w[y�UgHhIT@?U$I j �?EVZ�OmUDQ�I\S?C��NCiH\W0Q\K � I\KVUD@�U$O�@BC0A j I\KVfDC�K^Ug@BH�UDQU$O~C0�NW0KLI�Cx�6HJI j I\CiH0>�¯�@�I\S?C�U$I�S?C0Q1S j @B�¤w¶KLIYK�H1@?U$I�fDCxQ\Z�S?CxE � OmMBE'KLO+I\S?C;I\Q�C j I\y�C0@lIU$O'W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�KVH�� j H\Cx��UD@�HhUgy�C�][KV@B�¡U$O � C0Q\I\MBQ\� j I\KVUD@�I\S?CxUDQ�ZD>

RTS?KVH�KVy�y�Ci�NK j I\CxE^Z�Q j K�HhCiH�I�S?C�¬lM?CiHJI�K^Ug@���S?C0I\S?CxQ�I�S?C;C0µ�CiWuI�K^fgC;Q�CxH\M?y�y j I\KVUD@U$O�I\S?C � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I\KVUD@�HhCxQ\KVCxHTf[K j I�S?C�Fh´[FTW j @�Q�CxH\UDEVfDC�I\SBKVHTOmMB@B� j y�Cx@gI j E � Q\Ug�?E^Cxy 'RTS?C�Fh´[F�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�K^@B�?C0Cx��E^C j �?H�I\U j ��UDMB@B� >,��Us�+CxfDCxQxw$K^I��?UlCiH�@?UDI � C0Q\OmUDQ�y�Bj Q\I\K�W M?E j Q�EVZ%��C0EVE?OmQ�UDy j ¬lM j @lI\K^I j I\KVfDC � UDKV@lI~U$O.f[KVC0�Y>gFeI+UsfDCxQ\CiHJI�K^y j I\CxH , ! y%MBW�Sy�UgQ\C�I\S j @¾I�S?C��[ceUD@?EVZ�W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@¾MB@B�NC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I�CxH�KLIi>'��I;I�S?C�H j y�C�I\KVy�C�I�S?C�NKVH�H\U[W0K j I\KVUD@�Cx@?C0Q�ADZ�K�H1y%MBW�S�I\U[U¡E j Q\AgC j @���I\SBC�f[KV�?Q j I\KVUD@ j EÀOmQ\Ci¬gMBC0@BW0Z¡Q�C ��CxWuI�HI\S?CYfgC0Q�Z�HhS j E^EVUs�*OmUgQ\y U$O�I\S?CYCx@?C0Q�ADZ�H\M?Q\O j W Cg>

k?UDQ2W0UDy � EVC I�C0@?CiH\HxwBR j �?EVC­�i² j E�H\U�W0UD@lI j K^@�H�I\S?C%H � CxWuI�Q\UlH\W0U � K�W1W UD@�HJI j @lI�H�Ug�NcI j KV@?Ci�6��K^I\S�I�S?C�´[F\�~cGº�n2�8OmUgQY��UDI\S�C �?W�S j @?ADC j @B��W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@.>¶FG@�I\S?K�H�W j EVW0MNcE j I\KVUD@6I\S?C­HhI j @�� j Q���y�UDEVCxW0M?E j Q1UDQ��?KLI j E�H1S j fDC���CxC0@�MBH\Cx��OmUDQ1I\S?C­Cxf j EVM j I�K^Ug@�U$OI\S?C��NW c£Cx@?C0Q�ADZ j @�� � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E¢w���K^I\S?UgMNI%OmM?Q\I\SBC0Q�E^UNW j E^KV° j I\KVUD@ � Q�CxH�W Q�K � I\KVUD@.>�RTS?CK^y � UDQ\I j @�W C�U$O�I\S?C­MB@?KLI j Q�KLIJZ � Q\Ug�?EVC0y �NK�H�W MBH�HhCi��KV@¾´[CxW I\KVUD@¾qN> ²�KVH�Ug�[flKVUDM�H0>¤FG@�Bj Q\I\K�W M?E j QiwI\SBC��NK�H\H\UNW K j I\KVUD@�C0@BC0Q�ADZ¾K�H�W Ugy � E^C0I\CxE^Z U$µ>+RTS?K�H � Q�UD�?EVC0y W j @ ��CI\Q j W Ci��I\U�I\S?CT´[F\��Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxH�U$ONI\SBC~y�UDEVCxW0M?E j QÀW0UDQ�C+HhI j I�CxH+§ �D²»¨�%iRTS?C��+UDM?EVUDy;�%W Ug@NcI\Q�K^�?M?I\KVUD@�I�U��J�xpl²D�2Q\CiHhM?E^I\KV@?A�OmQ\Ugy·I\S?C;IJ��U$cGW C0@lI�C0Q1y�UgE^CiW M?E j Q�W UgQ\C�HJI j I�CxH��J��:��[w�2:��[���?KLµ¶C0Q�H~H\M?�BHhI j @gI�K j E^EVZ�OmQ�UDy I\S j I~Ug�NI j K^@?Ci����KLI�S­I\SBC�UD@BC cGW C0@lI�C0Q j I�UDy�K�W2W UgQ\CHJI j I\CiHY�J� 6i� w j H � ±������� � �� ² � � ± � , �� � ± � , � �G���C j E^K�HJI�KVW2´NF\�~ceºÀn2� Q\CiHhMBELI�H�OmUDQ�y�UDEVCxW0M?EVCxH'UgQ�HhUgE^K��?H'W j @�UD@?EVZ���C2UD�NI j KV@?Cx��Ug@;I�S?C� j H\KVH�UDO�H\UDy�CTE^UNW j E^KV° j I\KVUD@ � Q\CiH\W0Q\K � I\KVUD@%OmUDQ�¬lM j HhK^ce�?C0ADCx@?C0Q j I�C~HhI j I�CxH�§ �$²s¨£>$´[MBW�S jH\W�S?Cxy�C~CxH�H\C0@lI\K j EVE^Z�W Ug@BH\KVHhI�H�U$O?MBH\K^@BA2I\SBC+EVUNW j EVKV°0Cx��EVKV@?C j Q�W0UDy%�BK^@ j I\KVUD@BH�U$O � ±�� �����OmUDQ�I\S?C�Cxf j E^M j I\KVUD@ U$O2I�S?C�´[F\�8OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E j @��½S j H;I\U���C j$�B� E^KVCx�¾I\U j EVE�W UgQ\Cj @B��H\C0y�KLcGW UgQ\C�HhI j I�CxHx>.FeI�K�HYUD�[f[K^UgMBH�I\S j I%HhM�W�S j�� Q\CiH\W0Q\K � I\KVUD@6��CiW Ugy�CiHYQ j I\SBC0Q�NK32�W0M?ELI�I�U�S j @B�NEVC;KV@�y�UgQ\C�W Ugy � E^K�W j I\Cx��y�UDEVCxW MBE^CiH�KV@[fDUgE^f[KV@?A�H\C0fDCxQ j E�IJZ � CxH1U$Oj I\Ugy­H0>.¯�@?C;I\S[MBH1S j H�I\U¡Q�C j EVKV°0C�I�S j I�@?Ug@?C;UDO�I\SBC � Q�CxH\C0@lI�E^Z j f j KVE j �?EVC%KVy � E^K�W K^IOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H~W j @­W Ugy � C0I\C2��K^I\S­I�S?C�HhI j @B� j Q���º�n2�*UDQ+bYb��*OmUDQ~W0Usf j E^Cx@lI\EVZ%��UD@B�y�UgE^CiW M?EVCxHx>

FG@�H\M?y�y j Q�Z%Ug@?C2W j @�H j ZYI�S j IiwD��S?KVEVC�¹�´ � CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@�I�S?C0UgQ\Z;U$µ¶C0Q�H j n�kR�NCxH�W Q�K � I\KVUD@ U$OY�NK�H � C0Q�HhKVUD@ OmUDQ�W CiH0w'y�UlHJI�UDI\S?CxQ­Q\CiHhM?E^I�H�UD�NI j KV@?Cx����K^I\S�I\S?K�H jD� c� Q\U j W�S j Q�C�H\UDy�C0��S j I%�NK�H jD�?� UDKV@gI�K^@BAB>ÀRTSBKVH;KVH �Bj Q\I\K�W MBE j Q\EVZ�Ug�lf[KVUDMBH%��S?C0@�Ug@?CI j ]gCxH�K^@lI\U j W0W0UDM?@lI2I�S j I�I\S?C�W Ugy � MNI j I\KVUD@ j EÀ�NCxy j @B�?H�U$O�k��T²sceW j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@BH j Q\C@?U$I��?KLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI�OmQ�UDy I�S?UgH\C�UDOW0UD@[fDCx@gI�K^Ug@ j E.v�X+²»cGW j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@�H0w j H2CxH�HhCx@gI�K j E^EVZ�I�S?CH j y�C1C0@BC0Q�ADZ�C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@�H�S j fgC�I�U;��C�Cxf j EVM j I�Cx�¤>?´[U�wN��SlZ�H\S?UgM?EV��UD@?C j$�?� E^Z­I�S?CHhCiW UD@���UgQ��NCxQ�¯1X+v jD�?� Q�U j W�S.wgQ j I�S?C0Q�I�S j @�I\S?CY��C0EVE^c£CiHJI j �?EVKVH\S?Ci��v�X�²%H�W�S?C0y�C�'

Page 55: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ �#�

RTS?CYK^@BKLI�K j E.S?U � C�� j H�I\S j I�I\S?C � C0Q\I\MBQ\� j I\KVUD@�HhCxQ\KVCxH�Ug@�I�S?CY� j HhK�H�U$O�I\S?C�¹�´�Q\C0O�cC0Q�C0@BW0C�HhZNHhI\C0y#W Ug@lfgC0Q�ADCiH�O j HJI�C0Q�I�S j @¡I\SBC%v�X � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@¡H\C0Q�KVCxHxw?HhU�I�S j I2I�S?CHhCiW UD@��­UDQ��NC0Q+I\CxQ\y¿K�HTHhM2­W0K^Cx@lI+OmUgQ�y�UlHJI � M?Q � UlHhCiH0>��2Us��C0fgC0Qiw j E^E¶Q�CxH\M?ELI�H~KV@�I\S?K�H´[CxW I\KVUD@�K^@B�?KVW j I\C�I�S j I�I�U�HhCiW UD@���UDQ��NCxQ�I�S?C�¹�´6HhCxQ\KVCxH1K�H�HhEVKVADSlI\EVZ�E^CiH\H j W0W0M?Q j I\CI\S j @�I�S?C�v�X C � �Bj @�HhKVUD@.>NFG@ j �B�NKLI�K^[email protected]@BC1S j H+I\S?C��?C0ADCx@?C0Q j W0Z � Q\Ug�?EVC0y j I�I�S?Ck?C0Q�y�K¤HhM?Q\O j W0CDwlKLO�© � �« KVH�W Ugy%�?KV@?Ci����K^I\S�I�S?C1C � j W I+C �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\C0@lI�K j E¢>B¯�@�I�S?CU$I\SBC0Q1S j @B�.w�K^O�I�S?C;¹�´ � CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@�C � �Bj @�HhKVUD@�K�H1@?U$I1� j H\Cx��Ug@�I\SBC;C0� j WuI1C �[cW�S j @?AgCDw.K^I��?UlCiH�@?UDI�W0UD@[fDCxQ\AgC j I j EVE�§ �g²s¨£>ÀFeI�I\S[MBH�H\C0C0y­H�I\S j I j @ jD�?� Q�U � Q�K j I\CK^y � EVKVW0KLITW UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@;OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E£wD��S?K�W�S�W UgM?E��­��C�MBHhCi�­��K^I\S­I�S?C2C � j WuI~C0�NW�S j @?AgCDwQ\Cxy j K^@�H�I\U���C�OmUgM?@B�¤>

� ��� � !(" ��* %���% * � %�� # * !(')*���'(��� #,*&������ "$+�� * ! � *&+���! +�� "&�

� %&* � �(+�*&+���# '#� � ���14 ��!$#,� � *&��� !(� +�� %&* % +���� % RTS?K�H�HhI j I\Cxy�Cx@lI�K�H­OmM?Q\I\S?CxQW UDQ�Q�UD��UDQ j I\Ci���[Z j @ j @ j E^ZNH\KVHYUDO�I\S?C � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E�W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��NK^@BA�I\U6© � « >�FG@¾I�S?Cj$�?� EVK�W j I�K^Ug@BH��NK�H�W MBH�HhCi��K^@�´[CiWuI�K^Ug@BH~oB>^� j @B��o?> ²�I\S?K�H'OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j EBS j H j E^� j ZNH���CxC0@j$�?� EVKVCx� � CxQhI�M?Q�� j I�K^fgC0EVZDw$Ug@;I�S?C2� j HhK�H'UDO¶H\C0E^OÁW Ug@BHhK�HhI\C0@lI~W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@BH'��K^I\S�I\SBC�C �[cj WuI�©TªN>��2Us��C0fgC0Qiw�I\S?C+M?E^I\KVy j I\C�AgU j E$U$O?¹�´ � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@1I\S?CxUDQ�Z�K�H¤I\SBC+�NCxQ\KVf j I\KVUD@U$O j W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@YOmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EN��S?K�W�S;W j @;��CTMBH\Cx�%H\C0E^OÁW Ug@BH\KVHhI\Cx@gI�E^ZgwsQ j I\S?CxQ�I�S j @ �JMBHhI��C j �?�NCx� ��� �"� � ���� ����>

