2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers ›...

27

Transcript of 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers ›...

Page 1: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

� ��������� �����������������������! ��"���$#%�"�&#(')��*��+�,������! ��"���$#(-.��*/�"01')��*��2�����3�4�&�&5����*�6&�$�7�8��9�:*;��0<�"=>0?�@'7�+0��<�"=&0?�BA�C&0,DE�?*/�"� DGF

HJI KML5N&OQPSRTNVUWO:NYX?KZU[NJ\E]�^_R`O:P U?a�X�K:NYI5bdcea�I1f+ahgWX?ijKZk

l�m1n�HSl�o"f$KMp[L5IS^qpZNYiGrWKZs�aYU[t�f�rvu�w8xzyYuc�KMp{KMR>|}KZU&~MuYu�w

� r�KZ�J^qX�KMb1��p{t�aY|�KZU&~MuYuY���� I�KMNVU[iq^jKZU��YKZU[X[^ja�I�NVsSs}KMNVU?KMbd^qI.o����"��o��e���:l���m%~MuYuY�

�Q�����[�Z���8��5�Y�[�M�;�,���[�Z�8���z�d�M�����z� �8��¡��<¢�£q�h�:�,�[�¥¤¥�8¦��§�&¨W©��«ª,¤¥���8¢¬ª:¡��{�8�&ªz¡��­�®�8ªz�[¯ ª,¤¥�8�2ªz�d���,�Z�V¤¥°Y�­¢z¤§±h¯�¤§²®�[�8¯hª

���[�z£q�8�,¨��M¯��[��± �M¤¥¯�¢+¤¥¯:ª,�[�,¨�¢+�8£5�z�<°Y©��[��°:¦®�M¯�°Y³;¤´°Vª,¡>�M¯®°Q°Y���¥�{�hµ �8¯�°:¡�¤¥±8¡��[�2¢¬�Y¢¬ªz�[¨)ª,¡��,�8©�±h¡���©Yª<¶�·¸¯ª,¡�¤´¢+�,�[���8�zª+³��/�?¹��M¨�¤¥¯��/�h¯���¢z�[�,�8�[�¬º ¦®�8¢z��°��M¯�°�ª»³����,���?��¤§�h�[�¬º ¦��h¢¬�<°W�8�����,�h�8��¡���¢�µ8�M¯�°Q�?�8¨����8�z�2ª,¡��[¤¥����[�z£q�8�,¨��M¯��[�8¶G¼2¡���¢z�[�,�8���»ºV¦��8¢z��°Q�M�����,�h�h��¡Q¨��M½h��¢2©�¢z���M£¾¢¬�����[¤¥�8�§�¥�>°���¢z¤§±h¯��Zª,��°>¡��h¢¬ª,¢�µ��[�8�§�¥��°>�,�[���8¤§�¢z�[�,�8���,¢�µ5�[�Zº �¥�Y�[�Mªz��°¿³;¤§ªz¡.�z�h©Yªz���,¢�¤¥¯�¢z¤¥°���ªz¡���¯��?ª»³��8�,½�¶�·¸¯.ª,¡����,���?��¤§�h�[�zÀÁ¦®�8¢z��°�8�����,�h�h��¡SµS�8¯��§�­ª,¡����¯�°�¡�� ¢»ª�¢/Â_¢z�[¯®°Y�[���M¯�°��,���[�[¤¥�8�[��¢�ÃE�8�z�;¤¥¯V�8�h�§�h��°�¤§¯����z�,�8�¾�,���[�Z�8���z�h¶5Ä�¢z¤§¯�±W�M¯��8�§� ª,¤¥���M��¨��Y°Y�[�´¢�µ8³��;²���¢»ª¢z¡��Z³Åªz¡��Mª¾ªz¡��2ª,¡��z���2�§�Y�[�8�Y�z�<�?�Z�h�[�,���8�����,�h�h��¡���¢E�V¤§���¥°�¢z¤§±h¯�¤«²��[�M¯ ª,�§��¡�¤¥±8¡��[�¾���,�Mª,�V�[�8�Vª,¡��z�h©�±8¡���©YªG�M¯�°�¥�Z³��[��¦��M¯�°�³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z�8±8�Gª,¡��M¯��M¯��M�����,�h�h��¡�ªz¡��MªG°Y�V��¢�¯��Mª}©�¢z�$�¥�Y�[�8� �,���[�Z�8���z�h¶SÆ/�?¹Vª<µM³$�2°Y��¨��h¯�¢¬ªz���Zªz�ª,¡��Zª�¢¬���z�h�[�¬º ¦��h¢¬�<°:�¥�V���M�S�,���[�Z�8���z���V¤¥�[�´°�¢/¡�¤¥±8¡��[�/���,�Mª,�Y�?�8�Jª,¡��,�8©�±h¡���©Yª"�8¯�°!�¥�Z³$���;¦��M¯�°�³;¤¥°Vª,¡­©�¢,�M±8�ª,¡��M¯��,���[�[¤¥�8���»ºV¦��8¢z��°W�§�Y�[�8���,���?�Z�h�[�,��³;¡��[¯�ª,¡��/�,�[���8¤§�$¢¬���z�h�[��¢E¡®�{�8�;���,�Y�?��¢,¢z¤§¯�±����Z³$���G¢¬�¥¤¥±8¡ ªz�¥�W¡�¤¥±8¡��[�ª,¡��M¯&ª,¡��Zª/�8£����,���?��¤§�h�[�2�M¯�°!�e£q�[³Ç¡V©�¯�°Y�,��°>½V¤§�¥�8¦V� ªz�<¢2�M£}¦�©YÈJ�[�;���[�/¨e©��§ªz¤´�[�8¢¬ª/¢¬�<¢z¢z¤¥�8¯S¶

É�Ê}ËhÌÎÍ+Ï�Ð�Ñ»Ò�ϾÓ[Í$͸ÔhÕ ÕYÐ�Ѹֻ×�ØeÙZÚeÛ$Ü$Ý�Û�Ô Þ Øh×,ÑGß,Ð<ÞZָѬÓ�ß,Ö»Í+à�á�â<ã{ä[å[æçâ{è�æÁéEæÁêMá�ë<ãeÓ[ÞVØ�ì�ã<ã<êMá,æçâ{í�æÁéEæÁå<èMá�î8ï~

Page 2: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

� ������������ ��������

r�KMi_^qNV|5ijK­R&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t:^_X�U?K��®P5^jU?KMb |�k RTNYI®k NVsSs5iq^_pZNVt?^ja�ISX�X?PSp�L NYXQR&PSijt?^_pZNYX�t��EijK!t�U[NYISX��çKZUM\�X?LSNVU?KMb gWLS^jt�K{x|}a�NVU[b¾\�bS^qX�t�U[^q|5P t�KMb ^qI®t�KZU[NYp{t?^j�YKX?^_R>PSi_NVt?^ja�I NYISb b5^qX�t�U[^j|EP t�KMb p{a�R­s5P t?^qI����f�L KMX�K¿NVsSs5iq^qpZNVt?^qa�ISX�pZNYI s}aVxt�KMI®t?^qNYiqijk�LSN8�YK­X�KZ�YKZU[NYi2t?L a�PSX[NYISbSXea��/s5NVU?t?^qpZ^qs5NYI�t?XeX?pZNVt�t�KZU?KMb ah�YKZU:Nge^qb K>NVU[KMN ISKZt¬g�aYU��������YKMI1t?LSa�P���LpZP U?U[KMI�t�R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�t�I KZt¬g�aYU��JXZ\ X?PSp[L NYX�o,n R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t"I KZtzg"aYU��JXZ\JsSU?ah��^_b KWK��¿pZ^qKMI�t�U?a�P t?^qI��QNYISb b KMiq^j�YKZU?k­a��s5NYp �YKZt?X/t�a!�YU?a�P sEX2a��EU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X2|5NYX�KMb­a�I­R&PSijt?^_pZNYX�t��YU?a�P sTNYbSb U[KMX?X�KMXZ\Yt?L KZk!NVU?K�ija�X?X?k>NYISb­b a�I aYt;s5U?a8�J^qb Kt?L K!U?KMiq^_NV|5^qiq^jtzk ISKZKMb KMb |®k�t?LSK!NV|}ah�YK!NVs5s5iq^qpZNVt?^ja�I5X"��c�KMX?^#��IS^qI��.X?pZNYiqNV|5iqK&NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L KMX�NYI5b1NVU[p�LS^jt�KMp{t?P U[KMX�ÁaYUTU?KMiq^qNV|EijKdR>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�tZ\�t?LSNVtRTN$�YK1K��¿pZ^jKMI®tPSX�Kda���|}aYt?L t?L KÅISKZt¬g�aYU�� NYISb KMISb&%®LSa�X�t­U?KMX�a�P U�p{KMXZ\�^qXTNp[L5NYiqijKMI���^qI��&t?NYX����' aJpZNYiYU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k:NVsSsSU[a�NYp[L KMX��çaYUGU[KMiq^qNV|5ijK;R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?tZ\h^qI�gWL5^qp[L�N�ISKZt¬g�aYU���KMI�t?^jtzk�aYt?L KZU+t?LSNYI:t?L K/X�KMISb KZU$NY^qbSX^qI KZU?U?aYU�U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kY\2LSNM�YK­t?L K!s}aYt�KMI®t?^qNYi2t�adsSU?ah��^qbSK&X?^#��IS^(�EpZNYI®tes}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYI5p{K)��NY^qI5X�^qIÅt�KZU�RTX�a��"U[KMbSPSp{KMb|5NYISbSgW^qb t?LÇNYISb�b KMi_NMkY\�NYISb LS^*��L KZUTX?k�X�t�KMR t?L U?a�P���L sEP t"��o�I t?LS^_X!U?KZs}aYU?tZ\�g�KdK�+JNYR^qI K�NYISb p{a�R­sENVU?Kt?L U?KZKdbS^*,�KZU?KMI®t>iqa�pZNYi�U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kÇNVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMXZ\�a�I K U?K���PS^jU[^_I��ÅNYbSbS^qt?^ja�ISNYi/s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI�� NYISbÇpZNYp[LS^qI�� ^_ISX?^qb Kt?L K�I KZt¬g�aYU��TNYISbt?L KWaYt?L KZU�t¬g�a&|5NYX�KMbTa�I5ijk!a�IKMISb-%�t�a.%�KMISb¿RTKMNYISX"�;f�L K/�5U[X�t/NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L¾\�t�KZU[R­KMb10�2436587�9X�KZU?�YKZU:%�|5NYX�KMb&ija�pZNYi�U?KMp{a8�YKZU?kY\®RTN$�YKMX$P5X�K/a�� X�s}KMpZ^qNYiqijk�b KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMbQL a�X�t?XM\ pZNYiqiqKMb<;�9>=-0$5�;@?"9";A7�9�;A?�\Vp{a.%®ija�pZNVt�KMbgW^jt?L U?a�P t�KZU[X>NVt>X�t�U[NVt�K"��^_pTs}a�^qI®t?X:^qISX?^_b K!t?L K¿I KZtzg"aYU ���d��NYp�L U[KZs5NY^jUQX�KZU[�YKZU>X�KZU?�YKMX>t?L KTU[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�IU?K���P KMX�t?X�a��5U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X;^qI&^jt?X�ija�pZNYiJNVU?KMN�|�k � U?Kh�zt�U�NYISX?RT^jt�t?^_I��eijaJpZNYi�U?KZs5NY^jU�X"�$f�LSK"U?KZsENY^jU�X?KZU?�YKZU[X2t?L KMRTX?KMij�YKMXU?KMp{ah�YKZU�ija�X�t/s5NYp �YKZt?XB�çU[a�R KM^jt?L KZU�LS^*��LSKZU�ijKZ�YKMiEU?KZs5NY^jU�X?KZU?�YKZU[X"aYU"t?L K�X�KMISb KZU4�/l�a.%®ija�pZNVt?^_I��QU?KZsENY^jU"X�KZU[�YKZU[XgW^jt?LU?a�P t�KZU[X�^qXC�ÁP5ISp{t?^ja�ISNYiqiqkQK���PS^j�VNYijKMI�t"t�a>sEiqNYpZ^qI��:U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�J^qp{KMX"NVt�t?L KeU?a�P t�KZU[X"�/fWL KZU?K"�ÁaYU?KY\�^qt"^qX"NYiqX�as}a�X?X?^j|EijKWt�aP5X�K<0�2�365�7$9ED�9�36FHG$; I.58D&JQR­KMp�LSNYIS^qX[RTXLK´~8w�MGt�aTb kJISNYRT^qpZNYi_ijkTs5iqNYp{K�U?KZsENY^jU�X�KZU?�J^qp{KMX�NVtWX�t�U�NVt�K"��^qps}a�^qI®t?X�^qISX?^qbSKet?L K>I KZt¬g�aYU����o�I t?L KTU[KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L KMXM\$t?L KZU[K¿NVU?K I aÅX�s}KMpZ^qNYi�U?KZs5NY^jUQX?KZU?�YKZU[X"O;a�ISiqk1t?L K¿KMISb LSa�X�t?X � X�KMI5b KZUNYISb U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X���NVU[K!^_I��Ya�ij�YKMb ^qI1KZU?U?aYU�U?KMp{ah�YKZU?k��>f�LSKL�5U[X?teU?KMp{KM^q�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L ^qXE?"9"P QRG$;SJT0$D�5#U�5�DVJ��W L KMI KZ�YKZU.ija�pZNYiWU?KMp{a8�YKZU[k�a��:N ija�X?tTs5NYp��YKZtd^qXNVt�t�KMR­sSt�KMb¾\W^qtb kJISNYRT^qpZNYiqiqk�X�KMijKMp{t?X.N U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU¿ge^jt?LS^qIN ijaJpZNYiX�YKZa��YU[NVs5L5^qpZNYi�NVU?KMN t�a X[P sSs5ijk t?L KdU?KZs5NY^jU4�Çf�LSK�X�KMp{a�ISb U?KMp{KM^q�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L¾\�pZNYi_ijKMb t?L KY 9�?A5*J�D�0�3Z9 Y ;�9�2[9�5�7$9�;"NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L¾\�NYX[X?^*��ISX�NYIKMI5b&%�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�t?L K�t?NYX:�Ta��GX?P s5s5ijkJ^qI���U?KZs5NY^jU�X�^qI¿^jt?X�ijaJpZNYi�NVU?KMN-�W K:NYISNYijk&\ZK�t?L K�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i}t?L U?a�P���L s5P t�NYISb t?L K�I KZt¬g�aYU�� |5NYISb ge^qb t?LP5X?N$�YK�a��+t?L K:NV|}ah�YK:ija�pZNYi�U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kNVsSsSU[a�NYp[L KMX&^qI t?LSK]� NYp{K¿a���X�sENVt?^qNYiqijk p{aYU?U?KMiqNVt�KMbÇija�X?X�� W K]�5U�X�tQX?L ahg t?L5NVt&ijaJpZNYi/U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMXkJ^jKMiqb X?^*��IS^*�EpZNYI�t?iqk�LS^*��L KZU�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i2t?L U?a�P���L s5P t�NYISb ijahg"KZU�|5NYI5b gW^qb t?L PSX?N$�YK­t?L5NYI NYI NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L t?LSNVtb a�KMX:I aYtQP5X�KTijaJpZNYi;U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k�� �eK�+�tQg"Kp{a�RTs5NVU?KTt?L K­s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYI5p{K­a���t?LSKTija�pZNYi/U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMX"�^ ISb KZU2t?L K�NYX?X?PSRTsSt?^ja�I>t?LSNVt2U?KZs5NY^jU2X�KZU?�YKZU[X;L5NM�YK�X?P-� pZ^jKMI�t?iqk:LS^*��L&sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��eNYISb&|5P-,}KZU[^qI��epZNVs5NV|5^_iq^jt?^jKMXX�a t?LSNVtt?L KZkÇpZNYI I KZ�YKZUT|}K.|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp��JXZ\�g"K1X?L a8g@t?LSNVtTNYp{t?^j�YK1X?KZU?�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb�U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k kJ^jKMiqb5X&L5^*��L KZUsSU?aYt�aJp{a�i�t?L U[a�P���L s5P tTNYI5b�ija8g�KZUT|5NYI5b gW^qb t?L PSX[N$�YK�t?LSNYI�U[KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k�� � R­a�I�� t?LSK�t¬g�aU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU:%�|5NYX�KMb�NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L KMXt?LSK1X�KMi*��aYU���NYI5^*\M^qI�� a�I K1K�+JL5^j|5^jt?XTL5^*��L KZUTsSU[aYt�a�p{a�iWt?L U?a�P���L sEP tT|5P tTP5X�KMXR­aYU?KQ|5NYISb gW^_b t?L�' NYX?tZ\5g�K:KMX�t?^qRTNVt�KQt?L K:sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��­s}a8g�KZUeNYISbd|EP-,�KZU�^qI��­I KZKMb KMb1NVt�U?KZs5NY^jUeX�KZU?�YKZU[XeX�aTt?LSNVt�t?LSKZk.bSaI aYt|}KMp{a�R­K�|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp ��X"^qI­t?L K�U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZU"NVsSsSU[a�NYp[L� W K_��ISb!t?LSNVt"N:U?KZs5NY^jU/X�KZU[�YKZU"I KZKMbSX�NL�ÁKZg L®P5ISb U?KMb�J^qijaY|�k®t�KMX"a��G|5P-,}KZU�X�s5NYp{K�NYISbs5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��>s�ahg"KZU�X?iq^#��L�t?ijk­LS^#��L KZU"t?L5NYIt?LSNVt�a��+N>U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU8\�s}KZU�R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�tX�KMX?X[^ja�I¾\��ÁaYU�U?KMNYX�a�ISNV|EijK:ija�X?X�s5U?aY|5NV|5^qi_^jt?^jKMX"�

`

Page 3: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

f�L KQU?KMRTNY^qISbSKZU�a��2t?LS^qX�U[KZs�aYU[t�^qXWX�t�U�PSp{t?P U?KMb�NYX �Áa�iqija8geX"�"o�I�t?LSKQI K�+JteX�KMp{t?^ja�IÅg"K>K�+JNYR^qI K:t?L K>K�+J^_X�t?^qI��g�aYU�� a�I iqa�pZNYiWU?KMp{a8�YKZU?k �çaYU U?KMiq^_NV|5ijK�R&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t"�7o�I�HJKMp{t?^ja�I � g"K sSU?KMX?KMI�t¿t?L KÅt?L U[KZK1ijaJpZNYi�U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kNVsSsSU[a�NYp[L KMXeNYISb.a�P UWX�kJX�t�KMR R­a�bSKMi¾^qIÅH�KMp{t?^ja�I�����H�KMp{t?^ja�I��!p{a�I®t?NY^qISXWt?L K�t?L U?a�P���LSs5P t�NYISbd|5NYI5b gW^qb t?LNYISNYijkJX?^qX�� W K�p{a�RTs5NVU?K�t?LSK/s}KZU��çaYU�RTNYISp{K/a��Jt?L K�NYp{t?^j�YK"X�KZU[�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb&NYISb:t?LSK/U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|ENYX�KMb>NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMX^qI.H�KMp{t?^ja�I.y&�;o,I.H�KMp{t?^ja�Idw�g�K�X[^*\ZKWt?L KeU?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU[X��"l�a�ISpZiqPSX[^ja�ISX/NYISb¿bS^jU?KMp{t?^qa�ISX �ÁaYUC� P t?P U[K�g"aYU �NVU?Kp{a�I®t?NY^qI KMbÅ^_IÅH�KMp{t?^ja�IÅ�&�

� ������� �V�� � ���

m NYI�kTU[KMX�KMNVU[p[LSKZU[X�LSNM�YK�U?KMp{KMI®t?ijkTs5U?aYs}a�X�KMbbS^*,�KZU?KMI®t�NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L KMX@�çaYU�ijaJpZNYi5U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k���H�a�R­K�a��¾t?L KMX�K�NVs xsSU?a�NYp�L KMX�NVU[KWX?pZNYiqNV|5iqK�U[KMiq^qNV|5ijK�R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?tZ\�HJrWm � gW^jt?L­iqa�pZNYi U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k­KMISL5NYISp{KMR­KMI®t?X��XK���\®y�M»\�ija�pZNYi-�YU[a�P sp{a�ISp{KZsStZ\ '�� l KÎw�M»\2t�U?KZK[%�|5NYX�KMb R&PSijt?^_pZNYX�tQt�U[NYI5X�s}aYU?tQsSU[aYt�a�p{a�i¸\;f�m f�n K ` ~"M»\ ' ��r ��� K´~Y~�M»\/ija��.%�|ENYX�KMbU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�U?KMi_^qNV|5ijKWR&PSijt?^_pZNYX�tZ\ '�� rWm K �$M}NYISb¿U?KMiq^_NV|5ijKWR&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t"t�U[NYI5X�s}aYU?t�sSU[aYt�a�p{a�i¸\JrWm f�n K´~ ` M �/fWL KMX�KNVsSsSU[a�NYp[L KMX�pZNYI |}K&|SU?a�NYbSiqk�pZiqNYX?X?^(�EKMb NYX��Áa�iqijahgWX"� '�� rem ^_XeX�KZU[�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb¾\2HJrWm ge^jt?L ija�pZNYi�U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kKMISLSNYI5p{KMR­KMI�t?X^qX­X�KMi*�eaYU���NYIS^*\M^qI�� U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX?KMb�NYISb rWm f�n�\�f�m f�n NYI5b ' ��r ��� NVU?K�b KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMbU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU:%�|5NYX�KMbÇgW^jt?L s5U?K{x¬p{a�ISX�t�U[P5p{t�KMbÇiqa���^qpZNYi�LS^qKZU[NVU[p[L®k�� '�� l ^_XQNÅL®k�|SU[^qb a���t?LSK ija���^_pZNYi/t�U?KZK[%�|5NYX?KMbNVsSsSU[a�NYp[L NYISb HJrem � W KNYbSb N.I KZg bS^_R­KMISX?^ja�IÅt�adt?L K!KMNVU[iq^jKZU�g�aYU��Åa�I X�KZU[�YKZU�x»|5NYX�KMb U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k K �.M;|®kp{a�ISX?^_b KZU[^qI��!t?L K�sEiqNYp{KMR­KMI®t�a��$U[KZs5NY^jUWX�KZU[��^qp{KMXW^qISX?^qbSKet?L K:ISKZt¬g�aYU������P U.g�aYU�� ^_X¿t?LSK �EU[X�t.t�a NYISNYijk�t?^qpZNYiqijk p{a�RTs5NVU?K t?L K t?L U?a�P���L s5P t.NYISb�|5NYISb ge^qb t?L P5X?N$�YK a��>X�KZU[�YKZUN%|5NYX�KMbÇNYISb U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX?KMb�ijaJpZNYi/U[KMp{a8�YKZU?kÇNVsSsSU?a�NYp�L KMX"�Ån�U?KZ��^qa�PSX�t?L U?a�P���L s5P tQNYI5NYijk�X?KMXQLSN8�YK �ÁaJpZPSX�KMba�I p{a�R­s5NVU[^qI�� � l�O�x»|5NYX?KMb¿�YKZU�X?PSX�ISK"��NVt?^j�YK�NYp��JI a8gWiqKMb���R­KMI®t � � � O&�¬x»|5NYX�KMb sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX"t?LSNVt�bSa>I aYt�PSX�KijaJpZNYi/U?KMp{ah�YKZU?k K´~��J\"~M�J\�u�M�aYU>p{a�R­s5NVU�^qX�a�I a���ija���^_pZNYi/t�U?KZK[%�|5NYX?KMb�ijaJpZNYi/U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k ge^jt?L aYt?L KZU!I a�I&%®ijaJpZNYiU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k�NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L KMX)K´~��S\+~Y~�M �/o�I.a�P U�g�aYU���\5^qIdNYbSbS^qt?^ja�I.t�aTt?L U?a�P���L s5P tZ\Jg�KQNYiqX�aNYI5NYijkV\ZK�t?LSKQI KZt¬g�aYU��|5NYISbSgW^qb t?L P5X?N$�YK¿a��Wt?L K iqa�pZNYi"U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k�sSU[aYt�a�p{a�iqX�� W KdNYiqX�a KMX�t?^qRTNVt�K t?L K sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��1NYISb�|5P-,}KZU[^qI��U?K���PS^jU?KMRTKMI�t?Xa���U[KZs5NY^jU¿X?KZU?�YKZU[X"� � iqX�a�NYi_i�a���t?L KÅs5U?KZ��^qa�PSX­g�aYU���R­KMI®t?^ja�I KMb NV|}ah�YK NYX?X[PSR­KMXX?s5NVt?^qNYi^qISbSKZs�KMI5b KMISp{KdNYR­a�I��Çija�X?X�KMX"� W K PSX�KÅN�X�k�X?t�KMR�R­aJb KMi�t?LSNVt p{a�ISX?^qbSKZU[XTt?L K1X�s5NVt?^qNYiep{aYU?U?KMiqNVt?^ja�I K ` �$MsSU?KMX?KMI�t�^qIdISKZt¬g�aYU���ija�X?X�KMX��r�KMp{KMI®t?ijkY\Gn2NVs5NYb aYs}a�PSiqa�XR9�3_0$P K´~���M2L5NM�YKTX?P����YKMX?t�KMb KZU?U?aYU�U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k1gW^qt?LÅt?L K­L KMiqs1a���R­a�b5^(�EpZNVt?^ja�ISXeNVtt?L K&U?a�P t�KZU[X�����I K&p{a�ISp{KZU[I gW^jt?LÅt?LS^qX�NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L1^_XWt?LSNVt�^jteU?K��®P5^jU?KMX�R­a�b5^(�EpZNVt?^ja�I�^_IÅt?L K! N� NYX�tesENVt?L#"a��U?a�P t�KZU�X �ÁaYU�K��¿pZ^jKMI®t�aYs}KZU[NVt?^qa�I¾\®^qINYbSbS^jt?^ja�I!t�a>aYt?L KZU�p[LSNYI��YKMX��"��P U�NYp{t?^j�YK�X�KZU?�YKZU:%�|5NYX�KMb NVsSsSU?a�NYp�Lb a�KMXI aYt�U[K��®PS^qU?K�NYI�k.p[LSNYI��YKMXe^qI.t?LSK!�ÁNYX�tWs5NVt?Lda��2U?a�P t�KZU[X��

