NH 105 m Vestas NH 108 m Enercon NH 138 m Enercon NH ......Quelle: Schlegel, Stand: 31.07.2018 3068...

Quelle: Schlegel, Stand: 31.07.2018

30

68

32

10

32

20

28

47

24

20

29

86

14

80

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

V90-2MWNH 105 m

Vestas

E82-2MWNH 108 mEnercon



MM92-2MWNH100 mSenvion

V90-2MWNH 125 m

Vestas

V80-2MWNH 67 mVestas

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g in

MW

hStromerträgevergleich WP 2018 - verschiedene Standorte

WP 1 (SN) WP 6 (SN)WP 5 (SN)WP 4 (SN)WP 3 (SN) WP 7 (SN)WP 2 (SN)

Rprim

Rprim - Referenzanlage

(Mittelwert E1-7 = 2.958,6 MWh/a)


199,9%

100%

201,8%

163,6%

192,4%

217,6%

216,9%

207,3%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160% 180% 200% 220% 240%

Mittelwert - 6 WEA

WP 7 (SN) - V 80-2MW

WP6 (SN) - V90-2MW

WP5 (SN) - MM92-2MW

WP4 (SN) - E82-2MW

WP3 (SN) - E82-2MW

WP2 (SN) - E82-2MW

WP1 (SN) - V90-2MW

Prozentualer Stromertragsvergleich sächsischer WEA 2018

Ref - Referenz - WEA

NH 105m/RD 90m

NH 108m/RD 82m

NH 138m/RD 82m

NH 138m/RD 82m

NH 100m/RD 92m

NH 125m/RD 90m

NH 67m/RD 80m - Ref tv 1-7 = 739,9 h/a

Ø E = 2.958,6 MWh/a Ø tv 1-7 = 1.479,3 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.534,0 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.605,1 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.610,1 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.423,4 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.180,7 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.492,9 h/a


3068

2846

2299

2830

2900

2652

2420

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

V90-2MWNH 105 m

Vestas

V90-2MWNH 105 m

Vestas

MM92-2MWNH 80 mREPower

E82-2,3MWNH 138 mEnercon




Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g in

MW

h

Stromerträgevergleich WP 2018 - verschiedene Standorte

WP 1 (SN) WP 6 (SN)WP 5 (SN)WP 4 (SN)WP 3 (SN) WP 7 (SN)WP 2 (SN)

(Mittelwert E1-7 = 2.716,4 MWh/a)


183,6%

163,6%

179,2%

195,9%

191,3%

155,4%

192,3%

207,3%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160% 180% 200% 220%

Mittelwert - 7 WEA

WP7 (SN) - MM92-2MW

WP6 (SN) - MM92-2MW

WP5 (SN) - E82-2,3MW

WP4 (SN) - E82-2,3MW

WP3 (SN) - MM92-2MW

WP2 (SN) - V90-2MW

WP1 (SN) - V90-2MW


NH 105m/RD 90m

NH 105m/RD 90m

NH 80m/RD 92m

NH 138m/RD 82m

NH 138m/RD 82m

NH 100m/RD 92m

Ø E = 2.716,4 MWh/a

tv 1-7 = 1.180,7 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.293,5 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.534,0 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.422,8 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.121,6 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.230,6 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.260,7 h/a

Ø tv 1-7 = 1.289,2 h/a

NH 100m/RD 92m


32

20

33

82

33

52

39

46

40

40

41

73

43

23

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

5500

6000




3,2M-114NH 93 mRepower

3,2M-114NH 93 mRepower


3,2M114NH 143 mSenvion

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g i

n M

Wh


WP 1 (Lö) WP 6 (Er)* WP 5 (SN)WP 4 (SN)WP 3 (Ab) WP 7 (MS) WP 2 (Bo)

* Daten unkorrigiert

(Mittelwert E2MW 1-7 ≈ 3.318,0 MWh/a)


Quelle: Schlegel, Stand: 31.07 .2018

278,4%

292,1%

282,0%

273,0%

266,6%

226,5%

228,5%

217,6%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%120%140%160%180%200%220%240%260%280%300%320%