RTS?C�y�UlHJI�W Ugy � E^K�W j I\Ci�½HhI\C � U$O j H\C0E^OÁW Ug@BHhK�HhI\C0@lI�I\Q�C j I\y�C0@lI­U$O�© � « KVH�I�S?CC0f j EVM j I�K^Ug@�U$O�I\S?C � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�W UgQ\Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A�I\U�K^I�H�© � $ <« cGW UDy � UD@?Cx@lI&%D=+H � CxW0K j E^EVZI\S?C�W j E�W M?E j I�K^Ug@�U$OÀI\S?C�¬lM j �NQ j I\K�W�Q\CiH � UD@BH\C�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@�� �?�»�+KVHTfgC0Q�Z��NC0y j @B�NKV@?A�K^@I\S?CYW j HhC1U$O�y�UDEVCxW MBE j Q�UgQ�H\UDEVK���HhI j I\C�HhZNHhI\C0y­Hx>?k?UgQhI�M?@ j I�C0EVZDwN© � $ <« I\MBQ\@BH�UgMNITI\U��C­y;MBW�S�Hhy j EVEVC0Q�I\S j @�© D ' « K^@�y�UgHhI%H\KLI�M j I�K^Ug@BH0w¤��SBKVW�S�H\M?ADAgCxHhI�H1KLI�HY@?CxADEVCxWuIi>v�UDQ�C0UsfgC0Qiw$© � $ <« f j @?K�HhSBCxH�K��NCx@gI�KVW j EVE^Z;OmUDQ�IJ�+UDc£CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@­H\ZNHJI�C0y­H0w j H�KV@�I\SBKVH�W j HhCI\S?C�Q�C0EVC0f j @lI�y j I\Q�KL��CxE^Cxy�Cx@lI�H1U$O+I\S?C�y%M?E^I\K � EVKVW j I�K^fgC�¯1X+v C �?W�S j @?ADC � UDI\Cx@gI�K j EW UDKV@BW0KV�NC���K^I\S*I�S?UgH\C�UDO�I\SBC�@BUD@?EVUNW j E���kÀc£IJZ � C � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E¢>�RTS[MBHxw+KV@ UDQ��NC0Q�I\Uj fDUDK���I�S?C j y%�?KVADMBKLIJZ j H\H\UNW K j I\Ci����KLI�S�I�S?C�@?C0AgE^CiWuI�U$O+© � $ <« w¶I\S?C��NK�H\W0MBH�HhKVUD@6K^@I\S?K�H�´[CiWuI\KVUD@�W0UDy � EVC I\CxE^Z�OmU[W0MBH\CxHTUD@¡IJ��U$ceC0EVCxW I\Q�UD@�H\ZNHJI�C0y­H0>�+C0OmUDQ�C�C0� j y�K^@?KV@?A�I\S?C�OmM?EVE�¯1X~v Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@¾OmUDQ­© D ' « wK^I�K�H�K^@�HJI�Q\MBW I\KVfDC�I\U

I j ]gC j W0E^UlHhCxQ�EVU[UD] j I�I�S?C�¹Yº.F jD�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I�K^[email protected] j H�K^I�Q�C0fgC j EVH%I\S?C�KV@?AgQ\Ci�NK^Cx@lI�HU$O ® D ' « � 3 © D ' « H 3 0 y�UDQ�C;W0E^C j Q�E^Z¾§ ²Dqs¨£>¶RTS?C­¹Yº.F�Q\CiHhM?E^I�H�OmUgQ ® D ' « UD�NI j KV@?Cx���KLI�S6I�S?C­C � j WuIY�[c£Ug@?EVZ6¯1X~v HJI j I\CiH�OmUDQ � B w ��CDw ��C � j @B��2C�� � j Q�C � EVU$IhI�Cx�K^@�k�KVADM?Q�C����[>[¯�@BC2 B@B�BH�I�S j I ® D ' , � 6��« �NK^fgC0Q�ADCiH j H\Z[y � I\U$I�KVW j EVE^Z;OmUDQ j EVE�H\ZNHJI�C0y­H�mKV@�I\SBC�W j HhC�U$O � B I\S?C1�NKVfDC0Q�ADCx@BW C�HhC0I�H+K^@�H\UDy�Cx��S j I+OmM?QhI�S?C0Q�UDM?I��u>l`¸S j I�K�H�I�S?CQ\C j H\UD@1OmUDQ¤I�S?K�H.M?@ � SlZNH\KVW j Eg��CxS j f[K^UgQ ' ��Cx�NM�W Cx�1I�U�I\SBC~y�UgHhI�CxH�H\C0@lI\K j E$KV@?AgQ\Ci�NK^Cx@lI�HI\S?C�¹Yº�F j$�B� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�S j H�I�S?C�HhI\Q�MBWuI�M?Q\C

® � 6��« ������� �0 ����� 5 / ��U/ ����� 3 ©�«

3 ��U/ ����� � K2K�K � �J�D�xrl�

RTS?C�C � � Q�CxH�H\K^Ug@6Ug@�I\S?C�Q�KVADSlIhceS j @���H\K��NC­@?Us�/S j HYI\U���C j @ j EVZl°xCx�6OmUDQ%E j Q\AgCR�À>k?UDQY© D ' « I\SBC�H\M?y¼UsfgC0Q ��Q\MB@BH1UsfDC0Q j EVEE^CxfDC0E�H1U$O�I�S?C�¹�´�H � CiWuI\Q�M?y�>¤FG@�UgQ��?C0QI\U�C0�lI�Q j WuI�I�S?C���C0S j f[KVUDQ2UDO�I�S?C�@[M?y�C0Q j I�UDQ2UDO2�J�D�xrl�+OmUgQ2E j Q\AgC ��I\S[MBH2IJ�+U­� j HhK�W

Page 56: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� : Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

����� �I�#�� �$Æ�Ö�ÉiÙlÊ�É0ÐhÊgÆ�Ð�Ö�É0ÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ�ÒNÉ0ÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏ�É-ZÈ+�É-�ÁÆ�ÏÍÆ�Ö\ÈGÐJÉiÙ�Ì �DÌeÈJÆ�ÇYÌ0��ضÆ�ÐGÈ��DÐ��[Î0ÈJËÍ×»ÆÆ�×iÎ0Ï �lÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ�É-Z �0? Y��£Î0ÒlÒDÐJÉ =DËÍÇ�Î0ÈJËÍÉxÙ�ÉiÙ�ÈJÅlÆR�lÎxÌGËÍÌ�ÉWZTÆ>=gÎxÖ\È =S�¢ÉxÙlÏ���É0Ð��lË ÈhÎxÏÍÌ�Ü~Ú Z�É0ÐYÈ��ÉW�Æ�ÏLÆ�Ö�ÈGÐJÉiÙ�Ì �DÌeÈJÆ�ÇYÌ %�8 X3:) _ % ��QX) Û\Ü

HhK^I\M j I\KVUD@BH�y%MBHhI���C6�NK�HJI�K^@BADM?K�HhSBCx�+%+FeO � W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��?H�I\U j @ M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx� EVC0fDCxE3 © D ' « H 3 � U/ �������NCiW j ZNH j HÀO j HhI j H�I�S?C�S?K^AgS?CxHhIU[WxW M � K^Ci�;¹�´%HJI j I\CF� < �ÁRTS?C�´[E j I\CxQK^@lI\CxADQ j E�H�KV@;=+¬�>V���D³g� j EV� j Z[H�E^KV@?] j @%M?@?UNWxW M � KVCx�;��K^I\S j @%UNWxW M � KVCx�;HJI j I�CDwsHhU�I\S j I�NKLµ¶C0Q�C0@lI�K j I\KVUD@���K^I\S�Q\CiH � CxW I�I�U�I�S?C;MB@?UNW0W M � K^Ci��HhI j I\C%�BQ\C j ]NH2I�S?C�K^@lI\CxADQ j E j @B�E^C j fDCxH j @YUNW0W0M � KVCx�YHhI j I�Ci� >xFeO �Y�NCx@?U$I�CxH j @YUNW0W0M � KVCx��EVC0fDCxE 3 © D ' « H 3 ��U/ �����.�NCiW j ZNHy�UgQ\C�H\EVUs��E^Z�I\S j @ � <À>¶¯�@�I�S?C�U$I�S?C0Q�S j @B�.w?I\SBC%�NC0@�HhK^IJZ�KV@�I\SBC%�NC0@BUDy�K^@ j I\UgQ2U$O�J�D�xrl�+��C0S j fgCxH�E^KV]DC 1 � <À����� 1 >�RTSlM�H2¬lM j EVKLI j I�K^fgC0EVZ­UD@?C1 B@B�BH

® D ' , � 6��« ���¶� � 1 � < ���¶�F� � OWHu«G« ���¶� 11 � <������ 1 � �J�D�»qD�

��H j E^E�MB@?UNW0W M � K^Ci��HJI j I\CiHY�NCxW j Z�y�UDQ�C­HhEVUs��E^Z�I\S j @ � <�w ® D ' , � 6��« �NK^fgC0Q�ADCiH�OmUgQE j Q\AgC\�À>

¯�@?C2y�K^AgSlI� BQ�HJI~SBU � C2I\S j I�I�S?KVH��NKVfDCxQ\AgC0@BW0C�KVH j W Ug@BHhCi¬lM?C0@BW0C�U$O¤I�S?C�¹Yº�F jD� c� Q\U»�NKVy j I\KVUD@�>id�@NOmUDQ\I\M?@ j I\CxE^Z�I�S?K�HKVH�@?UDI�I�S?C�W j HhCg>s¯�@?CTW j @%C0� � E^K�W K^I\EVZ�fDCxQ\K^OmZ�I\S j II\S?C��?K^fgC0Q�ADC0@�W C�KVH � Q�CxH\C0@lI���KLI�S?KV@�I\S?C�OmM?E^E�¯1X~v § ²Dq»¨e>�kBUDQYI�S?C�W EVUgH\Cx�NceH\M?�BH\S?C0EVEj I\Ugy­H�W0UD@BH\K��NC0Q�Cx��K^@�I\S?K�H2´[CiWuI\KVUD@�I\SBC�¯1X+v¼Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@�Q\Ci�NMBW0CxH+I\U j Q j �NK j E¶K^@lI\C0cADQ j E¶Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@�§ ³$¨£w

' �� )T,�.�� � ,�7I,/. � ® ª «s� ,/. �8���1ª «s� , � 7 �J�D�iog�

��KLI�S j Q j �NK j E¤Q�CxH � UD@BH\C�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ � j @B� j W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��NK^@BA;KV@?S?Ugy�UgADCx@?C0K^IJZ�� ª « w

� � ,�7I,/. �9� 3 § r&: , 0 � , �e¨3 ®�� � , . � �J�D���$�

� ª « � , �4� 5/

� ' )Q, . 3 © ª «3 � / � , . � 3�/N� , . �3 ®�� � , � � � © ª «

� � / 3 � /3 ®�� � , �� � �J�D���g�

�2C0Q�C � /%�NC0@?UDI\CiH~I�S?C1Q j �NK j E �Bj QhI�U$O.I�S?C�¹�´�UDQ��?K^I j E£w � / ���­���¶��� � /N� , � # ��­��Y� H ,� � /�K�HW�S?UgH\C0@YI�U���C�Q\C j E��u>�+UDI\S � � ,�7I, . � j @���� ª « � , ��W j @���CTC0� � E^K�W K^I\EVZY��Q\K^IhI�C0@;K^@

Page 57: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ � �

I\C0Q�y­H.UDONI\S?C � / � , � j @B�1I\SBC+W UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A2H\CxW0UD@B�­�Á@?UD@Nce@?UgQ\y j EVKV° j �BE^C»�¶HhUgE^MNI�K^Ug@BH / � , ��U$O�I�S?CYQ j �NK j E.¹�´�Cx¬lM j I\KVUD@BH�OmUgQTI\S?C�¹�´�C0KVADCx@lf j E^M?CiHY§ ³$¨£>¯�@½I�S?KVH�� j H\KVH�@?Us� j � ��"� ��� �� � ��� ��� � � � � ������K^EVE2��C�MBH\Cx�½I\U�HhSBUs� I\S j I

® D ' « � , ���NKVfDC0Q�ADCiH2OmUgQ�E j Q\AgC , >.º.C0IYMBH j H�HhMBy�C;I\S j I ® D ' « �NU[CiH�@BU$I��NKVfDC0Q�ADCgw¤HhUI\S j I ® D ' « W j @���C�W�S?UlHhCx@�I�U�H j I\K�HJOmZ

® D ' « � , � � =� @!A p � � ® ª « � , �2� ® ª � , � � ® D ' « � , � � =

� @EA pF� �J�D���g�

`¸KLI�S�I\S?K�H j H�HhMBy � I\KVUD@�UD@?C1 B@��?HY§ r$�i¨

' �� )T,�. � � ,�7I,/. � ® � � � ,�. � � =� @!A - < 1 � <�� , � 1 �' C� )T,�. � <�� ,�. � (<�� ,/. �� ' �� )T,/. . 1 � <�� ,�. . � 1 ® ��� � ,�. . �C� �J�i²Dpg�

RTS?C j H\Zly � I�U$I�KVW1��C0S j f[KVUDQTU$OÀI\S?CYEVC O�I\c£S j @B�¡HhK��NCYU$OÀI\S?C%¯1X+v Ci¬gM j I\KVUD@��J�g�xol��K�HI\S[MBH�W0UD@lI\Q�UDEVE^Ci���[Z�I�S?C � Q�U[�?MBWuIYU$O�I\SBC��NC0@BH\K^IJZ�U$O+I\S?C­S?KVADSBCxHhI�U[WxW M � K^Ci�6HhI j I\Cj @B� j @;K^@B�?C  B@?K^I\CTKV@lI\C0AgQ j E[UsfDC0Q

� <À� , � <� , �uwg��S?K�W�S%K�HUD@?EVZY�+C j ][EVZ , cG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lIi>RTS?CxH\C , cG�NC � Cx@B�NC0@lI�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@BH j Q�C�y%M?E^I\K � EVK^Ci���lZ j W UD@�HJI j @lIxw¤��S?K�W�S�KVH1I�S?C­UDQ\c�?KLI j EÀC � � CiWuI j I\KVUD@�f j E^MBC�U$O ® ª «»>�=+¬�>��J�»²$pl��KVH�HhC �Bj Q j I�C0EVZ�f j EVKV�¡OmUgQ�C0�NW�S j @?AgC j @B�W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�>DFeOÀUg@?C��NK^f[K��NCxH�I�S?C�¯1X~v¼Ci¬lM j I�K^Ug@�OmUDQ�© D ' « �[Z�I\S j ITOmUDQ�I\S?C1C � j WuIC �?W�S j @BADC1UD@?C�C0@��?H�M � ��K^I\S

E^KVyC ���

� D ' « � , ��1ªN� , � � E^KVy

C ���� �� )T, . � � ,�7I, . � ® D ' « � , . �� �� )T, . . � � ,�7 , . . � ® ª?� , . . �� � �� )Q, . 1 � <�� , . � 1 ® D ' « � , . �

� �� )T, . . 1 � <À� , . . � 1 ® ª?� , . . � � � � �J�i²?�i�

X�Q�UsflK��NCi��I\S j II\S?C j H�H\M?y � I\KVUD@¡�J�D���g��KVHW0UDQ�Q\CiWuIxwxI\SBC�Q j I�K^U � D ' « � , � H ��ªB� , ��y%MBHhIj$�?� Q�U j W�S j W Ug@BHhI j @lITOmUDQ�E j Q�ADC , >

RTS?KVH�Q j I�K^U�W j @���C�C0� j y�K^@?Ci��@[M?y�C0Q�K�W j EVEVZDwlQ\CxE^Z[KV@?A;Ug@�HhI j @B� j Q��� B@BKLI�C��?KLµ¶C0Q\cC0@BW0CxH�y�C I�S?UN�?H�OmUDQ�I�S?C­C0f j E^M j I\KVUD@�U$O�I\S?C­Q j �?K j E�KV@?S?Ugy�UDADCx@?C0K^I\KVCxHx> ��CiHhM?E^I�H1OmUgQ�2C j Q�C�H\S?Us��@¾KV@ k�K^AgM?Q�CxH���� j @B�*���?>ak?UgQ�H\KVy � E^K�W K^IJZDwUD@BE^Z�I\SBC¡W0UD@lI\Q�K^�BMNI\KVUD@U$O�I�S?C;MB@?UNW0W M � K^Ci�.��ZN�N��C0Q�A�HJI j I\CiH2I�U � D ' « K�H�KV@BW0E^MB�?Cx��KV@�I�S?CxH\C � E^UDI�Hxw¶��S?K^EVCI\S?C�W Ug@gI�Q\KV�?MNI�K^Ug@­U$O¤I�S?C1W0UD@lI\KV@[M?M?y¿HhI j I�CxH�I\U�I�S?C�W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A�HhMBy�H+KV@�© D ' «j @B�¡=~¬�>��J�D���g�+K�HT@?C0AgE^CiWuI\Ci�6�¢W Ugy ��j Q�C�I�S?CYQ�CxH\M?ELI�KV@BW EVMB�NKV@?A�W0UD@lI\KV@[M?M?y HhI j I\CxH2K^@��C OJ>�§ ²gq»¨m�u>.k�KVADM?Q�C����� BQ�HhIYU$O j EVE��NC0y�UD@�HJI�Q j I\CxH�I�S?C­W UD@[fgC0Q�ADC0@�W C%UDO � D ' « ��K^I\SK^@BW0Q\C j H\K^@BA­@lMBy%��C0Q2UDO �2Z[�?��CxQ\A�EVC0fgC0E�H0>���H2KV@�I�S?C%W j HhCYUDO�© D ' « K^I�H\C0E^OJw�H\M?y�y j cI\KVUD@�M � I�U�I�S?C;H\S?C0EVE���K^I\S 0 �8�xp � Q\Usf[K��NCxH2CxH�HhCx@gI�K j E^EVZ�I�S?C;W0UDy � EVC I�C�Q\CiHhMBELIi>�FG@j �?�NK^I\KVUD@�w�k�KVADM?Q�C����­K^EVEVMBHJI�Q j I\CiH2I�S?C;UlH\W0K^EVE j I\UgQ\Z�@ j I�M?Q�C%U$O �1ª «i� , � %¤FG@�O j WuIxw j H jW UD@�HhCi¬gMBC0@BW0CYU$O�=~¬�>��mr��D�uwNI�S?C%Q j �?K j E.K^@lI�C0ADQ j E¤UsfgC0Q ��ª «�y%M�HJI�f j @?KVH\S.w j H�EVUD@?A j HUD@?EVZ��NK�H\W0Q\C0I\CYHhI j I�CxH j Q\C�KV@lfgUDEVfDCi�¤w

' �� )T, �1ª «i� , �2�¸p �

Page 58: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

� � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

-0.003

-0.002

-0.001

0

0.001

0.002

0.003

0.004

0.005

0.006

0.007

0.1 1 10 100��� �������

�� �������� �������� �������� ��������� ��� � !"�#%$

� ������'&)(*

����� �I !�� Y£ÙgÅlÉxÇYÉ��iÆ�ÙlÆ�Ë È��;É-Z¤ÈJÅgÆ�ÐhÎiÊgËLÎ0Ï.ÑTØ��¿ËÍÙsÈJÆ �xÐhÎ0϶Æ�6��[Î ÈJËLÉxÙRZ�É0Ð �+Æ#� � ÉxÙ$ÈGÐJË��T�gÈJËÍÉiÙÉWZ 7!�gÊT�NÆ\Ð ��ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆ�Ì�ÈJÉ,+ �SX) ×»Æ\ÐJÌ �lÌ2Æ>=gÎxÖ�È1Æ>=DÖ\ÅlÎxÙ,�iÆ�Ú%+ & ËÍÌ1ÌGÖ�ÎxÏÍÆuÊ �I� ` "� X Û\Ü�+ ��QX)ËÍÌ��iËÍ×»Æ�Ù Z�ÉxÐ Z�É-�gÐ1ÊgË Õ?Æ�ÐJÆ�ÙsÈ�ÌGÆ�ÈJÌ�É-Z��gÙlÉsÖ�Ö �gÒlËÍÆuÊ¡ÌeÈhÎ ÈJÆ�Ì�ËLÙ�ÈJÅlÆYÖ�É0ÐGÐJÆ�ÌGÒNÉiÙlÊgËÍÙ��­Ì �gÇYÌ�ËÍÙ( �SX) ÎxÙlÊ�Ô 6[ÜLÚ `c` � Û\Ü Y£Ù­ÉxÐhÊDÆ�Ð�ÈJÉ�Ö�É ×»Æ\Ð�ÈJÅlÆ ��ËLÊgÆ�ÐhÎxÙ��xÆ�ÉWZ.-YÏÍÉ��»Î0ÐJË ÈJÅgÇYËLÖ��xÐJËLÊgÌ�É-Z �lÒÈJÉ : � "�"�ÒNÉiËÍÙsÈJÌ�Å[Îu×»ÆG�NÆ�Æ�ÙR�lÌGÆ�ÊBÜ

1e-50

1e-45

1e-40

1e-35

1e-30

1e-25

1e-20

1e-15

1e-10

1e-05

1

10 100/10 2�3�4�576

8�9�:<;�=8�9�:<;�>8?9�:<;�@A

B CED%FGB0 2�3�4�5IHJ76

����� �I *�� A~Ì �DÇYÒgÈJÉxÈJËÍÖ;�NÆ�Å[Îu×$ËÍÉxÐYÉWZK+ & ) Z�É0Ð���Æ#� � ÉxÙ$ÈGÐJË��T�gÈJËÍÉiÙ�É-Z@7!�gÊQ�NÆ�Ð ��ÌeÈhÎ0ÈJÆ�Ì�ÈJÉ+ �SX) ×iÆ�ÐJÌ �lÌYÆ>=gÎ0Ö�ÈL+ & ÜÀÄ�É¡ÎxÏÍÏÍÉ � ZVÉxÐ;Î�ÏÍÉ��iÎ0ÐJË ÈJÅlÇYËÍÖ­ÌGÖuÎ0ÏÍÆ�ÈJÅlÆ­ÎW�lÌGÉiÏ��DÈJÆ�×iÎ0Ï��lÆ�Ì�Î ÐJÆÒgÏÍÉxÈGÈJÆuÊ¡Ú�ÈJÅgÆTÓ�Æ�ÐJÉxÌ�É-Z�+ �SX) Î0ÐJÆ�Ì �gÒlÒgÐJÆ�ÌGÌGÆuÊ[Û\Ü

RTS?C j H\Z[y � I\UDI\K�W���C0S j f[KVUDQ�UDO�� D ' « w���S?KVW�S KVH�U$O�KV@lI\C0Q�CxHhI�KV@¸I\SBC � Q�CxH\C0@lIW UD@lI�C �[Ixw'K�H � E^UDIhI�Cx��K^@ k�K^AgM?Q�C6���?>'k?UgQ­E j Q\AgC , Ug@?C� B@B�?H�I�S j I�� ª � , ��AgU[CxH�ADUI\U�°xC0Q�U�C0� � UD@BC0@lI\K j EVE^Z¸� j H;KVH;K^y�y�Cx�?K j I\C0EVZ¾W EVC j Q�OmQ�UDy =~¬[Hx>V�£²D²g�uw��¢² �l�h� >¯�@¾I�S?CU$I\SBC0Q¡S j @B�.w~I�S?C6��C0S j flKVUDQ�U$O � D ' « � , ���?C � C0@B�?H¡Ug@¸I\S?C�S?KVADS?CiHJI¡M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx�HJI j I\CYKV@BW0E^MB�?Cx�+%�RTS?C�y�UDQ�C ��ZN�N��CxQ\A­EVC0fgC0E�H j Q�C1I j ]DC0@�KV@lI\U j W0W UgM?@lIxw[I�S?CYOmM?Q\I\S?CxQUDMNI'I�S?CTC � � Ug@?C0@lI�K j E?�NCxW j Z%HhC0I�HKV@.>$FG@�O j W Ixw$k�KVADM?Q�C����1K^@��NKVW j I�CxH�I\S j I j W Ugy � E^C0I\CQ\CiHhM?y�y j I�K^Ug@�U$O j EVE&��ZN�N��C0Q�A�HJI j I\CiH'EVC j �BHI\U j�� Us��C0Q'E j ���NCiW j Z�UDO � D ' « � , � >gFG@j @[Z�W j H\CDw¶CxfDC0@�KLO�UD@?EVZ j Q�CxHhI\Q�KVW I\Ci��@[M?y%��C0Q1U$O+M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx��HJI j I\CiH�K�H1K^@�W EVMB�NCx�.w

Page 59: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ ���

� D ' « � , ��f j @?K�HhSBCxH.y;MBW�SYy�UDQ�C�HhEVUs��EVZ2I\S j @��1ªN� , � >»RTSBC�Q j I\KVU���C0IJ�+CxC0@�� D ' « j @B��1ª?� , ���?K^fgC0Q�ADCxH.C � � Ug@?C0@lI�K j E^EVZDwxK^@%W0UD@lI\Q j �?KVW I\KVUD@1I\U%�h�i²?�i�u>iRTS?K�H�Q�CxH\M?E^IÀW j @ j E�HhU���CfDC0Q�K^ BCx� j @ j E^ZlI�KVW j EVE^Zgw j H1E^Ug@?A j H�UD@BE^Z j  B@BKLI�C�@[M?y;��CxQ�U$OT�NK�H\W0Q\C0I\C�M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx�HJI j I\CiH¡KVH�W Ug@BH\KV�NCxQ\Ci�¤>2�+UD@BH\Cx¬lM?Cx@gI�E^Zgw~I�S?C j H�HhMBy � I\KVUD@ �h�D���l�­y;MBHJI���C6��Q�UD@BABw��S?KVW�S�KVy � E^KVCxH�I�S j I ® D ' « �NKVfDCxQ\AgCxH+OmUDQ�E j Q�ADC , > �

FeI�KVH�I�C0y � I�K^@?A�I�U j H�HhUNW0K j I\C�I\S?K�H��NKVfDCxQ\AgC0@BW0C;��K^I\S�I�S?C­MBH\C­U$O�HhCiW Ug@B��UgQ��?C0Q� CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@�I�S?C0UgQ\Z %�¯�@BC�W UgM?EV��� j H\KVW j EVE^Z j Q�ADM?C�I�S j I�I�S?C j HhZ[y � I�U$I\K�W�Q�C0ADKVUD@KVH j EVUs�¦�NCx@BH\KLIJZ�Q\CxADKVy�CgwN��S?KVE^C�I�S?C � CxQhI�M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@¡C0� �Bj @BH\KVUD@¡KVH�IJZ � K�W j E^EVZ j S?KVADS�NC0@BH\K^IJZ�C0� �Bj @BH\KVUD@.>l`¸KLI�S?KV@�I\SBKVH � S[ZNHhK�W j E^EVZ�y�U$I\KVf j I�Cx� � K�WuI�M?Q�C�K^I�K�H+@?U$ITHhM?Q � Q�KVHhcK^@?A�I\S j I�OmUgQ�E j Q�ADC , I\SBC+H\CxW Ug@B��UDQ��NCxQ.C � �Bj @BHhKVUD@YZ[KVC0E��?H j @?UD@?c � S[ZNH\KVW j E � U$I�C0@lI\K j E£>�2Us��C0fDCxQxwBUD@?C%H\S?UgM?EV����C j � j Q�C1I\S j I�I�S?C�� j HhK�WYy�CxW�S j @?K�Hhy#��S?K�W�S�E^C j �?H2I\U�I�S?C�NK^fgC0Q�ADCx@BW C­UDO ® D ' « K�H j EVH\U � Q�CxH\C0@lIYOmUDQ j @[Z�UDI\S?CxQ�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E~��S?K�W�S�EVK^@?]NH%U[W cW M � KVCx�¡��K^I\S�M?@BU[WxW M � K^Ci�¡¹�´¡HhI j I\CxH j I�I\SBC�H j y�C � UDKV@lI ��w?KV@BW0E^MB�?K^@?A­Q�CxH\M?y�y�Cx�OmUDQ�y�HTUDOÀI�S?C � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@¡H\C0Q�KVCxHx>

� ���(��* � � "$+�� %�� # * !(' *���'(��� #,*&������ "$+�� * ! � *�+���! +���" � �2Us� W j @�UD@?C j fDUgKV�I\S?C j H\Z[y � I\U$I�KVW1�NKVfDCxQ\AgC0@BW0C2U$O ® D ' « � 3 © D ' « H 3 0 j @B��Q�C0E j I�Cx� � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�H '1FeI�K�HUD�[f[K^UgMBH2OmQ�UDy·I�S?C­�NK�H\W0MBH\H\KVUD@�UDO�I\S?C � Q�CxW0Cx�NKV@?A�´[CxW I\KVUD@6I\S j I j y�U[�?KL �W j I�K^Ug@�U$OI\S?C�¯1X~v � Q�UNW Cx�?M?Q\C�K�H�Q\Ci¬gMBK^Q�Cx�¤w¶K^O+Ug@?C�� j @gI�H�I\U�]DCxC � I�S?C­C0@BC0Q�ADZ�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j EKLI�HhCxELO1M?@BW�S j @?ADCi�¤>'��H\M?K^I j �BE^C�y�UN�NKL �W j I�K^Ug@½K�H�y�UlHJI­C j H\K^EVZ�K^@lI\Q�UN�NMBW0Cx�¾Ug@½I�S?CE^CxfDC0E¤UDOÀI�S?CYKV@B�NKVflK��NM j E �Bj KVQ2W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�Cx@?C0Q�ADKVCxH � D ' � � w

� D ' � � � � �² 5 / , � �J� � - / � �J� � - � � ���� 1 1 � �¢� §V��� � 1 1 ��� � � ��� � 1 1 � � �G¨� � � � � � � / � ��� �J�i²g²D�

� � © D ' « �65� , �- � - � � D ' ��� �

RTS?C�� j H\KVW1HJI�Q\M�WuI\MBQ\C�U$O(� D ' ��� KVHTH\UDy�C0��S j I�H\K^y�KVE j Q~I�U%I�S j I�UDO.I\S?CYb1Q�C0C0@ . H+OmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ �£²Dqg����S?K�W�S6H\M?ADAgCxHhI�H�I\U j$�?� EVZ j W0E^UlHhMBQ\C j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@¾�£���1��K^@ j @ j E^UgADZI\UYI�S?C�¹Yº�F jD�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I�K^Ug@¡�£q$³l�uwlK¢> CD>DI\U jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�CTI\S?C1�NC0@?Ugy�K^@ j I\UgQ�K^@6�J�i²g²D��lZ�HhUgy�C j fgC0Q j ADC�C0KVADCx@lf j E^M?CY�NK^µ¶C0Q�C0@BW0CDw

� � � � � � � / � ��� � �R� ���O�I\CxQ�I�S?K�H2Q�C � E j W0C0y�C0@lI2UD@BC%W j @�MBHhC�I\S?C%W0UDy � EVC I�C0@?CiH\H�U$OI\S?C�¹�´�H � CxW I\Q�M?y�I\UC0EVK^y�KV@ j I�C j EVE¤M?@?UNW0W0M � KVCx��HJI j I�CxH�OmQ�UDy �h�i²D²g�uw

� �9� � � � �² ��R� � � ��� 1 1 1 ��� � � � ��� 1 1 1 � � � � 5

/ , �- / - � � ��� 1 1 � �¢�0§^��� � 1 1 ��� � � ��� � 1 1 � � �G¨I�

�J�i²D³g���ÄÅlÆ'ÉxÙlÌGÆ�È�ÉWZNÈJÅlËÍÌ�ÊDËÍ×»Æ�Ð �iÆ�ÙlÖ�Æ'ËÍÌ.Æ�×»Æ�Ù1×DËÍÌGË��lÏÍÆ'ËÍÙ1ÈJÅgÆ��[ÎxÌGËÍÌ�ÌGÆ�È.ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ ÈJÌEZ�É0Ð % �SX) ÌGÅgÉ ��ÙËÍÙ?�¶Ë �gÜ �ÉWZ 7+ÆIZ£Ü39 �c < b ËÍÙ�ÌGÒlË ÈJÆ�É-Z'ÈJÅgÆMZ�Î0Ö�È2ÈJÅ[Î È�Î �[Î0ÌGËÍÌ�ÌGÆ�È�ÐJÆ�ÒgÐJÆ�ÌGÆ�ÙsÈhÎ ÈJËLÉxÙ�É-Z % �SX)�lÏ ÈJËÍÇ�Î0ÈJÆ�Ï ��ÈGÐ��gÙlÖuÎ ÈJÆ�Ì'ÈJÅlÆ�ÊDËL×iÆ�Ð �iÆ�ÙsÈ~Î0Ì �gÇYÒDÈJÉxÈJËÍÖG�NÆ�ÅlÎu×DËÍÉ0ÐuÜ

Page 60: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

: " Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

��KLI�S�I�S?CYy j I�Q\K^��C0EVC0y�Cx@gI

� ��� 1 1 1 � �£�8� '*)+W, ± '*)+-, ��U� ��� ± �I� /B��� ± � ��U� ��� � ���h��� �1 � ± � � 1 �J�i²$rl�

��I\SBCxH\C�S?KVADS?CxQ+UgQ��?C0Q��+UgM?E^Ugy%�­KV@lI\C0AgQ j EVH+W j @­��C1C0f j EVM j I\Cx����K^I\S�I\S?C1H j y�C�y�C I�SNcU[�BH j HMBH\Cx�%OmUDQI�S?C�HJI j @B� j Q���´[E j I�C0QK^@lI�C0ADQ j E�H��u>s`¸K^I\S�I\S?C�W0E^UlHhM?Q�C j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\Cx��Bj KVQhcGW UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@­C0@?CxQ\AgK^CiHTUD@?CYW j @�I\S?Cx@¡Q�C0��Q�K^I\CY© D ' « KV@�I�S?C�OmUDQ�y

© D ' « � 5� , �- � - ��� ��� � �9� � 7 �J�i²gqD�

��KLI�S�I�S?CY��C0KVADSlI�H� ��� AgK^fgC0@¡�lZ

� ��� �)� D ' � � H � �9��� � �J�i²Dog�

d2@lI\KVE¶@?Us� © D ' « S j H�UD@BE^Z���C0C0@�Q\CiW j HJIiwg�?M?IT@BU$ITy�UN�NK^ BCi�¤w j H � �9��� j @B��I\S[MBH �R��NQ\U � UgMNI2U$OT�J�i²gqD� >[RTSBC�W0Q\M�W K j E¤HJI�C � KVH�I�S?CYS j @B�NEVK^@?A�UDO�I\SBC�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E��h�i²Dqg�+K^@I\S?C�¯1X~v � Q�U[W0Cx�NMBQ\Cg>xRTS?C'OmUgQ\y/�J�»²Dqg�¤HhMBADADCiHJI�H¶I\U�Q\CiHJI�Q\K�WuI.I�S?C�¯1X+v/f j Q\K j I�K^Ug@1I\UI\S?C+UDQ��?KLI j E^ce�?C � C0@B�NCx@BW C'UDO � �9��� wi��S?KVE^C~]DC0C � KV@?ATI\S?C+�+CxK^AgSlI�H

� ���  ?�NCx��I�S?Q\UgM?ADSBUDMNII\S?C�W UDy � EVC I�C;H\UDEVMNI\KVUD@�U$O��¢²��$�%§ ²gq»¨e>BFG@�I�S?KVH�� j Z�I�S?C;MB@?UNW0W M � K^Ci��¹�´�HhI j I\CxH��NU@?UYE^Ug@?ADCxQ~W Ug@lI\Q�K^�?M?I\CTI\U�I�S?C , cG�NC � C0@B�?C0@BW0C�U$O�I\SBC2K^@BS?UDy�UDAgC0@?CxKLIJZ¡�¢² �g�uw$I\S?CxZ j Q\CUD@?EVZ�Q�Cx¬lM?KVQ\Ci��OmUgQTI\S?CYCxf j E^M j I\KVUD@¡U$O

� � � >RTS?C � U$I�C0@lI\K j E�Ug�NI j K^@BCx� ��KLI�S½I�S?KVH­H�W�S?Cxy�C�OmUDQ �C�KVH�H\S?Us��@ KV@ kÀKVADMBQ\C�²$p��I\SBKVHYQ�CxH\M?E^IYKVHY¬lM?K^I\C�W�S j Q j WuI�C0Q�KVHhI\K�WYOmUgQ j EVE j I\Ugy­H1W0UD@BH\K��NC0Q�Cx��HhU�O j Qu�u>.RTSBC�W EVU$c

���� ����� �����

� � ����� �

����� �� I���� É0ÐGÐJÆ�ÏLÎ0ÈJËÍÉiÙ%ÒNÉxÈJÆ�ÙsÈJËLÎxÏgÉ-Z Æ�ÉiÙ�� � ÏÍÉiÌ �DÐJÆ�Î0ÒlÒgÐJÉ =DËÍÇ�Î0ÈJÆuÊ % �SX) Ú�� � � < � ATÛ 9 � � <×iÆ�ÐJÌ �lÌ1Ø���� ` �����1A 9 �2�;< b � � 9 � < Î0Ù[Ê�Æ>=gÎxÖ�È!9 � � < ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ È�ÚmÎ0ÏLÏ Z �lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙ[Î0ÏÍÌYÅ[Îu×»Æf�NÆ�Æ�ÙÆ�×iÎ0Ï �lÎ0ÈJÆuÊ ��ËÍÈJÅ%ÈJÅlÆ�Æ>=gÎ0Ö�È ��%É0Ð��lË ÈhÎxÏÍÌhÛ\ÜHhM?Q�C j$�?� Q\U»�NKVy j I\Ci� ® D ' « K�H­W Ugy ��j Q�Cx�¾��K^I\S�I�S?C�W UgQ\Q�CxH � Ug@B�NKV@?A6X~` �?�0cGbYb��j @B� �T´ � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E�H j H%��C0EVE j H%I\S?C�C0� j WuI ® « w��S?K�W�S½S j H;��CxC0@�C �[I\Q j W I\Cx��OmQ\Ugyv�UD@lI\C0cJ� j Q\EVU�W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@�H%§ q,�i¨e>BFeI�K�H�Ug�lf[KVUDMBH2OmQ\Ugy#k�KVADM?Q�C�²Dp�I\S j I�@BC0K^I\S?CxQ�I�S?C