$ %E��� �4� ��&('

W KdI a8g sSU[KMX�KMI�t!N X�KZU?�YKZUN%�|ENYX�KMb NYISbÇt¬g�a U[KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMX>t�a ijaJpZNYi"U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k �ÁaYU&U[KMiq^qNV|5ijKt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�I a��:bSNVt?N �çU?a�R N X?KMISb KZU t�a�R&PSijt?^js5iqKdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X"� � i_i�NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L KMX.NVU?K U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%®^qI5^jt?^qNVt�KMb� � O�x»|ENYX�KMb1NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMX"�Wf�L K>X�KZU?�YKZUN%�|5NYX?KMb1NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L1s5iqNYp{KMX�R>P5p[L1a��;t?L KQ|5PSU[b KMI �ÁaYUWKMISX[P U[^qI��­KZU[U?aYUU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k>a�I!U[KZs5NY^jU2X�KZU?�YKZU[X�s5iqNYp{KMb!^qI5X?^qb K/t?LSK�ISKZt¬g�aYU����2o�I&t?L K�X�KMi*�SaYU���NYI5^*\M^qI��eU?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX?KMb­NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L¾\t?L K KZU?U?aYUdU[KMp{a8�YKZU?k)|5P U�b KMI ^_X X[LSNVU?KMb7NYR­a�I�� t?LSK X?KMISb KZUdNYISb)t?L K s5NVU?t?^_pZ^js5NVt?^qI��ÇU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X"� o�I)t?L K

Page 4: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

b KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMb�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU�NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LG\ENbSKMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb1U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qXWNYX[X?^*��I KMbÅt?L KQt?NYX:�da��/X[P sSs5ijkJ^qI��!U?KZsENY^jU[X�^qI1^jt?XijaJpZNYiENVU[KMN-�/o,It?LS^qX�X�KMp{t?^ja�I g�K�NYX?X[PSR­KWt?L5NVt�R­KMp�LSNYIS^qX[RTX"NVU[K�N8� NY^qi_NV|5ijK/�ÁaYU�X?p{aYs5^qI��&R>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t?X"gW^jt?LS^_IN �ijaJpZNYi "�U?K"��^qa�I� W KWgW^qi_i�i_^qX�t;X�a�R­K�a��}t?L KeR­KMp[LSNYI5^qX?RTX �ÁaYU�NYpZp{a�R­sEiq^qX?LS^_I���t?LS^qX/NVt/t?LSK�KMISb­a��}t?L K�HJKMp{t?^ja�I� � ` �

$ � � ��� �&��� �V���� �#'��&�C� � � �& ����&�&�� %L�.���4� ��

W KeISa8g bSKMX?p{U[^j|}K�N!�YKMI KZU[^_p�X�KZU?�YKZUN%�|5NYX?KMbU?KMi_^qNV|5ijK�R>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t�iqa�pZNYi U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k­sSU[aYt�a�p{a�i¸\ ' ~V\®t?LSNVt�NYX?X?P5R­KMXt?L K�sSU[KMX�KMISp{K�a��2N ;:9 =-0$5�;)36;�9 9"�"f�LS^_X"U[KZs5NY^jU�t�U?KZK:^qX�t?LSK:s5L®k�X?^_pZNYi�R&PSijt?^_pZNYX�t�U?a�P t?^qI��&t�U[KZKQp{a�ISX�t�U[P5p{t�KMbd|®kt?L K:U[a�P t?^qI��!sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX�ge^jt?L.t?L KQX�KMI5b KZU�NYX�t?L K�U[a®aYtZ\SU[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XWNYXWijKMNM�YKMX�NYISbdU?KZsENY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU[XWp{a.%®ija�pZNVt�KMbgW^jt?L�U?a�P t�KZU[X"��f�LSK:U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XeU?KMp{ah�YKZU�iqa�X�t�s5NYp �YKZt?X �ÁU?a�R@U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU[XeNYISb�U?KZsENY^jUWX�KZU?�YKZU�XWU?KMp{ah�YKZU�ija�X�ts5NYp �YKZt?X<�ÁU?a�R KM^jt?L KZUTP sSs}KZU!ijKZ�YKMi�U?KZs5NY^jU­X�KZU[�YKZU[X!aYU­t?L KdX�KMISb KZU4� n/U?aYt�aJp{a�i ' ~ K�+ LS^j|5^qt?XQt?L K �Áa�iqijahgW^qI��|}KMLSNM�J^jaYU��

� fWL K"X�KMI5b KZU�R&PSijt?^_pZNYX�t?X�s5NYp��YKZt?X2t�a�N�R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�t$NYb5b U?KMX?X � X?NMk����Gt?LSNVt2^qX�X?P |5X?p{U�^j|}KMb�|®kQNYi_i�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[XNYI5bdU?KZs5NY^jU�X?KZU?�YKZU[X"�

� ��I­b KZt�KMp{t?^qI��:N:iqa�X?XZ\�N�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU8\®N$�Át�KZU/g�NY^qt?^qI����çaYU/N�U�NYISb a�R NYR­a�PSI®t/a��Et?^qR­KY\�R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t?X��/N�� � Ot�a�t?LSK�U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X;^qI&^jt?X;I KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�b>NYISb&t?L K�U?KZs5NY^jU;X�KZU[�YKZU � �çaYU;t?L K�s5PSU?s}a�X�K�a���� � O7X?P sSs5U?KMX?X?^ja�INYRTa�I��>U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X�^qI¿t?L KeI KM^#��L�|}aYU[L a�aJbE�2NYISb X�t?NVU?t?X�N&� � O9U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�It?^qR­KZU��2o �¾t?L KWU?KMp{KM^q�YKZUU[KMp{KM^j�YKMX�N>� � O �ÁU?a�R NYISaYt?L KZU"U[KMp{KM^j�YKZUB�çaYU"t?LS^qX"s5NYp��YKZtZ\S^jt"X?P sSsSU[KMX?X�KMX�^qt?X/a8geI¿� � O4NYISb¿X�KZt?X�t?L K� � O U?KZt�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�I t?^qR­KZU�NYXW^#�$^jt�LSNYbÅX�KMI�tWt?L K:� � OR�

� ��I�b KZt�KMp{t?^qI��TNija�X?XZ\SN!U?KZsENY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZUM\EN$�çt�KZUeg�NY^jt?^_I�� �çaYUWN!U�NYISb a�R NYR­a�P5I�t�a��2t?^qR­KY\SR&PSijt?^_pZNYX�t?X�N� � O t�a t?LSK!X?KMISb KZU � aYU:^jt?X�P s5X�t�U?KMNYRBU?KZsENY^jU�X?KZU?�YKZU<�eNYISb t?L K!aYt?L KZU�U?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU[�YKZU[X�NVt�t?L K­X?NYR­KiqKZ�YKMiW^qI t?L KÅt�U?KZK � �ÁaYUt?L K�sEP U?s}a�X�K.a���� � O X?P s5sSU?KMX?X?^qa�IÇNYRTa�I�� U?KZs5NY^qUTX�KZU?�YKZU[X��­NYISb X�t?NVU[t?XN� � O U?KZt�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�I&t?^qR­KZU�� W L5^qijK�g�NY^qt?^qI���t�aQX�KMI5b!a�P t�N:� � O �çaYU/t?LSKWija�X�t;s5NYp �YKZtZ\�^#�Et?L K�U[KZs5NY^jUX?KZU?�YKZUeU[KMp{KM^j�YKMXeN¿� � O �ÁaYU�t?L KQX?NYR­K>s5NYp��YKZt��ÁU?a�R@NYISaYt?L KZUWU?KZsENY^jUWX�KZU?�YKZU8\Et?L KMI1^jtWX?PSsSsSU?KMX?X?KMX�^jt?XahgWIÅ� � O NYISb�X�KZt?XWt?L K:� � O U?KZt�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I t?^qRTKZU�NYXW^*��^jt�LSNYb�X�KMI®t�t?L K:� � OR�

� o ��N1U?KZs5NY^jU&X�KZU?�YKZU­LSNYX>t?L Ks5NYp �YKZtR�çaYU&gWLS^_p[L ^qtQU?KMp{KM^j�YKMb N1� � O �çU?a�R NÅRTKMRQ|}KZU&a��W^jt?XL�YU[a�P s� a��"U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X<�X�ÁaYU�gWLS^qp�L1^jt�^qXeU?KMX�s}a�ISX?^j|EijKY\5^jt�R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�t?X�t?L K&s5NYp��YKZt�t�a.t?L K �YU?a�P s ��o �;t?L K>U[KZs5NY^jUX?KZU?�YKZU�b a�KMX�I aYt�L5NM�YK�t?L K�s5NYp �YKZtZ\E^jt�X�t?NVU?t?X�t?L K�sSU[a�p{KMX?X�a��$aY|St?NY^qIS^qI��Qt?L K�s5NYp �YKZt_�çU[a�R t?LSK�X?KMISb KZU� aYU�^jt?X�P sEX�t�U?KMNYR`U?KZsENY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU<��^*�$^jt�L5NYX�I aYtWNYijU[KMNYb k bSa�I K:X�a � NYXWbSKMX?p{U[^j|}KMbdNV|}a8�YKh�A�

� fWL KeX�KMI5b KZUM\�a�I U?KMp{KM^q��^qI��QN>� � O �ÁU?a�R t?L KWU?KZsENY^jU"X�KZU[�YKZU[XZ\JU?KMR&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t?X�t?L K�U?K��®PSKMX�t�KMbsENYp��YKZt�t�aNYi_i¾t?L K�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�XWNYISbdU[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU�X"�

� fWL KK�+Js5^jU[NVt?^qa�I a���t?L K � � O U?KZt�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I t?^qR­KZU!NVt&N1U?KZs5NY^jU&X�KZU?�YKZU � aYU­NÅU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU<��ge^jt?L a�P ts5U[^jaYUQU[KMp{KZsSt?^ja�I a���t?LSK¿p{aYU?U?KMX?s�a�I5bS^qI��ds5NYp �YKZt­X�KZU?�YKMX&NYX>t?LSK¿b KZt�KMp{t?^ja�I�a���NÅiqa�X�tQs5NYp �YKZt �çaYU&t?L KU[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU � aYUWt?L K�U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU<��NYI5bdNT� � O ^qX�U?KZt�U[NYISX?R^jt�t�KMb�

W K&KMISbdt?LS^qXWX�KMp{t?^ja�I1|®kdbS^qX?t?^qI���PS^qX[LS^qI��>|�KZtzg"KZKMI Niqa��X�KZU?�J^qp{KQNYISb1NTU?KZsENY^jUWX�KZU?�J^qp{K�� � ija��X�KZU[��^qp{KY\�NYXR­KMI®t?^ja�I KMb ^qI K �.M»\}sSU?ah��^qbSKMX�X?KMp{a�ISbSNVU?kÅX?t�aYU[N$�YKR�çaYU�s5NYp �YKZt?X:t�U[NYI5X?RT^jt�t�KMb �çU[a�R t?LSK!X?KMISb KZU���f�L K&KMI®t?^jU?K� Û+͸͸Ô���×�ֻˠÓ[Ö¾Ö»ËhÌ«Í��"Ô�� Ö»ÌÎß�Ó�Í Ö+Ó�Ø Ø8Ñ»×,͸Í��YØhÌ���×,Ñ»×,ÞMÖ��§Ñ»Ð��! "� ÌÎÍGÒMÞ Ð�ÏGÞeÖ»Ð�Ö»Ëh×�Ñ»×�ß�×,Ì$#<×,Ñ�ï

Page 5: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

bSNVt?N!^qX�X�t�aYU?KMbdNVt�t?L K�ija��­X�KZU?�YKZU[X@�ÁaYU�U?KZs5NY^jU[X�NYISb �iqNVt�K[%®p{a�R­KZU�X"� " ' a��!X?KZU?��^_p{K�X?LSa�PSiqbT|}K�bS^qX�t?^_I���PS^qX?LSKMb�ÁU?a�R t?L K1U?KZs5NY^jU¿X�KZU?�J^qp{KY\�s5NVU?t?^qpZP5iqNVU[ijkÇ^*�et?LSKÅU?KZs5NY^qUX�KZU?�YKZU[X NVU?K p{a�ISX?^qb KZU[KMb�I KZt¬g�aYU���U[KMX�a�P U[p{KMXt?LSNVtgW^qi_i�|}K�X?LSNVU[KMb a8�YKZU.X�KZ�YKZU[NYi�R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?tTX�KMX?X?^ja�I5X"� ' a�����^qI�� KMI®t?^jU?K�R&PSijt?^_pZNYX�tTX�KMX?X?^qa�ISX­NVtTt?L KMX�KdU[KZs5NY^jUX�KZU?�YKZU�X�RNMkI aYt�X?pZNYijKegW^jt?L¿t?L KeI�PSR>|}KZU�a��+R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t"X�KMX?X[^ja�ISX"|�KMpZNYP5X�KWa��Gt?LSK�X�t�aYU�N$�YK�U[K��®PS^qU?KMR­KMI®t"��o�Ia�P U�g�aYU��E\¾g�K­p{a�ISX?^qbSKZU�X�t�aYU�^qI��.a�ISijkdt?L K �U?KMp{KMI®t "�bSNVt?N.NVt�t?L K!U?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU[�YKZU[X��çaYU�t?LSK&X�a�iqK&sEP U?s}a�X�KQa��sSU?ah��^_bS^qI�� �®P5^qp�� U?KZs5NY^jU�X"�

$ � � � �& �-� � �V���� �#' �V @� � ���V ���� �V� %L�.���4� T�&('

W KTI ahg b KMX?p{U[^j|}K>t?L K!t¬g�a�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|ENYX�KMb ijaJpZNYi$U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX"� W K �5U[X�t�b KMX?p{U[^q|�K&t?L K­X�KMi*��aYU���N xIS^*\M^_I��­U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|ENYX�KMbÅs5U?aYt�a�p{a�i �ÁaYUeijaJpZNYiGU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k��efWLS^qX�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i¸\�t�KZU[R­KMb ' ` \E^_XWN<�YKMISKZU[^qp:�YKZU�X?^ja�I�a��HJrem K���M+ge^jt?L.ija�pZNYiGU?KMp{a8�YKZU?k.KMISL5NYISp{KMR­KMI®t?X"�/o�I ' ` \Sija�X[X�U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k�^_X�s�KZU �çaYU[RTKMbdNVt�t¬g�a¿ijKZ�YKMiqX�� � t�t?L K�5U[X?t�ijKZ�YKMi»\GN.U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU:t�U[^qKMXet�adU[KMp{a8�YKZUQsENYp��YKZt?XQiqa�pZNYiqiqk �çU[a�R a�I5ijkÅgW^qt?LS^qIÅ^qt?X�ija�pZNYi2I KM^#��L�|}aYU[L a�aJb� W Kb K��EISK � \}N¿U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU��ÎX�ijaJpZNYi+I KM^#��L�|}aYU[L a�aJbdt�adp{a�ISX?^qX�tea��/NYiqiGt?LSK>U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X�^qI�t?L K!X?P |5t�U?KZK � a��;t?L K!R&PSijt?^´xpZNYX�teU?a�P t?^qI��­t�U[KZKh��KMRTNYISNVt?^_I��]�ÁU?a�R ^jt?XeI KMNVU?KMX�tW|5NYp���|}a�I KQU?a�PSt�KZUeNVt�t?L K>KMb��YK:a��;t?L KQ|5NYp���|}a�I K��"o �2t?L KU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qX�P5ISX?PSpZp{KMX?X��ÁPSi¾^_IdU?KMp{a8�YKZU�^qI��t?LSK:s5NYp��YKZt�ijaJpZNYiqijkY\S^qt�t�U[^jKMXWt�aU?KMp{ah�YKZU�sENYp��YKZt?X �çU[a�R`t?L K>X?KMISb KZU� N��ijaY|5NYiEU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k "��A����NYp�LU[KMp{KM^j�YKZU�NYijt�KZU[ISNVt�KMX�|}KZt¬g�KZKMI.ija�pZNYiENYISb ��ijaY|5NYiEU?KMp{a8�YKZU?k¿PSI�t?^_i5^jt"U?KMp{KM^j�YKMX�t?L KRT^qX[X?^qI��&s5NYp��YKZt"��n/U[aYt�a�p{a�i ' ` K�+ LS^j|5^jt?X�t?LSK!�ça�iqiqa8gW^qI��&|}KMLSN8��^qaYU

� t?LSK�X�KMISb KZU;R&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t?X;NYi_i®sENYp��YKZt?X"a�I­NYbSb U?KMX?X � ���$gWLS^qp�L­^qX2X?P |5X[p{U[^j|}KMb:|�k>NYiqiJa��Et?L K�s5NVU?t?^_pZ^js5NVt?^qI��U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X"�

� a�I b KZt�KMp{t?^qI��ÅNdiqa�X?XZ\+NdU[KMp{KM^j�YKZU:g�NY^jt?X:NdU[NYI5b a�R�NYR­a�PSI®t�a��"t?^_R­KTNYISb R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t?X�N�ijaJpZNYi;� � ONYb5b U?KMX?X�KMb a�ISijk t�a t?L KU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X>^_I ^jt?X>I KM^*��L®|�aYU�L a®aJb NYISb�X�t?NVU?t?X!NÅiqa�pZNYi"� � O@U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�It?^_R­KZU � �EU[X�t %®ijKZ�YKMi"U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k �AO�^*��t?L KU[KMp{KM^j�YKZU­b a®KMX&I aYt>U?KMp{KM^j�YK t?L K¿ija�X?tQs5NYp �YKZt­|�K"�ÁaYU?KTt?LSK ijaJpZNYi� � O@U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�I t?^qR­KZU>K�+�sE^jU?KMXZ\�^jt:g�NY^jt?XL�ÁaYU&N�U[NYISb a�R NYR­a�PSI®tQa���t?^qR­K¿NYISb R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t?XQN��iqaY|5NYi�� � O t�a NYbSb U?KMX?X �`NYISb X?t?NVU?t?X>N ��ijaY|5NYi�� � O U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�I t?^_R­KZU � ��ijaY|ENYi�U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kS�A�fWL KQU[NYI5b a�R@g�NY^jt?^qI��t?^qR­KMX�NYISb1t?L K&� � O U?KZt�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I�t?^qR­KZa�P t�� NYi_P KMXeNVU[K&bS^*,�KZU?KMI®t/�ÁaYU�t?L Ktzg"a�iqKZ�YKMiqXWa��"U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k��Qf�L KE�5U[X�t�ijKZ�YKMi$U?KZt�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�IÅt?^qR­KZa�P t�gW^qi_iG|}K>X?RNYiqijKZU���o>�;t?LSK>U?KMp{KM^q�YKZUbSa®KMX�I aYt�U[KMp{a8�YKZU�t?L K�ija�X�t�sENYp��YKZt�|}K"�çaYU?Ket?L K/��iqaY|5NYiE� � O9U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�I­t?^qRTKZU�K�+Js5^jU?KMXZ\�^jt"X?t?NVU?t?Xt?LSKQijaJpZNYi}U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k1N$��NY^qI�

� a�IÇU?KMp{KM^q��^qI��1N ijaJpZNYi"� � O �ÁaYU!gWLS^qp�L ^jt!LSNYX&t?L K.NYX?X�aJpZ^qNVt�KMbÇs5NYp��YKZtZ\�N1U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU­R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�t?X&t?L KsENYp��YKZt.a�ISijk t�a ^jt?XI KM^#��L�|}aYU[L a�aJbO�|}K"�çaYU[K1X�KMISb5^qI�� t?LS^qXU?KZs5NY^jU¿s5NYp��YKZtZ\�N U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU g�NY^jt?X �çaYU.Np{KZU[t?NY^qI U[NYISb a�R NYR­a�PSI®t�a��Gt?^qR­K�NYISb X?P sSsSU[KMX?X�KMX�^qt?X"ahgWI t�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I^*�GNYI aYt?L KZU�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X?KMISbSXa�PStdt?L K U?KZs5NY^jUdsENYp��YKZtÅ^qI)t?L5^qX t?^qR­K��@��I)U?KMp{KM^j�J^qI�� N ��ijaY|ENYi�� � O �çaYU1N s5NYp��YKZtZ\:N U?KMp{KM^q�YKZUX[P sSsSU?KMX[X�KMX�^jt?X�ahgWI�� � O ^#��^jt�^_X�s5iqNYISIS^_I��>t�a¿X�KMISbda�I K!�ÁaYU�t?L K>X?NYR­K:s5NYp �YKZt"�

� PSs�a�I.U[KMp{KM^j��^_I��TN ��ijaY|5NYiG� � O­\St?L K:X�KMI5b KZUWR&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t?X�t?L K�s5NYp��YKZt�t�a �)�

f�L K­NV|}a8�YKsSU?aYt�aJp{a�i;NVt�t�KMR­sSt?X:t�adKMI5X?P U?K!t?LSNVt�a�ISiqkÅa�I K­� � O NYI5b a�ISijkÅa�ISK&U[KZs5NY^jU:NVU?KR�YKMI KZU�NVt�KMb NVtKM^jt?L KZU­U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k ijKZ�YKMiS� ^ I5iq^*�YK�HJrWm K��.M»\ ' ` �YKMISKZU[NVt�KMX J�P(G�� 0$PX;�9>=-0$5�;A? G$D�P��<QA;:G�� 3�9 ?�9�D Y 9";>t?LSKZU?KZ|®k

� Ê}ËhÌÎÍ�Ø8× �VÞhÌÎÖ»ÌÎÐ�Þ�Ó�Þ ØeÐ[ֻˠ×,Ñ$Øh×��VÞ Ì Ö»ÌÎÐ<ÞhÍGÐ � �ÎÐZß�Ó ��Þ ×,Ì���ËMÙYÐ�ѻˠÐZÐMØ�ß�Ó�Þ�ÙY× �¥Ð<ÔhÞVØeÌÎÞ�� ã��qï

