© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved. Safe Education for Parents Safe...

Post on 13-Jan-2016

217 views 0 download

Transcript of © Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved. Safe Education for Parents Safe...

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Safe Education for Safe Education for ParentsParents

Mentor training module II

SAFESAFE

Karl Heinz BrischPediatric Clinic and Polyclinic

Dr. von Hauner Children‘s Hospital

Department of Pediatric Psychosomatics and Psychotherapy

University of Munich

®

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

John Bowlby

"Bindung ist das gefühlsgetragene Band, das eine Person zu einer anderen spezifischen Person anknüpft und das sie über Raum und Zeit miteinander verbindet."

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Overview I

• Postnatal adaptation

• Fears

• The three of us - parenthood

• Interaction and its disorders

• Video sensitivity training

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Overview II

• Circle of safety

• Day care

• Partnership

• Family of Origin

• Exercises

• Open questions

• Outlook

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

“Weather chart"

• How‘s baby doing today?

• How am I doing today?

• How are both of us doing today?

• What I urgently need to tell

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

The babies introduce themselves

• Separately, mother/father introduce their baby in the group as if they were the baby themselves. To do this, they must imagine themselves into the inner world and experience of their baby.

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Happy moments

• Moments of happiness

• Moments of joy

• Moments of agreement

• Moments of happy surprise

• Moments à trois

• Five positive adjectives for your relationship with your baby

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

“Unhappy" moments

• Moments of unhappiness

• Moments of fear

• Moments of dissonance

• Moments of helplessness

• Moments of loneliness

• Five “heavy“ adjectives for your relationship with your baby

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Mothers introduce themselves

• Preparation in small groups

• Introduction in the group

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Fathers introduce themselves

• Preparation in small groups

• Introduction in the group

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

The “family group introduces itself

• Who all belongs to the new “family“ or family group?

• How do we experience ourselves as three or more?

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

We three or four?

MotherFather

Baby

Siblings

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Questions, questions, questions

• Spoil• Sleep• Nurse• Dangers when exploring• Setting limits and frustration• Playing alone and together• Babysitter• Partnership• Rivalry• Traveling and vacations with baby• …………….??????

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Preconditions for the development of secure attachment in the child

• Sensitivity on the part of the caretaker

• Emotional availability

• Clearing up misunderstandings

• Recognizing projections

• Clarifying notions of the ideal

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

AAI (1)

• Semi-structured interview

• Questions– description of the family situation– relationship to the parents with earliest memory– five adjectives for your relationship to your

parents in childhood– closeness to mother and/or father

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

AAI (2)

• Questions– help when “not feeling well" (sorrow, fear,

illness)– first separation from parents– rejection by parents– threats by parents– effect of parents on personality– explanation for behavior of parents

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

AAI (3)

• Questions– loss of important attachment figures– changes in the relationship with parents– reactions to separation from own child

• real child

• imagined child

– learning from childhood experiences

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Assessment of the AAI

• Scientific assessment very complicated

• Suspicion of unresolved trauma– trauma is reported– symptoms of posttraumatic stress– coherence of speech flow– dissociative phenomena

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Unprocessed trauma in the mother/father

• Disordered interaction and disorders in affective communication with the infant

• Fearful maternal behavior

• Fear-inducing maternal behavior

• Helpless maternal caregiving behavior

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Triggers for traumatic memories in the parents

• Triggers in the behavior of the infant, – crying, worry, pain, neediness – desires for attachment, closeness– separation, boundaries

• Triggers in affective arousal

• Unconscious processes!!!

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Reenactment of trauma

• In the interaction with the infant– rejection of desires for closeness -- avoidance– violence– abrupt break off of actions– overstimulation (sexual-sensory)

• In affective communication– transfer of traumatic affects

• rage, shame, agitation

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Video feedbackSensitivity training

• The action level– What are the mother, father, and they be doing?

• The motivational level– Why do they behave this way?

• The emotional level– How does feel to you?

• Empathic level– What would I do if I were the mother, father, or baby in

this scenario?