Page 61: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ : `bYb��/@?UDQ�I�S?C��T´ � U$I�C0@lI\K j E'S j fDC�y%MBW�S�K^@�W0UDy�y�UD@���KLI�S6I�S?C�C � j W I ® «iw���S?K^EVCI\S?C¡y�U[�?KL BCi�¾H\CxW Ug@B��UgQ��NCxQ � U$I�C0@lI\K j E ® D ' , �9« Q�C � Q�UN�NMBW CiH�K^I�H;y j KV@�OmC j I\M?Q�CxH&%® D ' , �9« KVH � UlHhK^I\KVfDC�KV@�I\SBC�f j EVC0@BW0C�Q\CxADKVUD@ j @���OmUDEVE^Us�2H�I�S?C�H\S?C0EVE+HhI\Q�MBW I\M?Q�C�U$OI\S?C�C � j W I ® «»>gd2@?OmUDQ\I\M?@ j I\CxE^ZgwgK^I+W EVC j Q\EVZ�UsfDC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I�CxH�I\SBC�H\S?C0EVEBUlH\W0K^EVE j I\KVUD@BH j @B��NCxW j Z[H;I�UlU�H\E^Us��EVZ�OmUDQ­E j Q�ADC , >~FG@ �Bj QhI�KVW0M?E j QiwÀI�S?K�H�E j IhI\CxQ��NC  �W KVC0@BW0Z � Q�C0fDCx@lI�HI\S?C��NKVQ\CiWuI�MBHhC�U$O ® D ' , �9« KV@ j$�B� E^K�W j I\KVUD@BHx>2C0fgC0Q\I\S?CxE^CiH\Hxw ® D ' , �9« K�H�I�S?C; BQ�HhIn�kR/W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@ � UDI\Cx@gI�K j E���S?K�W�S�HhS?Us�2H j IYE^C j HhI%¬gM j EVKLI j I\KVfDC j ADQ�C0C0y�Cx@gI���K^I\SI\S?C�C � j WuI+Q�CxH\M?E^Ixw[Q�C �BCiWuI\KV@?A;I\S?C� BQ�HJI\c � Q\KV@BW K � EVCxH+UDQ�K^AgK^@�U$OÀ© � « >[FG@ j �?�NK^I\KVUD@�wlUg@?CW UDMBEV��S?U � C�I�S j IYI�S?C�¬lM j @lI�KLI j I\KVfDC j ADQ�C0C0y�Cx@gI�W j @���C�KVy � Q�UsfDCx�6�[Z j H\M?KLI j �?EVCQ\CiHhM?y�y j I�K^Ug@ U$O�I\S?C � CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVUD@¸H\C0Q�K^CiH�� j @B�¤w � C0Q�S jD� H0w j Q\C0 B@?Ci��W�SBUDK�W C�U$O� ��� � >

� �­�\| �� � � ��� �

FeO�UD@?C�W Ugy%�?KV@?CiH�I�S?C�Q\CiHhM?E^I�H+U$O´[CxW I\KVUD@�³;��K^I\S�I�S?UgH\C1U$O�´[CiWuI�K^Ug@�o%I\S?C1C0y�C0Q�ADKV@?A� KVW I\M?Q�C¡KVH­H\UDy�C0��S j I j y%�?KVADMBUDMBHx>'¯�@½I\S?C�Ug@?C�S j @B�¤w�I�S?C�C � j W I;I�Q\C j I\y�Cx@gI�U$OC �?W�S j @BADC2K�H���C0EVE�CiHJI j �?EVK�HhS?Ci�­�[Z;@BUs� %���M?K^I\C j @[M?y%��C0Q�U$O � Q j WuI\K�W j EBQ�C j E^KV° j I\KVUD@BHU$O�I�S?C;MB@B�NC0Q�EVZlKV@?A��lceUD@BE^Z�¯1X~v OmUDQ�y j EVKVH\y j Q�C j f j KVE j �?EVC�§ ³Bw qDp?w qN�gw q �?w q �?w �$r$Â��,�s¨j @B� j E^E j$�?� E^K�W j I\KVUD@BH'KV@B�NK�W j I\C�I\S j I�n1k�R ��K^I\S�I\S?C�C � j W I~C �?W�S j @?ADC�K�H~CiH\H\C0@lI�K j E^EVZCx¬lM?KVf j E^Cx@lI�I\U�I�S?C ��k jD�?� Q�U j W�S�� j I%EVC j HJIiw.K^@¾I\S?C�W j H\C­U$O�ADQ�UDMB@B��HJI j I\C � Q\Ug�NcE^Cxy�H��u>�RTS?C�MBH\C�UDO�I�S?C�C0� j WuI%C0�?W�S j @?AgC�y�UlHJI;@?U$I j �?EVZ�Q�CxH\UDEVfDCiH1I\S?C��?K32�W MBELI�K^CiHU$O.I�S?CYW UD@[fgC0@lI\KVUD@ j EB�?W c¢OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�H+��K^I\S�I\SBC1�NCiH\W0Q\K � I�K^Ug@�U$O�@?C0A j I�K^fgC�KVUD@BHx>Nk?M?Q\cI\S?CxQ\y�UDQ�CDw�I�S?C�¹Yº.F j$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\KVUD@½§ r$¨ � Q�Usf[KV�?CxH j fDC0Q�Z�C 2�W0K^Cx@gI j @B� j W0W0M?Q j I\CI\U[UDE¶OmUgQ � Q j WuI�KVW j E.W j EVW0M?E j I\KVUD@�H+��K^I\S�I�S?CYC � j WuI�C �?W�S j @?ADCg>

¯�@�I\SBC1UDI\S?CxQTS j @B�.wgI�S?C�UDQ��?K^I j E^cG�NC � C0@B�?C0@lI+I�Q\C j I�y�Cx@lI�UDO�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@­Q\C � Q�C cHhCx@gI�H j y%MBW�S�y�UgQ\C;HhCxQ\KVUDMBH1W�S j E^EVC0@?AgCYI\S j @�I�S j I�U$O�C0�NW�S j @?AgC�%�RTSBC;H\Z[HhI\Cxy j I\K�W�NC0Q�K^f j I\KVUD@�U$O¤HhM�W�S;OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H�f[K j HJI j @B� j Q��;y j @[Zlc£��UN�NZ�I�S?C0UgQ\Z;E^C j �?H'I\UYQ j I\SBC0QW UDy � EVK�W j I�Cx�%C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@BHx>»RTS?C0KVQQ\KVADUgQ\UgMBH jD�?� EVKVW j I\KVUD@%��KLI�S?K^@�I�S?C�¯1X+v @?UDI�Ug@?EVZQ\Ci¬gMBK^Q�CxH�I\S?CTCxf j E^M j I\KVUD@%U$O¶�+UgM?E^Ugy%�;y j I\Q�KL��CxE^Cxy�C0@lI�H���C IJ��C0C0@%I\S?C�W0UDy � EVC I\CTH\C IU$O�¹�´6HhI j I�CxHxw¤�?MNIiw¤K^@ � Q�K^@�W K � E^Cgw j E�HhU¡Q�C0EVK^CiH�Ug@�I�S?C�][@?Us��E^Ci�NADC�U$O�S?KVADS?CxQ1UgQ��?C0QQ\CiH � UD@BH\C�OmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@BHx>?FG@ � Q j WuI\K�W j E¤W j E�W MBE j I\KVUD@BH+I\SBCxH\C� �Q�HhIhc � Q�K^@BW0K � E^CiH~OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�H@?CxW0CxH�H j Q\KVE^Z�I�M?Q�@�UgMNI­I\U���C�Q j I\SBC0Q­KV@?C 2�W KVC0@lIiw�C0fgC0@ KLO1I\SBC0Z j Q\C�Ug@?E^Z¾I\Q�C j I�Cx�� CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVfDCxE^Zg>NFG@ j �?�NK^I\[email protected][I�S?C � U$I\Cx@lI\K j E¤Q�CxH\M?ELI�K^@BA%OmQ�UDy j E j Q�ADC�W E j H�H�U$O�H\MBW�SOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�HÀKVH�@?UD@Nc � S[ZNHhK�W j EsOmUDQ� B@?K^I\CTHhZNHhI\Cxy�Hx>���UDI\S � Q�UD�?EVC0y­H j Q�C�Q\CxE j I\Ci�1I\U2I�S?C� Q\CiHhCx@BW C;U$O~MB@?UNW0W M � K^Ci��HhI j I\CxH�KV@�I\SBC%OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�H���SBKVW�S�K�H1K^@BC0f[KLI j �?EVC j H1HhU[UD@j H�H\UDy�C�f j Q\K j @lI�U$OHJI j @B� j Q���y j @[Zlce��UN�NZ­I�S?C0UgQ\Z­K�H�MBH\Cx��OmUDQ2I\S?C��NCxQ\KVf j I�K^Ug@.>

¯�@?C�I�SlM�H�S j H.I�U� �@B� jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�K^Ug@BH¤��S?K�W�S j fgUDK��1I\S?C � Q�CxH\C0@BW0C�U$O�´NE j I\C0Q�KV@NcI\C0AgQ j EVH'W0UD@?@BCxWuI�K^@BA1UNWxW M � KVCx����K^I\S�M?@?UNWxW M � KVCx��HhI j I\CxHx>Dd�@NOmUDQ\I\M?@ j I\CxE^ZgwsI\SBC j f j K^E^cj �?EVC�H\C0y�K^c£Cxy � K^Q�K�W j ElOmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�H0wsK£> Cg>»I\S?C2´[F\�~cGº�n�� j @B��I�S?C��+UDEVE^C0cG´ j EVfDC I\I\KlOmM?@BW cI\KVUD@ j E¢w.��SBKVW�S���UDI\S¾H j I�KVHhOmZ�I\SBKVH%Q\Ci¬gMBK^Q�C0y�C0@lIiw.�NU�@?U$I�AgK^fgC�Q�CxH\M?E^I�HYW0UDy �Bj Q j �BE^CI\U���S j I�UD@?C�UD�NI j KV@BH%��K^I\S�HJI j @B� j Q��¾bYb���Hx>�FeI­H\C0C0y­H%I\S j I%I�S?C¡�?C0Q�K^f j I�K^Ug@¾U$OHhM?K^I j �?EVC jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�K^Ug@BH�y;MBHJI�HhI j Q\I�OmQ\Ugy HhUgy�C� BQ�HJI\c � Q�KV@BW K � EVCxH�C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@­EVKV]DC© � �« j @B��I\S?Cx@�H\KVy � E^K^OmZ�I�S?KVH2C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@�UDQiw j I2EVC j HhIxw[I�S?C�W UgQ\Q�CxH � UD@B�NKV@?A � UDI\Cx@Nc

Page 62: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

:�� Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

I\K j E£>s¯�@?C � UlH\H\K^�BE^C�HJI�Q j I\C0AgZ�UDONI\S?K�H.IJZ � C~K�H.I�S?C+W0E^UlHhMBQ\C jD�?� Q�U»�[KVy j I�K^Ug@1KVEVE^MBHhI\Q j I�Cx�K^@�´[CiWuI\KVUD@�o?> ³?>�2Us��C0fDCxQxw � CxQ\S j$� H1K^I�K�H�@?UDI�I�S?C­W UD@�HJI�Q\MBW I\KVUD@6U$O+KVy � EVKVW0KLI�W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@�OmM?@BW c

I\KVUD@ j EVH���S?K�W�S�KVH1I�S?C­Q�C j E��?UDy j KV@6UDOT¹�´ � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@�I\S?CxUDQ�ZDw¤�?MNI�Q j I�S?C0Q�I�S?C�NC0@BH\K^IJZ�OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E�Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI j I�K^Ug@�UDOI\S?C;M?@B�NCxQ\EVZ[K^@?A�W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\Ci��y�UDI\KVUD@�U$O'I�S?CC0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BHx>�RTS?C�W Q�MBW K j E � UgK^@lI�K�H�I\S j I�I\SBC � C0Q\I\M?Q�� j I�K^Ug@�C � �Bj @BH\K^Ug@�UD@�I\SBC;� j HhK�HU$O¤I\SBC1¹�´ � j y�KVELI�UD@?K j @�W j @���C�M?I\KVE^KV°0Ci�­OmUDQ j EVE�]lKV@B�?H+U$O.y j @lZlce��UN�NZ � Q�U � C0Q\I\KVCxHx>RTS?KVHK�HÀI\Q�M?C�K^@ �Bj Q\I\K�W MBE j Q�OmUgQÀI�S?CTy j @[Zlc£��UN�NZY� j fgC OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@���� ± / ± 7 �-�W� � � / � 1 " !KLI�HhCxELOJw[�?MNI j E�HhU�OmUDQ�I�S?C1y�UlHJI�HhKVy � E^C1¬lM j @lI\K^IJZ���S?K�W�S�Q\C��BCxW I�H�I\S?C1W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\Ci��y�UDcI\[email protected]�S?C%²»c �Bj QhI�KVW0E^C��NC0@�HhK^IJZ � ��� ± 7 � �uw� ��� ± 7 � ��� �¾� � � �»�

² ' ) + , + � � ) + , � 5.;������.�

1 ��� ± / ± 7 � / 7 � + / + 7 �W�-��� � / � 1 " ! 1 ��J�i²��$�

d�H\K^@?A�I\S?C � CxQhI�M?Q\� j I\KVfDC j$�?� Q�U j W�S�U$OÀ´[CiWuI\KVUD@­r�I\U� �Q�HhI~UDQ��NCxQxwgUD@?C2Cx@B�?H~M � ��K^I\S� � ± ��� ± 7 � �� � �

² 5 � - � 5 / �h� � - /$� � - � ��� � 1 1 � � � � � � 1 ® ª 1 � !� � � � /� � ��U� ��� ± � � / ��� ± � 0 ��� � � 0 ��� ± �I� U� ��� � � / ��� �� 5

�- � � ��U� ��� ± � � /B��� ± � ��U� ��� �I� �\��� � � � U� ��� ± � ���\��� ± �I��U� ��� � � /?��� ��� �

� �² 5 � , � - � - � 5 / , � �J�

�- /$� �h� � - �¢� � ��� 1 1 � �¢� � � ��� 1 1 ���B�� � � � � � � / � � �

� ��U� ��� ± �I� / ��� ± � ��U� ��� �I� � ��� � � � � � � � �J�i² �g�

RTS?KVH2C � � Q�CxH�HhKVUD@�Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI�H j @�KVy � E^K�W K^I��NCx@BHhK^IJZ�OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E¤OmUgQ � ��� ± 7 � ��K^@�I�S?CH j y�CYH\C0@BH\C j HY�h���g�+K�H j @¡KVy � E^K�W K^I��NCx@BHhK^IJZ­OmM?@�WuI\KVUD@ j E¤OmUgQTI\S?CYC0�NW�S j @?AgC�Cx@?C0Q�ADZg>�2Us�8Q\C j EVKVHhI\K�W EVZ��NU[CxH � � ± �NCxH�W Q�KV��C�I�S?C¡�+UDMBE^Ugy%��W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^Ug@���C IJ��C0C0@�I�S?C

C0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BH '�RTS?KVHT¬lM?CiHJI�K^Ug@�K�H j @BH\�+CxQ\Ci�­K^@�k�K^AgM?Q�C�²?����S?K�W�S�H\S?Us�2H+I\S?CY²»c �Bj QhI�KVW0E^C�NC0@BH\K^IJZ1UDO?I\SBC ��C~ADQ�UDMB@B��HhI j I�CD>»k?UgQ#��C~UD@BC~S j H�Ug@?E^Z1I�S?Q\CxC+Q�C0EVC0f j @gI�W U[UDQ��NKV@ j I�CxH��S?KVW�S� ?�½I\S?C � UgH\KLI�K^Ug@BH�U$O1I\SBC�IJ�+U�C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@BH�Q�C0E j I�K^fgC�I�U�I\S?C�@[MBW0E^CxMBH­KV@ I�S?C� E j @?C�H �Bj @?@?Cx���lZ;I\SBC�I�S?Q\CxC �Bj QhI�KVW0E^CiH��mI\S?C1U$I�S?C0Q~I\S?Q�C0C1W U[UDQ��NKV@ j I�CxH~W0UDQ�Q\CiH � UD@��I\U½Q�U$I j I�K^Ug@BH�UDOYI\S?C6I\Q�K j @?ADEVC��NC0 B@?Ci�¸�[Z I�S?C�@lM�W EVC0MBH j @B�¸I\S?C�IJ�+U C0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BHj Q�UDM?@B�¡I�S?C � UgH\K^I\KVUD@�UDO'I\S?C;@lM�W EVC0MBH��u>�`¸KLI�S�I\SBC;@[MBW0E^CxMBH��NC0 B@?KV@?A�I�S?C%UgQ\KVADKV@�U$OI\S?C1W U[UDQ��NKV@ j I�C�HhZNHhI\Cxy¡wDI\S?C�y�UgHhI�H\M?KLI j �?EVC�W0U[UDQ��NK^@ j I\CiH j Q�C�I�S?C�Q j �NK j E��NKVHhI j @BW CiH��C0IJ�+CxC0@�I\SBCYIJ�+U­CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@BH j @��¡I\S?C;@lM�W EVC0MBHxw , ± w , w j @B�¡I�S?C j @?ADEVC�-8��C0IJ�+CxC0@I\S?CxK^Q � UgH\K^I\KVUD@BHxwS� ± K � � , ± , W UgH�-�>D��H'KV@�I\SBC2W j H\CTU$O�I\S?C�Q j �NK j ENHhKV@?ADEVC c �Bj QhI�KVW0E^C�NC0@BH\K^IJZDwsI�S?C � Q\Ug� j �BK^EVKLIJZ�I\U1 B@B� j @�C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@�K^@ j W CxQhI j KV@;Q j �?K j ElQ j @BADC�§ , ± 7I, ± � 3 ¨KVHTUg�NI j K^@?Ci�¡�lZ�y%M?E^I\K � EVKVW j I\KVUD@�UDO � �[Z , ± >?RTS?C j$�?� Q\U � Q\K j I�C1¬lM j @lI\K^IJZ­I\U � EVU$I2K�H

Page 63: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Ñ+Ð��lË ÈhÎ0Ï����TÆ�ÒNÆ�Ù[ÊDÆ�ÙsÈ���lÙgÖ�ÈJËÍÉiÙlÎxÏÍÌ :

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3

������������� �� �� ��� � � � � �

� ������������� ��! ��� �#" � ��"%$ �& ' ��(�)%* �#+

���,& ' ��(�) +

����� ��� ��� �ÁÒ[Î ÐGÈJËLÖ�ÏLÆI�£ÊDÆ�ÙlÌGË È+��ÉWZ ��Æ�ÏLË��gÇ�� 7�ÎxÊgËLÎxÏ$ÌeÈGÐ��lÖ\È��gÐJÆ(ZVÉxÐ�- à _ "$Ü � � .�ÉiÅDÐ b.- _0/21 "DÜ�¶Ë ÐJÌeÈ~ÉxÐhÊDÆ�Ð~ÒNÆ�ÐGÈ��gÐ��lÎ0ÈJËÍ×»ÆTËÍÇYÒgÏLËÍÖ�Ë È�Z �gÙlÖ�ÈJËÍÉxÙ[ÎxÏB×»Æ�ÐJÌ �gÌ =Q�ÁÉxÙlÏ��%ÎxÙlÊ�Æ>=gÎxÖ�È'ÐJÆ�Ì �lÏ È89 ��� < ÜI\S[MBH��Ár&:�� , ± , � � , ± 7 , 7 -Y� w�H\U¡I\S j I�I\SBC�Q j �NK j E��NCx@BHhK^IJZ�r�: , ± 0 � , ± ��KVH�UD�NI j KV@?Cx��lZ�K^@lI\CxADQ j I�K^Ug@�UsfgC0Q , j @B� - ��K^I\S?UgMNI�OmM?Q\I\S?CxQ�y j @?K � M?E j I�K^[email protected]

r&: ,�± 0 � , ± ��� �mr&:�� V,� ± ' �� ,�)T, ' �

� ) - � � , ± 7I, 7 -Y���FG@*kÀKVADMBQ\C�²?� , ± S j H­��CxC0@*H\C I�I�U¾p?> qsrl³#��UgS?Qxw'��SBKVW�S¸K�H�I\SBC�Q j �NKVMBH j I���SBKVW�S, ± 0 � , ± �.S j HÀK^I�HÀy j �NK^y;M?y�>iRÀUDAgC I\SBC0Q���K^I\S%I\S?C+@[MBW EVC0MBH j IÀI\S?C�UDQ�KVADKV@�I\S?C � UlHhK^I\KVUD@U$O�I�S?C� BQ�HJI�CxE^CiWuI\Q�UD@¡�NC  �@?CxH j HhI\Q j KVADSlI�E^KV@?C j EVUD@?A���S?K�W�S�I�S?C�H\CxW Ug@B��CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@�K�Hy�UsfgCx�¤wlK£> Cg>lk�KVADM?Q�C1²?��H\S?Us�2H'I�S?C , cG�NC � C0@��NC0@BW0C�OmUgQ - �*p�� � UgH\K^I\KVfDC , cef j EVM?CxH��j @B� - � : �m@?CxA j I�K^fgC , cef j EVM?CxH��u>.kBUDQ , � � p?> qsrl³ �+UgS?Q1I\S?C�IJ��U�C0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BH�HhK^IUD@�I\U � UDOÀC j W�S�UDI\S?CxQx>

RTS?C+H\UDEVKV��E^KV@?C�Q\C � Q\CiHhCx@lI�H¤I�S?C�C � j W IÀQ�CxH\M?ELIiwxUg�NI j K^@BCx��OmQ�UDy I\SBC+y�UgHhI j W0W0M?Q j I\Cf j Q\K j I�K^Ug@ j El� j fDC OmMB@BWuI�K^Ug@%U$O¶¹�K^@BUgH\S?KLI j § � �$¨£>D¯�@?CTW j @�H\C0C+I\S j I'I\SBC+IJ��U1C0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BH� Q\C0OmC0Q j �?EVZ�y�UsfDC~Ug@%U �?� UlHhK^I\CTH\KV�NCiH�U$OBI�S?C�@lM�W EVC0MBH&%sRTS?CTE^KV]DCxE^KVS?U[UN�YI\U�W Ugy�C�W0E^UlHhCI\U�C j W�S½U$I\SBC0Q�KVH�Ug@?E^Z�S j E^O j H�E j Q�ADC j H%I�S j I�U$O�Q\Cxy j K^@BK^@?A�UD@½U �?� UgH\KLI�C¡H\K��NCxHx>v�UDQ�C0UsfgC0Qiw?I\SBC�²»c �Bj Q\I\K�W EVC;�NCx@BH\KLIJZ�W0E^C j Q�E^Z�H\S?Us�2H�I\SBC�CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@Nc£CxE^CiWuI�Q\Ug@�W MBH ��j I� ± � � >Bk�K^AgM?Q\C�²?� j E�HhU � Q�UsflK��NCiH�I\S?CY�[ceUD@?EVZ�Q�CxH\M?E^IxwN��S?K�W�S�W UDQ�Q�CxH � Ug@B�?H�I\U�I�S?CADQ�UDM?@B�%HJI j I\CT¹�´�´[E j I\CxQ��NC0I\CxQ\y�KV@ j @lIx>s��H�I\S?K�H�NC I�C0Q�y�KV@ j @gI'Ug@?E^ZYW0UD@lI j K^@BHX j M?E^K£w�?MNI+@BU$IT�+UgM?E^Ugy%�­W UgQ\Q�C0E j I�K^[email protected]»I\SBC�C0EVCxW I\Q�UD@BH�y�UsfgC�K^@��NC � C0@B�?C0@lI\EVZ�K^@�I�S?C2�[ceUD@?EVZj$�?� Q�U»�NK^y j I\[email protected] � � � , ± 7I, 7 -Y�8� 1 � ± � � , ± � 1 1 � ± � � , � 1 �RTS?C � Q\Ug� j �?KVEVKLIJZ�OmUDQ�I�S?C�C0EVCxWuI�Q\Ug@BH%I\U�HhK^I�Ug@¾I�U � U$O�C j W�S¾UDI\S?CxQ�K�H j H;S?KVADS j HI\S j I2OmUDQ�H\K^IhI\KV@?A j I2I\SBC%H j y�CYQ j �NK j E��NK�HJI j @BW0C�UD@�U �?� UlHhK^I\C;HhK��NCxH2U$OI\S?C%@lM�W EVC0MBHx>kÀKV@ j E^EVZDw�I\SBC�KVy � EVKVW0KLI�OmM?@BW I\KVUD@ j E2�J�»² �g��K�H � E^UDIhI\Ci�¤>¤FeI�K^@BW0UDQ � UgQ j I\CiH�y�UgHhI�U$O~I�S?C�+UDM?EVUDy;��W UDQ�Q�C0E j I\KVUD@�KV@ � >gFeI�H\E^KVADSlI\EVZ�UsfDC0Q�CxHhI\KVy j I�CxH�I\SBC�H\M �?� Q�CxH�HhKVUD@�UDO�I�S?C�Ug@NcI\U �6� UlHhK^I\KVUD@�w��BMNIxw¤UsfgC0Q j EVE¢w?K�H1Q j I\S?CxQ�Q�C j E^K�HhI\K�W���I�S?C­HhUgy�C0��S j I�EVCxH�H � Q\Ug@?UDM?@�W Cx�W MBH � K�H j � j H\KVHTH\C IiwNK¢> CD>N@[M?y�C0Q�K�W j E£w[C µ¶CxW I��u>�RTS?KVH�Q�CxH\M?E^I��?C0y�UD@BHhI\Q j I�CxH�C � � EVK�W K^I\EVZI\S j I�I�S?C�W UD@�W C � ITUDO�KVy � E^K�W K^ITOmM?@BWuI�K^Ug@ j E�HTW j @�@?UDITUg@?EVZ­��C�MBH\Cx��OmUDQ��?WuceC0@?CxQ\AgK^CiH0w

Page 64: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

: � Ô'ÜNÔ.Ù��xÆ�Ï

�?MNI j E�HhUYOmUgQ~I�S?C��NCxH�W Q�K � I\KVUD@�UDO.E^UNW j E�W0UDQ�Q\CxE j I\[email protected]��S?KVW�S�y�KVADSlIT��C�U$O�KV@lI\CxQ\CiHJI�K^@I\S?C�W0UD@lI\C0�lI�UDOH�W j IhI\CxQ\KV@?A j @B�¡y;M?ELI�K � E^CYC0�NW0KLI j I�K^Ug@ � Q�UNW CiH\H\CxHx>