Page 6: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

NM�Ya�^_bS^qI��­t?L KQU[^qX:� a�� ��iqaY|5NYi¾U?KZs5NY^qU�K�+�sEija�X?^ja�I�;o�I1HJrem \5U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XeNYISbdt?L KQX?KMISb KZUWPSX?K:N­U[NYISb a�R |5NYp��®xa$, X?t�U[NVt�K"�Yk.t�a �YKMISKZU[NVt�KQN&U?KZs5NY^jU4� � KZU?K�NYiqi�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X�NYISb t?L K�X�KMISb KZU �iq^qX?t�KMI#"E�ÁaYU�N!U?KZs5NY^jU4��o �Gt?L KZk b aI aYteU?KMp{KM^j�YK&t?L K:U?KZs5NY^qUWgW^jt?L5^qIdNp{KZU?t?NY^_IÅt?^qRTK:t?L KMI1t?L KZk �YKMI KZU[NVt�K!NTU?KZsENY^jUW^*�2t?L KZk�LSN8�YK&^qt"���eaYt�K&t?LSNVtN�U[KZs5NY^jUQLSNYXQt�a1|}KTs5U?a�p{KMX[X�KMb NVt>KMNYp[L I aJb K­gWL KZt?L KZU&^jtQ^qX>X�KMI®tQaYUQU[KMp{KM^j�YKMb� � KMISp{Kt?L K¿a8�YKZU[LSKMNYb�a��sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��>N ��ijaY|5NYiEU?KZs5NY^qU�PSI5b KZU�H rWm NYISb ' ` gW^_iqiS|}K�p{a�R­s5NVU[NV|5iqK��/� aYU�ijaJpZNYi5U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kY\5I a!s5NVU[t?^qpZPSiqNVUL a�X�t!^qX>iq^*�YKMijk t�a LSNM�YK.t?L K U?KZs5NY^jU�XQNYISbÇL KMISp{KY\/NYX&^qIÇH rWm�\ ' ` PSX?KMX>N1U[NYISb a�R |5NYp��®x»a$,�X?t�U[NVt�K"�Yk �ÁaYU�YKMI KZU[NVt?^_I��­ija�pZNYi�U?KZsENY^jU[X"�;n/U[aYt�a�p{a�i ' ` L5NYX"|}KZKMI.b KMX?p{U�^j|}KMb¿NV|}a8�YK:^_It?L K�pZNYX�K�a��+t¬g�aVx¬ijKZ�YKMiGU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k���o,tp{a�PSiqb.|}K�KMNYX?^_ijk �YKMISKZU[NYiq^*\ZKMbdt�a¿R>PSiqt?^js5ijK�ijKZ�YKMiqX�a���U?KMp{ah�YKZU?k��f�L K&b KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMbÅU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU�iqa�pZNYi+U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k1sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i¸\�t�KZU[R­KMb ' � \¾^qXWX[^qRT^qiqNVUWt�a¿sSU[aYt�a�p{a�i � ` b KMX?p{U�^j|}KMb�^qIK´~Y~�M gW^jt?L&X�a�R­K�RT^_I aYU�b5^(,�KZU[KMISp{KMX"�$fWL K"U[KZs5NY^jU2t�U?KZK�^qI ' � � NYISb � ` �$^qX�N�ija���^qpZNYi�t�U?KZKLK´~�� \ ~Y~�MSp{a�ISX�t�U�PSp{t�KMbgW^jt?L¿KMISb L a�X�t?X � t?L K�X�KMISb KZU�NYISb t?L K�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X<�A�/f�LS^qX�ija���^qpZNYiEU?KZs5NY^jU�t�U?KZK�^qX�bS^(,}KZU?KMI�t@�ÁU?a�R t?LSKes5L®kJX?^qpZNYiR&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t�U[a�P t?^qI��!t�U?KZK��"o,ISX?t�KMNYbda���X?s�KMpZ^_NYi}U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZUeL a�X�t?XM\SKMNYp[L1I a�IJx¬ijKMN$��U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qX�NYX?X?^*��ISKMbdt?L Kt?NYX:� a���sSU[a8�J^qbS^qI��¿U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�J^qp{K!t�a�^jt?X�p�LS^qiqb U[KMI��o,I sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' � \+t?L K­X�KMISb KZU�R&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t?X�t?LSK&aYU�^*��^qISNYit�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�ISX;a��GN:sENYp��YKZt�t�a&NYi_iSt?L KeU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X"|5P t�PSISiq^*�YK ' ~V\�^qt"R&PSijt?^qpZNYX�t?X�U?KZt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�ISX;a�ISijk!t�a!^jt?Xp[L5^qiqb U?KMI ^qI¿t?L K:ija���^qpZNYi�t�U?KZK��"f�LS^qX�p{a�PSiqb |}K�bSa�I K�|®k PSX?^qI��&N­X�KZs5NVU[NVt�K:R&PSijt?^_pZNYX�tC�YU[a�P sdt�a!gWLS^qp�L NYi_iEa��t?L K:b KMX[^*��ISNVt�KMb.U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�XWNYISb.t?L K:X?KMISb KZU�|}KMija�I����;f�L K:� � O:XB�çU[a�R b KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMb.U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X�NVU[KQNYiqX�a­X�KMI®ta�I�t?L5^qX_�YU?a�PSs �ÁaYUWt?L K>s5P U?s}a�X�K�a��;� � O X?P sSs5U?KMX?X?^ja�I ����NYp�L1b KMX[^*��ISNVt�KMb1U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�U?KMp{a8�YKZU[X�ija�X?t�s5NYp��YKZt?X�ÁU?a�R ^jt?XQs5NVU?KMI®tQNYISb X?PSsSs5iq^jKMX�U?KZsENY^jU[X�t�a ^jt?X:p[L5^qiqb U?KMI ^_I t?L Kija���^_pZNYi;t�U?KZK�� o,I ' � � PSI5iq^*�YK � ` �:NÅI aJb Kb a�KMX�I aYtWX?KMISbdNYI�k.s}KZU[^jaJbS^qp�NYp��JI ahgWijKMb���R­KMI®t?X�t�a¿^jt?X�s5NVU?KMI®t"�m1a�X�t/a���t?L KX��ISa8gWI­ijaJpZNYiJU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k­R­KMp[LSNYI5^qX?RTX��ÁaYU�X?P s5s�aYU[t?^qI��eX?KZU?�YKZU/aYU/U?KMp{KM^q�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMbTiqa�pZNYiJU?KMp{ah�YKZU?kNVU[p�LS^jt�KMp{t?P U?KMXepZNYId|}K:NVt�t�U[^j|5PSt�KMb.t�a K´~ ` M$NYISb K y$M ��� aYUWt?LSK�s5P U?s}a�X�K�a��2X?p{aYs5^qI��­t�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�^qIdNTijaJpZNYiNVU?KMN!a�I K�a��$t?L K�t?L K��ça�iqiqa8gW^qI��>R­KMp�LSNYIS^qX?RXC�ÁU?a�R K y.M»\ � 5q��f�f ' � t?^qRTKet�aTiq^q�YKh� %�|5NYX�KMbdijaJpZNYi�U?KMp{a8�YKZU?kY\ � 585q�NYbSRT^_IS^qX�t�U[NVt?^q�YK�X[p{aYs5^qI�� \ � 5�585q��X�KZs5NVU�NVt�K>R&PSijt?^qpZNYX�tX�YU[a�P s5XZ\SpZNYId|}K:PSX?KMb�f�L K�X[P |St�U?KZK�R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t;t�KMp[LSIS^ �®P KY\�t?LSNVt�PSX�KMX/o,n KMISpZNVs5X?PSi_NVt?^ja�I � X�KZK)K´~ ` MÁ��\JpZNYI­|}K�PSX�KMb!t�a&bS^jU?KMp{t2U?KZsENY^jU[X�ÁU?a�R N U?KZs5NY^qUTX�KZU?�YKZUTt�a a�I5ijk t?L K�bSa8gWISX?t�U?KMNYR U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X"��� aYU^qI��çaYU[R^qI�� t?L KdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XNV|�a�PSt­t?L KM^jUgWL KZU[KMNV|�a�PSt?X � �çaYU"K�+JNYRTs5ijKY\�t?LSK�o,n�R>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t�NYb5b U?KMX?X�KMX�I KZKMb KMbTt�aQU?KMNYp[L¿t?L K�U?KZsENY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU�X���t?L K�U[KZs5NY^jUX�KZU?�YKZU�X;pZNYI­X�KMISb!a�P t;X?ijahg U[NVt�K�NYb �YKZU?t?^qX?KMR­KMI�t?X��2fWLS^qX�L KMijs5X2^qI&LSNYISbSi_^qI��eISKZgÇU[KZs5NY^jU;X�KZU?�YKZU/NYX?X[^*��ISR­KMI®t?XbSP K�t�aU?a�P t?^qI��­p�LSNYI��YKMX"�

� � '"� ����� ���

W KQI ahg7sSU?KMX�KMI®t�t?L K�I KZtzg"aYU��dija�X[X�NYI5bdX�k�X?t�KMR R­aJb KMi�t?LSNVt�gW^qiqiE|}K�PSX�KMb �ÁaYU�t?L K�s}KZU��çaYU�RTNYISp{K�NYISNYijkJX?^qXa��GsSU[aYt�a�p{a�iqX ' ~V\ ' ` NYISb ' � �;o�I K ` �$M»\���N�?IS^*� 9"3 0�P�LSNM�YK�aY|5X?KZU?�YKMbt?L5NVt�R­a�X?t"a��¾t?L K�ija�X?X?KMX�t?N$�YK�s5iqNYp{K�^qIt?L K�iq^qI���XH�çU?a�R t?L K�X�a�P U�p{K�X[^jt�Ket�a!t?L K�|5NYp �®|}a�I K � g�K�pZNYi_iEt?L5^qX�t?LSK�X?a�P U[p{K�iq^qI��S�;NYISb.^qI¿t?L K�iq^qI��JX � pZNYi_ijKMb �t?NY^qi;iq^_I���X "��X�ÁU?a�R t?L K­|5NYp �®|}a�I K!t�adt?L KT^_ISbS^j�J^qbSPSNYi+X?^jt�KMX � t�KZU[R­KMb X?t?P | b a�RTNY^qI5X�^_I K � MÁ��\+NYX�X?L ahgWI ^qI�2^*��P U?KT~$��f�L K�|ENYp���|�a�ISKQNYISbdt?L K>^qISbS^j�J^qbSP5NYi5X?^jt�KMXWLSNM�YK>|�KZKMI�aY|5X�KZU?�YKMbÅt�a|}K:R­a�X�t?ijk.ija�X?X_�çU?KZK��"ozteLSNYXNYiqX�a>|}KZKMITI aYt�KMb ^qI K ��M�t?LSNVt�t?NY^qiEiq^qI��JX;NVU?K�iq^*�YKMijk!t�aQ|}K�|}aYt�t?ijKMISKMp��JXH�ÁaYU�t?L K �çaYU[KMX�KZKMNV|5ijK �ÁP t?PSU?K�� � KMISp{K�^qIa�P U�ija�X?XWRTa�b KMi+g"K&p{a�ISX?^qbSKZUeija�X?XWa�ISijkdNVtWt?LSK>X�a�P U�p{K>NYISbÅt?NY^qi+iq^_I���X�� ' a�X?X�KMX�NVtWt?L K&X�a�P U[p{K&iq^qI��¿gW^qiqi¾|}KX�KZKMIÅ|®k.NYiqi¾t?L KQU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XWgWL KZU?KMNYX�iqa�X?X�KMXWNVteN­t?NY^qiGiq^_I��gW^_iqi�|�K:X?KZKMIda�ISijk |®k.t?L KQU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XeNVt�t?NYp[L KMb1t�a

y

Page 7: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

local neighborhood

Source

Repair Server

Receiver

Backbone Router

Tail links

site

receiversin each tail link(no loss within a site)

p

pl

l

Backbone links

Source link

Source

loss free backbone

�2^*��P U?KT~ ��HJk�X�t�KMR@mÅaJb KMi

w

Page 8: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

^jt"� ' a�X?X?KMX�NVt�t?NY^qi�iq^qI���XeNVU?K&NYX[X?PSR­KMb1t�a.|�K&R>PSt?PSNYiqijk�^qI5b KZs}KMISb KMI®t"� W K­NYiqX�a.NYX?X?PSR­K&t?LSNVt�ija�X?X�KZ�YKMI®t?XNVU?K¿t�KMR­s}aYU[NYiqijk ^qISbSKZs�KMI5b KMI�t"� ' KZt>t?L K¿iqa�X?X:sSU[aY|5NV|5^qiq^qt¬k ^qI t?L K.X�a�P U[p{K iq^qI�� NYISb�KMNYp[LÇt?NY^qi�i_^qI�� |�K ��� �f�L K�KMI5b&%�t�a.%�KMISb�ija�X[X�sSU?aY|5NV|E^qiq^jtzkTNYXWX�KZKMId|�k.N!U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUM\ � \S^qX�K��®P5NYi¾t�aÅ~�� � ~�� ��� � � � W KQNYiqX�aTNYX?X[PSR­Kt?LSNVt�� � O:X�NVU[KeI KZ�YKZU�ija�X�t"�;f�LS^_X;NYX?X?PSR­s5t?^ja�ITp{a�PSiqb|}K�U?KMiqN.+JKMbT|�kR�ça�iqiqa8gW^qI���t?LSKeNYISNYijkJX?^qX ��^j�YKMI^qI K´~Mu.M �W K>NYX[X?PSR­K:t?L5NVtWg�KMiqi %®b K��EISKMbdija�pZNYi$I KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�bSX�K�+ ^qX�tWNYI5b�t?LSNVt�t?LSK>R­KMp�LSNYIS^qX?RX�b KMX?p{U[^q|�KMbdNVtet?L KKMISb1a��/t?L K>sSU?KZ�J^ja�PSX�X�KMp{t?^ja�I p{a�PSiqb1|�K&PSX�KMb1t�a NYb5b U?KMX?Xes5NYp��YKZt?X�t�a.X�s}KMpZ^(�Ep>I KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�bSX�� ' KZt�t?L KZU?K|}KQa�I K&X�a�P U[p{K&iq^qI��.NYISb�� t?NY^_i+iq^qI���X�geL KZU?KQKMNYp�L t?NY^qi+iq^_I�� L5NYXeR&PSijt?^jsEijK�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X�� ' KZteKMNYp[L P sEX�t�U?KMNYR|5NYp �®|}a�I K U?a�P t�KZUM\/NVt&t?L K KMb��YK.a���t?L K |5NYp���|}a�I KY\/LSN8�YK�� t?NY^qi�iq^qI��JX"�ÅfWL K I�PSR>|}KZUQa��WX?P5p[LÇ|5NYp���|}a�I KU?a�P t�KZU�XZ\ ^qX�K���PSNYiEt�a�� ����� W K�NYX?X?PSRTKWt?LSNVt�p{a�RTR&PSIS^qpZNVt?^ja�I¿|}KZt¬g�KZKMI.t¬g�a>U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X�a�I.bS^(,}KZU?KMI�t"t?NY^qiiq^qI���X�t?N$�YKMX�sEiqNYp{K�a�ISijk t?L U?a�P���LdNT|5NYp���|}a�I K�U?a�P t�KZU � X<�A��c�^jU?KMp{t�X?^jt�K{x¬X[^jt�K:iq^qI��JX � t�KZU[R­KMb1X�t?P | x¬X�t?PS| KMb��YKMX^qI K � MÁ��NVU?K:iq^*�YKMijk¿t�aT|}K��YKZU?k.U[NVU?K��f�L K&NV|}a8�YK­ija�X?X�R­aJb KMi+LSNYX�^qR­sEiq^qpZNVt?^ja�ISX�a�IÅt?L K&s5iqNYp{KMRTKMI�t�a��/U?KZs5NY^qUeX�KZU?�YKZU�X�^_ISX?^qb K�t?LSK&I KZtzg"aYU ��� W KNVU���P K�t?LSNVt�t?L K�U?KZsENY^jU�X?KZU?�YKZU[X�X?L a�P5iqb|}K�s5iqNYp{KMb gW^jt?L¿t?L K�U?a�P t�KZU�X�NVt�t?LSKeKMb��YK�a��+t?L K�|5NYp���|}a�I K��/f+a­|}KNV|5ijKet�a!t?N$�YK:NYb � NYI®t?N$�YK�a��$ijaJpZNYiEU?KMp{a8�YKZU?kY\ENQU?KZsENY^jU�X?KZU?�YKZU�X?L a�PSiqb|}KW|}aYt?L¿PSs5X�t�U?KMNYR a��+NYISb.NYX�pZija�X�K�t�at?L K:s}a�^qI®t�a���iqa�X?X�NYX�s}a�X?X[^j|5ijK��2�2^*��P U?KT~:X[L a8gWX�t?L K�s5iqNYp{KMR­KMI®t�a��2U?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU?�YKZU[X"�W KWKMI5b!t?LS^qX/X�KMp{t?^qa�I­|®k­I aYt?^_I���t?LSNVt �ÁaYU�a�P U�X?k�X�t�KMR R­a�bSKMiJt¬g�a.%®ijKZ�YKMi5U[KMp{a8�YKZU?kT^qX�X?P-�¿pZ^jKMI®t �ÁaYU/sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i' ~$� o,I NYISNYiqkV\M^qI�� ' � \�g"K�NYX?X[PSR­Kdt?LSNVtTt?LSKZU?KÅ^qX­N tzg"a�ijKZ�YKMi�LS^jKZU�NVU[p[L®k�geL KZU?Kda�I KdU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU¿^qI KMNYp�LI KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�b¿^qX�NYX?X?^*��ISKMb.t?L K�t?NYX:�a���X?P sSs5iqk�^qI��:U?KZs5NY^jU�X�gW^qt?LS^qI¿t?L K�I KM^*��L®|�aYU�L a®aJb�2f�L KMX�K�b KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMbU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X�U?KMp{ah�YKZU�ija�X?t�s5NYp��YKZt?X�bS^jU?KMp{t?iqk]�ÁU?a�R`t?L KQX?KMISb KZU��

� % �&���>� � � � � � � ��� '4�('

o�I)t?LS^qXdX�KMp{t?^ja�I)g�K NYISNYijk&\ZK t?L K KMISb7X?k�X�t�KMR(sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI�� NYISb7ISKZt¬g�aYU�� |ENYISb gW^qbSt?L U?K���PS^jU[KMR­KMI�t?X.a��sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX ' ~V\ ' ` NYISb ' � �� a�iqiqa8gW^qI�� t?L K1NVs5sSU?a�NYp[L �5U[X?tX?P����YKMX�t�KMb�^qI K´~��$M»\�t?L KÅU?KMp{KM^q�YK1sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI�� p{a�X�t � t?^qR­Kh�T^qXTb KZt�KZU[R^qI KMb|�kÇp{a�R­sEP t?^qI�� t?L Kdt�aYt?NYieNYR­a�PSI®tTa���sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI�� ^qI®�Ya�ij�YKMb�^_I 2 G$;[;:9 2�36P��ÅU?KMp{KM^q��^qI�� N U[NYISb a�RTiqk p[L a�X?KMIs5NYp �YKZt"�"f�LS^_X/^qISpZiqP5b KMX2t?L KWt?^_R­KWU?K���PS^jU[KMb­t�aQU?KMp{KM^q�YKet?L a�X?Kep{aYs5^jKMX"a��¾t?LS^qX�s5NYp��YKZt � ^S� K��j\�t?L KeaYU[^*��^qISNYi5p{aYs®ks5iqP5X�NYI�kdU?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX���t?LSNVt�NVU?U[^j�YK>NVtWt?L K:U[KMp{KM^j�YKZUM\�t?L K:t?^qR­KQU?K��®P5^jU?KMbdt�a X�KMISb��hU?KMp{KM^q�YKQNYI�k�� � O:XNYX?X�aJpZ^qNVt�KMbgW^jt?L!t?LS^qX2sENYp��YKZt�NYISb­t?L K�t?^qRTK�I KZKMb KMb­t�a&LSNYISbSijK�NYI®k>t?^_R­KZU�^qI®t�KZU?U[P s5t?X;NYX?X�aJpZ^qNVt�KMbTgW^qt?L!t?LS^qXs5NYp �YKZt"�"f�L K�X�KMISb¿sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��Qp{a�X�t�^qX�bSKZt�KZU[RT^qI KMb|®kt?L Ket�aYt?NYi}X�KMI5b KZU"s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��Q^_I��Ya�ij�YKMb ^qI p{aYU?U?KMp{t?ijkt�U[NYISX[RT^jt�t?^qI��TNTs5NYp��YKZt�p{aYU?U?KMp{t?ijk.t�a NYiqi¾t?L K:U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X"��f�LS^qX�^_ISpZiqPSb KMX�t?LSKQp{a�X�tWU[K��®PS^qU?KMb.t�asSU[a�p{KMX?XeNYI�kU?KMp{KM^j�YKMb1� � O:XZ\SNYI5bdsSU?aJp{KMX?X�U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�t?LSNVtWNVU[KQX�KMI®t�a�P tW^qI.U?KMX?s�a�I5X�K�t�aTt?L KMX�K:� � O:X"�^ ISiq^*�YK:aYt?LSKZU�NYI5NYijk�X?KMX � K�� ��� K uJ\$~�� \2~Y~Y\�~��J\$~M�.MÁ��g�K&NYiqX?a¿NYISNYijk&\ZK&t?L K � 0$D Y F 5 Y 3 U?K���PS^jU?KMRTKMI�t?XWa��/t?L K�VNVU[^ja�PSX�sSU[aYt�a�p{a�iqX���� aYUeNYI5NYijkV\M^_I��­|5NYISb ge^qb t?L¿g"KL�ÁaJpZPSX�a�Idt?L KE�ça�iqiqa8gW^qI��>tzg"a¿|5NYISb gW^_b t?L.R­KZt�U[^qpZX"�

~$����G�3 0$P ��0$D Y F 5 Y 3��&?�0�J&9��Åt?LSKÅt�aYt?NYi�I®PSR>|}KZUTa���|®k�t�KMXX?KMI�t¿s�KZU¿X?PSpZp{KMX?X:� PSi�sENYp��YKZt t�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�INYiqa�I��NYiqi}a���t?L KQiq^_I���X�t�aNYi_i¾t?L K�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X��$�

��� Ð[Ñ»× ��×�Þ ×,Ñ¬Ó � �ÎÚ�Ï�×"ß,Ð<Ô��«Ø:ËVÓ #{×�Ó�Ö»ËhÑ»×�×"ØhÌ ��×�Þh͸ÌÎÐ<ÞVÓ ��Ö¬Ó�Ù �Î×"ÏGÌ Ö»Ë�ֻˠ×�ØhÌ ��×�Þh͸̫Ð�Þ Í$ÙY×�ÌÎÞ ��ÖÁÚ8ÕY×�Ð �5ÕVÓ[ßzÒ{×zÖ��qØ Ó?Ö¬Ó[æ_ÕVÓ[ßzÒ<×,Ö

Page 9: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

��� º ªz¡���ªz¤¥¨���ª,�����,�V�[��¢,¢$ªz¡���ª,�,�8¯�¢¬¨�¤´¢z¢z¤¥�8¯Q�8£}�����h��½8�[ª;�Mª/��¢z�[¯®°Y�[���� º ªz¡���ªz¤¥¨���ª,�����,�V�[��¢,¢2��Æ������Zª/��¢z�[¯�°Y��� � º ªz¡���ªz¤¥¨���ª,�����,�V�[��¢,¢2�e¯��[³;�¥�Q�,���?��¤§�h��°Q���8��½h�?ª/�Zª/���z�<�?��¤§�h�[�� º ªz¡���ªz¤¥¨���ª,�����,�V�[��¢,¢2�Wª,¤§¨����8©Yª��Mª��e�,���[�[¤¥�8��� � º ªz¡���ªz¤¥¨���ª,�����,�V�[��¢,¢2�M¯�°Qªz���M¯�¢z¨�¤«ª �{�,���[�[¤¥�8����Æ������Zª/���,���?��¤§�h�[�� º ªz¡����[¯�° º ªz�Mº �[¯®°Q�¥�h¢,¢2���,�8¦��8¦�¤§�¥¤§ª»�:�Zª����z�<�?��¤§�h�[���� º ªz¡���¢¬�h©��,�[�"�¥¤¥¯�½Q�h�2ª,�M¤¥� �¥¤§¯�½>�§� ¢z¢2���z�h¦��M¦�¤¥�¥¤«ª»�� º ªz¡���ªz�Mª��M� ¯��®¶¾�M£Eª,�M¤¥�S�¥¤§¯�½V¢� º ¯V©�¨W¦��[�;�8£Eª��M¤¥�S�¥¤§¯�½Y¢2���[�/¦®�8��½V¦®�h¯����z�h©Yªz�����Z�z�����M¤¥��¢z�[�,�8������5µ �� º ªz¡���¢¬��¯�°!�M¯�°>�z�<�?��¤§�h�"���[�/�®�8��½8�[ª����z�Y�?�<¢z¢z¤¥¯�±