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Feedback

• Ego messages• At least 2 positive responses BEFORE

critical response• Always begin work with positive

interactions• Caution with critical responses• Follow up critical responses with “AND"

positive responses

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Videotaped practice examples

• Diapering

• Nursing

• Playing

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Adaptation – processing the birth

• Exchange in the group about the birth

• Exchange about positive and negative experiences

• Traumatic experiences– individual psychotherapy

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Adaptation and grief workThe real versus the fantasized child

• Temperament

• Abilities

• Powers of resistance

• Threat

• Effect on owning personality

• Effect on partnership

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Bonding of the parents

• Emotional availability

• Capacity for sensitive care

• Empathy with the child‘s needs

• Recognition of unclear agitation in the parents themselves -- trigger points

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Ideals versus reality

• The ideal mother -- the real mother

• The ideal father -- the real father

• The ideal baby -- the real baby

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Me as mother

• Physical changes• Psychological changes

– protection– worries and fears

• Relational changes– with partner– with own children– with own parents– with own friends

• Development of postnatal attachment - bonding

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Me as father• Physical changes• Psychological changes

– protection– worries and fears

• Critical phases and responsibility• Relational changes

– with partner– with own children– with own parents– with own friends

• Development of postnatal attachment - bonding

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Partnership and “egoism“

• Time for exchanges

• New things to talk about

• Time for activities together

• Time for sexuality

• Time for vacation

• Time to be alone!

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

“Resources” exercise

• Safe place

• Vault

• Tree exercise

• Helpful helpers

• Lighting

• Remote-control

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care

• Babysitter

• Family members

• Day mother

• Crib

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

“Natural” separation situations

• Going to sleep• Parents‘ night out / the babysitter arrives• Kindergarten

– overnights

• Enrollment in school• Country day school • Transfer to next school• Free time / vacation

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Preparation for separations

• Time for transition / separation• Buildup secure attachment with replacement

attachment figure• Rituals• Announcements• Availability• Admits to pain and sadness• Understand and withstand anger

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

“Unnatural” separation situations (1)

• Moves / migration / flight• Admission to hospital• Parental divorce• illness of one parent – emotional separation

– cancer– addiction / alcoholism / psychosis– chronic disease / multiple sclerosis

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

“Unnatural” separation situations (2)

• Unexpected death of an important reference figure– child / fetus

– parent

– friend

– grandparents

– teacher• natural cause of death

• accidental death without farewell

• suicide

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

The experience of separation as psychotrauma

• Sudden occurrence

• Over-stimulation of autonomic nervous system

• Loss of attachment figure - security

• Neither fight nor flight possible

• Nightmares

• Dissociation of memories

• Triggers of flashbacks

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and attachment

• Study of the US National Institute of Child Health and Development

• 1364 families and their children

• Follow-ups at 6, 15, 24 and 36 months

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and attachment

• Forms of day care– grandparents/relatives

• in the parents‘ home• in the caregiver‘s home

– Day care centers of varying quality– Babysitter

• in the parents‘ home• in the caregiver‘s home

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and attachment

• Variation– the quality of day care– number of hours per day and week– Beginning day care

• from birth

• 4-6 months after birth

• 7-15 months after birth

– all social classes different

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and attachment

• First year of life– 76% non-maternal day care

• Control group– 24% of children under maternal care

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and attachment

Results• Risk of insecure attachment increases if

– mother‘s behavior is insensitive– high number of hours in daycare– constantly changing care arrangements

• These effects did not occur when the mother-child relationship was good

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and attachment

• Summary– Quality of the mother-child relationship as a

relatively robust determinant of attachment outcome

– Poor quality day care is a risk factor if the mother-child relationship is already stressed -- more frequent insecure attachment

– High quality day care is a protective factor for children with very insensitive mothers -- more frequent secure attachment

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and attachment

• Summary– Care and support for mothers with sensitivity

problems– High quality of day care

• Long adjustment times (min. 3-4 weeks)

• Latchkey child caretaker of 1:2 (3)

• Sensitive reference person is a constant

• Regular day plan

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Day care and aggression

• Contradictory results (late effects)

• effect of – quality of the parent-child relationship– characteristics of the child (sex-boy)

• Secure attachment is a protective factor

• Fewer effects of early day care

• Poor quality of day care

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Mother‘s fears

• Spoiling child• Child in parents‘ bed• Eating and sleeping• Lack of support from partner• Illnesses• Stress with family of origin• Loss of female attractiveness• Loss of profession and end of career

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Father‘s fears

• Spoiling child

• Child in parents‘ bed

• End of sexuality

• Lack of support from partner

• Stress with family of origin

• Child as a burden on career

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Steps toward forming a SAFE group (1)

• Find a co-facilitator – couple • Find an organizational partner (e.g., family

education center)• Find a large space • Advertise in the local press and distribute flyers• Organize individual care• Organize a hotline • Organize cooperative arrangements with local

psychotherapists

© Copyright Karl Heinz Brisch Munich 2012. All rights reserved.

Steps toward forming a SAFE group (2)

• Start with approximately 5-6 couples• Conduct AAI interviews• Distribute the trauma questionnaires• Be reachable• Question the parents empathetically• Get supervision • Enjoy the babies‘ development and the parent-

child relationships