� #�� !(* � ����' 4 � ��! +�%F¤�+UgM?EV��EVKV]DC'I�U�I\S j @?]�y%Z�W UgE^EVC j ADM?CiH �Y>»v�>xn�Q\CxK^°xE^CxQxwi��>»k j W0W U��+Ug@?C I\I\K£wi�%>��;PUgW�]¶w�Y> %>�´NW�SBy�K�� j @B��´¶> ��>�+'UlHh]gU�OmUDQ�y j @[Z�f j EVM j �?E^C;�NKVH�W M�H\H\K^Ug@BH j @B�¡I\S?CxK^Q�W Ug@NcI\Q�K^�?M?I\KVUD@BH�I�U�I\S?C���UDQ�] � Q�CxH\C0@lI\Ci�½KV@ I\SBKVH­Q�C0f[KVC0�Y>'FeI�� j H j�� EVC j HhM?Q�C¡OmUDQ­I�S?Cj MNI�S?UDQ1I\U ��j Q\I\K�W K �Bj I�C;KV@�I\S?C��+UDKVy%�BQ j H\W�SBUlUgE'UD@�n�kR UDQ�A j @BK^°xCx���[Z���>.k�KVUDE^cS j K�H0w�v�>Bv j Q�¬lM?CiH j @B��k�> �UDADCxK^Q j K^@�I�S?C;� j Q j y;M?E^U�y�UDM?@lI j KV@BH0>�RTS?C0Q�C�W j @���C@?U��NUgM?�NI1I\S j I�I�S?C�K^@BH � KVQ\KV@?A�C0@[f[K^Q�UD@?y�Cx@gI j @B��I\S?C�C �?W0C0EVE^Cx@gI�OmU[U[� j I1I\S?C�W Ug@NcOmC0Q�C0@BW0C�HhK^I\C � Q�UsflK��NCi��I�S?C�Q�KVADSlI%y�UDy�C0@lI�M?y OmUgQ�I�S?C �JUgK^@lI;C0µ�UgQhI;��S?KVW�S�EVCx��I\UI\S?K�H���UlUg]¶>

� � ������|�� � �` Ü 72Ü ��Ü ��ÐJÆ�ËLÓ�ÏLÆ\Ð�Î0Ù[Ê�Ô'Ü���Ü ��Ü��+ÐJÉiÌGÌ�Ü�������� ������������������������! �"�$#��0Ü �$ÒgÐJËÍÙ��xÆ�Ð b.ÀÆ�ÐJÏÍËLÙ b ` �#�#"$Ü

� Ü 72ÜgÄ�Ü �$Å[Î0ÐJÒ�ÎxÙlÊ���Ü ��Ü �+ÉxÐGÈJÉiÙBÜ&%' (����)!*+��,�) b �#"8� ` � b�` �#�-$ÜDÜ.-DÜ�1ÜlĶÎ0ÏLÇ�Î0Ù�Î0Ù[Ê ��Ü ��Ü �DÅlÎiÊ&��ËÍÖ%LNÜ&%' ��$��)/*0��,�)!1 b ` � � : b�` � �;: Ü� Ü.-DÜ .+Ü �TÐJËÍÆ �iÆ\Ð b � Ü ?�Ë b ÎxÙlÊ���Ü2-gÜ Y£ÎWZVÐhÎ ÈJÆiÜ'%' (����)�34�����5)/1 b ` � : � � � : bC` ���#"DÜ�$Ü ��Ü ��ÉxÅlÙ�Î0Ù[Ê ?�Ü2-gÜ �$Å[Î0Ç�Ü6%' (����)!*+��,�) b ` � " A � `c` c b ` � : �sÜ: Ü�NÜ � ��Ü ��Î�Î0Ù[Ê ��Ü A2Ü .ÀÐ��gÆ�Ö%LDÙgÆ�ÐuÜ&%& �����)!*+��,�) b ` : �8� ` � b�` � :#� Ü� ÜF��Ü � Ü ?�Î0Ù��xÐJÆ\ÈJÅ�ÎxÙlÊ ��Ü2-gÜ ��Æ�ÅlÏ�Ü'%' ��$��)/*0��,�)�34�����5) b � � � � � : b�` � � ` Ü� ÜF��Ü � Ü ?�Î0Ù��xÐJÆ\ÈJÅ�ÎxÙlÊ ��Ü2-gÜ ��Æ�ÅlÏ�Ü'%' ��$��)/*0��,�)!7 b �2� � ` � "#� b�` � � DÜ�DÜ � ÜT�1Ü �9��ÎxÙ[Ê;�1Ü � Ü ?�ÎxÙ��0ÐJÆ�ÈJÅ�Ü&%& ��$��)/*0��,�)/7 b -&� � � b�` � � : Ü` "DÜ.-DÜ[ضÜlضÆ�ÐhÊgÆG� Î0Ù[Ê � Ü���ÎxÙ,�gÜ&%& �����)!*+��,�)!7 b c8� ��� "�" b�` � � : Ü`-` Ü.-DÜ[ضÜlضÆ�ÐhÊgÆG��Ü'%& ��$�8)!*0��,�)!7 b -&� �#����� bC` � �&: Ü` � Ü.-DÜ�ؤܤضÆ�ÐhÊgÆG��Ü?Y£Ù�Ø¶Ü � ËÍÆ�ÌGÖhÅlÆ�ÎxÙ[Ê ��Ü.Ô�ÌGÖhÅgÐJË � b ÆuÊgË ÈJÉxÐJÌ b'9 �:�;����#;�����=<2��#��2������#;�>�@?

<���� �A��CB�DED(B b Ò[Î �iÆ `-` Ü A LiÎxÊgÆ�ÇYËÍÆE/ÀÆ�ÐJÏLÎ � b .�Æ�ÐJÏÍËÍÙ b ` �#� ` Ü` DÜ.-DÜ[ضÜlضÆ�ÐhÊgÆG� b ��Ü5. �gÐL»Æ b Î0Ù[Ê ��ÜlÔ¤ÐJÙ2F�Æ�ÐJÅgÉ-Z¢ÜG%& ��$��)/*0��,�)!3/�����5) b ��� � �&: � b ` �#� : Ü` � Ü0A2ÜQ�1Ü .ÀÆ�Ö LiÆiÜ0HI)'J/ 2��KL)�%' (����) b � � � � ��M � bC` � � :�N` � N A N � N .&O8P L�O N %' (����)!*+��,�)!1 b � � #"#� � b�` � ���IN` :IN - N �RQ$S;S"TVU+Q�W�X 7 N2Y�N -�Z�WO8U N HI)�%& ��$��)!� b � � `c` � " b�` � � � N` ��N ? N - N ��[�Q�\ N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)�7 b2] M8� ] �1�&: bC` � � � N` �IN A N ��^Z�S"_VTVW2`LQ�W2X � N ?!O8aI� N %& ��$�8)!*0��,�)!1 b ��"&� ` � : bC` �#� � N` � N.bRN �CZ�c�Q$W2T N HI)d%' ��$��)fe'J6����AE���2��)4g��$���5��# b ` "&� ��M � `-bC` ��� �INM2" N.hiNLh W2`�O8_jQ�W2X A NLk Q$P8P8Z .'Z�WO�c;c"T N Y5W A N �lO�S"W0mQ$W�XIO8F�n ?/Q$`�o2W2Q b - N �=Q$S"o�Q$W2T b

7 N �pP �qO8O8WI� b Q�W�X � N �rTV_VU;Z�W b OsXTtc"Z�S"U biu �2�$�2����Kv<���"�5��K��.f�w�! 2�;��#;������"���iJ/ 2��Kyx ����#��z����AR%& ��$�������{0|���:)fB�e7+���"��'%G#;��}8�:��K��0����A~g>�sA(���<���"�5��K�� b�� Q$`�O+M�M ��N �C_Vo8�'O�S b� Z(Z�S�XIS"O�P�[(c b M�"�"#" N

M ` N � N �IO�T�XI_ b - N2�4N�� O�S�XOG� b Q�W�X � N �CoS;c"[ N %' (����)!*+��,�)d34�����5) b � � � �2" � " b M�"�"#" NM�M N - N��4N2� O�S�XOG��Q$W�X!A N � o2W`�O�S N %& ��$��)/*0��,�)/7 b M ] � ��" � � bC` � � ` NM ] N 7 N5� Z�_V_VOzQ�W�X Y�N �IQ�_VaEO�c;c"T N �! 2�;��#;���5)0J/ �fK�)d1+�������f7R��#��:) ��� ] � � ] M����4� � � � NM�� N.hiN2h W`�O8_�� A N ��^Z�P%L���Q$W�X/7 N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�S N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)�1~� : ��� " ] M���"�M��/M�"�"#" NM�� N A N�k Q�P8P�Z�.'Z�WO�c;c"T�� hiN�h W`�O8_���7 N N �IP�[2\�T:Xd�$Q�W�X87 N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�S N %' ��$��)2*0��,�)I34�����5):��&: � M�M������M�"�"I� N

Page 65: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

Y S��2Ttc�Q$_Vn � O � O8W�XIO8W(c k o2WP�c"TVZ�W2Q�_VU : �

M :IN � N � N /&Z�U LEZ� ? N �rTV_�L���Q$W�X � N oU"Q�TtS N J6���d)4HI)d%' (����):� � � �:�sM�"�"I� � � � " NM ��N 7 N N �IP�[2\�T:X�� hiNEh W2`�O8_���7 N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�Ss� �4N .'_:Q$[�QI�EQ�W2X � N ��P�[I�GQ$S"F N 1+A�,�) u ����2�5)

J/ ��KL):� ]�] � M�"#���4� ��� ��NM �IN - N��4N(� O�S�XIOG�C�I- N A N8� [2O�a�Q�S-�(��� N � N /6Z�U L�Z� � N A N -�Q�P%LIU;Z�W!� � N 7 NE� OsXO�S"U;Z�W!� � N - N

��TVW2`�[��Q�W�X �lN�k TVZ�_V[2Q�TVU N %& ��$��)/*0��,�)/7i�2� : � : :#� ���/� �#��M NM2� N.hiN h W2`�O8_�� � N �CO8_V_VO�Ss�+A N k Q$P8P8Z .'Z�W2O�c;c"T�� � N � ^o_:_VO�Ss�6Q$W�X 7 N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�S N %& ��$��)

*0��,�)�1~� ��MI� M � �2"I� �0�#�1� N] " N.hiN2h W`�O8_�� � N �CO8_V_:O�Ss��Q�W2X 7 N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�S N %& ��$�8)!*0��,�)/1R�5� ] �V� ] :1� � � ��� :IN] � N � N /&Q$S"`�QI� . N k S"TVP%LEO�� � N �lTtS�Q$c�QI� bRN .GQ$U@c"o2`I��/ N/� O�S"U;[2TVW2QI� Q$W�X � N4k S"TVc"F�U;P�[O N HI)

%& ��$��)GJ/ ��KL)!1~�d� "$��� : �#�1�(�4M2"#"�" N] M N � N ?�T:opQ�W2X �lN a�Q�W � ^o_:_VO8W N HI)GJ/ ��KL)d%' (����):�!��� ] � M#��" : �!M2"#"#" N]�] N 7 N2Y�N -�Z�W2O�UlQ$W�X Y�N �RoW2W�Q�S"U;U;Z�W N *0��,�)!g��sA()d%' (����):� : ��� :�� ���4� � � � N] � N.hiN2h W`�O8_��2- N A N � [O8a�Q$S-�(� ? N � N �=Q�PsXIZ�W2Q�_:X��2Q�W2X � N � N /6Z�U LEZ N�� )d%& ��$�8)��~��M ] � � �

�0�#��M N] � N � NEb O�S�Q�LIoIS�QI� bRNIY `�oP�[T���A N 7 N �rTV_V_:T:Q$\�U8��Q�W2X�- N � ^o��2_VO�S N %& ��$�8)�*+��,�)270� ] "&� � � ] ��

�0� � � N] :IN.bRN �lN ?!O8oW2`� �lN�bRN � [�Q$W!�2Q�W2X . N N �~Q�S"\�Z�W N %& ��$��)/*0��,�)�70�2����� M���M ] � � �#��� N] ��N.�4N � o��fO L�� � N .'_:Q�[2QI��Q�W�X � N ��P�[I�GQ$S"F N %& ��$�8)!*0��,�)/70�5�2"&� � M � �I� �0�#�$� N] �IN.hiN2h W`�O8_!Q�W2X � N � N /6Z�U LEZ N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)�70�� � �V� ] � : �� �0�#� ] N] � N A N �Ia�Q�W2O~Q�W�X Y�N �RoW2W2Q$S"U;U;Z�W N %' ��$��)�*+��,�)�34�����5):� : �8�V���8� � � � ���#" N�#" N / N �Q�[W2T��2- N �lS"oO8W2O���Q�o\=�Q�W�X - N��4N� O�S�XIOG� N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)!70��M : � � ] � ���4� � � M N�I� N.�4N �RZ�[2O8W���O�S"`yQ�W�X � N �CZ�[2W N %' (����)!*+��,�):��� ] : .E� � : ��4�0� : � N�EM N ? N - N ��[�Q�\ Q�W�X � N ��P�[_ ^oc"O�S N %& �����)!*+��,�)d34�����5)V�������V� �#��� � �0� � ] N� ] N � N2hiN � Q$U;T�XQ N %' (����)!*+��,�)�1R� �(�#� M#�2"1��� �0�#�#� N��� N - N . N �~S"TVO8`�O�Ss� � N ?!T��2Q�W2X�� N - N Q�� S�Q�c"O N %' (����)�34�����5)/1R���8� � � � � "�� � ���#" N�1� N.bRN �lS�Q���ZI� bRN �~S"O�T �TVP�[���� N �CoIS;c"[!��Q�W�X h0N � N � N �lS"Z�U;U N� W / N��N A+W2TVU;TV\�Z�ad�$OsXITtc"Z�Ss�

<��#;�����jJ6���I�V��Ky}LJ6�$#�#;���V���������Cf� 9 �:�"����#@���2��z<2��#��������#"� J6���V���I�V������$�2��e�7R���E�$��A�� 2�3!�s�����d������"f����1�����#;���� K�������$�2� � Q�`�O�M2" ] N �RZ�S�XIZ�W�Q$W�X .&S"OsQ�P�[!�!� ���#� N

��� NzY�N�� oW2W�Q�S"U;U;Z�W�Q$W�X�� N��N� o2W�X 6(aITVU@c N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)!70�!� ]�� �(M��$�I�4������� N��� N.hiN$h W2`�O�_��� N$k Q�P8P�Z!�'Z�W2O�c;c"T�� � N �CO8_V_VO�Ss� �N +W�X�S"O#"�LEZ�a�TVP8U8�$Q�W2X%$ N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�S N %& ��$��)

*0��,�)�1~�&�' � �����I�4������' N��' N.hiN2h W`�O8_!Q�W2X � N � N�( Z�U LEZ N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)�1~���� � M�'�)�)I� �*��� ] N��� N%+lN&k S"Z(O�U;O k T:U;P�[2O�S N �! 2�-,C��#���#;�"��xf�/�s�/. g ��� �sAL?8��#L1+����K�� N10 T:_VO�2(�43lO�5 � Z�SL��

�*����� N&�) N � N� a�Q�W2Z�a�� � N �RTtS�Q$c�Q���Q$W�X6$ N - N �GQ$S;c"_VO�c;c N %' (����)�*+��,�)�34�����5):�' ]�� &���&�&�� ������� N&(� N.hiN2h W`�O8_��� N ��^Z�P%L���Q$W�X7$ N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�S N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)�1~���EM � )��(M�&�)�M��/M�)�)�) N&�M N8� N�� Q�Q"L�U;Z�WO8W!� �4N�� 2�2:L:Ld^ZI�(Q�W2X � N �IoW�XI[2Z�_V\ N J6�$K9�����5)�%& �����)�*0�:��):��� � ] � ] �d����'�� N& ] N � N�� T���- N � N �~S"TVO8`�O�Ss��Q�W2X ��N - N Q�� S�Q�c"O N J/ 2��KL)d%& ��$�8)�34�����5):�!����� � ] '��4�����EM N&�� N%+lN n Y�N l_V\;�_�Q�X[ Q�W2X-< N aEZ�W��GQ�S;c"[ N %& �����)!*+��,�)!70� ] � � ] M ] ���4�*��'�& N&�& N � N���N -�Z�[W2U;Z�W!� �4N � N=� TV_V_���Q$W�Xp- N N� Z � _VO N HI)'J/ 2��KL)�%' (����):����' � &��I�sM��4�*��� ] N&�� N N � N �pP � OsQ$W!�>� N?� TVo!�'Q�W2X ��N � N>+ [2Q�W�XI_VO�S N aEZ�_:o\�O�'�� Z���1A@@% J6���s?s��#;�������

%G#;�s���"�;A�f������� � Q�`�O8��)��/����'EM N&�� N%+lN - N <R\yS"TV`EQ�SlQ�W�X � N� Z�WF8O N %' (����)�*+��,�)!1R��&�) � ] '�M���� �*���$� N&�' N.bRN �CZ�c�Q$W2T!Q�W2X � N L�Q�T N %& ��$�8)!*0��,�)!7i��&�� � ����&�)EM(� ������� N&�� N � N ��c�^Q�XO8_VO���- N N �=QB" O�50U L�T�� �4N�( Z�`�_���Q�W2XC N�� ^Z�S"_VTVW2` N %& ��$�8)2*+��,�)34�����5):����� � M�)�'��I�

�*����� N��) N � N �=Q�U;U;T:X2Q�� � N�� Z�U@c"O�S"W�Q�L���Q�W2X6 N �GQ$_:XO�S"O8U;P�[2T N %& �����)!*+��,�)!70���' � &�)�&�'I�4�*��� ] N��� N.hiN2h W`�O8_��� N ��^Z�P%L���Q$W�X � N�( Q�S"`EQ N %& ��$��)/*0��,�)/7i�� ]�� ��M�&���M(���!M�)�)I� N��M N.hiN2h W`�O8_!Q�W2X6$ N � N � S"O8TVF8_VO�S N HI)'J6��K9�����5)'J/ 2��K�):��M�) � ] ���4������� N

Page 66: uni-frankfurt.deengel/papers/e03b.pdf · 2006. 11. 14. · s ) ( ¥ % §, @

��� hiN�h W2`�O8_

� ] N � N+lN� Q$W2`�S"O�c"[=Q�W2X=- N2�4N�� O�S�XIO�5 N %' (����)!*+��,�)�70���B& � M�'�'$�� ������� N�$� N - N �RQ$S;S"TVU N %' ��$��)/*0��,�)�1~��M�� � ������'I� �*��'�� N��& N � N �IO�T�XI_���- N2�4N�� O�S�XO�5C��Q�W�X � N� O8a�2 N %' (����)�*+��,�)!1R��&�� � &����4������� N��� N �N�� TVW�XI`�S"O8W N @���5)4HI) u �2�$�2����K J/ 2��KL)/<2�$K9�d):��& � ������4������� N��� N � N $ N 3lZ�S"\LQ$W=Q�W2X � N � N �CZ(O8_V_VT:W` N %& �����)!*+��,�)!70� ] ) � &�& ] )I�4�*��'�� N��' N - N���N �~Q�S;S"T:U;Z�W N HI)GJ/ 2��KL)d%& �����):���' � ��&���M�� �*��' ] N��� N - N���N �~Q�S;S"T:U;Z�W N HI)GJ/ 2��KL)d%& �����):���� � M�M���&�� �*��' ] N��) N - N���N �~Q�S;S"T:U;Z�W N HI)GJ/ 2��KL)d%& �����):��'�� � M�'����I� �*��'�� N�(� N � N $ N2� O8XO�S"U;Z�WjQ�W�X +lN�+lN� TVW N HI)'J/ 2��K�)d%' ��$��):��'�' � ��'�)��(�4����'�' N��M N � N $ N2� O8XO�S"U;Z�W!�$ N N �RO8Q$c"Z�W���Q$W�X +lN=+lN�� TVW N HI)'J/ 2��K�)�%& ��$��):�'�) � ������M(� ����'$� N� ] N � N $ N2� O8XO�S"U;Z�W!�$ N N �RO8Q$c"Z�W���Q$W�X +lN=+lN�� TVW N HI)'J/ 2��K�)�%& ��$��):�'�M � M���'�'�� ����'�& N��� N - N�+ [O8W!�2- N � N �~S"TVO8`�O�Ss��Q$W�X ��N - N� QB� S�Q$c"O N ��#�f,$���5�����$K�K������"����������M�)�)I� N��& N.bRN �.Q$c"Z N %i��#"�R1������:)�g���� 2):����) � �B&���� ����&�� N��� N.bRN� S�Q���ZLQ$W�X h0N � N < N�� S"Z�U;U N J/ 2��KL)d%& �����)�34�����5):��M$��) � �8����4������& N��� N - N �4N � O�S�XIO�5C� � N �CoS;c"[�� N � o � Q$W!�/Q�W2X � N �'_:Q�[2Q N %& �����)'*+��,�)&34�����5):� '�M � M�&�����

�*����� N��' N � N�� O�T:W���- N�k'N � Z��U;Z�W!�2Q�W2X hiN � N < N�� S"Z�U;U N HI)'J6��K �����5)iJ/ 2��K�):�2M�) � �sM��4�*����� N��� N � N � N �ITV_VaEO�S N %& ��$�8)!*0��,�)!1R��M�� � ����)���� ����'�) N'�) N $ N N lF8TVFCQ$W�X � N - N �I_:Q�\LQ$W N HI)GJ/ 2��KL)d%& ��$�8)V��$� � '�)$����� �*����� N'�� N.k'N�� o2Z� ��N �pP��GQ�WO�� ��N �CTV\=� +lN�k'N� TVO8U;O���Q�W�X 0 N $ N� O8W(c;S 2 N HI)'J/ 2��K�)d%' ��$��):�

��' � ] &����I�4����� ] N'�M N � N2hiN�0 Z(Z�W N HI)GJ/ ��KL)d%' (����):�!��)�) � M�' ] 'I� �*����� N' ] N � N - N�+ [�Q�L(S�Q�a�Z�S;c#2(� � N $ N�� 5GQ�_tc"W2O�2(� h0N $ N � Qsa�T:XU;Z�W�� k'N N�� Q$S � T:Q���Q�W2X +lN(k S"Z(O�U;O

k TVU;P�[2O�S N %& ��$�8)�*0��,�)/1R���� � ] ������� ����� ] N'$� N - N $ N�k _VZ$S"O8U N HI)GJ/ ��KL)�%' ��$��):����' � &����(M(�4����� ] N'�& N (zNb O�S"\LQ$c"[�� 0 N �C_VZ �2� O�Ss�2Q�W2X 0 N �Coc"F8O�_:WTV`�` N HI)GJ/ 2��KL)d%& ��$�8)V��$� � M�)�)EM�� �*����� N'�� N � N� U;[2T�L�Q*5iQyQ$W�X � N �CZ(P N %& �����)!*+��,�)�1R��&�) � ��� ]�] � �����$� N'�� N.hiN $ N � Qsa�T:XU;Z�W�� � N N �~Q$`�U@c;S"Z�\=� � N - N + [�Q"L(S�QsaEZ$S;c#2(� (zN �pO8TVU;O�S <l\LQ$Ss�iQ$W�X

+lN2k S"Z(O8U;O k TVU;P�[2O�S N %& �����)�*0��,�)/1R�2��� � ��)������ ������� N'�' N -$S N - N N �pZ�W(c"`�Z�\�O�S 2(�- N�0 N�Y P�[(c"O�S"U L�T��Q�W�X ��N N�� O�c"O�S"U;U;Z�W N HI)'J/ 2��K�)d%' ��$��):�

�*)I� � &���)�)I� ������� N'�� N � N4hiN4k S"O8o2W2X�� � N � N �lo

�c�Q��_:O��/Q$W�Xq- N � N �pZ�S"`�Q�W �N %& ��$�8)6*0��,�)'1R�4M�� � ��'�)I�

�*��'$� N��) N � N��4N �Ro���O�S~Q$W�X ��N � N �RO�S"F���O�S"` N g����:�;���I�V��#z<���;����#;�j����ALg����:�;���I�V��#z<2��#�������I#;�s)

@I|4)�J6����"�����2���0� ?6�C������$K���&g����:�;���I�:��� N�( Q$W83RZ�U@c;S�Q$W�X8$lO�T:W[2Z�_�Xd�B3RO�5 � Z$SLd��������� N��� N.bRN� S�Q���ZI� bRN �~S"O8T �2TVP�[!�2Q�W�X h0N � N < N� S"Z�U;U N g����:) 9 ����f������#�f�����=� � M����/�*����� N��M N � N�0 Q�SLEO8W N J/ 2��KL)d%& �����)d34�����5):��M ] � � M�&��I� ������& N� ] N �N�� S�Q���Z�50U L�T�� � N �lTtS�Q$c�QI� � N� a�Q�WZ�ad�8Q�W2X!$ N - N �GQ$S;c"_VO�c;c N HI)dJ/ 2��KL)E%& ��$��):�E���*� � ���I�B&(�

M�)�)�M N�$� N.bRN �CZ�c�Q$W2T N %' (����)!*+��,�)�70�&�) � ����'����I� �*���$� N��& N � N � N �?2I_:Q�W�XIO�S+Q�W2X �6N �C_VO8TVW2\LQ$W N %& ��$�8)!*0��,�)!34�����5)V�=�$� � ] ����)I�4�*����& N��� N8� N�k S"TVc"U;P�[2O~Q�W�Xp- N � o�Q$W N %& ��$��)/*0��,�)/1R�&�� � ] �(M�&(�4������' N��� N N�� ^Z�S"_VTVW2` N %& �����)!*+��,�)d34�����5)V��' ]�� &$��&��I� �*����� N��' N $ N N � 2I\LQ�W�� � N � N �(c"T:_VO8U8�2Q�W2X� N � Q�W`�50TV_V_ N %& �����)!*+��,�)!70���EM � ��&�&�M����!M�)�)�) N��� N.bRN �CTVW2Z�U;[2Ttc�Q N %& �����)!*+��,�)V�!�*)�& � ������)�� ����&�� N