ªz¤¥¨���¤§¯!���,�Mª,�Y�?�8�������<���8µ����Yµ��! #"f$NV|EijKT~ ���eaYt?NVt?^ja�I

` ����;:0%$ 2 2 G$D�2[9�D 36;:0�365SG$D ��t?LSK U�NVt?^ja a��>NM�YKZU�N$�YK |5NYISbSgW^qb t?L PSX?N$�YK a��Qt?LSK iq^qI�� gW^qt?L t?L K L5^*��L KMX�tN8�YKZU[N$�YK&|5NYISb gW^_b t?LPSX[N$�YK:t�a­t?L K:NM�YKZU�N$�YKQ|5NYISbSgW^qb t?L PSX?N$�YK�ah�YKZUeNYiqi¾iq^_I���X�^qI.t?L K�I KZtzg"aYU ����f�LS^qXRTKMNYX?P U?KQL5NYX�|}KZKMIdPSX�KMbdt�ap{a�RTs5NVU?K:t?L K�s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYI5p{KMX�a��2U?a�P t?^qI��!sSU[aYt�a�p{a�iqX�K ` \ ��M �

� � � %L��� � '�'����'&)()� '�� � ��� '4�('

W K�I ahg bSKZU[^j�YK K�+�sSU[KMX?X?^ja�ISX)�ÁaYUTX�KMISb KZU!NYISbÇU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU­sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI�� U?K��®P5^jU?KMR­KMI®t?XE�ÁaYU!sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX ' ~V\ ' `NYISb ' � � f�NV|5ijK ~ b KMX?p{U[^q|�KMX¿t?L K I aYt?NVt?^ja�I7PSX?KMb�^_I t?L K NYISNYijkJX?^qX�� HJa�R­K1a��>t?L K I aYt?NVt?^ja�I)LSNYX.|}KZKMIU?KM^qI®t�U?aJbSPSp{KMb �ÁU?a�R K´~M�J\�u$M � W K NYX[X?PSR­K¿t?LSNVtQsSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI���t?^qRTKMXQLSN8�YK �YKMISKZU[NYi"b5^qX�t�U[^j|EP t?^ja�ISX�NYISb t?LSNVtt?L KZkdNVU?K:^qI5b KZs}KMISb KMI®t"a��2KMNYp[L1aYt?L KZU��

� � � � � � ��� '4�(' � � �

�eaYt?NVt?^ja�I�X?s�KMpZ^*�Ep!t�a ' ~T^qX>b KMX?p{U[^j|}KMb ^qI f$NV|5iqK ` �d� a�iqijahgW^qI���t?LSKNVsSsSU?a�NYp�L�bSKMX?p{U[^j|}KMb ^qI K´~M� \�u�M»\2t?L KR­KMNYI s}KZU�s5NYp��YKZt�s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI�� t?^qR­K �çaYU:N U[NYI5b a�RTijk�p�L a�X�KMI s5NYp �YKZtQNVt�t?L K­X�KMISb KZU �ÁaYU�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' ~!pZNYI|}K�K�+�s5U?KMX?X�KMb�NYXM\

* K +-, � M�. * K /10:M * K +32$M�4 � * K /10�M � ~8� * K +65VM � �&�q~8�f�L K/�5U[X�t"t�KZU[R p{aYU?U?KMX�s}a�ISb5X/t�a&t?L K�RTKMNYIsSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��QU[K��®PS^qU?KMb­t�a!t�U[NYISX?R^jt�N>s5NYp��YKZt"��f�L KeX?KMp{a�ISb t�KZU[Rp{aYU?U?KMX?s�a�I5bSX�t�aTt?L KQRTKMNYI�� � O sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��­U?K���PS^jU?KMb.NVt�t?LSKQX�KMISb KZU4�f�L K:RTKMNYIdsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��&U[K��®PS^qU?KMR­KMI®t�NVtWN­U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU �çaYUeN­U[NYISb a�Rijkp[LSa�X�KMI�s5NYp �YKZt�^_X

* K 7 , � M�. * K /18 M � ~ � ��� � * K 7 2 M�4 � * K /18�M � ~8� * K 7 5 M�4 * K � /:9�� ` �%; M * K 7=<6M � �&� ` �Ð�Ñ$ì2Û�>�? �hÖçÚ8ÕY×�Ð � �ÎÌ«ÞhÒ �j͸Ð�ÔhÑ»ß�× �ÎÌ«ÞhÒ � Ö¬Ó�Ì � �ÎÌÎÞ ÒeÐ�Ñ$ÙVÓ[ßzÒMÙYÐ<Þh×"�«ÌÎÞhÒ@?¾Ó[ÞVØ�ØhÌ Ñ»×�ßzֻ̫Ð�Þ�Ð<Þ�Ö»Ëh× �ÎÌÎÞ Ò �jÔ ÕhÍ Ö¸Ñ»×�Ó ��Ð�Ñ�ØhÐ�ÏGÞhÍ Ö¸Ñ»×�Ó ��? �Ö»ÐeØh×,Ö»×,Ñ ��ÌÎÞh×�Ö»Ëh×�ÙVÓ[ÞVØMÏĢØMÖ»ËQÓ�͸͸ÐZß�Ì«Ó[Ö»×�Ø>ÏGÌ Ö»ËQÖ»Ëh×"ָѬÓ�ÞhÍ ��ÌÎ͸͸̫Ð�Þ>Ð �¾Ó�ÕVÓ[ßzÒ{×zÖ2Ð #{×,Ñ/Ó�ß�×,Ѹ֬Ó[ÌÎÞ��ÎÌÎÞ Ò�ÌÎÞ>Óeß�×,Ѹ֬Ó[ÌÎÞ&Ø8ÌÎÑ»×,ß,Ö»ÌÎÐ<Þ®ïÊ}Ë ×,Þ�Ï}×;ß�Ð�Ô��«ØeÍ¸Ô � Ð #{×,Ѿֻˠ×;Ù Ó�Þ Ø8ÏGÌ«Ø8Ö»ËeԠ͸×�ØWÐ #<×,Ñ$Ó � � �ÎÌÎÞ ÒMÍ�ï

u

Page 10: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

��� º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�/�8£5ªz���M¯®¢¬¨�¤´¢z¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨7ªz¡���¢¬��¯�°Y�[�;�,��� ©�¤¥�,��°Q£q�8�/�M�¥� �,�[���8¤§�¢¬���z�h�[��¢+ª,��¢¬©����?�<¢z¢¬£q©��¥�§�:�,���[�[¤¥�8�������8��½h�?ª

��� º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�/�8£5ªz���M¯®¢¬¨�¤´¢z¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨9���,�[���8¤§�;¢z�[�,�8�[�2�,��� ©�¤¥�z�<°�£q�h��e�,���[�[¤¥�8���$ª,�:¢¬©®�[�?�<¢z¢¬£q©��¥�§�Q�z�<�?�[¤¥�8�������8��½h�?ª

��� º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�/�8£5ªz���M¯®¢¬¨�¤´¢z¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨9���,�[���8¤§�;¢z�[�,�8�[��ª,���8�§�ªz¡����,���[� ��¢$£q�8�;³;¡�¤´��¡!¤«ª/¤´¢2�,��¢z�®�h¯�¢¬¤¥¦��¥��¢¬©����?�<¢z¢¬£q©��¥�§��z�<�?�Q����½ ª;À+�8¢,¢z©�¨�¤§¯�±�ª,¡��Zª/¯�����½ ª�¢/�M�,��¢¬��¯hª2£q�,�8¨7ª,¡���¢z�[¯�°Y���

��� º ªz¡������[�/�®�8��½8�[ª����z�Y�?�<¢z¢z¤¥¯�±Wª,¤§¨��W�Mª2ªz¡����,�[���8¤§�;¢z�[�,�8���f$NV|EijK ` ���eaYt?NVt?^ja�IÅX�s}KMpZ^(��p�t�a ' ~

f�L K]�5U[X�t>t�KZU[R p{aYU?U?KMX�s}a�ISbSXQt�a t?L KsSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��ÅU[K��®PS^qU?KMb t�a p{aYU?U?KMp{t?ijk U?KMp{KM^j�YK.NÅs5NYp �YKZt"� f�L K¿X?KMp{a�ISbt�KZU[R p{aYU[U?KMX�s}a�ISbSX2t�a>t?L K�R­KMNYITs5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI���t?^qR­K�U[K��®PS^qU?KMb&t�aQX�KMISbTNYI5b­U?KMp{KM^j�YKW� � O:X� $�;f�L K�t?LS^jU�b!t�KZU[Rp{aYU?U?KMX?s�a�I5bSX�t�a�t?L K�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��eU?K���PS^jU[KMb>t�a�K�+JKMpZP t�K�U[a�P t?^qI KMX;bSPSK�t�a�K�+Js5^jU�NVt?^ja�I&a���� � O)U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�It?^qR­KZU4� � KZU?KY\ ��� � ; .)RN.+�� ��� ��� � f�L KWRTKMNYIsSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��:t?^qRTKWNVt�NQU?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU@�çaYU�NQU�NYISb a�RTijk!p[LSa�X�Ks5NYp �YKZte^qX

* K�� , � M . * K /10NM � ~ � ��� � * K 7 2$M�4 � * K / 8 M � ~8� * K +32�M�4 � * K /10:M � ~8� * K 7!5&M4 � * K / 8 M � ~8� * K 7!5VM�4 * K � /10 � ` � ; M * K 7 < M � �&� � �

f�L K �5U�X�t>tzg"a t�KZU�RTX­p{aYU?U?KMX�s}a�ISbÇt�a t?L K.sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI�� a��Wt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�ISXQNYISb U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�ISXM\�U[KMp{KM^j�YKMb�ÁU?a�R t?L K�X�KMI5b KZUNYISb t?LSKdU?KZt�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I5X&X?KMI�tTa�PSt­t�a t?L K�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X­U?KMX�s}KMp{t?^j�YKMiqk�� f�L K.t?LS^jU�b t�KZU[Rp{aYU?U?KMX?s�a�I5bSX�t�adsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI�� a��"� � O:X:X�KMI®t�t�adt?L KTX�KMISb KZU�aYU:U[KMp{KM^j�YKMb1�çU[a�R aYt?L KZU:U?KZs5NY^qU�X?KZU?�YKZU[X"�&f�L K�Áa�P U?t?L�t�KZU�R p{aYU?U[KMX�s}a�ISbSX�t�a t?L K:sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��Ta��/� � OQXWU?KMp{KM^q�YKMb �ÁU?a�R t?LSKQU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�XeNYISbÅt?L KL���çt?LÅt�KZU[RU?KZsSU[KMX�KMI�t?X.t?LSK s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��Çp{a�X�tda��Qt?L K � � O U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�I t?^qR­KZa�P t.U?a�PSt?^qI K�� f�L K t�KZU[RTX * K / 0:M»\* K /18�M»\ * K /:9[M$NYISb * K � /:9 � ` � ; M$NVU?K>p{a�R­s5P t�KMb�NYX/�ça�i_ija8gWX��� K /10���� M . ~ � ��� � ��� . ~ �"!"!"!GNYISb * K /10:M'. ~ � � ~ � ��� �A� W K �JI a8g t?LSNVt �çaYU�NYI®k�U[NYISb a�R@� NVU�^qNV|5ijK+ \EX?PSp[L�t?LSNVt�+ .4~ � ` � � �"!"!"!ç\

* K + M . ~�4 #$�&% �

� ~ � � � +'�(�1����� � �&���®�

�ea8g � � / 8 �(�1� . � ~ � � � � �*)®\5L KMISp{K

* K / 8 M . ~�4 #$�&% �

� ~ � � ~ � � � � � ) �

�ea8g � � / 9 �(�1� .4~ � ��� � \5LSKMISp{K * K / 9 M � ~ . ��� � � ~ � ��� ��NYI5b * K � / 9 � ` � ; M . � �� � � ~ � ��� �A�+*, Þ ß�Ð�Ô ÞZÖ»ÌÎÞ �Qֻˠ×�ÞMÔ ��ÙY×,Ñ�Ð �;ì2Û�>;Í�Ó�Þ ØÖ»Ëh×�ÞMÔ��"ÙY×,Ñ�Ð �2Ö»Ì ��×�Ð<Ô8Ö»Í�ֻˠ×,Ñ»×�ÌÎÍWÓ�Þ¿Ì ��Õ��ÎÌÎß�Ì ÖWÓ�͸͸Ô���Õ8Ö»ÌÎÐ<ÞTÖ»ËVÓ[Ö�Ö»Ëh× �ÎÐ<Í Ö

ÕVÓ[ßzÒ<×,Ö�ÌÎÍ�Ó #�Ó�Ì �«Ó�Ù �Î×�Ó[Ö�ֻˠ×�Ñ»×�Õ Ó�Ì Ñ�͸×,Ñ #<×,Ñ�ï>à Ð�Ñ�ֻˠÌÎÍ�Ó[͸͸Ô���Õ8ֻ̫Ð�Þ!Ö»Ð:Ë Ð��«Ø���ÐZÐMØ¿Ó�Ñ»×�ß�×,Ì$#<×,Ñ�Ë Ó�Í/Ö»ÐQß �«× #{×,Ñ � ڭ߬ˠÐZÐ<͸×Wì2Û�>Ñ»×,ָѬÓ[Þ Í ��ÌÎ͸͸ÌÎÐ<Þ�Ö»Ì ��×�Ð�ÔhÖ�#�Ó �ÎÔ ×�Í�ï.-$Ö»Ëh×,ѸÏGÌÎ͸×��hÖ»Ëh×;ÞMÔ���ÙY×zÑ}Ð �Sì�Û'>;Í}ÏGÌ � ��ÙY× ��Ð[Ñ»×�Ö»ËVÓ[Þ�ÏGËVÓ?ÖGÏ}×;ËVÓ #{×�ß�Ð<ÔhÞMÖ»×�Ø�ï

~��

Page 11: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

� º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�;�M£Eªz���M¯�¢z¨�¤¥¢,¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨ ªz¡���¢¬��¯�°Y�[�2£q�h�/�M�¥� �z�<�?��¤§�h�[��¢ªz���z�<�?��¤§�h��ª,¡������8��½h�?ª/�?�h�z�,���?ªz�¥��¤«£�ªz¡��[�,��³$���z��¯����§�Y���M� �,���?�Z�h�[�,�

� � º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�;�M£Eªz���M¯�¢z¨�¤¥¢,¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨ ªz¡���¢¬��¯�°Y�[�2£q�h�/�M�¥� �z�<�?��¤§�h�[��¢¤§¯!���§�Y���M� ¯���¤§±h¡ ¦��8�,¡��V�Y°�ª,���,���[�[¤¥�8��ªz¡������8��½h�?ª;�?�8�,�,����ª,�§�Q¤«£�ªz¡����z�³$���z��¯����§�Y���M�S�,���[�Z�8�[�,�

� � º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�;�M£Eªz���M¯�¢z¨�¤¥¢,¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨ ªz¡���¢¬��¯�°Y�[�2ª,���[¯�¢z©��,�"ª,¡��Zª��Mª�§�<�8¢¬ª2�h¯����z�<�?��¤§�h�[�2¤§¯!�<�8��¡Q¯��[¤¥±8¡V¦®�h�z¡�� �Y°>�z�<�?��¤§�h��¢$ªz¡����®�8��½8�[ª/�?�8�,�,����ª,�§�

� �� º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�;�M£Eªz���M¯�¢z¨�¤¥¢,¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨ ªz¡���¢¬��¯�°Y�[�2ª,���[¯�¢z©��,�"ª,¡��Zª��Mª�§�<�8¢¬ª2�h¯����z�<�?��¤§�h�[�2¤§¯­��¯���¤§±h¡ ¦��8�,¡��V�Y°:�,���[�[¤¥�8��¢$ª,¡������8��½h�?ª/�?�h�z�,���?ªz�¥�¤«£�ªz¡����z��³��[�,��¯����§�Y�[�8� �z�<�?�Z�h�[�,�

� º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�;�M£Eªz���M¯�¢z¨�¤¥¢,¢z¤§�h¯�¢�Âq±8�¥�8¦®�M� �8�;�¥�Y�[�8�´Ã$�,��� ©�¤¥�z�<°£q�8�/�M¯V���,���[�[¤¥�8�[���eªz���?�h�z�,���?ªz�¥���z�<�?��¤§�h�������h��½8�[ª

f$NV|EijK � ���eaYt?NVt?^ja�IÅX�s}KMpZ^(��p�t�a ' `

� � � � � � ��� '4�(' � � �

W K!I a8g NYISNYijk&\ZK&t?L K>X�KMI5b KZU�NYI5b�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��p{a�X�t?X�a��/s5U?aYt�a�p{a�i ' ` ���WaYt?NVt?^qa�I X?s�KMpZ^*�Ep�t�a t?LS^qXNYISNYijkJX?^qX�^_X:b KMX?p{U[^q|�KMb ^_I f$NV|5iqK � � W K¿NYX[X?PSR­KTt?L5NVt:t?L KTU?K���PS^jU[KMb sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��.t?^qRTKMX�U?K���PS^jU?KMb t�a X�KMISbNYISbU?KMp{KM^j�YK�N:s5NYp �YKZt�NVU[KWt?L K�X?NYR­K � ^jt�LSNYX"|}KZKMITaY|5X�KZU[�YKMb¿^qI K u.MEt?L5NVt�t?L KMX�K�NVU?K�NYiqR­a�X�t�X?NYR­Kh�A� W K�NYiqX�aRTN$�YKTt?LSK­aYsSt?^qRT^qX?t?^qp>NYX[X?PSR­sSt?^qa�I t?LSNVt�a�ISijk1a�I KTU?KZt�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�I1^_X��YKMI KZU[NVt�KMb s}KZU:� � O@bSP U[^qI�� ijaJpZNYiU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k ^qI ' ` � fWLS^qX�NYX?X?P5R­sSt?^ja�I gW^_iqi2U?KMX?PSiqt:^qI ijahg"KZU>U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU&sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��dp{a�X�t?X)�ÁaYU ' ` �.f�L K¿R­KMNYIsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��!t?^qR­K:NVt�t?L K>X�KMISb KZUX�ÁaYUeN!U[NYI5b a�RTijk p[L a�X�KMIÅs5NYp��YKZt�^qX

* K + , � M . � * K /��#M 4 * K�� � / � /�� ��� `�� MÁ� * K +32�M� * K /��#M 4 * K�� � / � /�� ��� `�� M � ~8� * K +65&M � �&� ���

f�L K��EU[X�t�t�KZU[R@p{aYU[U?KMX�s}a�ISbSX�t�aTt?LSK�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��!U?K���PS^jU[KMb �çaYU�t�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�NYISb.U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�a��2t?L Ks5NYp �YKZt"� f�L5^qXTt�KZU[R ^qX¿RTNYb K1PSs a��:tzg"aÇs5NVU?t?X"�vf�L K �EU[X�tTs5NVU[t¿^qX¿t?L KÅK�+Js}KMp{t�KMb�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���p{a�X�t¿a��� U?Kh�zt�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�ISX&a��et?LSK�s5NYp��YKZt X�a t?LSNVtTNVtiqKMNYX�t­a�I K�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU^qI KZ�YKZU?k I KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�bÇU?KMp{KM^j�YKMXt?L Ks5NYp �YKZt"��f�L KdX�KMp{a�ISb sENVU?t­^qX&t?L KdK�+�s}KMp{t�KMb s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI�� p{a�X�tTa���NYbSbS^jt?^ja�I5NYi"U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�ISX)�ÁU?a�R t?L KX�KMISbSKZU�geL KMI U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X�pZNYI5I aYt�ijaJpZNYiqijk­U?KMp{ah�YKZUWt?L K�ija�X�t�s5NYp �YKZtWKZ�YKMI.t?L a�P���Ld^jt�^qX�NM�VNY^qiqNV|5ijK�^qI¿t?L K:ijaJpZNYiI KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�b �r�KMpZNYiqi�t?LSNVt>N�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU!NYijt�KZU[ISNVt�KMX>|}KZt¬g�KZKMI�ijaJpZNYi/NYISb ��ijaY|5NYi;U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k ^_I t?LSNVtQaYU�b KZU��f�L KZU[K"�çaYU?KY\� � / � / � ��� `�� ^_X:t?L K I®PSR>|}KZUQa���NYbSb5^jt?^ja�ISNYi;t�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�U?K���PS^jU[KMb �ÁU?a�R t?L K X�KMISb KZU>t�aKMISX?PSU?K�t?LSNVt NYiqi�t?L K1U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X p{aYU?U?KMp{t?iqk U?KMp{KM^j�YKÅt?LSKÅs5NYp �YKZt"�9f�L K X�KMp{a�ISb�t�KZU�R p{aYU?U[KMX�s}a�ISbSX­t�aÇt?L KsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I���a����ijaY|5NYiE� � O:X/U[KMp{KM^j�YKMb|�k­t?L KWX?KMISb KZU��;f�LS^_X/I®P5RQ|}KZU/a����ijaY|ENYiS� � O:X�^qX;K���PSNYiEt�aQa�I K�ijKMX?Xt?LSNYI.t?L K:I�PSR>|}KZU�a�� � U?Kh�zt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�ISX@�çU?a�R t?LSK�X?KMISb KZU�|}KMpZNYPSX�K�a�ISijk¿a�I K�� � O ^qX@�YKMI KZU�NVt�KMbds}KZU�ija�X?XbSP K�t�a¿� � O X?P s5sSU?KMX?X?^qa�I����� ×,Ñ»×2ֻˠ×2Ó�͸͸Ô���Õ8Ö»ÌÎÐ<Þ�ÌÎ;ֻËVÓ?Ö+ì2Û'> ͸ԠՠÕ8Ñ»×�͸͸ÌÎÐ<Þ�Ï�Ð�Ñ»ÒMÍ+ÕY×,Ñ �´×�ßzÖ �ÎÚZï

~Y~

Page 12: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

f�L K:RTKMNYIdsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��&t?^_R­K:NVtWt?L K�U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU/�ÁaYUWN­U[NYI5b a�RTijk p[L a�X�KMIÅs5NYp��YKZt�^qX* K 7 , � M . � * K / �8M 4 * K�� � / �:/ �¸��� `�� MÁ� � ~ � � � � � * K 7�2.M