Mittelwert - WEA 3MW

WP7 (MS) - 3,2M114

WP6 (Er) - E101-3MW

WP5 (SN) - 3,2M-114

WP4 (SN) - 3,2-M114

WP3 (Ab) - E82-2,3MW

WP2 (Bo) - E82-2MW

WP1 (Lö) - E82-2MW


NH 138m/RD 82m

NH 138m/RD 82m

NH 138m/RD 82m

NH 93m/RD 114m

NH 93m/RD 114m

NH 143m/RD 114m

Ø tv 1-7 = 1.302,9 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.691,0 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.610,1 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.457,3 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.233,2 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.262,4 h/a

Ø E3MW = 4.120,5 MWh/a

NH 135m/RD 101m tv 1-7 = 1.368,3 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.350,8h/a


3946

4040

4173

4323

4225

3633

4172

0500

1000150020002500300035004000450050005500600065007000

3,2M-114NH93 mRepower

3,2M-114NH93 mRepower

E101-3MWNH135 mEnercon

3,2M114NH143 mSenvion


V112-3MWNH140mVestas

E101-3MWNH135mEnercon

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

ung

in M

Wh

Stromerträgevergleich WP 2018 -verschiedene Standorte

WP 1 SN) WP 6 Har) WP 5 (Erz)WP 4 (MS)WP 3 (Er) WP 7 (SN) WP 2 SN)



275,2%

281,9%

245,5%

285,5%

292,1%

282,0%

273,0%

266,6%

220% 240% 260% 280% 300%

Mittelwert WEA 1 - 7

WP7 (SN) E101-3MW

WP6 (Har) - V112-3MW

WP5 (Erz) - E101-3MW

WP4 (MS) - 3,2-M114

WP3 (Er) - E101-3MW

WP2 (SN) - 3,2M-114

WP1 (SN) - 3,2M-114


NH 93m/RD 114m

NH 93m/RD 114m

NH 135m/RD 101m

NH 143m/RD 114m

NH 135m/RD 101m

NH 135m/RD 101m

Ø tv 1-7 = 1.306,4 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.262,4 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.233,2 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.368,3 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.350,8 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.385,1 h/a

Ø E3MW = 4.073,0 MWh/a

NH 140m/RD 112m tv 1-7 = 1.181,3 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.367,9h/a


39

13

34

26 38

88

33

42

41

72

40

91

39

80

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

V112-3.3MWNH140mVestas






V112-3MWNH140mVestas

Str

om

ein

spe

isu

ng

in M

Wh

Stromerträgevergleich WP 2018 -verschiedene Standorte

WP 1 (Lip) WP 6 Mau) WP 5 (MauWP 4 (Str)WP 3 (Lip) WP 7 (SN) WP 2 (Lip)



258,8%

268,9%

276,4%

281,9%

225,8%

262,7%

231,5%

264,4%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160% 180% 200% 220% 240% 260% 280% 300%

Mittelwert WEA 1 - 7

WP7 (SN)V112-3MW

WP6 (SN) - E101-3MW

WP5 (SN) - E101-3MW

WP4 (Str) - E101-3MW

WP3 (Lip) - V112-3.3MW

WP2 (Lip) - V112-3.3MW

WP1 (Lip) - V112-3.3MW


NH 140m/RD 112m

NH 140m/RD 112m

NH 140m/RD 112m

NH 135m/RD 101m

NH 135m/RD 101m

NH 140m/RD 112m

Ø tv 1-7 = 1.211,8 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.038,3 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.185,6 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.178,0 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.095,8 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.367,9 h/a

Ø E3MW = 3.830,3 MWh/a

NH 135m/RD 101m tv 1-7 = 1.341,2 h/a

tv 1-7 = 1.294,3 h/a


38

88

41

73

39

46

40

91 44

99

47

38

43

23

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000



3,2M-114NH93mSenvion




3,2M-114NH143mSenvion

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g in

MW

hStromerträgevergleich WP 2018 - verschiedene Standorte

WP 1 (Lip) WP 6 Str) WP 5 (Str)WP 4 (Mau)WP 3 (SN) WP 7 (MaS) WP 2 (Er)



41

73

38

88 43

23 48

43

41

72

49

70

50

87

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

5500

6000

6500

7000



3.2M-114NH93mSenvion

3.4M114NH143mSenvion




Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g in

MW

h


WP 1 (Er) WP 6 Str) WP 5 (Mau)WP 4 MaSa)WP 3 (MaSa) WP 7 (Soh) WP 2 Lip)


Quelle: Schlegel, August 2018 bearb.