4 � * K ��� /:5 �:/ �5 ��� `�� � � ~ ��� 4 � � � ~8� � ~ � � �� �����S� * K 7 2�M4 � * K /��#M 4 * K�� � / � / �¸��� `�� M�� ~8� * K 7!5VM4 � * K / �5 M�4 * K ��� / 5 � / �5 ��� `�� M � ~8� * K 7 5 M4 � * K � / < � ` � ; M�4 * K � / �5 � ` � ; MÁ� * K 7 < M � �&�«y��

f�L KL�5U[X�t�tzg"a¿t�KZU[RTXWp{aYU[U?KMX�s}a�ISbdt�a¿t?L K:sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��­a�����ijaY|5NYiGNYISbÅija�pZNYi+t�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I5X�NVtet?L K:U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU��f�L KeI®PSR>|}KZU�a��GijaJpZNYiSU[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�ISX�^qX�b KZt�KZU�RT^qI KMb­|�kTp{a�ISX?^_b KZU[^qI��:N&ijaJpZNYi5I KM^#��L�|}aYU[L a�aJbT^qIT^qX?a�iqNVt?^ja�INYISb!b KZt�KZU[R^qIS^qI��Wt?L K�I�PSR>|}KZU$a��St�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX$I KZKMb KMb �çU[a�R9t?L K�X�KMI5b KZU$t�a�KMISX[P U?K�t?L5NVt2NYi_i�t?L K�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X^qI t?LSK¿I KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�b U[KMp{KM^j�YK¿t?LSKTs5NYp��YKZt­p{aYU?U[KMp{t?ijk���f�L KMI t?L KI�PSRQ|}KZU>a���t�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�U?K���PS^jU[KMb t�aKMISX?PSU?K.t?LSNVtNVtijKMNYX?tTa�I KdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU ^qI t?L K�I KM^#��L�|}aYU[L a�aJb�U[KMp{KM^j�YKMXTt?L KdsENYp��YKZt¿^_XR�ça�P5ISb� � NYi#�Wa���t?L KbS^(,}KZU?KMISp{K.^qI�t?L KMX�K ��PSNYI®t?^jt?^jKMX&k�^qKMiqbSX:t?LSK.I�PSR>|}KZU&a���ijaJpZNYi�U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX"� W K.t?N$�YK�t?L Kdp{KM^qi_^qI��Åa��t?LS^qX&I�PSRQ|}KZU&t�a NYpZp{a�PSI®tR�çaYU!t?L K �ÁNYp{t­t?L5NVt!N U?KMp{ah�YKZU?k X�K��®PSKMISp{KdNYijg�N8k�X!|}K"��^qI5XQgW^qt?L�ijaJpZNYi�U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k��� ijaJpZNYi�t�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I1^qX �YKMI KZU[NVt�KMb gW^qt?LS^qI�N t?NY^qi�gW^jt?L N¿sSU?aY|5NV|5^_iq^jt¬k ~ ����� � U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�U?KMp{KM^j�YKMX�N.ijaJpZNYit�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�I �YKMI KZU[NVt�KMb.^qITNYI aYt?LSKZU"t?NY^qiEiq^qI��!^qIT^qt?X�I KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�bTgW^jt?L­sSU[aY|5NV|5^qiq^qt¬k � � � ~8� � ~ � � � � � ���S�A�� KZU?K:g�K:aYsSt?^qRT^_X�t?^qpZNYiqijkTNYX[X?PSR­K:t?L5NVt�a�ISijk¿a�I KQijaJpZNYi}U?KZs5NY^jU�^_XX�YKMI KZU[NVt�KMbÅs�KZUeija�pZNYi¾� � OR�f�L KÅt?LS^jU[b t�KZU�R ^qI � �&�«y��p{aYU[U?KMX�s}a�ISbSX­t�aÇt?L K R­KMNYI s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI�� t?^qRTKÅU?K���PS^jU?KMb t�a X�KMISb NYISb�U[KMp{KM^j�YK��ijaY|5NYiE� � O:X"�;f�LSK_�ça�PSU?t?L­t�KZU[R ^qX/t?L KeR­KMNYITsSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI���t?^qR­KWU?K��®P5^jU?KMbR�ÁaYU"X�KMI5bS^qI��:NYISbTU?KMp{KM^j�J^qI��QijaJpZNYi� � O:X��­ozt:^qX�^_R­s}aYU?t?NYI�t�t�a1I aYt�KTL KZU?K­t?LSNVt � � ijaJpZNYi;� � O:X:NVU[K<�YKMI KZU[NVt�KMb KZ�YKMI |}K"�çaYU[K&t?LSKTs5NYp��YKZt&^qXNM�VNY^qiqNV|EijKQ^qIdt?LSK>ijaJpZNYi+I KM^#��L�|}aYU[L a�aJb��fWL KQiqNYX�tWt�KZU[R ^_X�t?L K&R­KMNYI�sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��Tt?^qRTK:U?K���PS^jU?KMb �ÁaYU�t?^qR­KZUU?a�P t?^_I KTK�+JKMpZP t?^ja�ISX"�1f�LS^qX:p{a�I5X?^qX�t?XQa���t¬g�a sENVU?t?X"��f�L K<�5U[X�t>s5NVU?tQ^qXQt?L K K�+�s}KMp{t�KMb�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��1p{a�X�t>a��t?L K�t?^qRTKZU�U[a�P t?^qI K�K�+JKMpZP t?^ja�ISX�gWLSKMI¿t?LSK�s5NYp��YKZtW^_X�t�U[NYISX?RT^qt�t�KMb � ��iqaY|5NYiqijkTaYUeija�pZNYi_ijk ��NYISbdI aYt�U?KMp{KM^q�YKMb�f�L K�X?KMp{a�ISbTs5NVU[t�^qX2t?L K�K�+Js}KMp{t�KMbs5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI���p{a�X�t"a���t?LSK�t?^qR­KZU/U[a�P t?^qI K�K�+JKMpZP t?^ja�ISX/gWL KMITijaJpZNYi U?KMp{ah�YKZU?kNVt�t�KMR­sSt?XQNVU?K!|�KM^_I�� RNYb K­^qI |�KZtzg"KZKMI ��ijaY|5NYi�U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k NVt�t�KMRTsSt?X�KZ�YKMI |}K"�ÁaYU?K>t?LSK&sENYp��YKZtQ^qX�N8� NY^_iqNV|5ijK^qI1t?L K­ijaJpZNYi�ISKM^*��L�|}aYU[LSa®aJb� W KTbSKZt�KZU[RT^qI K&t?L K&K�+�s5U?KMX?X?^ja�I5X/�ÁaYU * K / M»\ * K / � M»\ * K / 5VM2NYI5b * K / �5 M/NYX�Áa�iqija8geX �W K>P5X�K�t?L K�U?KMpZP U�X?^j�YK�t�KMp[L5IS^#��P K:b KMX?p{U[^q|�KMb.^qI K´~"M+t�aTaY|St?NY^qI

� K / ���SM . ��� �$� %� ��� � � � � ~ � ��� � ��� � � ~ � � ��� �� ���

� K /:5 ���SM . ��� �$� %� �� � � � � ~ � ��� � ��� �5� ~ � � ��� �� � )

� K /�� ���SM . ��� �$� %� �� � � � � ~ � ��� � ��� �5� ~ � ��� ��� ��� )� ���

� K /��5 ���SM . ��� �$� %� �� � � � � ~ � ��� � ��� �5� ~ � ��� ��� ��� )� �

* K / M»\ * K / � M»\ * K /:5VM�NYISb * K / �5 M2pZNYI |�K&b KZt�KZU[RT^_I KMbÅPSX[^qI�� � �&���®�eNYISb pZNYI |�K&X?P |5X?t?^jt?P t�KMbÅ^_I�t�a � �&� ���~ `

Page 13: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

� � º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�;�M£�ªz���M¯®¢¬¨�¤´¢z¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨7ªz¡���¢¬��¯�°Y�[�;�,��� ©�¤¥�,��°Q£q�8�/�M�¥�S°Y�<¢¬¤¥±8¯��Mªz�<°�z�<�?�[¤¥�8���,¢+ªz�:¢z©����?��¢,¢¬£q©��§�¥�:�,���[�[¤¥�8�������8��½h�?ª

� � º ¯ ©�¨W¦��[�;�M£�ªz���M¯®¢¬¨�¤´¢z¢z¤§�h¯�¢$£q�z�h¨9��°Y��¢z¤¥±8¯��Mªz��°>�,���?��¤§�h�[��ªz�:�8�§�ªz¡����,���[� ��¢$£q�8�;³;¡�¤´��¡!¤«ª/¤´¢2�,��¢z�®�h¯�¢¬¤¥¦��¥��¢¬©����?�<¢z¢¬£q©��¥�§��z�<�?�Q����½ ª;À+�8¢,¢z©�¨�¤§¯�±�ª,¡��Zª/¯�����½ ª�¢/�M�,��¢z�[¯ ª;£q�,�8¨7ª,¡���¢z�[¯�°Y���

��� º ªz¡������[�;���h��½8�[ª2���z�Y�?�<¢z¢z¤¥¯�±Wª,¤§¨����Mª;ªz¡���°Y�<¢¬¤¥±8¯®�Zªz�<°Q�,���[�[¤¥�8���f$NV|EijK � ���eaYt?NVt?^ja�IÅX�s}KMpZ^(��p�t�a ' �

NYISb � �&�«y��A���Wahg:\ � � / < � ��� .4~ � � � � � KMISp{KY\* K � / < � ` �%; M�. #$� % � � ~ � � � / < � �,����. � � � � ~ � � �* K � /��5 � ` � ; M . #$ � % �

� ~ � � � / �5 � �,�����. * K / �5 M � ` 4 � � / �5 �9~8���. * K /��5 M � ` 4 � ~ � ��� � � ~ � � )� �

�SP U[t?L KZUM\

* K�� � / � /�� ��� `�� M . � * K / M � * K / � MÁ��� ` � � � / � /��ç^_X�a�bSb5��� `* K ��� / 5 � /��5 ��� `�� M . � * K /:5VM � * K /��5 MÁ��� ` 4 � � /:5 � /��5 ^_X�a�b5b5��� `

HJ^qI5p{K­U[NYISb a�R��VNVU[^qNV|EijKMX3/ NYISb / � � NYI5b NYiqX�a /:5 NYISb / �5 ��NVU[K¿I aYtQ^_ISb KZs}KMISb KMI®t�^jt:^qX:I aYt>KMNYX�k t�aaY|St?NY^qI.X?^_R­s5ijKeK�+�sSU[KMX?X?^ja�ISX@�ÁaYU�t?L K�ija�X?X�sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jt?^qKMX � � / � / � ^qX�aJbSb5��� ` NYISb � � /:5 � / �5 ^qX�a�b5b5��� ` ��eaYt?^qI��t?L5NVtWt?L K>� NYiqPSKMXWa��;t?L KMX?KQt¬g�a sSU?aY|5NV|5^_iq^jt?^jKMX�gW^qi_i¾|}KQX?^*��IS^*�EpZNYI�tWa�ISijk gWL KMI�t?LSK>I�PSRQ|}KZUea��;t?NY^qiqX^qX�X?RNYiqi¾NYISb�ija�X[X�sSU?aY|5NV|E^qiq^jt?^jKMX�NVU?KQiqa8g:\ g�K:|}a�PSISb * K�� � / �:/ � ��� `�� M2NYISb * K ��� / 5 � / �5 ��� `�� M�|®k

* K�� � / � / �¸��� `�� M�� � * K / M � * K /��#MÁ��� ` � ~ � `* K ��� / 5 � / �5 ��� `�� M�� � * K / 5 M � * K / �5 MÁ��� `

� � � � $ � ��� '4�(' � � $

W K­I a8g4NYISNYijk&\ZK&t?L K&X?KMISb KZUM\�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�NYISb1b KMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU�s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��p{a�X?t?Xea���sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' � �e�eaVxt?NVt?^ja�IÇX�s}KMpZ^(�Ep­t�a t?LS^qX>NYISNYijkJX?^qX>^qXQb KMX[p{U[^j|}KMb ^qI�f$NV|5iqK ���Åf�LSK¿R­KMNYI�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���U?K���PS^jU?KMR­KMI®tQNVt&t?L KX�KMISbSKZU_�çaYUeN!U[NYISb a�RTiqk¿p[LSa�X�KMI�s5NYp �YKZt�^_X

* K + , � M . * K /���M * K +32$M�4 � * K /��"M � ~8� * K +65&M � �&�§wY�~ �

Page 14: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

f�L K&R­KMNYI1U?KMp{KM^j�YK&sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��U?K��®P5^jU?KMR­KMI®tWNVt�NijKMN$�;U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU�t?L5NVte^qXeI aYt�iqa�pZNVt�KMb NVtet?LSK>X?NYR­K!X?^jt�K&NYXt?L KQbSKMX?^*��ISNVt�KMbdU[KMp{KM^j�YKZUW^qX

* K 7 , � M�. * K / � M � ~ � � � * K 7�2.M 4 � * K / � � ~8� * K 7=5TM 4 � � � � ~ � � � * K 7 < M � �&�«���

f�L K�R­KMNYI>U?KMp{KM^j�YK�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���U?K���PS^jU?KMR­KMI®t+NVt;NWiqKMN$�SU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU;ijaJpZNVt�KMb>NVt�t?L K�X?NYR­K�X?^jt�K�NYX$t?LSK"b KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMbU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qX

* K 7 , � M . * K / � M * K 7 2$M�4 � * K / � � ~8� * K 7!5&M�4 � � � � ~ � � � * K 7 < M � �&�«u��f�L K:RTKMNYIdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZUesSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��!U?K���PS^jU[KMR­KMI�t�NVteNTb KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMbdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qX

* K���, � M . * K / �"M � ~ � � � * K 7 2.M 4 � * K /���M � ~8� * K 7!5VM�4 � � � � ~ � � � * K 7 < M� * K / � M � ~8� � * K +65 4 * K +32$MÁ� � �&�q~����

o,tQ^qX:^qRTs�aYU[t?NYI�t�t�aÅISaYt�K¿L KZU?Kt?LSNVtZ\$t?LSKI®P5RQ|}KZU�a���� � O:X>X�KMI�tE�çU?a�R N�ijKMN$��U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU!^qX�a�ISiqk1a�I K¿ijKMX?Xt?LSNYI.t?L K:I�PSR>|}KZU�a��+t�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�ISX@�çU?a�R`^qt?X�s5NVU?KMI®t"��f�LS^qX�R­KMNYISX�t?LSNVt�^*�+t?LSK:b KMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb.U[KMp{KM^j�YKZUWb a�KMXI aYt�LSNM�YK&t?L KQU[KZs5NY^jUWsENYp��YKZtZ\GNYI�KMI5bJx»U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�g�NY^qt?X/�ÁaYU�X[P-�¿pZ^jKMI®t?ijk.ija�I��t?^_R­KQ|}K"�ÁaYU?KQX�KMISb5^qI��TN � � O­\X�aTt?L5NVt�t?L K:b KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMbdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qX�^jt?X?KMi*�$NV|5iqK�t�aTU?KMp{a8�YKZU�t?L K:sENYp��YKZt"����t?L KZU?gW^_X�KY\Jt?L K:U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qX�iq^*�YKMiqkt�aTX�KMISbdRNYI�k.R­aYU?K:� � OQX�t�aT^jt?X�b KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMbdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�t?L5NYI.gWLSNVt�g�K:LSNM�YK:p{a�PSI®t�KMbÅ^_I¿K���PSNVt?^ja�I5X � �&�«���NYISb � �&�q~����A�^ X?^qI��­t?L K�U[KMpZP U[X?^j�YK�t�KMp�LSIS^#��P K:b KMX[p{U[^j|}KMb.^qI K´~�M»\

� K /�� � �SM .� % ��� �$� %

� �� � � � � ~ � ��� � ��� � � ~ � � ��� �� � �� K / � � �SM .

� % ��� �$� %� ��� � � � � ~ � ��� � ��� � � ~ � � ��� �� � ) � �

* K /���M$NYI5b * K / � M$pZNYI1I a8g |}K:b KZU�^j�YKMbdPSX?^qI��&K���PSNVt?^ja�I � �&���®�A�f�L K>RTN.+J^_R>PSR sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��!U[NVt�K&NVtWt?L K>X�KMISb KZUM\ ��� 0 . ~ � * K + � M�NYISbdt?L K&RTN.+J^_R>PSR sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��!U[NVt�K&NVtt?L K­U?KMp{KM^q�YKZUM\ ��� 9 .@~ � * K 7 � M»\$gWL KZU?K����"��W~ �� ` �� � � � ^ ISb KZU�t?L KTNYX?X[PSR­sSt?^ja�I t?L5NVt�t?L K­U?KZs5NY^jU:X?KZU?�YKZU^qX.I KZ�YKZU�NÇ|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp �E\�t?L K a8�YKZU�NYiqi�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i�t?L U?a�P���LSs5P t]�ÁaYU ' ~ ^qX ��^j�YKMI)|�k t?LSK R^qIS^qR&PSR a��>t?L Ks}KZUN%�s5NYp �YKZtWsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��!U[NVt�KMXWNVt�t?LSKQX�KMISb KZU�NYI5bdt?L K:U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU��

� , ��.)RT^qI�� � , �0 � � , �9 � � �&�q~Y~8�

f�L KWa8�YKZU[NYiqiEsSU?aYt�aJp{a�iEt?L U?a�P���L sEP t �çaYU ' ` ^qX ��^q�YKMIT|�k­t?L KeRT^_IS^qR&PSR4a��¾t?L KWs}KZUN%�sENYp��YKZt�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���U�NVt�KMXNVt�t?L K>X�KMISb KZU�NYISb�t?L K:U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU

� , ��.)RT^qI�� � , �0 � � , �9 � � �&�q~ ` �

f�L KWa8�YKZU[NYiqiEsSU?aYt�aJp{a�iEt?L U?a�P���L sEP t �çaYU ' � ^qX ��^q�YKMIT|�k­t?L KeRT^_IS^qR&PSR4a��¾t?L KWs}KZUN%�sENYp��YKZt�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���U�NVt�KMXNVt�t?L K>X�KMISb KZUM\ t?LSK�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUeNYI5bdt?L K:b KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMbdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU

� , ��.7RT^qI.� � , �0 � � , �9 � � , �� � � �&�q~ � �

� KZU?K:t?L K:RTN.+ ^qR&PSR`sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��!U[NVt�KQNVtWNb KMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb�U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZUM\ � , �� .4~ � * K�� , � M �~��

Page 15: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

� � � � ���� � ������ � ��� '4�('

f$a�NYISNYijk&\ZK&t?LSK&|ENYISb gW^qbSt?LÅs}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYISp{K&g�KTp{a�ISX?^qb KZU�t?L K­I KZtzg"aYU �1t�ad|}K!RTNYb K­P s a���t?L U[KZK­t¬k�s�KMX�a��iq^qI���XZ\JNTX�a�PSU[p{KQiq^qI��E\�|5NYp���|}a�I KQiq^_I���X�NYISb�t?NY^qiGiq^qI���X"�2f�L KMI�t?L K:R­KMNYI�t�aYt?NYi+|5NYISb ge^qb t?L.PSX?N$�YKY\5bSKMI aYt�KMb|�k�� � \SgWLSKZU?K ��� ��e~ �� ` �� � � \}pZNYId|}K�K�+JsSU?KMX?X�KMbÅNYXZ\

* K � � M . * K � �0 M�4 * K � �� M 4 * K � �< M � � �&�q~��®�� KZU?K * K � �0 M»\ * K � �� M$NYISb * K � �< M$NVU?K:t?LSKQR­KMNYI�|ENYISb gW^qbSt?L P5X?N$�YK:a�I�t?LSKQX�a�P U[p{K>iq^qI���\ N­|5NYp���|}a�I KQiq^_I��NYISb Ndt?NY^_i;iq^qI���U[KMX�s}KMp{t?^j�YKMijkY\��ÁaYU�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i �_�T� aYU&b KZt�KZU[RT^_IS^qI�� t?L KMX�K]��PSNYI®t?^jt?^jKMX�g�KI KZKMb t�a ��ISb t?L KR­KMNYI I�PSR>|�KZU�a��"s5NYp��YKZt?X��Ea8gW^qI��.^_IÅKMNYp�L a���t?L K­iq^_I���Xes}KZU�X?PSpZp{KMX?X:� PSi�t�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�I�a��"N.sENYp��YKZt!�ÁU?a�Rt?L K&X�KMISb KZU�t�a NYi_iGt?L K&U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X��W� aYU�X?^qR­sEiq^qpZ^jtzkY\Sg"K!NYX?X?P5R­KQt?LSNVt�t?L K&X�a�P U[p{KY\}|5NYp �®|}a�I K&NYISbÅt?NY^_i+iq^qI���XKMNYp[L p{a�ISX?^_X�t?X�a��;NTX?^qI���iqK�sEL�kJX?^qpZNYi¾iq^_I���� � s5NYp��YKZt�^qX�p{a�PSI®t�KMbÅ^#�$^jt�^qX�t�a|�K�a$,}KZU?KMbÅt�aNTiq^qI����f�L K�t�U�N.�¿p:p{a�ISp{KMI®t�U[NVt?^ja�I¾\Eb KMI aYt�KMb�|�k� � \SpZNYI�|}K�K�+�s5U?KMX?X�KMb�NYXM\

� � . RTN.+ � * K � �0 M � * K � �< MÁ��� � * K � �0 M 4 * K � �< M � � � � 4)~8��� � �&�q~����W K.K�+JpZi_PSb KTt?L K |5NYp �®|}a�I K iq^qI��JX!�ÁU?a�R K���PSNVt?^ja�I � �&�q~����>|}KMpZNYPSX�K¿g"K.pZNYISI aYt&s5^qI&%�s}a�^qI®t�t?L K |5NYp���|}a�I Kiq^qI���X�t?LSNVtWNVU[KQPSX�KMb �ÁaYUWbS^_X�t�U[^j|5PSt?^qI��QsENYp��YKZt?X�NYp{U?a�X?X�t?LSK�|5NYp���|}a�I K���f�LS^_X�K�+JpZiqP5X?^ja�I.gW^qi_i�ISaYt�N.,�KMp{tea�P UU?KMX?P5ijt?X;|}KMpZNYPSX�K�t?L KW|5NYp���|}a�I KWiq^qI���X;b a:ISaYt/|}KMp{a�R­K�|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp ��X"� � a8g�KZ�YKZUM\Jg�KWb aL�YKZt�X�a�R­KZgWLSNVt"ija8g�KZU�VNYiqP KMX�a��2t�U[N.�¿p>p{a�ISp{KMI®t�U[NVt?^ja�I1|�KMpZNYP5X�K:t?L K:|ENYISb gW^qbSt?L P5X?N$�YKQ^qIdt?LSK:|5NYp���|}a�I KQiq^_I���X�t�KMI5bSX�t�aTU[KMbSPSp{Kt?L KQN8�YKZU[N$�YK&|5NYISb gW^_b t?L¿P5X?N$�YK:a8�YKZU�NYiqi¾iq^_I���X��2�SaYUWsSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' ~V\

* K � , �0 M . * K /10:M * K � �"M 4 � * K /10:M�� ~8� * K � 5VM* K � , �� M . * K /10:M � ~ � ��� � * K � ��M 4 � * K /10:M � ~8� * K � 5TM* K � , �< M . * K / 8 M * K � ��M�4 � * K / 9 M � ~8� * K � 5VM

� KZU?KY\� ��^qX�N!U[NYISbSa�R � NVU[^_NV|5ijK�U?KZsSU?KMX?KMI�t?^qI��&t?LSK�|5NYISb gW^_b t?LU[K��®PS^qU?KMb �çaYU�N­bSNVt?N x»sENYp��YKZt�t�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�IaYU�U?KZt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�I�NYISb�� 5 ^_XeNYI aYt?LSKZU�U�NYISb a�R � NVU[^_NV|5ijK:U?KZs5U?KMX�KMI®t?^qI��t?LSK>|5NYI5b gW^qb t?LÅNYX?X�aJpZ^qNVt�KMb gW^jt?LNÇ� � O a8�YKZUÅNYI®k�a��:t?L K NV|}a8�YK t?L U[KZK1tzk®s}KMX a��Qiq^qI���X"� W K NYX?X?PSR­K1t?LSNVt�� �1NYISb � 5 LSN8�YK �YKMISKZU[NYibS^qX?t�U[^j|5P t?^qa�ISX"NYI5bdNVU?KQ^qISbSKZs�KMI5b KMI�t�a��2KMNYp[LÅaYt?L KZU���� aYUesSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' ` \

* K � , �0 M . � * K /��#M 4 * K�� � / � / �¸��� `�� MÁ� * K � �4M4 � * K /�� M�4 * K�� � / � /�� ��� `�� M�� ~8� * K � 5TM

* K � , �� M . � * K /��8M�4 * K�� � / � /�� ��� `�� MÁ� � ~ � ��� � * K � ��M4 � * K / � M 4 * K�� � / �:/ � ��� `�� M�� ~8� * K � 5VM

* K � , �< M . � * K / � M�4 * K�� � / � / � ��� `�� MÁ� � ~ � ��� � * K � ��M4 � * K ��� / 5 � /��5 ��� `�� � � ~ ���64 � � ��~8� � ~ � ��� �����S� * K � �"M4 � * K / �8M�4 * K�� � / �:/ �Á��� `�� M � ~8� * K � 5&M4 � * K / �5 M 4 * K ��� / 5 � /��5 ��� `�� M�� ~8� * K � 5&M

~��

Page 16: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

� aYUesSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' � \

* K � , �0 M . * K /���M * K � �"M 4 � * K /��"M � ~8� * K � 5VM* K � , �� M . * K /���M � ~ � ��� � * K � ��M 4 � * K /��"M ��~8� * K � 5&M

�ea8g4t?L KQt?NY^_iqXWijKMNYb5^qI��­t�a.X?^jt�KMX�ge^jt?LÅb KMX[^*��ISNVt�KMb�U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X�LSNM�YK!R­aYU?K>t�U[N.�¿p �5a8gW^_I��Tt?L U?a�P���L�t?L KMRB^qIp{a�R­s5NVU�^qX�a�ITt�a&t?NY^qiqX"ijKMNYbS^qI��:t�a&X[^jt�KMX�ge^jt?L a�P t�NYI®kb KMX[^*��ISNVt�KMbTU[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X"�/� aYU�t?NY^qi_X"ijKMNYb5^qI��:t�a&X?^jt�KMX"gW^jt?Lb KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMbdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�XZ\

* K � , �< � M . * K /���M � ~ � ��� � * K � ��M 4 � * K /��"M ��~8� * K � 5&M4 � * K / � M � ~8� * K � �"M�4 � * K / � � ~8� * K � 5TM

� aYUet?NY^qiqX�I aYt�iqKMNYbS^qI��!t�aX?^qt�KMX�gW^jt?L�bSKMX?^*��ISNVt�KMbdU[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XZ\

* K � , �<�M . * K / � M � ~ � ��� � * K � �"M�4 � * K / � � ~8� * K � 5&M

f�L KZU[K"�çaYU?KY\V�çaYU"sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' � \�t?L KWp{a�I®t�U[^j|EP t?^ja�I­a��}t?L K�t?NY^_iqX/iq^qI���X2t�a>t?L K�|5NYISbSgW^qb t?L!PSX?N$�YK�^qX * K � , �< � M 4* K � , �<

�M � � ��� 4�A�

� � � ������& ����� � � �� � � � � �� � � ( � �������$�('�����'

o�IÅt?LS^_XeX�KMp{t?^qa�I1g�K)�5U[X�t�p{a�R­s5NVU?K&t?L K&t?L U?a�P���L sEP teNYISb1|5NYISbSgW^qb t?L�P5X?N$�YK>a���sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX ' ~V\ ' ` NYISb ' �gW^jt?L N&sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i}� ` K´~M�.M}t?LSNVt�b a�KMX�I aYt�PSX�K�ijaJpZNYi5U?KMp{ah�YKZU?k���t�a&KMX?t?NV|5iq^qX?L¿t?L K�|}KMI K��5t?X"a��$ijaJpZNYi�U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k��� ` ^qX�N.U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�aYU[^jKMI®t�KMb sSU[aYt�a�p{a�i2t?LSNVt:P5X�KMX ��ijaY|5NYi;� � O`X?PSsSsSU?KMX?X[^ja�I1NYI5b ^_X�X?L a8geI1t�ad|}K!t?L K!|}KMX�ta��;t?L U?KZK)��ijaY|5NYi+U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k1X?p[L KMRTKMX � sSU[aYs�a�X?KMbÅ^qI K´~M�.MÁ�A���WK�+JtWg�K!p{a�R­s5NVU?K>t?L KQs}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYISp{KMX�a�� ' ~V\ ' `NYISb ' � ��o,I p{a�R­s5PSt?^qI�� ' ~��ÎX�t?L U?a�P���L sEP tWg�K&NYX[X?PSR­K&t?LSNVt�t?L K>U[KZs5NY^jUeX?KZU?�YKZU�LSNYX�X?P-�¿pZ^jKMI®tWs5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��s}a8g�KZU�NYISb1^_XeI KZ�YKZU�N¿|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp�����f�L K>U?K��®P5^jU?KMb�s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��¿s�ahg"KZU��ÁaYUet?L5^qXWt�a.|}KQt�U�P K>^qX�b KZt�KZU[R^qI KMb^qI.t?L K>I K�+�t�X?KMp{t?^ja�I�o�IaYU[bSKZU�t�a­p{a�R­sEP t�Ket?LSK�X�KMI5b¿NYISb U?KMp{KM^q�YK�s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��Qp{a�X?t?X�g"K�PSX�K�t?L K�R­KMNYX?P U[KMR­KMI�t?X�U?KZs}aYU?t�KMb ^qI1K u.M�ÁaYU�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��­t?^qR­K:NYX?X�aJpZ^qNVt�KMbÅgW^jt?L�X�KMI5bS^qI�� �hU?KMp{KM^q��^qI��&NTb5NVt?NTs5NYp �YKZteNYISb1NT� � O s5NYp �YKZtZ\�NYXWg"KMi_iGNYXt?L K­t?^qRTKZa�P t�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI�� t?^qR­KMX�� W KTPSX?K * K +32$M . * K 7�2.M . � � ��GX�KMpZXZ\ * K +65VM . * K 7=5�M . � ��GX�KMpZX>NYISb* K 7 < M�. ��` �GX�KMpZX"� � KZU?KNdbSNVt?N�s5NYp��YKZt&^qX�a���X?^*\ZK�~�� ` �Å|�k�t�KMXQNYISb N�� � O`s5NYp��YKZt&^qX�a���X?^*\ZK ��` |�k�t�KMX"�f�L K¿I®PSR>|}KZU�a���t?NY^qiqX:s}KZUQISKM^*��L�|}aYU[LSa®aJb � NYX>b K���I KMb ^qI H�KMp{t?^qa�I � � ` ��\ ��\$^_X:X�KZtQt�a �&� �SaYU>|5NYI5b gW^qb t?Lp{a�R­s5NVU�^qX�a�ISXZ\ g�KQp�L a®a�X?K * K � ��M�.4~�� ` � NYISb * K � 5VM�. ��` ��2^*��P U?KMX ` NYISb � X[L a8g)t?L K�t?L U?a�P���LSs5P t�^qI5p{U?KMNYX�K�NYISb |5NYISb gW^_b t?L­U?KMbSP5p{t?^ja�I¿b5P KWt�a­ijaJpZNYi5U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k���f�L Ks}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYISp{K�a�� ' ~�^qX2X?^*��IS^(��pZNYI�t?ijk:L5^*��L KZU2t?LSNYI­� ` �2�5P U?t?L KZUM\Yt?L5^qX�|�KML5NM�J^jaYU;|}KMp{a�R­KMX;R­aYU?K�sSU?a�ISa�PSISp{KMbNYXet?L KQI�PSRQ|}KZU�a��;t?NY^_iqXZ\�Q\ENYISb�t?L K&ija�X?X�s5U?aY|5NV|5^qi_^jt¬kY\ � ^qISp{U?KMNYX�K�� ' ` NYiqX�a¿s�KZU �çaYU[RX�R>PSp�LÅ|}KZt�t�KZUet?LSNYI� ì2ä"ÌÎÍ+Ó�ÞVÓ � Ú �,×�Ø �´Ð[Ñ+Ð<ÔhÑ+Í Ú8Í Ö»×�� ��ÐMØ8×���Þ Ð�Ö+Õ8Ñ»×�͸×�ÞZÖ»×�ØeËh×,Ñ»× �¥Ð�Ñ$ÙhÑ»×�#MÌ ÖÁÚZï

~My

Page 17: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

100 1000 10000 100000

Ove

rall

Prot

ocol

Thr

ough

put G

ain

Number of Tail Links

L3/N2 - p=0.05L3/N2 - p=0.25L2/N2 - p=0.05L2/N2 - p=0.25L1/N2 - p=0.05L1/N2 - p=0.25

�2^*��P U?K ` ��f�L U?a�P���LSs5P t � NY^qI

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

100 1000 10000 100000

Ban

dwid

th U

sage

Number of Tail Links

L3/N2 - p=0.05L3/N2 - p=0.25L2/N2 - p=0.05L2/N2 - p=0.25L1/N2 - p=0.05L1/N2 - p=0.25

�2^*��P U?K � � � NYISbSgW^qb t?LdrWKMbSPSp{t?^ja�I

~8w

Page 18: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

� ` � � a8g�KZ�YKZUM\�t?L KdU[NVt?^qa a��et?L U[a�P���L s5P t&aY|St?NY^qISKMb PSISb KZU ' ` NYI5b � ` U?KMRNY^qISX!K���PSNYi�t�a ` NYISb b a�KMXI aYt�p[LSNYI��YK!X?^*��I5^(�EpZNYI®t?ijk¿ge^jt?L�^qISp{U[KMNYX�K>^qI�� aYU � ��f�LS^qXW^qX�|}KMpZNYPSX�KQt?L KQ|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp �ÅI aJb K � U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU �ÁaYU� . ��! � �TNYISbdX�KMISb KZUX�ÁaYU � . ��! ` ����PSISb KZU ' ` bSa®KMX�a�I5ijkLSNYi*�$t?L K�NYR­a�PSI®t�a��$s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��!^qIdp{a�R­s5NVU�^qX�a�It�aTt?L K�|}aYt�t?ijKMISKMp��.I a�bSK � X?KMISb KZU<��PSI5b KZU�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iG� ` b5P K�t�a ' ` �ÎX�NYiqt�KZU[ISNVt�KQijaJpZNYi¾NYISb ��ijaY|ENYi¾U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k��f�L K>t?L U?a�P���LSs5P t�aY|St?NY^qISKMb1PSI5b KZU ' � ^qXWbSKZt�KZU[RT^qI KMbÅ|®kdt?LSKQt?L K!b KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMb�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU �ÎXet?LSU?a�P���L s5PSt � aYU|�kt?L K�X�KMISbSKZU�t?L U?a�P���L sEP tH�ÁaYU��YKZU?k.LS^*��L � NYISb ����NYISb.^qX�a�ISijkRNVU���^qISNYiqiqkTLS^*��L KZU�t?LSNYI.t?LSNVt�aY|5t?NY^qI KMbPSISbSKZU�� ` �f�L K!t?L U[a�P���L s5P t�NYISb |5NYI5b gW^qb t?L p{a�R­s5NVU�^qX�a�I a���s5U?aYt�a�p{a�i_X ' ~V\ ' ` NYISb ' � ^qX�K�+ LS^j|E^jt�KMb1^_I ��^#��P U?KMX �NYISb �&�Åf�LS^_X:|}KMLSNM�J^jaYU&p{a�PSiqbÇNYiqX�aÅ|}K^_I��çKZU[U?KMb �ÁU?a�R �2^*��PSU?KMX ` NYISb � �1n/U[aYt�a�p{a�i ' ~¿LSNYX>t?L K L5^*��L KMX�tt?L U?a�P���L s5P t�NYI5b¿ijahg"KMX?t�|ENYISb gW^qbSt?L­PSX?N$�YK�^qIp{a�RTs5NVU[^qX�a�I¿t�a ' ` NYISb ' � �/f�L K ' ~WX?KMISb KZU�^qX�U[KMX�s}a�ISX?^j|5iqK�ÁaYU:p{aYU?U?KMp{t?ijk t�U[NYISX?R^jt�t?^qI�� s5NYp��YKZt?X>a�ISijk1a8�YKZU:t?LSKTX�a�P U[p{KTiq^_I���� � I ' ~!U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUQb a�KMX�I aYt�U?KMp{KM^q�YKNYI�kU?KMbSP5ISbSNYI®t:s5NYp��YKZt?X �ÁU?a�R t?L K¿X�KMI5b KZU�� ^ ISb KZU ' ` t?LSK¿X�KMISbSKZU>^qXQU?KMX�s}a�ISX?^j|EijK �çaYU!RTN$�J^qI��ÅX?PSU?Kt?LSNVt&NVtijKMNYX�t�a�I K�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�^qIKMNYp[LdI KM^*��L®|}aYU[L a�a�bU?KMp{KM^j�YKMX�t?L K�s5NYp��YKZtB�Ya�^qI��>t?L U[a�P���Lt?LSK�X�a�PSU[p{K�NYI5bt?NY^qi�iq^qI���X"�HJ^qI5p{K�NYi_i s5NYp��YKZt?X�NVU?KWR&PSijt?^_pZNYX�t;t�aQNYiqiJU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[XZ\�t?LSK�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X/U?KMp{KM^j�YKWX�a�RTK�U?KMbSPSI5bSNYI�t2U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�ÁU?a�R�t?L KTX�KMI5b KZU��­� aYUQt?LSKMX�K­U?KMNYX�a�ISX:t?L KX�KMISbSKZU:NYISb t?L KTU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X:^qI t?L KTpZNYX?KTa�� ' ` b a�R&PSp[L R­aYU?KsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��e^qI&p{a�R­s5NVU�^qX�a�I&t�a�t?L K�X?KMISb KZU;NYISb>U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X;PSI5b KZU ' ~V\�ijKMNYbS^qI��Wt�a�LS^*��L KZU2X�KMISbSKZU2NYI5bQU?KMp{KM^q�YKZUt?L U?a�P���L s5P t�PSI5b KZU ' ~$��fWLS^qX�U?KMX[PSijt?X�^qIÅLS^*��L KZUea8�YKZU[NYiqi+sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i+t?LSU?a�P���L s5PSt�PSISb KZU ' ~$� � XeR­aYU?K&bSNVt?Ns5NYp �YKZt?X"NYISb� � O:X�NVU[KWR>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t;t�a:t?LSK�KMI�t?^qU?K�I KZt¬g�aYU��­PSISbSKZU ' ` \ ' ~�PSX�KMX�R>PSp�LijKMX[X2|5NYISb gW^_b t?L&t?LSNYI' ` �o,t�^qX��YKZU?k.^qI�t�KZU[KMX�t?^qI��­t�aTI aYt�K>^qId�2^*��P U?KMX �TNYISb �&t?LSNVt�KZ�YKMIdt?L a�P���L ' ` NYp�LS^jKZ�YKMXWNLS^*��L KZU�t?L U?a�P���L s5P tt?LSNYI ' � \ ' ` NYiqX�a PSX?KMXR­aYU?KÅ|5NYISb gW^_b t?L� f�L5^qX­^qXT|}KMpZNYPSX?K�t?L K�U?KMX?s�a�I5X?^j|5^qi_^jt¬k a���sSU[a8�J^qbS^qI�� U?KZsENY^jU[X^qXdp{a�ISp{KMI®t�U[NVt�KMbvNVt�t?L K X�KMISbSKZU�NYISb)t?L K b KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMb7U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X�PSISb KZU ' � KZ�YKMI7t?L a�P���L iqKMX?X.s5NYp��YKZt?X�5ahg a�I t?L KTiq^qI���X"�>f�L KTX�KMISbSKZU�^_I ' � LSNYX�t�a�p{a�I®t?^qI�P KTX�KMISbS^_I��¿U[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�ISX�PSI®t?^qi$t?L KTb KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMbU?KMp{KM^j�YKZUT^_I�KMNYp�L�ijaJpZNYi�I KM^*��L®|�aYU�L a®aJbÇp{aYU?U?KMp{t?ijk�U?KMp{KM^j�YKMX­t?L K.s5NYp �YKZt"� o,IÇt?L KdpZNYX�Kda�� ' ` \�t?LSK.X?KMISb KZUX�KMISb5X;U?KZt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�ISX�a�ISijk!PSI�t?^_iSNVt�ijKMNYX�t�a�I KWU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU"^qI­KMNYp�L¿iqa�pZNYiSISKM^*��L�|}aYU[LSa®aJb&U?KMp{KM^j�YKMX"t?L K�s5NYp �YKZtp{aYU?U?KMp{t?iqk � t?L K.NYbSbS^jt?^qa�ISNYi/t�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�ISXQb5P Kt�a1� NY^qiqP U?Ka��eijaJpZNYi�U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k b a I aYt&p{a�I®t�U[^j|EP t�K R&PSp�LE�A�f�L KZU[K"�çaYU?K t?L KdX�KMISbSKZU&PSI5b KZU ' � X�KMISbSX&R­aYU?K.U?KZt�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�ISX"� � iqX?a \;t?L Kdb KMX?^*��ISNVt�KMbÇU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU!P5ISb KZU' � bSa®KMX�R&PSp�L�R­aYU?K:s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��&t?LSNYI�N­U[KMp{KM^j�YKZUWPSISbSKZU ' ` ��f�LSK�|}aYt�t?ijKMISKMp��dPSISb KZU ' � R­a8�YKMXW|}KZt¬g�KZKMIX�KMISbSKZUeNYISbÅt?L K>b KMX[^*��ISNVt�KMb1U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�gW^jt?L�p�LSNYI��YK!^qIÅija�X[X�sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jtzk¿NYISb I�PSRQ|}KZU�a��;t?NY^_i+iq^qI���X"��f�L�PSX' � LSNYX/ijahg"KZU/t?LSU?a�P���L s5PSt2^_ITp{a�R­s5NVU[^_X�a�I!t�a ' ` �/c�P K�t�aQt?L K_� NYp{t/t?LSNVt/U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX �ÁU?a�R t?L KWX?KMISb KZUNVU?KQX?KMI�t�a�I5ijkt�aTt?LSKQb KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMbdU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[XM\5ijKMX?X�|5NYI5b gW^qb t?L.^qX�P5X�KMb�PSISbSKZU ' � �W K!I a8g4ija�a���NVtet?L K>t�U[N.�¿p&p{a�ISp{KMI®t�U[NVt?^ja�I PSISb KZUesSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX ' ~V\ ' ` NYI5b ' � ���2^*��P U?K>y¿X?L ahgWX�L a8g t?L Kt�U[N.�¿pp{a�ISp{KMI�t�U�NVt?^ja�I aY|5t?NY^qI KMb P5ISb KZU�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�iqX ' ~V\ ' ` NYISb ' � �VNVU[^jKMXQgW^jt?L t?L Kiqa�X?X:sSU[aY|5NV|5^qiq^qt¬k �ÁaYU~�� � � �.t?NY^qiqX���ozt�pZNYI |�K&X�KZKMI t?LSNVt�t?L KQt�U[N.� p>p{a�ISp{KMI®t�U[NVt?^ja�I P5ISb KZU ' � ^_ISp{U?KMNYX�KMXegW^jt?L1ija�X?XesSU?aY|5NV|5^_iq^jt¬k��f�LS^_X"^qX�|}KMpZNYPSX�K�t�U[N.�¿p�^_X"p{a�ISp{KMI®t�U[NVt�KMbÅa�I.t?L Ket?NY^_i�i_^qI��JX"ijKMNYb5^qI��Qt�a­t?LSK�bSKMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X � NYISb.t?L KX�a�P U�p{K:iq^qI��R�ÁaYUWLS^*��L � NYISb����A��� aYU � . ��! ` �!t?L K�t�U[N.�¿p�p{a�I5p{KMI�t�U[NVt?^qa�IÅPSISbSKZU ' � ^qX ` � � � LS^#��L KZU�t?LSNYIt?LSNVtWP5ISb KZU ' ~�NYI5b ' ` ��fWL K�t�U[N.�¿p:p{a�I5p{KMI�t�U[NVt?^qa�IÅPSISbSKZU ' ~:NYISb ' ` ^qX�NYijg�NMkJXWNYi_R­a�X�tQ~$�� aYU&N.s�KZU �çaYU[RNYISp{KTp{a�R­s5NVU[^_X�a�I t?LSNVt:t?N$�YKMX&^qI®t�a�NYpZp{a�PSI�tQt?L KTsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I�� p{a�X?t?XQNVt:t?L KU?KZs5NY^jU:X�KZU[�YKZU[XZ\ijKZtWP5X�NYX?X?PSRTK�t?LSNVt�t?L K:U[KZs5NY^jUWX�KZU[�YKZU[XWNVU?KQt?L KQX?NYR­KE��^qI5b.a��2RNYp[LS^qISKMX�NYX�t?L K>X�KMISb KZU�aYUWaYUeN­U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU��� KMISp{K�g"K:p{a�I5X?^qb KZU * K +32.M»\ * K 7�2.M»\ * K +65TM»\ * K 7=5TM»\ * K 7 < M �ÁaYU�N!U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZU�t�a­|}K�t?LSK�X[NYR­K:NYX�t?LSNVtX�ÁaYU

~M�

Page 19: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

100 1000 10000 100000

Ove

rall

Prot

ocol

Thr

ough

put G

ain

Number of Tail Links

L1/L2 - p=0.05L1/L2 - p=0.25L3/L2 - p=0.05L3/L2 - p=0.25L1/L3 - p=0.05L1/L3 - p=0.25

�2^*��P U?K � ��f�L U?a�P���LSs5P t � NY^qI

0.4

0.45

0.5

0.55

0.6

0.65

0.7

0.75

0.8

0.85

100 1000 10000 100000

Ban

dwid

th U

sage

Number of Tail Links

L3/L2 - p=0.05L3/L2 - p=0.25L1/L2 - p=0.05L1/L2 - p=0.25

�2^*��P U?K ��� � NYISbSgW^qb t?LdrWKMbSPSp{t?^ja�I

~Mu

Page 20: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

2.2

2.4

2.6

0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25

Tra

ffic

con

cent

ratio

n

Loss Probability

L1,L2N2L3

�2^*��PSU?K:y���f+U�N.�¿p>l�a�ISp{KMI®t�U[NVt?^ja�I

N!U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUWaYU�X�KMISb KZU�� W KQt?L KMI �EISb t?L K�R­KMNYIdt�aYt?NYiGs�KZU�sENYp��YKZt�sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��!p{a�X�t?XWNVt�NYiqi}I aJb KMX � X�KMI5b KZUM\U?KZs5NY^qU&X�KZU[�YKZU[XZ\�U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X��>PSISbSKZU>sSU[aYt�a�p{a�i ' ~$� W K�NYiqX�a �EISbÇt?L K.R­KMNYI t�aYt?NYi�s}KZU&s5NYp��YKZtTs5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��p{a�X�t?X!NVt>NYi_i�I aJb KMX � X?KMISb KZUM\�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X<�:PSI5b KZU ' ` NYISb ' � ��� aYU!t?L K¿pZNYX?K¿a���N1X?^qI���ijKU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU&s�KZU>t?NY^qipZ^jU[pZP5^jtZ\��2^*��PSU?KQw&X?L a8geX�L a8g7t?L K�R­KMNYI�t�aYt?NYi¾s}KZU�sENYp��YKZt�sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��&U[NVt?^ja!� NVU�^jKMX�gW^jt?L �9NYISb � �;o,t�pZNYI|}K­X�KZKMI t?LSNVt!�ÁaYU � . ��! � ��\+t?L KTRTKMNYI t�aYt?NYi;s}KZU�s5NYp��YKZt>sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��.p{a�X�t:PSI5b KZU ' ~­^qX�R­aYU[K&t?L5NYI t?LSNVta�� ' � �df�L5^qX�^qX:|}KMpZNYPSX?K<�çaYU&ija8g ija�X?X:sSU?aY|5NV|5^_iq^jt?^jKMX�t?L K¿U?KZs5NY^jUQX?KZU?�YKZU&bSa®KMX>I aYt>I KZKMb t�a1X?PSsSs5ijk RTNYI�kU?KZs5NY^qU[X2|5P t�^qt/X�t?^qiqi b a�KMX;t?L KWK�+�t�U[NQg"aYU �&a��}U?KMp{KM^q��^qI��:NYiqi a��}t?L K�s5NYp �YKZt?X"��f�L5^qX2|}KMLSNM�J^jaYU�^qX�NYiqX�a:aY|5X?KZU?�YKMbgWLS^_ijKp{a�R­s5NVU�^qI�� ' ~¿NYI5b ' ` �ÁaYU � . ��! � � NYISb�iqKMX?XQt?L5NYI t?L a�P5X?NYISb�t?NY^qiqX"� W ^jt?LÇNYI ^qISp{U?KMNYX?K¿^qI�t?L KI�PSRQ|}KZU:a���t?NY^_iqX:NYISb�ija�X?X:s5U?aY|5NV|5^qi_^jt¬k1t?L K¿R­KMNYI t�aYt?NYi�s�KZUQs5NYp��YKZt!sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I���p{a�X�t>P5ISb KZU ' ` NYISb ' �X�t?NVU?t?Xe^qISp{U?KMNYX[^qI��&U?KMiqNVt?^j�YK�t�aTt?L5NVtWPSISb KZU ' ~$�/f�L K:R­KMNYI�t�aYt?NYiGs}KZU�s5NYp��YKZtesSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��!p{a�X?tWPSISb KZU ' � ^qXijKMX?XWt?LSNYI ' ` �W�eaYt?^qI��¿t?L KE� NYp{tet?L5NVtet?L K>U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��Tp{a�X�t�PSISb KZU ' ~Q^_X�t?L K&ijKMNYX�tZ\}NYbSbS^qI��¿R­aYU?KU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X�s}KZU�t?NY^qi¾gW^_iqi � P U?t?LSKZU�U?KMbSPSp{KY\SU[KMiqNVt?^j�YKMijkY\ t?L K>R­KMNYIdt�aYt?NYiGs}KZU�s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��­p{a�X�tWP5ISb KZU ' ~$�o�I1X?P5RTRTNVU?kY\Eg"K!X�KZK&t?LSNVt�iqa�pZNYi+U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k ijKMNYbSXet�a L5^*��L KZUWs5U?aYt�a�p{a�i$t?L U?a�P���L s5P tWNYI5b1ijahg"KZU�|5NYI5b gW^qb t?LPSX?N$�YK�� W LS^qiqK!p{a�RTs5NVU[^qI��.t?L U[KZKTija�pZNYi2U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k sSU[aYt�a�p{a�iqXM\+^*��U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU[XQNVU?KI aYt�|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp ��X:t?L KMI' ~eK�+ LS^j|5^jt?X�LS^*��L KMX�t�t?L U?a�P���L sEP t�NYISb PSX�KMX�ijKMNYX�t�|5NYISb ge^qb t?L� � R­a�I�� ' ` NYISb ' � \ ' ` LSNYX"L5^*��L KZU"L5^*��L KZUt?L U?a�P���L s5P t�|5P t ' � LSNYXQija8g�KZU�|5NYISb ge^qb t?L PSX?N$�YK��&o,I®t�KZU?KMX�t?^qI���ijkY\G^*��g�KTp{a�ISX?^_b KZU�t?L K­U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZU[X�t�aLSN8�YK"t?L K�X?NYR­K"sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���s}ahg"KZU2NYX$X?KMISb KZUGaYU�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X$t?L KMIQt?L KZU?K"^_X+NYI:ah�YKZU[NYiqi®U?KMbSPSp{t?^qa�IQ^qI�s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��p{a�X�t?X�^qI!t?L K�U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZU�|5NYX�KMb¿NVsSsSU?a�NYp�LTgW^qt?LT^qISp{U?KMNYX[^qI���ija�X?X;s5U?aY|5NV|5^qi_^jt?^jKMXZ\YI�PSRQ|}KZU/a��}t?NY^qi5iq^qI��JX;NYISbI�PSRQ|}KZU�a��2U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUWs�KZUWt?NY^qi¾iq^qI����f�L K�X�KMISbSKZU"t?L U[a�P���L s5P t�PSISb KZU ' � ^qX"a�ISijkTX?i_^*��L�t?iqkTR­aYU?K�t?LSNYI t?L K�b KMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb¿U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�t?LSU?a�P���L s5PSt"��o�I