57

44

50

90

59

01

68

24

57

06

68

10

32

20

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 *

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g i

n M

Wh

Stromerträgevergleich 2012 - 2018: E82-2MW/NH138m

Ea max = Maximum → ∆Emax/min ≙ [≈ 34%]

Ea min = Minimum

∆E

* kumulativ

Quelle: Schlegel, August 2018 bearb.

54

17

73

10

69

17

80

47

67

49

83

72

41

73

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

10000

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018*

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g i

n M

Wh

Stromerträgevergleich 2012 - 2018: E101-3MW/NH135m

Ea max = Maximum → ∆Emax/min ≙ [≈ 24%]

Ea min = Minimum ∆E

Betriebsbeginn: 30.03.2012

* kumulativ

3.0

68

1.4

80

1.5

34

740

0,00

500,00

1.000,00

1.500,00

2.000,00

2.500,00

0,000

500,000

1.000,000

1.500,000

2.000,000

2.500,000

3.000,000

3.500,000

4.000,000

Vestas V90-2MW/NH 105m Vestas V80-2MW/NH67m

Vo

llla

sts

tun

den

ta

in h

/a

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g E

in

MW

h/a

Stromeinspeisung Volllaststunden

Quelle: Schlegel, 31.07.2018 (August 2018 bearbeitet)

Stromertragsvergleich WP «Silberberg» (L) – WP «Naundorf» (TDO) 2018

[+10

7,3%

]

4.8

43

1.4

801.4

37

74

0

0,00

500,00

1.000,00

1.500,00

2.000,00

2.500,00

3.000,00

0,000

500,000

1.000,000

1.500,000

2.000,000

2.500,000

3.000,000

3.500,000

4.000,000

4.500,000

5.000,000

5.500,000

Senvion 3,4M114/NH143m Vestas V80-2MW/NH67m

Vo

llla

sts

tun

den

ta

in h

/a

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g E

in

MW

h/a



Stromertragsvergleich WEA 3,4M114 – WEA V80-2MWRef 2018

[+22

7,3%

]

5.0

87

1.4

80

1.5

41

74

0

0,00

500,00

1.000,00

1.500,00

2.000,00

2.500,00

3.000,00

3.500,00

4.000,00

0,000

500,000

1.000,000

1.500,000

2.000,000

2.500,000

3.000,000

3.500,000

4.000,000

4.500,000

5.000,000

5.500,000

6.000,000

6.500,000

Vestas V126-3.3MW/NH137m Vestas V80-2MW/NH67m

Vo

llla

sts

tun

den

ta

in h

/a

Str

om

ein

sp

eis

un

g E

in

MW

h/a



Stromertragsvergleich WEA V126-3.3MW – WEA V80-2MWRef 2018

[+24

3,7%

]

48

4

15

7

311

22

6

13

1

10

6

65

742

332

516

424

321

216

176

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

WP-Stromerträgevergleich 2018

Referenz-WEA V80-2MW (P = 2 MW, NH = 67 m, RD = 80 m); (tv = 739,9 h/a)

WEA Ø 8xV90-2MW (P = 2,0 MW, NH = 105 m, RD = 90 m); (tv = 1361,1 h/a)

DE1-7 [WEA Ø 8xV90-NH105m / WEA V80-NH67m] ≙ (+ 83,9%)

Quelle: Schlegel, 17.08. 2018 (bearbeitet)

484

157

311

226

131

106

65

1369

648

896

693

526

410

302

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1800

WP-Stromerträgevergleich 2018

Referenz-WEA V80-2MW (P = 2 MW, NH = 67 m, RD = 80 m); (tv = 739,9 h/a)

WEA 3.4M114 (P = 3,37 MW, NH = 143 m, RD = 114 m); (tv = 1437,1 h/a)

DE1-7 [WEA 3.4M114-NH143m / WEA V80-NH67m] ≙ (+ 227,3%)

Quelle: Schlegel, 17.08. 2018 (bearbeitet)

NH 105 m Vestas NH 108 m Enercon NH 138 m Enercon NH ......Quelle: Schlegel, Stand: 31.07.2018 3068...

Documents

Transcript of NH 105 m Vestas NH 108 m Enercon NH 138 m Enercon NH ......Quelle: Schlegel, Stand: 31.07.2018 3068...