` �

Page 21: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

100 1000 10000 100000

Ove

rall

Proc

essi

ng R

educ

tion

Number of Tail Links

L1/L2 - p=0.05L1/L2 - p=0.25L1/L3 - p=0.05L1/L3 - p=0.25

�2^*��PSU?K>w ��m1KMNYIÅf$aYt?NYi+n�KZUen2NYp��YKZt�n/U[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��­rWNVt?^ja

� NYp{t!�çaYU:LS^#��L KZUe�VNYiqP KMX�a�� � � � ��! ` ����NYISb iqNVU��YK!� NYi_P KMX�a�� � t?L K­X�KMI5b KZU�t?L U?a�P���L sEP t�^_X�iqa8g�KZU�t?LSNYI t?L Kb KMX?^#��ISNVt�KMb U?KMp{KM^q�YK¿t?L U[a�P���L s5P t"� o ��sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' � ^qX:U[K{x¬b KMX?^*��I KMb�X?PSp�L t?LSNVt!NYiqi;t?L K¿t�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I5X:NYISbU?KZt�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�ISX�g�KZU?KR&PSijt?^qpZNYX�tQt�aÅKZ�YKZU?k U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU>NYISb�I aYt �?PSX�t:t?L K¿b KMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUM\�t?L KMI t?L KZU?KgW^qi_iG|}K>ijKMX[Xe|EP U[b KMIÅa�I t?L K&bSKMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X�t�a.X[P sSs5ijk.t?L K!U?KZsENY^jU[X"�:H�t?^qiqi»\5t?L K&t?L U?a�P���LSs5P teP5ISb KZU' � gW^qi_iG^qR­sSU[a8�YKQa�I5ijk�X?iq^*��L®t?ijk � t?L K&U?KZt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�IdsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��¿p{a�X�t�NVt�t?L K&X?KMISb KZUeX?t?^qiqiGU[KMRTNY^qIS^qI��Tt?L KX?NYR­Kh�A� � tet?L K>X?NYRTK:t?^qR­K:t?LSKQ|5NYISbSgW^qb t?L.PSX?N$�YK&NYISbÅRTKMNYI�t�aYt?NYi$s�KZUWs5NYp��YKZt�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��­gW^qiqi}^qI5p{U?KMNYX�KNTijaYt�RTaYU?K��f�LS^_X�NYi_X�aÅX?P����YKMX?t?X�t?LSNVtQPSX[^qI�� �ÁNYX?t�KZUQRTNYp[L5^qI KMX:NYX>b KMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X:ge^qiqi�I aYtQL KMijs R&PSp�L |}KMpZNYPSX�Kt?L K�X�KMISb KZU"t?L U?a�P���L sEP t;gW^qiqi5b a�RT^qISNVt�K�� ' ` gW^qi_i X�t?^qiqi LSN8�YK�N&LS^*��LSKZU/sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i5t?LSU?a�P���L s5PSt;t?LSNYI ' � ����I Kg�NMk!t�a:^qR­sSU[a8�YK�t?L K�t?L U?a�P���L s5P t�gW^jt?L a�PSt2^_ISp{U?KMNYX?^qI��e|5NYI5b gW^qb t?L>^qX2t�a:p{a�ISX�t�U�PSp{t/N�ija���^qpZNYiJt�U?KZKEK´~Y~�M gW^jt?LN X?RTNYiqi�NYISb p{a�ISX�t?NYI®t�|SU[NYISp�LS^qI��<� NYp{t�aYU���o�ISX�t�KMNYb a��/tzg"a�ijKZ�YKMi_X � X�KMI5b KZU�X�KMISbS^qI��TU?KZt�U[NYISX[RT^qX?X?^qa�ISX�t�adNiqNVU��YK�I�PSRQ|}KZU"a��+b KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMbU?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X�NYISb¿bSKMX?^*��ISNVt�KMb¿U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X�X?PSsSs5ijkJ^qI���U?KZsENY^jU[X/t�a&aYt?L KZU�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�X���\t?LS^qXWt�U?KZK!g"a�P5iqbÅLSN8�YK­X�KZ�YKZU[NYi2ijKZ�YKMiqX�b KZs}KMISbS^qI��TP s}a�I�t?L K!I®P5RQ|}KZUWa���t?NY^qiqX�iq^qI��JX"��f�L K>s}KZU��çaYU�RTNYISp{KQa��t?LS^qX�NVsSsSU[a�NYp[L ^qXe�YKZU?kÅX�KMISX[^jt?^j�YKQt�a.t?L K&|SU[NYI5p[LS^qI��<�ÁNYp{t�aYU�a���t?L K&iqa���^qpZNYi+t�U[KZK�� W K!K�+Jt�KMISb t?L K!NYISNYijkJX?^qX^qI K´~Y~"M�PSX?^_I��da�P U!ija�X?X:R­aJb KMi�t�a �EISb t?LSNVt>t?LSKija���^qpZNYi�t�U?KZK NVs5sSU?a�NYp[L�sSU?ah��^_b KMX�K�+ p{KMiqijKMI®tQt?L U?a�P���L s5P tNYISb |5NYISbSgW^qb t?Ls�KZU �çaYU[RNYISp{KegeL KMI t?L Ke|5U[NYISp[L5^qI�� �ÁNYp{t�aYU�^qX��YKZU?k X?RTNYiqi � � a8g�KZ�YKZUM\��ÁaYU�N!iqNVU��YK�I®P5RQ|}KZUa��:t?NY^qi_XZ\�N�X?RNYiqijKZU|5U[NYISp[L5^qI�� � NYp{t�aYUd^qISp{U?KMNYX�KMX¿t?L K b KZsSt?L a��:t?L K t�U?KZK1U[KMX?PSijt?^qI�� ^qI ija�I��YKZU¿U?KMp{ah�YKZU?ks5NVt?LSX��2fWLS^qX�pZNYI s}aYt�KMI®t?^qNYiqijk­ijKMNYb¿t�a&L5^*��Lb KMi_NMkJX"� � R­KMNYIS^qI����ÁPSi5p{a�R­s5NVU[^qX?a�Ia��Gt?LSKeija���^qpZNYiEt�U?KZK[%�|5NYX?KMbNVsSsSU[a�NYp[L a�� K´~Y~�M�gW^jt?LÇt?L KdijaJpZNYi�U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMX!K�+JNYRT^_I KMb ^qIÇt?LS^qX&U?KZs}aYU?t­^qX&s}a�X?X?^j|EijKa�ISiqk |®kR­aJb KMiq^qI��>t?L K>b KMiqNMk |}KMLSNM�J^jaYUW^_IdNYbSbS^jt?^ja�I t�a R­a�bSKMiq^qI��&t?L K:t?L U[a�P���L s5P t�NYISb.|ENYISb gW^qbSt?L P5X?N$�YK��

` ~

Page 22: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Proc

essi

ng R

atio

(Rep

air

Serv

er/R

ecei

ver)

Loss Probability

Tails-per-Repair Server=4Tails-per-Repair Server=8

�2^*��P U?KQ����reNVt?^jaTa��;r�KZsENY^jUeH�KZU?�YKZU�t�a¿r�KMp{KM^j�YKZU�n/U?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��l�a�X�t

� � ���T�6��& � ������� ��� ��� � �&��� �V��' �6� �

o�I¿t?LSKesSU[KZ��^ja�P5X"X�KMp{t?^qa�I¿t?LSK�t?LSU?a�P���L s5PSt�a��GsSU[aYt�a�p{a�i ' ~�g�NYX�aY|St?NY^qI KMb.PSISbSKZU"t?L K�NYX?X?P5R­sSt?^ja�I¿t?LSNVt�t?L KU?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU?�YKZU�LSNYX�X?P��¿pZ^jKMI®t/sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���s�ahg"KZU�NYISbT^qX"I KZ�YKZU"NQ|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp����2o,It?LS^qX/X?KMp{t?^ja�ITg�Keb KZt�KZU�RT^qI Kt?L K:s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��­NYISb.|5P�,�KZU�U[K��®PS^qU?KMR­KMI®t?X�a��2NTU?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZUWX�aTt?LSNVte^jt�b a�KMX�I aYt�|}KMp{a�R­KQN­|}aYt�t?ijKMISKMp����

� � � %L��� � '�'����'& % � � �V�

� U?KZs5NY^jU$X�KZU?�YKZU2R>PSX?tGs}KZU��çaYU�R)U?KMp{KM^j�YK[%®X?^qbSK�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I���a��Js5NYp��YKZt?X2NYISb>� � O:XZ\VNYISb:X�KMI5b&%®X?^qb K;s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��a�� U?KZs5NY^qU[X"� W K�I ahgÇbSKZt�KZU[RT^qI K�t?L K"s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI���s}ahg"KZU�U?K���PS^jU?KMb:NVt2NeU?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZUM\Vs}KZU�R&PSijt?^_pZNYX�t$X�KMX[X?^ja�I¾\X�a�t?L5NVt$^jt+bSa®KMX$I aYtG|}KMp{a�R­K�t?LSK�|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp ���/HJ^qISp{K/NWU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU$s�KZU �çaYU[RXGR­aYU?K/s5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI���t?LSNYIQt?L K"X?KMISb KZUPSISbSKZU ' ~V\¾g�K!b KZt�KZU[RT^qISKQt?L K&sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��s}a8g�KZU�a��/t?L K&U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU�^qI1t�KZU[RTX�a��/t?LSNVt�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU � P5X?^qI��K���PSNVt?^ja�ISX � �&� ` �WNYI5b � �&� � ���A�Wo �;NTU?KZsENY^jUWX�KZU?�YKZU�pZNYI RTNVt?p[L t?L K>U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU�t?L U?a�P���L sEP t�t?L KMIÅ^qtWgW^qi_i¾I KZ�YKZU|}K:N!|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp��d^qIdNR>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�t�X�KMX?X[^ja�Idt?LSNVtWP5X�KMX�sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i ' ~$�o�Id��^#��P U?KQ�!g�K�s5ijaYt�t?L K�U�NVt?^jaTa��2R­KMNYIdU?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU?�YKZUWs5U?a�p{KMX[X?^qI��!p{a�X�t � NYX[X?PSRT^qI��&t?L5NVtW^jt�LSNYX�t?L K>X?NYR­KsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I��s}a8g�KZU:NYX�N U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU<�eNYISb t?L K­R­KMNYI U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��¿p{a�X�t!�ÁaYU�� NVU?kJ^qI�� KMISbJx»t�aVx»KMI5b ija�X?XsSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jtzkY\ � � � U[KZs5NY^jUWX�KZU[�YKZU�I KZKMb5XWN­sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��­s}a8g�KZUet?L5NVte^qX�ISaR­aYU?K>t?LSNYI ~$�q~MyTt?^qR­KMX�t?L5NVtWa��/NU?KMp{KM^j�YKZUE�çaYU:N.I�PSRQ|}KZU�a���t?NY^_i;iq^qI��JXWs}KZU�U?KZs5NY^qU�X?KZU?�YKZU�K��®P5NYi2t�aÅ�¿NYI5b1�çaYU�ija�X?X�s5U?aY|5NV|5^qi_^jt?^jKMXWiqKMX?X�t?LSNYI�-� ` �&��f�L K�U?KMbSP5p{t?^ja�I�^qI.t?NY^qi+iq^qI��JX�s�KZUeX�KZU?�YKZUebSa®KMX�ISaYtWp[LSNYI��YKQt?LS^qX�U[K��®PS^qU?KMR­KMI®t�|�KMpZNYP5X�K:KZ�YKMI�t?LSa�P���Lt?L K�U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU;LSNYX$t�a�X?P sSs5iqk �ÁKZg"KZU2U?KZsENY^jU[XZ\ t?L K�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��ep{a�X�t�NVt;NeU?KMp{KM^j�YKZU;^qX�NYiqX�aeU?KMbSPSp{KMb>|}KMpZNYPSX�K^jt�I ahg U?KMp{KM^j�YKMX/�çKZg�KZUWU[KZt�U[NYISX?RT^_X?X?^ja�ISX�a��2N­s5NYp �YKZt"�

`�`

Page 23: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

f�L�PSX;N�U?KZs5NY^qU/X�KZU?�YKZU�I KZKMbTa�ISijkQ|}K�N�iq^jt�t?iqK@� NYX�t�KZU/t?L5NYITN�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU/t�a>NM�Ya�^qb­|}KMp{a�RT^_I���N�|}aYt�t?ijKMI KMp��!^jt?X�KMi#��ÁaYUWU?KMNYX�a�I5NV|5ijKQija�X[X�sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jt?^qKMX"�/f�LS^qX�U?KMX?PSijt�^_X_�Ya�a�b �çaYUea�I K>R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?tWX�KMX?X?^qa�I��o �;NTU?KZs5NY^qUWX�KZU?�YKZU�^qXt�aLSNYI5bSijK � R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�t�X�KMX?X[^ja�ISXZ\ t?L KMIÅ^jt�LSNYX�t�aT|}K � t?^qR­K!� NYX�t�KZU�t?L5NYIÅN!U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU4�

� � � � ��� �&� ����� � ������� �&��� '

� U?KZs5NY^qUeX�KZU?�YKZU�LSNYXet�a |5P-,}KZUeN X�KZtea��;sENYp��YKZt?X�^qIÅaYU[b KZU�t�a¿|}KQNV|5iqKQt�a U?KZt�U[NYISX?R^jtWt?L KMRBbSP KQt�a ija�X[X�KMX^qI�t?L K t?NY^qi"i_^qI��JX"�1f�LSKZaYU?KZt?^qpZNYiqijkY\2KMNYp�L s5NYp��YKZtTX[L a�PSiqb |�K L KMiqb �çaYU­NYI ^qI-��IS^jt�KMijk ija�I��1t?^qR­K t�a KMI5X?P U?Ks}KZU��ÁKMp{t?ijk¿U[KMiq^qNV|5ijK�ijaJpZNYi¾U?KMp{ah�YKZU?k �ÁU?a�R N­U?KZsENY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU���r�KMNYiq^_X�t?^qpZNYiqijkY\ ^jt�^_X�s}a�X?X?^j|5iqKet�aP5X�KQN �EI5^jt�K�X?^*\ZK|5P-,}KZUWX?P5p[L1t?LSNVtWt?L KQsSU?aY|5NV|5^_iq^jt¬k¿a��/ijaJpZNYiGU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k � NY^qiqP U?K!�ÁU?a�R@t?L K:U?KZs5NY^qUWX�KZU?�YKZU�^qX�K�+Jt�U?KMR­KMiqk.X[RTNYiqiS�o�IÅt?L K>U[NVU?K&KZ�YKMI�t�a��/ijaJpZNYi$U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k �ÁNY^_iqP U?KY\Et?L K>ija�X?tes5NYp �YKZt�X?L a�PSiqbÅ|}K:U?KZt�U[^jKZ�YKMb �ÁU?a�R t?L K>X�KMI5b KZU��Wo�It?LS^qX>X�KMp{t?^ja�I¾\2g�K¿PSX?K¿X?^qRTs5ijK­NYISNYijkJX?^qXQt�a1b KZt�KZU[R^qI KTt?L K¿K�+�s}KMp{t�KMbÇ|5P-,}KZUQU[K��®PS^qU?KMR­KMI®tQNVtQKMNYp�L�U[KZs5NY^jUX�KZU?�YKZU�NYX�NR� PSISp{t?^ja�I.a��2t?L K�s5U?aY|5NV|5^qi_^jt¬kTa��;ijaJpZNYi}U?KMp{ah�YKZU?k �ÁNY^_iqP U?K��W K�R­a�bSKMiSN:U?KZsENY^jU"X�KZU[�YKZU�NYX"NYI¿^qI��EIS^jt�K�pZNVs5NYpZ^jtzk]��P KMP K�gW^qt?LNYI^_I-�EIS^jt�K�I�PSR>|}KZU/a��GX�KZU?�YKZU[XM\®NYX?X?P5RT^qI��t?LSNVt�t?L K­U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZUQL5NYX�X?P-�¿pZ^jKMI®t�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��¿s}a8g�KZU�� � KMI5p{KY\+N.s5NYp��YKZt&^qX�^qRTR­KMb5^qNVt�KMijkÅNYX?X[^*��I KMb NX�KZU?�YKZU!a�I ^jt?X&NVU?U[^j�VNYi�NVt!t?L K ��P KMP K�� f�L K¿X?KZU?�YKZU­L a�iqbS^qI���t?^qR­K¿a���KMNYp[L s5NYp �YKZtT^qX&b KZt�KZU[RT^qISKMb |�k t?L KI�PSRQ|}KZU�a���U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX/�çU?a�RBt?L K&U?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU[�YKZU�t�a t?LSK&U[KMp{KM^j�YKZU[X � t?L K!U?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU[�YKZU�^_XeU[KMX�s}a�ISX?^j|5iqK�ÁaYU<�eNYISb t?L K!t?^qR­K­b KMiqN8k1|}KZtzg"KZKMI U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX"�:fWL K­I®PSR>|}KZU�a���U?KZt�U[NYI5X?RT^qX?X[^ja�ISX �çU?a�R t?LSK&U[KZs5NY^jUX�KZU?�YKZUet�aTt?L K�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[XW^qX�bSKZt�KZU[RT^qI KMb.|�k t?L K:sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jtzkTa��2^qR­s}KZU��ÁKMp{t�U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k�� � s5NYp��YKZtea�pZpZP sE^jKMX�N|5P-,}KZUX�ÁaYU�t?L KQbSPSU[NVt?^ja�I.a��2t?L K:L a�iqb5^qI��&t?^qR­K��o ��� ^qX�t?L K�I�PSRQ|}KZU�a���U?KZt�U[NYISX?R^qX?X?^ja�I5X�a��2N!s5NYp��YKZt/�çU?a�R t?LSK�U?KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU8\SNYISb¾\��d^_X�t?L K�R­KMNYIds5NYp �YKZtNVU?U[^q� NYi�U[NVt�KY\SNYISbG\ t?L K�b KMiqNMk¿|}KZt¬g�KZKMIdt?L K�U?KZs5NY^qU�X?KZU?�YKZUWNYISb t?L K�U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[X�^qX�Tt?LSKMI¾\-�çU?a�R ' ^jt�t?ijK �ÎX�iqN8g:\t?L K:K�+Js}KMp{t�KMbd|5P-,}KZU�aJpZpZP s5NYISp{k.NVtWN­U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU�^qX�K���PSNYi¾t�a

����

f�L K:I�PSR>|}KZU�� ^qX�b KZt�KZU�RT^qI KMbdNYX/�ça�iqiqa8gWX"� ' KZt� |}K�t?L KQI�PSRQ|}KZU�a��2U?KZt�U�NYISX?RT^qX[X?^ja�ISX�a��;N­s5NYp �YKZt/�ÁU?a�Rt?L KTU[KZs5NY^jU:X�KZU?�YKZU4�To>� �:^_X�t?L K­sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jtzk�a���ijaJpZNYi;U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k �ÁNY^qi_P U?K!t?LSNVtQpZNYI |}K­t�a�ijKZU�NVt�KMb¾\$t?LSKMI���^qXt?L KR^qIS^qR&PSR � NYiqPSK­a��&� � � � ����t?L5NVtQX?NVt?^qXN�EKMX�t?L KT^qI K���PSNYiq^qt¬kY\ � � � �1��� ��� � � � � � �1��^qXb KZt�KZU[R^qI KMb.|�k PSX[^qI��!t?L KL�Áa�iqijahgW^qI��!K���PSNVt?^ja�I�

� � � �1� .4~ � � � '�(�1� . ~ � � ~ � � � ; �� � )r�KMpZNYi_i �ÁU?a�R HJKMp{t?^ja�I �1t?LSNVt � � ^qXQt?L Kt?NY^_i�iq^qI�� ija�X[X:sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jtzk1NYISb � ^qXQt?L K¿I�PSR>|}KZUQa���t?NY^qi"iq^qI��JX:NU?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU?�YKZUe^_X�U?KMX�s}a�ISX?^j|EijK �ÁaYU��

� � � �V�$�� � ���� � � ��(�

W K�p[LSa®a�X�K�� . ` �YRTX � t?L K�NVsSsSU[a�+ ^qRTNVt�K U?a�PSISbÇt�U[^js b KMiqN8k �ÁU?a�R ^ m NYX?XZ\ � RL KZU[X�t&t�a ^jt?X&|5NYp���|}a�I KU?a�P t�KZU{��NYISb � . �&��f�LSK>R­KMNYI s5NYp �YKZt�NVU[U[^j�VNYiGU[NVt�K­^qXWK��®PSNVt�KMb t�a t?L K&a8�YKZU[NYiqi�t?L U[a�P���L s5P tWa��/sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i' ~V\�^S� K��j\��:. � , �

��T�2^*��PSU?Ku.X?L ahgWX�t?L KbSKZs�KMI5b KMISp{K!a��"K�+Js}KMp{t�KMb |5P�,�KZU�aJpZpZP s5NYISp{k � ^qI1��|®k�t�KMX���a�I �

�ÁaYU:t¬g�aÅbS^(,}KZU?KMI®t�KMISb&%�t�a.%�KMISb�ija�X?X�sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jt?^qKMXZ\ � . ��! � � � ��! ` � � U[KMpZNYiqi;t?LSNVt � . ~ � � ~ � � �� ���A�­f�L K` �

Page 24: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

1e-06 1e-05 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1

Exp

ecte

d B

uffe

r O

ccup

ancy

(in

kbyt

es)

Probability of Local Recovery Failure

p = 0.05p = 0.25

�2^*��P U[K�u�� � P-,�KZUer�K���PS^jU?KMR­KMI®t�NVtWNTrWKZs5NY^jUeH�KZU[�YKZUM\ � . ` � � � NYI5b���.7�

K�+Js�KMp{t�KMbT|5P-,}KZU�aJpZpZP s5NYI5p{k>NVt/N�U?KZs5NY^jU;X�KZU[�YKZU/^qX�~MuY���®|�k�t�KMX;NYISbd~ � w �®|�k�t�KMXZ\��ÁaYU � . ��! ` ��NYISb � . ��! � �U?KMX�s}KMp{t?^j�YKMiqk¿gWLSKMI ��.4~�� � �$�f�L�PSX;N�U?KZsENY^jU/X�KZU?�YKZU"U?K��®P5^jU?KMX;N!�ÁKZg9~�� �!�J^qijaY|�k®t�KMX/a���|EP-,�KZU/X?s5NYp{K�s}KZU/R>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t/X�KMX[X?^ja�IR�ÁaYU/U?KMNYX�a�I5NV|5ijKija�X?X�sSU?aY|5NV|5^_iq^jt?^jKMX"�

� ( ��� 6��'4������'

o�I t?LS^qX­U[KZs�aYU[t­g"K LSNM�YK ^qI��YKMX?t?^*��NVt�KMb a�ISKÅX�KZU?�YKZUN%�|ENYX�KMb NYISb t¬g�a U?KMp{KM^q�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb�ijaJpZNYi�U?KMp{a8�YKZU[k NVs xsSU?a�NYp�L KMXR�ÁaYUTX?pZNYiqNV|5iqK¿U?KMi_^qNV|5ijK.R>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t"��o,IÇt?L KdX�KZU?�YKZU:%�|5NYX�KMb�NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L¾\�b KMX?^*��I5NVt�KMb L a�X�t?XZ\/sEiqNYp{KMb^qISX[^qb K�t?L K!I KZt¬g�aYU���\¾NVU?K&P5X�KMb1NYX�U?KZsENY^jUeX�KZU[�YKZU[X"��o,IÅt?L K>U[KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L KMXM\�KZU[U?aYU�U?KMp{a8�YKZU?k ^qXb a�I K>^qI��Ya�iq��^qI��&a�I5ijk¿t?LSK:s5NVU?t?^qpZ^qs5NVt?^qI��­U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[XWNYISb�t?L KQX�KMISbSKZU�� W K&NYISNYijk&\ZKMbÅNYISb�p{a�RTs5NVU?KMb�s5U?aYt�aVxp{a�iqX>b KZ�YKMijaYs}KMb �ÁaYU:t?L KMX�KNVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMX"� ^ X?^qI���NYI5NYijk®t?^_pZNYi/R­aJb KMiqXZ\Gg�Kb KMRTa�ISX�t�U[NVt�KMb t?L KTs}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYISp{K��NY^qISX�^qI­PSX?^qI��et?L KeX�KZU?�YKZUN%®NVsSs5U?a�NYp[L¿^qI!t�KZU[RTX;a���sSU?aYt�aJp{a�i t?L U[a�P���L s5P tZ\®I KZt¬g�aYU��!|5NYISb ge^qb t?L&NYISb­a8�YKZU�NYiqisSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I���p{a�X�t?X"�/f�L K�s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYI5p{KX��NY^qISX/^qI5p{U?KMNYX�KWNYX�t?L K�X?^*\ZK�a��}t?L K�ISKZt¬g�aYU��TNYISb­t?L K�iqa�X?X;sSU?aY|ENV|5^qiq^jtzk^qISp{U[KMNYX�K¿RTN$�J^qI��Åt?L K X?KZU?�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMbÇNVsSsSU[a�NYp[LÇR­aYU?K.X?pZNYiqNV|5ijKgW^jt?L U[KMX�s}KMp{tQt�a t?L KMX�K s5NVU[NYR­KZt�KZU[X�� W KNYiqX�aQKMX�t?^qRTNVt�KMbt?L K�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI���s�ahg"KZU�NYISb­|5P�,�KZU/pZNVs5NYpZ^qt¬k­U?K���PS^jU?KMb­NVt"t?L K�U?KZs5NY^qU�X�KZU?�YKZU[X�s}KZU/R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�tX�KMX?X[^ja�I �çaYU�NYp[LS^qKZ��^qI��­t?L K�s}KZU��çaYU�RTNYISp{K!��NY^qISX��� X?KZU?�YKZUN%�|5NYX�KMb NVs5sSU?a�NYp[L p{a�PSi_b�|}K.b KZs5ijahkYKMbÇt�a ^_R­sSU?ah�YK s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYI5p{K¿^qIÇo�I�t�U[NYISKZt?X>geL KZU?K.X�KZU?�J^qp{KMXU?K���PS^jU[^_I��eU[KMiq^qNV|5ijK�R&PSijt?^qpZNYX?t/NVU?KWa$,}KZU?KMb� � ITo�I�t�U[NYISKZt�I KZt¬g�aYU��!sSU?ah��^_b KZU�p{a�PSiqbTs5iqNYp{K�t?L K�U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU[�YKZU[XNVt�NVsSs5U?aYsSU[^qNVt�K�ijaJpZNVt?^ja�ISX���c�KZs}KMISbS^qI���a�I!t?LSK�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��es}a8g�KZU�NYISbT|5P-,}KZU/X�s5NYp{K�t?LSNVt�pZNYIT|�K�sSU[a8�J^qb KMb

` �

Page 25: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

a�I�t?LSKQU?KZs5NY^qUeX�KZU?�YKZU�XZ\5t?L K&I KZt¬g�aYU��dsSU[a8�J^qb KZUWp{a�PSi_b�U?KMX�t�U�^qp{t�t?L K&PSX�K:a��;U?KZsENY^jUWX�KZU?�YKZU�X/�ÁaYUWa�ISiqk.p{KZU[t?NY^qII�PSRQ|}KZU!a���R>PSiqt?^qpZNYX�tTX�KMX?X[^ja�ISX � |�kÇNYX?X[^*��IS^qI�� X�KZs5NVU�NVt�KÅR>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t­NYbSb U[KMX?X�KMX­NYISb iq^_RT^jt?^qI��1t?L K�PSX�Kda��U?KZs5NY^qU"X�KZU?�YKZU�X�a�ISiqk �ÁaYU�t?L a�X�KeNYb5b U?KMX?X�KMX<�A�/mÅaYU?K�R>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t�X�KMX?X?^ja�I5X�p{a�PSiqb|}KWNYiqijahg"KMb¿gW^jt?Lt?L Ke^qI5p{U?KMNYX�K^qI.sSU[a�p{KMX?X[^qI��!s}a8g�KZUeNYISb.|5P�,�KZUWX?s5NYp{KQNVt�t?L K�U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU�X"�� XL� NVUQNYX:t?L Ko,I®t�KZU[I KZtQ^_X:p{a�ISp{KZU[I KMbG\$gW^_b K­X?pZNYijK ?�3 0�36562&b KZsEija8kJR­KMI®t:a���U?KZs5NY^jU:X�KZU[�YKZU[X:gW^qt?L X?P-�¿pZ^jKMI®tsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^_I���s}a8g�KZU;NYISbQ|EP-,�KZU2pZNVs5NYpZ^jtzk>RTN8kQI aYt�|}K�KMNYX�k��2o,t�^qX+s}a�X?X?^j|5iqK/t?LSNVt�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZUN%�|5NYX?KMb&NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMXZ\KZ�YKMI gW^jt?L1N¿ijahg"KZU�s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYISp{KY\}RTN8k�|}K>R­aYU?K!NVt�t�U[NYp{t?^j�YK�� � ^q�YKMIÅt?L K&s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYISp{K&^qR­sSU?ah�YKMR­KMI®t?Xea��t?L K�X�KZU?�YKZU:%�|5NYX�KMbdNVsSsSU[a�NYp[L¾\S^jt�^qX�g�aYU?t?L.X�t?PSb kJ^qI��&L a8g7t�a­RTN$�YK:^jt�R­aYU?K�b kJISNYRT^_peNYISb �5K�+ ^j|5iqK��$o�I t?LS^qXU?KZs}aYU?tZ\®g"K�LSNM�YK�p{a�ISX?^qbSKZU?KMbTt?L K�R­KMNYI¿t�aYt?NYi5s}KZU�sENYp��YKZt�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��:p{a�X�t�NVt�NYiqiSISa�b KMX � X�KMISb KZU8\®U?KMp{KM^q�YKZU[XNYISb U[KZs5NY^jU:X�KZU?�YKZU�X���NYXQN.s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYI5p{KTR­KZt�U[^qp �ÁaYUQt?N$�J^qI���^qI®t�a�NYpZp{a�PSI®tQt?L KsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��dp{a�X�t>a��"U[KZs5NY^jUX�KZU?�YKZU�X"� W K I KZKMb t�a ��ISb |}KZt�t�KZU¿p{a�X�tRTKZt�U[^qpZXTt�a t?N$�YK1^qI®t�a NYpZp{a�PSI®tt?L KÅsSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI�� NYI5b |5P-,}KZU[^qI��U?KMX�a�PSU[p{KMXPSX?KMb ^qISX?^qbSK t?LSK�I KZt¬g�aYU���� W KÅNYi_X�a I KZKMb t�a�X�t?PSb kÇt?L K�s}KZU��ÁaYU[RTNYISp{K�bSK"�YU[NYbSNVt?^ja�I�b5P Kdt�a^qISX[P-�¿pZ^jKMI®t�sSU?aJp{KMX?X?^qI��­NYISb.|EP-,�KZU�^qI��!U?KMX�a�P U�p{KMX�NVtWt?L K�U[KZs5NY^jU�X�KZU?�YKZU�X"�W KWNVU���PSKMb!t?LSNVt;t?L K�U?KMp{KM^j�YKZU:%�|5NYX�KMbTNVsSs5U?a�NYp[L!t?LSNVt;|EPS^qiqbSX�ija���^qpZNYiJt�U[KZKMX/^qX2iq^*�YKMijkQt�a:^qISpZP U;LS^*��LSKZU2bSKMiqNMkJX"�� KMISp{K­t?L KZU?KT^qX�NYI ^_RTR­KMbS^qNVt�K­I KZKMb t�a�NYI5NYijkV\ZK­t?LSKTb KMiqNMk1a��"t?L5^qX�NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L � NYISb NYiqX�a ' ~­NYISb ' ` �ÁaYUp{a�R­s5NVU�^qX�a�IE��NYISbÅX�t?PSb k t?L K:t�U[NYbSKZa$, |�KZtzg"KZKMI1b KMiqN8kY\St?L U?a�P���LSs5P t�NYISbd|ENYISb gW^qbSt?L P5X?N$�YK�����PSUWX�kJX�t�KMRR­aJb KMi+p{a�P5iqb�|}KQK�+Jt�KMISb KMb1t�a t?N$�YK!^_I�t�a NYpZp{a�PSI�t�t�KMR­s}aYU[NYi�p{aYU?U?KMiqNVt?^qa�I1^qI�t?L K&ISKZt¬g�aYU��Åija�X?X�K ` �.M2NYISbÅt�aNYiqX�adp{a�ISX[^qb KZU�R­aYU?K­p{a�R­s5ijK�+1t�aYs�a�iqa���^jKMX�gW^jt?L L KZt�KZU?a��YKMI KM^qt¬k��&ozt�^qXeKMNYX�k t�a K�+Jt�KMISb t?L K­NYISNYiqk�X?^_XWa�� ' ~NYISb ' � t�a:NYI®k!p{a�R­s5ijK�+&t�aYs�a�iqa��Yk��/f�L K�NYISNYijkJX?^qX�a�� ' ` ^qX;X?iq^*��L®t?ijk:R­aYU[K�t�U[^qp���k��;r�KMp{KMI®t?ijk&t?L KZU?K�LSNYX2|}KZKMINYI­^qISp{U[KMNYX?^qI���^qI�t�KZU[KMX�t;^qIQU[KMiq^qNV|5ijK�R>P5ijt?^qpZNYX�t2NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L KMX;PSX?^_I��/�ÁaYU?g�NVU[b&KZU?U?aYU;p{aYU?U?KMp{t?^ja�I � �2��l��BK´~ � \ ~My�M �f�L KMX?K!NVs5sSU?a�NYp[LSKMXQNVU?K­|5NYX?KMb a�I KMISbJx»t�aVx»KMISb U[KMp{a8�YKZU?k �ÁU?a�R t?L KTX�KMI5b KZU��>fWL KZk1LSN8�YKTt?L K­s}aYt�KMI®t?^qNYi2t�aU?KMbSP5p{K�I KZtzg"aYU �|5NYISbSgW^qb t?LTP5X?N$�YK��/o,t"g�a�PSiqb¿|}K�^qI®t�KZU?KMX�t?^_I��Qt�a­p{a�R­s5NVU[K�t?LSKe|5NYI5b gW^qb t?L¿PSX?N$�YK�a��$ijaJpZNYiU?KMp{ah�YKZU?k�NVsSsSU?a�NYp�L KMX�ge^jt?L.t?L a�X�K:t?L5NVtWPSX�K:�2��l��

��� � �V���&� � '

K´~[M>n � � LSN$��NMg�NVtZ\�n �În �$m ^qX?L U[NÅNYISb�H��ÎOR�$f+U[^qs5NVt?LS^¸\ ��� 9�2�3 GNQ ��GA=-G�P(G�J � 58D�� 9�;�Q�G$; �<0$D�2[9 GNQ��/9�P 560��"P*9� �&P(365S2 0.?�3� G � � �-D�5S2 0�365SG$D���n/U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI���X�a��$o����"��o�I��Áa�p{a�Rd\5]�PSI KT~MuYu����

K ` M>f!� � ^_iqiqLSNVU?t:\Y\�]�� � �Jl�NY^qIG\��_���SNVU[U?KZk�x � a�PSb U?KMNYP¾\Jc ���2^jK"�QNYISb H�� � NVt?X�KMiqi¸\� 9�;�Q�G$; �<0$D�2[9!0$D Y �_9�?�G��-;:2A9� G.?�3�� G�� =-0�;A58?�G$D�?LQ�G$; 3-9��� � 0$D Y ��� ��� �-P 365S2 0.?�3��XG���365�DVJ��B;:G�3 G�2AG$P ? 5�D����� � D�745�;NG�D �]9�D 3�?[�n�U?a�p{KZKMb5^qI���X�a���o,�"��� o,I��ÁaJp{a�Rd\G~MuYuYy&�

K � M>OR�El�NYij�YKZU?tZ\5m �5c�a�NVUeNYISbd�/���}P��YKZU�NJ\ � G Y 9"P 5�DVJ��AD 3Z9";AD 9"3 � GA=�G$P(G J �$�Eo����"��l�a�RR>PSI5^qpZNVt?^ja�ISX�m N$�VxN$\M^qISKY\E]�PSISK!~MuYu�wV�

K �$M!H�� c�KZKZU[^qI�� \Sc)�S�"X�t�U[^qIG\�c �S�SNVU[^_ISNYpZpZ^¸\��)�5]�NYp{aY|5X�a�I¾\El�� ' ^qP.NYISb ' � W KM^¸\�� D�� ;:2 T563Z9�243 �&;�9HQ�G�;! 5 Y 9� ;�9�0 � �-P 365S2 0.?�3"�_G���3658DVJ��5n/U[a�p{KZKMbS^_I���X�a�� � l�m H�o � l���m m \ s5N$�YKMX>~ ` yhx[~ � ��\ � P���P5X�t:~MuYu����

K���M!H��J�2ija8kJb¾\#�)�S]�NYp{aY|5X�a�I¾\SH��Jm1p8l�NYI5I KY\5l � ' ^qP¿NYI5b ' ���}LSNYI�� \$�%�_9"P 5S0��"P*9 � �-P(36562A0.?[3&;N0��]9"FHG$; I_Q"G$;' 5(J V3)(>FC9"5(J V3*� 9�? ?A5SG$D�?R0$D Y �@=�=�P 5S2 0�365SG$D ' 9�7�9�P+& ;:0�� 58DVJ��¾n/U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI���Xea�� � l�m HJo � lW��m1m�\5sEN$�YKMX� � ` x � �Yy�\ � P���PSX�t:~MuYu �&�

` �

Page 26: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

K y�M!H��J�2ija8kJb¾\#�)�S]�NYp{aY|5X�a�I¾\SH��Jm1p8l�NYI5I KY\5l � ' ^qP¿NYI5b ' ���}LSNYI�� \$�%�_9"P 5S0��"P*9 � �-P(36562A0.?[3&;N0��]9"FHG$; I_Q"G$;' 5(J V3)(>FC9"5(J V3*� 9�? ?A5SG$D�?R0$D Y �B=�=�P 5S2 0�365SG$D ' 9�7�9�P�&;N0 � 5�DVJ�� � i_NVt�KZU��YKZU�X?^ja�I�a��;t?LSK � l�m�HJo � lW��m1ms5NVs}KZUM\S�ea8�YKMR>|}KZU&~MuYu �&�

KÎw4M>m � � a�� RTNYISIG\ � D�0��"P 5�DVJ��B;NG �4= � G���� �-D�5S2 0�365SG$D 5�D��BP*G���0$P��)9�36FHG$;AI4?A�Sn�U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI���X�a�� � ijaY|5NYi¾�eKZt�xg�aYU��J^qI�� �«u�w®\}l�NYi*��NVU?kY\El�NYISNYb5NJ\5�Wah�YKMRQ|}KZU&~MuYuYy&�

K ��M � � W � � a�ij|5U?a®a���\�H��ÎO<�/H ^qI���LSNYi�NYISb c �ÎrL�"l�L KZU[^jt�a�I¾\ ' G�J ( 0.?"9 Y �_9 2A9"587�9�;��_9"P 5S0���P#9 � �-P(36562A0.?[3 Q"G$;�E58?[36;[5 � �-3Z9 Y �AD 3Z9�;:0�2�365�7$9 ��5 � �-P(0�3656G$D ��n�U?a�p{KZKMb5^qI���X­a�� � l�m H�o � l���m m�\/s5N$�YKMX ��` �hx � �S~V\ � P���PSX�t~MuYu �&�

K u�M!HJISKMLSN OR�"O:NYX�KZU[NJ\e]�^qR O:PSU?a�X�KÅNYISb�c�a�I f$a8geX?ijKZk � 2 0$P*0���P#9 �/9�P 560��"P*9 � �-P 365S2 0$?[3���?[58DVJ � �-P 365 =�P#9� �&P(365S2 0.?�3��B;:G���= ?[�En/U[a�p{KZKMbS^_I���X�a�� � l�m HJ^*��R­KZt�U[^_pZXWl�a�I��ÁKZU?KMISp{KY\E]�PSI K­~MuYu�wV�

K´~��.M � �Î�)� ' KZ�J^qI K"NYI5b&]�� � NVU[pZ^_N x ' PSISN x � p{KZ�YKMXZ\+� � G�� =-0�;A58?�G$D GNQ�)D�G�F D � P*0.? ?�9[?_GNQ��_9�P 5S0���P#9 � �-P 365S2 0.?�3�X;NG�3 G42 G$P ?A�¾n/U[a�p{KZKMbS^_I���X�a��2o,�"����o?l�l�l�\J�ea8�YKMR>|}KZU&~MuYuYy&�

K´~Y~[M � �Î�)� ' KZ�J^qI KY\ c � � � ' NM�Ya¿NYISbd]�� � NVU[pZ^qN x ' PSISN x � p{KZ�YKMXZ\ � -9 � 0.?�9HQ�G$;��/9�P 560��"P*9 � G$D�2 �-;A;�9�D�3 � �&P(365 (2A0.?[365�DVJ� ?A5�DVJ � &0$;�9 Y �/2"I���;�9 9[?[�5n/U[a�p{KZKMbS^_I���X�a�� � l�m m1PSiqt?^qR­KMbS^qNJ\ �ea8�YKMR>|}KZU>~MuYuYy&�

K´~ ` M!]��§l � ' ^qI1NYISb H��En2NYPSi¸\ � � �+��� � �_9"P 5S0��"P*9 � �-P(36562A0.?[3���;N0�D�? =-G�;[3 �B;:G�3 G�2AG$P �$n/U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI���Xea���o����"�o�I��Áa�p{a�Rd\$~MuYu �&�

K´~ � M!]�� �Wa�ISISKMISRTNYp[LSKZUM\S�_� � ^jKZU[X[NYp��.NYISbdc �Sf+ahgWX?ijKZkY\��/0$;A563 �� 0.?"9 Y ' G$? ?��_9�2AG$7$9";�� Q"G$;��_9�P 5S0���P#9 � �-P (365S2 0.?�3 ��;:0$D�? � 58? ?[56G�D���n�U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI���X�a�� � l�m H�o � l���m m�\ � P���P5X�tQ~MuYu�wV�

K´~��$M­l��$n2NVs5NYb aYs}a�PSija�XM\ � �2n2NVU[PSi*�VNVU!NYISb � � �/NVU���L KMX?KY\ ��D � ;A;:G$; � G$D 36;:G$P*��2 -9 �]9 Q"G$; ' 0$;SJV9� ��2 0�P*9� �&P(365S2 0.?�3$�B=�=�P 5S2 0�365SG$D�?[�En/U[a�p{KZKMbS^_I���X�a���o,�"����o�I��Áa�p{a�R�\Sm1NVU[p�L ~MuYuY�&�

K´~���M­H �Vn"^qI���NYiq^»\ c ��f$a8gWX?iqKZk>NYISbT]��VOQP U?a�X�KY\�� � G�� =-0�;A58?�G$D GNQ � 9�D Y 9�; ( �AD 5�365S0�3Z9 Y 0�D Y �/9�2A9"587�9�; ( �AD 5�365S0�3Z9 Y�_9"P 5S0��"P*9 � �-P 365S2 0.?�3"�X;NG�3 G�2 G$P ?A�}n/U[a�p{KZKMbS^_I���X�a�� � l�m HJ^*��R­KZt�U[^_pZXZ\G~MuYu����

K´~My�M ' �5rW^#\"\ZaNYISb ' � ��^_pZ^qX?NYI a \*� �_9�P 560 ��P#9 � �-P(36562A0.?[3$� 0�3 0��E5 ?�36;A5 � ��365SG$D �B;:G�3 G�2AG$P+ 0.?�9 Y G$D � GNQ[36FH0�;:9& � � ��9 2 TD�5�� � 9�?A�hn�U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI���X$a�� t?L K�� a�P U?t?L>o,�"��� � n�l�H �«u�w W aYU��JX?L aYsG\�l�L5NYi*��^_bS^*�J^¸\ � U?KZKMp{KY\®]�PSI K~MuYu�wV�

K´~8w4M&c ��f+KMISISKMISL a�PSX�KY\2]���H RT^jt?L¾\ W �2H ^qISp{a�X:�J^jKY\+c � W KZt?LSKZU[NYiqi�NYI5b � �+m ^qISbSKMI¾\�� ���&;[7$9 � GNQ �/2436587�9� 9"36FHG$;AI �_9�?"9 0$;N2 T�5o����"��l�a�RR>PSI5^qpZNVt?^ja�ISX�m N$��N$\M^qI KY\}]�NYI�PSNVU?k ~MuYu�wV�

K´~M��M&c ��f$a8gWX[ijKZkY\�]���O:P U?a�X�K�NYISbH �Vn"^qI���NYiq^»\�� � G�� =-0$;[5 ?"G$D GNQ � 9�D Y 9�; ( �AD�56365S0�3Z9 Y 0$D Y �/9�2A9"587�9�; ( �AD 5�365S0�3Z9 Y�_9"P 5S0��"P*9 � �-P 365S2 0.?�3"�X;NG�3 G�2 G$P ?A��o�������]®H � l�\ � sSU�^qi2~MuYu�wV�

K´~Mu�M&c �Sf$a8gWX[ijKZkY\*� D!� D�0$P��.?A58?EGNQ)0 �_G$5�D 3)(N3 G ( � �-P 365 =-G$5�D 3 � &0$D�D 9�P�� ?A5�DVJ 0��_G ( 0�2"I (�� � ;[;NG$; � G$D 36;:G$P�X;NG�3 G42 G$P �}o,�"����f$U[NYISX?NYp{t?^qa�ISX�a�I1l�a�RTR>P5IS^qpZNVt?^ja�ISXM\ � � � ` � ` x ` � ��\Gm NVU[p�L ~MuY� �&�

K ` �.M&m � ��N��IS^#�E\¾]��}O:P U?a�X?K>NYISb c ��f$a8gWX[ijKZkY\ �_0�2"I�9"3 ' G.? ?!� G$;[;:9"P(0�365SG$D 58D 3-9 � G�D�9 � �&P(365S2 0.?�3�)9�3)(FHG$;AI���n/U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI���X�a�� � ijaY|5NYi¾o�I�t�KZU�I KZtel�a�I��ÁKZU?KMISp{KY\5�ea8�YKMR>|}KZU&~MuYuYy&�

` y

Page 27: 2t?LS^qXU[KZs aYU[t^qXWX t U PSp{t?P U?KMb NYX › ~kasera › myPapers › Kasera97-Comparison.pdf · ¥ Z³ [ ¦ M¯ ° ³;¤¥°Vª,¡e©®¢z 8±8 Gª,¡ M¯ M¯ M , h h ¡ ªz¡

K ` ~[M&rE� ��N8� NVt:�VNVUM\�]�� � U[^*�a®KMIÇNYISb m �/H PSbSNYI¾\�� �_9�P 5S0���P#9��E58? ?�9 � 58D�0�3656G�D �B;:G�3 G�2AG$PQ"G$; �AD 3Z9�;:0�2�365�7$9� G$P�P*0���G$;:0�365�7$9��@=T=�P 5S2 0�3656G$D�?A�En�U?aJp{KZKMbS^qI��­a�� � l�m m1P5ijt?^qR­KMbS^_NJ\J�ea8�YKMR>|}KZU&~MuYu �&�

` w